Ajaib Singh v. Pubjab Water Resources Management & Development Corporation Ltd & ORS


  

         

"#$%$&'(')* 
 +"',-')./ $#'#')$0 (!

1$0(2( /$2)+","#$0 $(20&$( ")".$3$)#")%$4$563$)# 060"#') 7'3'#$%")%#/$0(  $(6)%$)# (!

 *  87  - 9 7-  0$($)#*:

0 900";%4&"#$;0#/$6$#'#')$0 0-20';%4&"#$;00$(6)%$)#(  /$#/$0#/$ $60#$0(5&"5)$<(6"6$03"=,$"55<$%# ($$#/$+2%.3$)#>
 ,$0$$00$%##/$ $60#$00)# ? /$#/$0#/$+2%.3$)#(/25%,$0$60#$%')#/$%'.$(#> ::

::

7- 

7!

/$6$#'#')$0<"( <0@')."( "2,$<$55  6$0"#0') #/$ 0(#</'5$2)+",-#"#$2,$<$55 060"#')7'3'#$%(')&$A? # &3$(  2#  #/"#  %20').  /'(  ($04'&$;  "  0'3')"5  365"')#   
   B B<"('5$%"."')(#/'3"5).<'#/#/$0""&&2($%;</'&/<"(#0'$% "5).<'#/#/$-#"#$&"($/$5$"0)$%-2,'4'(')"52%'&'"5 ".'(#0"#$; "5$0@#5";  4'%$  +2%.3$)#    &)4'&#')  ")%  0%$0    ($)#$)&$  %"#$% 


B ))$C20$::
!;&)4'&#$%/'3"5).<'#/#/$0"&&2($%2)%$0 -$&#')(
; B")%  ")%"&&0%').5=($)#$)&$%/'3#2)%$0. 3"C'3230'.02('360'()3$)#0#/0$$=$"0("5).<'#/')$ 55#/$ ($)#$)&$(<$0$0%$0$%#02)&)&200$)#5=/$"66$"5'5$%,=#/$60$($)# 6$#'#')$0  "5).<'#/  #/$0  &:"&&2($%  "."')(#  #/$'0  &)4'&#')  <"( %'(3'(($%,=#/$5$"0)$%%%'#')"5-$((')(2%.$;-").020;4'%$+2%.3$)# %"#$%
?A

 ))$C20$::?!&&0%').5=;#/$60$($)#6$#'#')$0<"(

:
:

"00$(#$% ")% &33'##$% # +"'5  <$4$0; 5"#$0);/$'5$% &0'3')"5 0$4'(')  '$ 

      

 ,$0$  #/'(  20#;  </'&/  '(  5=').

"%3'##$% /$6$#'#')$0<"(65"&$%2)%$0(2(6$)(');4'%$0%$0%"#$%


 ))$C20$::A!7"#$0);4'%$0%$0%"#$%A
? ))$C20$:

:!;/$<"(0$')(#"#$%')($04'&$")%#0$"#$%#/"4$0$#'0$%03($04'&$ #/$ 060"#')<'#/$$&#03?
?)"##"')').#/$".$A=$"0( %3'##$%5=;#/$+,#/$6$#'#')$0'()#6$)(')",5$")%)5=0$#'0"5%2$( 6"=",5$"0$;.0"#2'#=;5$"4$$)&"(/3$)#$#& <;0$(6)%$)#
/"( 6"(($%#/$0%$0%"#$%

? ))$C20$:: !'$"#$0#/$0$#'0$3$)# #/$6$#'#')$0;</$0$,=)"&&2)#/'(&)4'&#')')"&0'3')"5&"($; </'5$')4@'). $.25"#')
"! 1!")% 1!#/$-$04'&$=7"<( #/$  060"#')  ')  (/0#  8#/$  =$  7"<(    #/$  060"#')8!;  /$  <"( %'(3'(($%03($04'&$<'#/$$&#03


B;</$)/$<"(&)4'&#$% ,=#/$5$"0)$%-2,'4'(')"52%'&'"5 ".'(#0"#$; "5$0@#5" /$(#")% #/$0$(6)%$)#('(#/"#)&$#/$6$#'#')$0'( &)4'&#$%;/$&25%)#,$0$')(#"#$%')($04'&$2)%$0#/$("'%0$.25"#') #/$,=5"<(#/$ 060"#') /"4$/$"0%#/$5$"0)$%&2)($50#/$6$#'#')$0;#/$5$"0)$% &2)($500$(6)%$)#(")%/"4$"5(&"0$255=.)$#/02./#/$'5$ /$  6$02("5    25$ 
"!    #/$  0(#</'5$  2)+",  -#"#$ 2,$<$55 060"#')365=$$(-$04'&$=7"<(;BB ')(/0#8= 7"<(    BB8!;  (/<(  #/"#  '#  '(  "665'&",5$  #  #/$  $365=$$(    #/$

060"#')")%#/$62)'(/3$)#3$)#')$%#/$0$')&"),$"<"0%$%##/$ $365=$$   <$4$0;  )&$  #/$  6$#'#')$0  0$#'0$%  03  ($04'&$;  #/$ 0$5"#')(/'6$365=$0")%$365=$$&3$(#")$)%")%;#/$0$0$;) 0%$0&25%,$6"(($%2)%$0 25$
"!#/$("'%=7"<(BB

:?:

/'( 20#'(')03$%#/"#0$."0%').#/$604'(')(;)</'&/ #/$("'%,=5"<("0$('5$)#;#/$2)+", '4'5-$04'&$( 25$("0$"665'&",5$

)%$0#/$2)+", '4'5-$04'&$( 25$(;#/$604'(')#%$"5<'#/(2&/ %$5')D2$)#0$#'0$%$365=$$'(604'%$%2)%$0 25$

 ,!#/$2)+",

'4'5-$04'&$( 25$(;1523$:; /"6#$0:;</$0$')0($0'2(&0'3$")% .0"4$3'(&)%2&#;"&2#')#/$6$)(')&"),$'36($%6$03")$)#5=00" (6$&''$%6$0'%")%0#/$5((&"2($%##/$%$6"0#3$)#;#/$0$&4$0=&") ,$$$&#$% ##/$'0(#')(#")&$;#/$62)'(/3$)#0%$0'#($5'('55$."5")% &25%)#/"4$,$$)6"(($%"#$0/'(0$#'0$3$)#03($04'&$;%'(3'((')./'3 03#/$%"#$/'(&)4'&#') /$5$"0)$%&2)($500$(6)%$)#( /"(0$D2$(#$% #/"##/$ 0$(6)%$)#(3"=,$"55<$%#60&$$%2)%$0 25$

 ,!#/$2)+",

'4'5-$04'&$ 25$(;1523$:; /"6#$0: "3#/$4'$<#/"##/$("3$3"=)#,$6$03'((',5$/$ 60$($)#+,'()#6$)(')",5$;#/$0$0$;)&2#')#/$6$)(')'(6((',5$ 20#/$0;  #/$  6$#'#')$0  <"(  &)4'&#$%  )   "  60'4"#$  &365"')#  ")%  ) 6$&2)'"0=5((<"(&"2($%##/$ 060"#')/$0$0$;0#/$,4'2( 0$"();)5((&"),$0$&4$0$%03/'3/$0$0$;'#<'55"5()#,$ 6((',5$#60&$$%"."')(#/'32)%$0 25$

 ,!#/$2)+", '4'5 -$04'&$( 25$(;1523$:; /"6#$0: /'( 20#;')#/$('3'5"0&'0&23(#")&$(;/"(#"@$)('3'5"04'$< ')



  



A

;

%$&'%$%)
B
! /$6$0"#'4$6"0##/$0%$0'(0$60%2&$%"( 2)%$0*:

/$6$02("5

 ,!3"@$('#&5$"0#/"#')&"($

6$)(')$0;#/$%$6"0#3$)#"560&$$%').(/"4$#,$')'#'"#$% "66"0$)#5=#%$#$03')$</$#/$0#/$3'(&)%2&#'(F.0"4$G0 </$#/$0#/$&0'3$</'&//$/"(,$$)&)4'&#$%;'(F($0'2(G #55<(#/"#<'#/2#/5%').%$6"0#3$)#"560&$$%').(;) 0%$02)%$0 25$

 ,!&25%,$6"(($% /$6$02("5#/$'362.)$%0%$0(/<(#/"#)(2&/ %$6"0#3$)#"560&$$%').(<$0$&)%2&#$%%3'##$%5=;"#$0 #/$&)4'&#')#/$6$#'#')$02)%$0-$&#')
B")%
 ;

#/$6$)(') '5$<"( 34$% ")% '# 0$3"')$% 6$)%')./$ 6')')#/$'(#0'&###0)$=7$."5<"("5((2./#")% 25#'3"#$5=#/$3"##$0<"(%$&'%$%)B ?
A'$)5="#$0 #/$0$#'0$3$)##/$6$#'#')$0##/"##'3$;#/$6$#'#')$0/"% "50$"%=,$$)0$#'0$%03($04'&$)? 
A")%"((2&/#/$ '362.)$%  0%$0  %"#$%  B ?
A  

  ,$').

&)#0"0=##/$604'(')( 25$

 ,!'(/$0$,=($#"('%$H #,$').(;#/$60$($)#<0'#6$#'#')'("55<$%/$'362.)$% 0%$0  %"#$%  

?  ))$C20$:: !  '(  /$0$,=  ($#  "('%$  /$ 0$(6)%$)#("0$%'0$&#$%#0$5$"($"55#/$0$#'0"5,$)$'#(##/$6$#'#')$0 <'#/'))$3)#/03#/$%"#$0$&$'6#&6=#/'(0%$0"5).<'#/ ')#$0$(#"##/$0"#$I;(#"0#').#/0$$3)#/(03#/$%"#$0$#'0$3$)# #'55#/$6"=3$)#

7- !

  


 (+@( /$#/$0(6$"@').0$"()$% * $( /$#/$0 $60#",5$ * $(