High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2198/2021dismissed

Krishan Lal And Sons And ORS v. Ashok Jain

2023-06-01Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan13 pages

!"#$ " %

&' (")* +

$,(

!-$.

/0",/( - "

&)"'"1,(

3 $1 ,

4$$ (")* *", 5'6 4,6 "$ ,(78$

"8'0"

5198 $ :

(

,; "

0 + 7!"#$ "'0" + ,/"+6 44<<,6 "$,(78$

"'0"$0$+ !"#$"& 3$, %7 3$ / " 3$ )0 .

+ 7 /"+ 6 44<< 6 "$ , (78$

"7"+ (+

4$$,!"#$ " + 6 =-'

"7"+

" "+ 6 = ++ "" >'0 ' "7"+,+17 ?;4+ 7 "@ "7"+"8 '

!"#$ 0 8' 5$-

" ", -$0

"78'8'

4A1+ $0

, + " "0 " 8' - "'

@ 7 - *'1,-@$

" $+

00"+6 44"+"80

"8' "'0"

,-"08' "@ "+-$81+

$18 ) B"+

$7 ">' ""+>'

" +$ '

'+ 8 ' " "+

48 ) ""+ , ""+

,-"08'

>'+7 47 $" 8' $'"0 '0"

,7$1, 6"*"8 $+$7"- $0 8' ""'8() *@

>' ""+ +'

"() *() *C- 6"*8 ' () *+ '+

( "0' )81

)0.

+ - "1" ' "$ $ 1" $ "7+ 7++$>'$$- " "7 (

,"" 1"+

"1 =- "'

18$ '

"+ 7*'1,-,-"

" " +4 + + >' 7

"10',

)0.

+ 4 "8'0"

8 $$,(78$ =

, ++ $.

7 0 " +

0 +$71 8.

0'$ 1 '++ 7 $

81 $0$$ "++ -+81"7'8 (78$ ' +$+ @"" $ " + 80"+6 4,6 "$,(78$

"D CEC, "+ -"

"- )81

7 /.8 "@ "+-0 81

"0' ">' "7 8 '

'+ "'0"

6"*@7

, " '0"

-7 "1"-$$

$ - """'8$-$"@

,"""'8 0.8$"@ ""+0 6"*$10 '

'+@ " +

" $ ' " ++ -+81"7'8 (78$

@ "+ ' 1 + 80 $8'$080 6 - " '8'78 ,-"

"-0 '

$8'$07.+ "7 $$80' $ +'+, " , " +

$$0 $ $ 80

7 8$ 07$@

8 . $$ "#

= !"#$,-""$

8""--,'0"

8+ 6 ="$0$"B"+ '0"

7$ "

F7 " +$0 " + , $$-0 ' -

7 G" " $8$ 8.

7 ""+ +'

"0' +$ 1

$$0H %% G" "

0'$ 1 '++ 7 $

% G" "+ "0 1$ ' $

% = G" " "+

7 8$H % G" "

8 . 1+ H

% $ B" + -

>' ++ ' $ '++ "+

$7 < +" ,

"7$ 0 " 7 %G8E70"'0"

$-6" *%G,&G$%G"() *%G=B"

$ '7 :E% :E% <8'

$,+ 6%73$0 " 7

G ' "E7I'G B"+ "$ '7 ; (

"00'7 , $$,(78$8100

'- 0.'07 ;"7

F$000,

$$"++ " (++$$ ('

" 1

*'0, (78$ 81-1 $0 ++$,-"

"-0 ( $

*'0,(78$J '7J (++$$ ('

" 1,(78$,-".'07 ="

+ "++$B"+ 4 -0 -7 " 7

7 " .'07 " " + +7' " 1

4$$, $0-"

$$ -'$ 8 $8 1 ++ " " 7+

E '

0' .

+ 4 6- - ' + 4 $00

"1" 7 "' 81-1 $0 "+ +

"-0 4$$,-""+'

++ "'0" '$ <""$ '$ "+ 800

"'0" " # '$ "+

" +

$$ " $ " '78 " "+4++ 8$00 "7 (78$

81 7)0 +

7 "

,-"

""-8$0 ' $--071

" +$:E%,$ '$ +

" " ""+ + K, -"

"$10 "'0" $781

$$," "0 ""+ "7'0"

6"*8'

"$0- "

" "'8 +'

0 '+ $" 0.8 " " 1 ' ""+816"*,'0"

$$ 1-$$8'81'0"

$$ E+ " 8'

>'+7 47 $ 8 1 $8$

0 ""++ +

, " " +

"8 $- "'

" 8018 1$8$

" " ", $ '$ + 0 + J$$" ' "0'7 0

$$" $17 $

7 "'

- "0 " "++ +81"7<+6;

, "8+

$$1+$

" $

0 /.

00"+6 44 "+"8 "8' "'0"

,-"'0" 8' "++6, +$ "+-$ 81 " +

$ 1 8 ) 8 $0 " +

# '$ "'87

(") !'7 0

0 " 7 %G " E7 " "'0"

6"*7

70,"$% ")'$$0- """'8 "$ B"'0""" ' " ""+$10 '" '+8'

"$ 6"*"8 0 + F7 '

" +$ 0 81 +

" E7 , 8 ""+$10 $

; 8'80' 7 ",$ "'0" 7'

6"*" 808' "0'$8F' "7,-" + 6%73$0 " 7 G," " E7 ;;"7

'0"

08' ""+,-"

"- 0 81

"0' +$ 1 " '0"

, "-, "'0"

" '0"

01-)8'

" " 7'

"80 : "-, 8 ""+-"

" "$$" 0 "+'+ 08'81"'0"

$D81 "'0"

$- "$$ E+0 "8'< "+

"$$ " -"+$,-"

"""$ 7 "+7'

$B" $

" +$:E%$ = B"$--$$

$ $$8 .'0 " >'7 B"+ + "$$,-"" 808'

>'+7 " "+>' 7"++ +

-$$"+$1$81 "$$ 7 "+< "$$- E+"8' "7"+"0

", " "0-0"'

"+$5

8 7 "+$ E+ "8' $$- "+

)++ ""+ +'

"0 " "++ $$0$18$00

J $$, $ (++$$ ('

" 1, (78$ " .'07 "$ - " +

$+6 <+ 6, "++ 1806#$*5+ $, /3D,(78$

"8 ' 0 -

"+ 8$"

"1" $ /7$$1+6, " "++ 16, ""

60,(78$

88$00 +

J$$ $ 81 G I', BE $), , (78$ / L , (78$

"8$ - "B"++ 1 "7 - '0"

$- "$$ $ 77 $ ' 7 +1 7 0 :E/ .

, "$$-)0+ 77 $ ++ 1,"- '18$0 $8'

" " ++ "0 ' $4 77 $/ ""+ -" " "$$'0"8'. "7 "+ "$$- E+"8', "7 "+"8 ' 8'

8$ +'+ "

81 "$$ ""'$ ""

7 "+$ "8'0 + 7 ""+81 # '$ "+

" "0'7 ""+>' 7+ $"' "' "++ 1 '$ "8 7 $

$- "'

+7 " $$, " ,

'$ 8'0"

77 $+'+ ; G",$ '$ "8'

0 "8.

1 B"7++ 1807 "+0"

"1800,-"

""8 '

" "

$18 )-"""8'05$-8'

" "" "+

( 7 " +$ +" 0+" 7++ 1, "7 7 "+ "+ - "

0 .0"+B" "0 "- "-

$+'+-''

" 1+

7 F' "7, " 7 "+ . " "+ +

-3DB" , 7'

" ' $

77 $++ 1B" , "8.

81$ '$ +

$ )7 .

0$1 "0 ".'07

81$ '$ +

, - " $ ' 8,

$$ " 8 8$ "- " " 8 >'7 "7"+ 8$"'0"

$- E+ "8'B" , ".'07 "$+ '$ +

17 /7$$1 " " .'07

#$%%& '

() %

& % * '

!) +

# *

% '

'++ ( !$,

! % -. /' $!

% $,

0 # $, ./

1 2

0 & # +

-' !

!3(! +

'. #

-- + + ! %

' '13

# - 2

+ +. 5 "

6 2 %

. 81$ '$ "

++$ 8$ "+ '

'7 " ">'7

$$"8 ' 88 - " $7 7 $

- "0 " 77 $++ 8$00 "7"0 8 ' 8 " # '$ " + " $ .'07 #

1 2

1 1 2 & %8

$ 0 ./9

" +/ "

2!1 2

$ % + '''++ "

>'7 $$ 8 7 "+ 7 '

8$ E+ 8'81

J$$ # '$ " ' " .'07 $# %

,, 1 + 81/0$*'0 "' -" - 8 $8$ 1 77 $++ 1 "7

1-'$ +$$ "0"

0 "++ 1 0' E+ 8' "78'$0 # '$ " ' "+ .'07 &

#* $, '81/0$*'0 "' -" -8

$$ $-1+ "0 /

(

"- +.' '

' +$0 0 , "'

8 .

= # '$ " ' "$'+

!3 "

% - 81/0$*'0 "' -" -8

'0"

"+, "$$

>' $

77 ,-"

"-80' $ +'+ "0 " + , "$ '$

"+$ $ '+.'07 (

# 2 ,

4 ) % //

' -" -8 "50"' "+- ++

$' 8'

$0$ 1,0'$ 1++ 1 < "+ , "+81 $$, (78$70 "

$81 "$$-8'$1 -0$$0$'$ 8$ 1 '

'$+ ++$1 ++$1 $- +++ 7 #

$$,(78$ $$1 $$-0 "

" $ $1 0 , $ "0$8$ + ">' ""++'

"8 ,-"

"$$"8'0"

0 0 + ""8 "7"+"'

" - .' -"B"- "0 "-

$81

4$$- "7$ " 7 " E ' : "- ' /

5198 $ :

(

,;,

"$$ '

""+ 7 "+

- "+ "1, " "0 0"

++ " " $$ B" , "#0$ ' " + ++ 0' 0 .

E ' ;

" " ", " .'07 $ 81 (++$$ ('

" 1,(78$18$ "-0'++$ 7

"7'$ ++++

'$+

+ "$1 $0- "'++$ $-

#(++$$ ('

" 1,(78$- '$$1.'

0 "+81 $$,(78$,-"

7$$0$ 7 $$-0 ".

B" 7+'0 + 81 " (++$$ ('

" 1, (78$>'

$-$$ '

71 $$0$ 1 7 1 "01$7 8 + 1 B"$.'

"' >'

'7 , " - " "7+'081-1 E 0 "$ .'

F07 "+

, "7 7 / " 7 +

" 8 7, 7 $$'++$ , 1, +

0$1 3.

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#