High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2618/2015dismissed

Ankit Kumar v. Cbse And ORS

2016-02-23Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain3 pages

#$% &%'()(*+,

!+ - .!// .

0%)%*$+ !0#(*#(*&%0/#(*(1&2'#$% 0$3%4%$($(*%0 !0#0)355#06#71&2'#$% 00%)4*&%*$ !0/#*$.#7 #06#7#1&2'#$% 00%)4*&%*$)$8 #9%)3 (*&#7 3%4%$($(*%0163#44%#0%&(*%*$0#7%#'3%07(5(:(7($; %)$ 0)30$1--"(*<7;1 ,3#) (7%&$3%40%)%*$4%$($(*)%%=(*5 )%$$(*5#)(&%$3%0%)<7$ $3%4%$($(*%0#)>* #(0!%#*)? .%#0*%&'<*)%7 0$3%4%$($(*%0)<:@($$%&$3#$$3%4%$($(*%0 #44%#0%&(*3%7&* A ,3%0%)<7$$3%0% 6#)&%'7#0%&* B ,3%4%$($(*%06#))<040()%&$ (*&<$$3#$#5#(*)$3()0%)<7$1 >* #(0!%#*)?6#)@%*$(*%&%0% %00%&$$3%

5$0%5()$%0%&:;

$3%/'37*$3%&#$% %C#@(*#$(*0%40$(*5$$3%47('%$3#$#*)6%0 )3%%$ 077 8

B B 3#& :%%* 7)$ 6 &#;) $3%0%# $%01 * , A ,1$3%)'37163%0%$3%$%)$6#)'*&<'$%&10%40$%&$3#$$3% #*)6%0)3%%$3#&:%%* <*&3%)#@%6#))%*$$$3%%*$0#7 #0&

/%'* &<'#$(* 0 )30$1 -$3% #0&-"1 36%2%01 ($ 6#) *$ 5$ %2#7<#$%&#*&$3%0%)<7$6#)&%'7#0%&#)>* #(0!%#*)?% %00(*5$$3% 7%$$%060($$%*:;$3%0(*'(4#7 $3%/'37163%0%$3%$%)$6#)'*&<'$%&1

00%5()$0#$(* $3%1 3%)<:@($$%&$3#$$3% #'$))$#$%&$3%0%(*#0% &(

%0%*$$3#*$3%

5$0%5()$%0%&#*&)(@(7#0()$3%4)($(*(*$3% '@@<*('#$(*&#$%&, A , 0@%*$0%/<4%0(*$%*&%*$$$3% #0&1 2(&%63('3$3%#*)6%0)3%%$ $3%4%$($(*%06#))%*$1$3%)#@%3#2(*5 :%%* <*&(*:<)3%)*%#0$3%)'37*'%$3%#*)6%0)3%%$3#&:%%*

<*&1$3%)#@%)3<7&3#2%:%%*%2#7<#$%&3%4%$($(*%0'#**$:% 4%*#7()%& 0#*;(00%)4*)(:7%#'$(**$3%4#0$ $3%)'37163%0%$3% $%)$6#)'*&<'$%& *$3%$3%03#*&17%#0*%&'<*)%7 0$3% #0&)<:@($$%&$3#$ $3%$%)$(*D<%)$(*6#):9%'$(2%$;4%*!)3%%$3%4%$($(*%01(*

#'$13#&)*#$'3%&3())3%%$#*&0%@2%&$3%)#@%<$)(&%$3%'%*$0%* )<'3#)($<#$(*1$3%0%)<7$ $3%4%$($(*%06#)0(53$7;'#*'%77%&6($3 >* #(0!%#*)?3%40%)%*$4%$($(*6#) (7%&:;$3%4%$($(*%0#:<$

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

'#*&(&#$%)1*% $3%'#*&(&#$%))*#$'3%&$3%'77%'$%& #*)6%0)3%%$)1$3<53)3%$0(%&$)#2%1:<$ (*#77;*%!)3%%$ 077 8

B B6#) <*&@())(*5163('3:%7*5%&$$3%4%$($(*%03% 0(*'(4#7 $3%/'37(@@%&(#$%7;60$%#7%$$%0$$3%/'*'%0*%& )4%'( ('#77;@%*$(*(*5$3%# 0%)#(& #'$)#*&0%D<%)$%& 0#44040(#$% #'$(**$3%:#)()$3%0% 1

, 6#)0%5()$%0%&* A , $%0 $6&#;)1*, A ,1$3%%*$0%/<4%0(*$%*&%*$)%*$$3%#*)6%0)3%%$

, $3%4%$($(*%0$$3% #0&@%*$(*(*5$3#$*)%#0'31$3%4%*) $3% )'37 <*&$3%#*)6%0)3%%$(*:<)3%)3%@#$$%06#)#7)0%40$%&$ $3%47('% 3%'*$%*$(* $3%4%$($(*%0$3#$*'%$3%#*)6%0)3%%$6#)

<*&1($)3<7&3#2%:%%*5$%2#7<#$%&136%2%01&*$ (*&#*;@%0($ (* $3% )<:@())(* @#&% $ () '7%#07; @%*$(*%& (* $3% 7%$$%0 :; $3% *2(5(7#$0$$3%%*$0%/<4%0(*$%*&%*$$3#$#*)6%0)3%%$)6%0%)*#$'3%& :; )@% '#*&(&#$% #*& * '<*$(*51 *% 6#) <*& @())(*51 63('3 :%7*5%&$$3%4%$($(*%03%&(

%0%*'%(*$3%2%0)(**$%&(*$3%

#*&$3%0%40$ $3%*2(5(7#$0&%)*$'@%$$3%0%)'<% $3%4%$($(*%0

0$3%0%#)*$3#$(*$3%7%$$%060($$%*:;$3%0(*'(4#7 $3%/'37$$3% 47('%1)#@% #'$)3#2%:%%*@%*$(*%&#)6%0%0%40$%&:;$3%*2(5(7#$0 $6#)*7;(*$3%

$3#$'@47%$% #'$)3#2%*$:%%**$('%&*! )3%%$1$3%#*)6%0)#0%> %)?0>?0@%0%7;>$('=E@#0=%&?*'%($() *$&()4<$%&$3#$$3%#*)6%0)3%%$ $3%4%$($(*%03#&:%%*0%@2%&<$

$3%'%*$0%1$3%0%()*%000(*$3%&%'()(* $3%#<$30($(%)(*'#*'%77(*5 $3% 0%)<7$ 0%)%*$7;1 $3% 4%$($(*%0 '#**$ 5%$ #*; <0$3%0 0%7(% #) #&@($$%&7;3%3#):%'@%2%0E#5% 0$3%0%#)*)@%*$(*%&#:2%1&*$ (*&#*;@%0($(*$3% 40%)%*$4%$($(*''0&(*57;1$3%)#@%()&()@())%& #9%)3 (*&#7"

<&5% ,