← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4038/2024dismissed

Bhagwat Dayal v. M/S S.D. Precision Tech. Pvt. Ltd. And ORS

2024-07-25Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja11 pages

 

         

 !

!

" #$   %& '(!) *!

!

          

   

   ! "      #" #( +,#  - .-#   $ %#   &    ' (&     ) %* &   '  +" ,  ....  .-# /"

,$      ' " "  (&     /

 ' 010102&3 (4"

 &

   ,   "01% &1&21 113% 1& 55%& 61&7$  



   

   

    

!

 -   ""  '      ' "   (,   - 

  151112&3 (4" 6  ' 6  ,  2 4    "01% &1 & 2 '%3 % 48'6&9 61&7$ '%     '  ' " (&     "

7 - 

  15111

    81911

:!; :!; '

        '     %   :    "%  :    '      ' "    ; 9 2 ;* " 

    6    :

  <181< " ( '  2  

   4=3 '  '      '  >

  181<    " 

     %  8) 5     

     ' 

      "  -  "   + , % -

 1151? #"  (,       % 

%   

(

'  '

   '  '%  ""

       ?111 "  -  =3  6        3    $(  

      



  !"#$!#%&  '

  ( ) *+    ,   

  ( * )  )  (() - .

 / , )

 !0#!!#!#

)  #1#$!#!#

( 

 %!#$!#!# 2  

 %&#$!#!#  23 4.5  89((9%&#!!#!# 7:;,2#!1$8< :

@ "   '

    "   '%  ""

 

81911 -

:

 -

 '' #9 0 11(& %'#8  11(25A' - %  4  " (&    %

   6  &     '% ' - =3  6    15111    -       ' #9 <11(      "   (,  -'  =3  6    5111       "  ""

  ' / 3   "% ' "    -     % 

 %      ' " (&      -B 

     '       11 '

   -     " '      ""

   3 ""

 ' "       :

; @ %  1011 "

 " -'  '  -:      / C   #  ?1 '  6  ' 6    ?1             15111 "  -  =3  6 

   '%     ' ' (&    :); & '

 "   (,  ' ' ""

 % -"

  01010  

  81911> "  "  :<; @%"  '  01010" D  &""

 6 

     '  "   -% -: '  '" -'

B   

81911



:

 -   

    

    ""

 

%    111' '% *   '

  

      '

    '      %    C  #  ?1'  6 6    ' ""

 >

   "       " 

     - 

 - '    ''  7'

        '  

  '  > 61&01 62=& -: '  '"    % -  -'

 "( " % - %

%'C  # ?2424' '6    

%  (

- -:    % - - ''  :*; C  

   '  ("    ,   -%   "  

 '3  - =3  6         ?111      / "

  1911    % - 

  81911   -  """ '%  -'

" - 

'       > 61&0162=&

"  ' -     %    "%

 -  =3  6         5111  -  -   -    ' C   #  5 '  6  ' 6     > % 62=& " -     " % ' - " -   -

81911      "" %  - %/

:);  ' C  # <<24'  6  '6    

- -     "   -    - ' '   ( "   :; &'

       ' "     

  ""(-/  @ % - '  -   -% % - '' '  "  

 % -  / 'C  # << 5 ?1' ' 6  ?1  ("    ''$( **  "+  " ,- .,"  = 7%8 '  >   > )    * ( *> *()  ) )   )  6  ((   (. )  )

 ( *.)  ( -- 6  7!8

 (. )  ((*   )   /(  3-.

/*   (( 

 ).   (  (   )>   )(>    (>   )*(/ 78

   > * (?      > ( * ))

 ) >    @A 7*8

              >  * ( )   )

  )       )     

>) -  



 B .

A 78 >) .*  )    > ) ()*(A 78

.

 >)  () A  78 >   ) - )  6  )  . )(     

:<; + )  3-    (    > ?)   )   

() -



.  



(. )    *  -)   3-.

/* *>.    (C1)  (( *  >

 -) )   )  (   3-.

/*   ( 

 6 ) )

)    ) - ) )  ( ((*

 )) -  6  

 )  (. )   ()   ).  ( 

  > *  (. )  (( ) (   ).  )  > -)  *> ) *    ) @ 7$8 D>

() )   (  ) ( (( * .

) *>  .

 )-    ))) .

) *  )*  )- ) - )) )  () -  

) ) -   >+   *  ) *>

    .+) -  )) )   .

  ) *> */( 7!8  * )) ) 

(. )          ) ) -  .

   *

)))  (. )  6 .> .. >   .) ) +   >  ..   .> .) ).)    > .

   ) ).    > .

 )  ) 

  )  ( ) -   %/

+   .-+  ""

 .0+ - ((.

  /. > >*( ((*

)*>   )

6 * 6 (  

:*;

) 

>.  (    >  )   )  (( ) -  .

 * 

))

6     (( 

- >  / ).>*

) ( (0! 2

.."

   "  3 

3" -   7%8 '  > )..*(   >   *  ( )  )      /(  

  >    

) (  )   *( ) )* )        )

     *>  ( .> 

(>   6    )  ( - . )()-() > ) *() ) -  ) )  7!8 , ( (( *    )   -   )-() >   ) *() ) -    ) - )  (       6  )   ) )

 

()

   )  *

)() 3>*>    )-() > 7$8 ,

() )    ) (  ) ( (( *

 )   >- ) 

()

( +  *   ) 

(. )  (    

( ) / . *       ) 

.

    > ( (( *>) (* -  

) - ) (  ) (@< :>; & "

  "- (&   

-: '  '" 



81911  % -  

  ""

  B    '  '  %  *       111 /%   %- "'

6  C   '

 ""

" ( ,  % 111 %   -:

:; ()     % - %   "   ' 3 "     

   "  % *   -:  %' 3 "       ' 

 -   ,    >

  "

 ""

  "

  -  

   ' " (&      @    %  "  -%  ''-  (    % -

'-:  %'  % -  111' '% *     %/ %  

-      "  & 

    '     %   "   ( ,   '

'

  %- '  

 ""

    %

    -        "   ' 3         

        

81911 :?

&  -%% - '' ( &    -:  "

   %/ "  %'C # ?24' '6  ?1  -   -  '% @

 "          

 '3  -  =3  6         ?111     / "

  1911  "  -  "     101911  %

  

81911  "   1911       -    " ""  '% =3  6     "

 "   (, 

:>;       % %   -  "  

  D    '

    "  %"

  

'''#<11( -   #9 0 1( 

#9 0 11(     

 -  '  6 

,  

 >

 :??; @   '     %        

 '' %" 

'3  6 

  %- "' 6 

-: 

  

' -" -'  ' '' " D  %   -           " % ' - " -   -

 81911     " "   (,    >

 % "

'  %' C # <<24' '6  @  % 



81911  - #'   - %    '  4" 

+ ," 

  5  

. +!6 .

 % &7$) .+    77$#  "(8 '("    $( 0 D -  () - *>  ) ) 

6        

  (

) )  !%2(C1  !%2(EE  -   )      >)  ( )  )  .  >  ) (( *   

       > )  *) - ( )    )      >   >))  ()  )  

       > )  *) - ( )   (() >   ((  )  

   ()*(  * +  9  <

:?

:?!;   '%  '   %   '  ' " (&   15111   % -:  '  '"  "

" '-   %  %   

  

 - "

  '%  - %     "

" (&    -B 

 5111= ""     -B  " ' -   %   

 %/ '% ' % 15111

% - ' % 'C # 5' '6   -     %     - "    ''



'% '  @ "   

 81911   - 85A '    %    "  % 

  5111                   #'  -%  " '

".      

" 

.  84

9 &7 ) .+   6 7*/  #   "(< '  ( "    $( E ;

F(.;(. ) -   %&&E7C8 660#C )    *  (   *()- )         ) ((  . >) ) ).) .  > ).

  .

()  (    (  (() >  .)-() ><  :?

@   3"

  '     %       "   

    ' 

 '3  - =3

-  %  "      C 

:??; #  <<24  

  #  5 '  6  ' 6      -  -: '  " 

 =3  6   -  %      %%

  "'    -   ":

  

    "

D &""

6  3'"   C  # ?1' '6     %"

 "( "  %'C # ?' '6      %

' ' -:     %    

-

B  - '  "

(  "   "" - -'        :?

@ '  % - ' %  " "  %- 3=3  :?); &     "   (,  ''

"  %      -' 

%- " -'   " ' 

'% "

' ' "

'  >   %     "  

   -   ,  ' B '3 "  '' ' " 

-    :

  "-

"   :?<;  %

 ""

 24 '



 

" '' 6@!)/!

!

    " .-# $ G++.G       E "/

F E #" - F