← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/26117/2015disposed of

M/S Paramveer Auto Fuels v. Indian Oil Corporation Ltd And ANR

2016-07-11Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary9 pages

 

     

 ! "# $!%&'( )*+, "

-.' $$/* *'

 '*'

%$ 0$1% $%$)

'0%'

 

 

  



 

  

)))0'!)&$0$0'/$+2$3%') 4*%5/6

2!%)0'6 )))4*%5/')*%20%)%5'6  



 

  

  4$+8*/$-$,





  ! " # !

$ &'( &* +,



 + -  

 

    #

+    

 

 

 



  .  / #0 # # 1

    &*   , 

 

 .  2 

   2 3)  



 #! # # !

&#  3   



+

,  

 

+ +  %    

   + * 5  6 10!'

# !

  " 1 # !

 7

 

 3

  & 

 

+  

    +

   + 3

 

  

8

& *   ## 0 # !

 1 ,

 

 +  

,  

 

 9 ,  , , 

+  

 



 

  7 !





 &*  0 ' # !

&0 &*

 +,

  

  

3

+,

 

+      

 +,

/ ! " # !

$ &'( ) +,  0 ' # !

+ & * 

 +         + )



*5 6 10!'

# !

$ &7(

 ) + &  & * $  &"

&;( ,

+  +,      

  + +,

<  +

     +  



 ! " # !

$ &'(  +

    , 

 

.  2   

   2 3)   * #0 # # 1



 3 



+

,   

 

     

+

  3 



   

   +



  + 3

 +    +  

, 

  7 !





 *

/ 0 ' # !

 0  +,  

   / ! " # !

 ' + 

 

  +   

 , 

! 

%

$$$$9 :

3$')+ ""#; "<"

     

& ="

6

 

 >      .

 



  

6





 ) + ?

) ) 











+     

  

 +



  

 

) 



;

% = 99 = 99  

+&   

)

  ) +       



 6   

    

       

 +

@ .

,   

     

 %  9  

  A  A 2



 +

&3 ) ), 

  )+     

  

 



  + 

   

+

 ,+ 



      

 6









    

 



   

  )

,  : ) , )   ) + 



     )  







     

  

5  

 >  

#!      

+

 = *99

 % B+ *,

 =C



3 99 : )  * 5+ . 5, $;07( 17 B> 11   DB   



  ) 



,  =    =+  



  + :

     99        

 ?

  

  ,           + 

 

)  

  

&3 

   

,   

  

  



3  E

-  



  ,  + 

  



 + 

 





!"

# # 

$  " $ 

# $% # $ #

$ & $#  ( ;

2** 1;0

& D'

% C, 9  @ * B * 

  %

@ *  % 5 *          



, $2 "'"&;'

4

 * ( "

+  

&3    

      

,

,  )  2 %9 ;

!

FF FF FF !

 )    : :  +   



   

   3 

&3 

 



 :   

   

 

   + >         ) )  %

&3   

  + >   %  

,     %   >  

)

)

 

,  ) 

&3  

  )

>     +   

 

 

  +   

   )  

  ) 

,   



?

 

&3        +  

    



     )3   

  9 

  

:  

)  )  ,

: ?

 

&3 



 )

8



,  

 ) ,+ +  

     

 

>

 

 

 



  9 ))& 9

  

, 

  ) 



   ) +





, 

,  

,    

,

)3 )   $2 G 2 

G ?

* $;"'(  <+ @+ > + '7&'7'( 

  

)    



, 

+

 

    2) ?

  2 $;;1( ;

B<>> !!7 !0#  #;

  H  /% #  B5*

* 1 ! +    * <

> 

 D



 

 D : 

+      





  +

 



  DG D E '

: + )

 ! " # !

$ &'(

& ,

  +  + <9) 

' ( $)  



 !"

#   $ (

)

 

  &*  ,     

 + 6   )  )  , % 

  =4$+8*/$-$>  *%5  = $/%$$> *+, "

*%5 99 5 , 8 I86 5 ) I86