Ramesh Kumar & Others v. State Of Haryana And Others



  
  



  


   


 ! "# $ %&'

( ( 

)* %+

,-!-%& '

 ."/)"0

  

            

232

 

            
 '

4 5 ( 6
 66   7 4 5 6( 6
 678    !"#!$ #!%!&$'! (#  )*!+&+, !-!!.# ! !)!#/#!#!& ,& !-!!

 !*!"#!0&,& !-!! 1!02 0#&$'! (  345
/678995374:8; 66   71 ( 8 '!'%%*$+$"##.  #("##. &!!%!"+"'#*0#! '%%$'



4

#!)("$-#(!'!!)(%/67899537 4:8; < #*0#  #  !  &  #    !-  (  # *!'(!.(%!!%*(0!#% *0! 8=:=4:8;&  !  %"    >*  788&  !  "-  #  +! /%%''&#*0##>'0 .* '54( #!*2!" +0
/+!!$( !0%! '&895;
#!((!?#'(895;@&$.#'##  !  !

+'!  (  #    (  0  !  # % +%!(#'+!'#%  !#-!89A;&#! "%#-!+"'!%!00$(%>*79&.#"- #  '  /++'&  B#.!&  #!  $      %  (  #  . '(* '44
8!4<
4(#/&#*0##!

0 B!*-!0!&*#!#%!'! '0(#  *'!* 5 #-!89A;'+!(#!($++!0!+.! !!#!!,+ *!&#+!'B#.!&!& !0#

.!'!**#'(895;# '0(

 !!('#%!7 !.'% +"-# & "*  #   '$  #-'!+    .!    0  +$  "-  # '%   !*#-  ''&    !''!'  .#  #  '#%    #  '$#!#+&!'C*+-!++##!"!#!#+( "##!%! #-'!+ $#+!&!.! >0 #'#%('+! !#-!89A;#

'#!0.!+-((' !

&!&#+ #-'!+ .! *" = 0!0#'+!&#!%*+ ++0!& .#'#.*  D"+ * %/*# D"+ >/*/$+

!+ 84;8(89;:&+!?    



  



@& !#&!!84:<8994& .#("'%>!'#!(!0(##!( >!''+#!# D"+ >/*"$#!# !+'&/+!( +0& !-!!&%0 # (#!

++!* '54(#'(895;&!% "!&!&# 0#/*!+%0#. (+ "#!+((#

0#'#%('+!


 .$& !''*(#(!'#!#'+!+!#-!89A;&!# .! !#-!8994&#"-# D"+ >/*#+#! # 
  $!+". #0##+ '*+" + #

++!!$!+!0* '48(#'(895;

     
      


   
   


    
 



   
   
 


    

    

      
        !

  "# $  
 % 


  "
&  
'()*


+$    
 




 

"




   
      
  

  
     

      


  
#



,

  

  $
 

    +



 $ -
    +





      $ 

   .        

        
  +



     /  


  $ $
    
      +




 
 
 $
     $  


   0

      
 ( 
1  


 $-$


 

   
 

 
    
 $  
   
 #  


 




 
    2 3 #    !  #  #!"!  (  #  $++!0  (% <::989A;++!! $# *+!&!>

'+!(89A;&!!('+!#-. *

!''0#'#%"-#'% !*#-'' *0# # !##!"!("##$++!0 #!$'*'#!+#*!!'*'&'+*0 *".++'$# '$(+&.#'#%!-(!++##!( # !''0#'+!'#%(89A; A 6#  #    '!%    ).  #!  #  !*#- ''&-0% +%#(*''+!'#%(89A;& #-*"%! !!4::34:8<##/#(&

!-!!6#!'.!!)"-#!*## !& #-*/674=A<374:8<&"(#/*#/*#*0#! %!4=884:8<'#',!+&/+!&

!-!!'# !(# .#(%# !(' (##!"'%>!'#!(

!

, 
    $         

     


  
      
  3
   

    5  

/
 

 ()6*1

 
 
      +



           
        ,
      
    




 7
   

  
  
   

  
,
    
+




  
  

     
   
   
  
 
  
  
 

  

  

    
   
  4

 



  
 
   
 


8"+ 

  96 :(;3
      
5  






    
   <  <   

  $    

  
  
 


  ,
      
  $ 
 =  $
   
 





 

 

      
  5   






  
  -
  



 

 $  

  1 

     
 $

$(:(  :(; ,  

 


 









5  


+  >    - 
  
       

     -  

 
 
 >   $ 



 
 


 2 ; # !0!!

!'##/*#*0##(+0 /6783<8874:8A#! .! (.#!'#

"

!*#''& !#(!+.#! (.%# (%#!(' (!'(' -(# 9  >*79&# ''&!!0

'0>'*#'+!'#%(89A;&#* &#

!0!!

!'##/*#*0##(+0/678=A=97 4:8;!49:34:8;#/**'!!-# (*# '0.# '% +%!(#'+! '#%(#-!89A;8=:=4:8; #!*#-''&7 !((%!$+-'
>*788#!

+'! !(#

  '#!++00  #  !'  (  #     ''&  #* % +%0#'+!'#%(#-!89A;>*788#! "'#!++0"(#/* 6 666   5 

65   6 8: #+!'*+(# #!*"%#!# '(+!'#!

+&#*("# ''& % +%#(!+E'+!'#%(#-!89A; (*# *"%#!'+- !

!%! '(+$-(

#-'!+ #!#+''&.#.#%*'#

'+!"+$#'+!'#%&!& #* !('.#'#''*%( '44(#'( 895;/C*+-&#*"%#!#!*% ( #-'!+  $#!'(+!&.#'##."'!%!0#! #+&!#!#!'(#!#+.#"'% !++#!!'(+!&!#!$ #$&!& #*#!!$ *'# "*.#!  


#



#*'%%'0(%895;* +.#!!#"*"-((+*> (% !"+*+#$$7!7$# '$! #+'' 88 /C*+-&#+!'*+(# *"% #!#!!$ '!"*+>' #*0#!*(

"'%0*!0!#+$!!#+&.##!$ !*%!$ &$#!

!'(+!#(&!

'#!++0!+%!>*79 6 666   5 

6 
65 84   #  #  #!&  +!  !  '*+  *"%  #!  # '+!'#%.!(!+E#-!89A;&!''!'.##

$(#'(895;&!&# !##!"!! ++0!+ (#!

 566   6 66  5 

65   6



  5 

6 
65 8< !0(#!"$>!'&!%!"-# D"+ >/*&*(+#!#"-# D"+ >/* *"#%!"-#/*.#"-%#'#!++0 %!"-#!00$# !* '54(#'( 895;&#*"-#/+!(('''&.#"-#%'! "(#%* '54(#'(895;"'!%2' 85  $&!+!

!#!#"-&# D"+ > /*  #!  "$  #!  #  '#!++0  %!    #  7 !0  !

     #  !

  (!+E  '#%  !+  "'!%  %

#+' !(7 !"'!%'# %!*'#!0&!*'#&# D"+ >/*"$#!-#

$

 $!+".#0##+'!"+%( ' 48(#'(895; 8= B #!! %!-& %!00$! #+* /674=A<374:8<"(#/*&!&#!. &#!"$ >!'.!%!&#*.#"-'. !* # ',!+&/+!& !-!!&!#0$!'(#

 **!'#!%!'&#% *0#! " !.#"-# !(# 7!00$! #+#!"% 83 # ('$-
 #  &!& #   $+$&  *  #  !%!"+-  ( '  "'%0 !!#!'(# ''&#*#*0## !.0  (  >*  79&  .#"-  !%   !  %!    '*' %!'! ( #  * & !&  #"- * +- * ''$+$-( #-'!+ #!#+&$.# +!.(*+!!# #-'!+ !*%"-#!#+&   .#%  *'#    !    !++&  !&  .#  .  "*      # % +%!(#'+!'#%#-!89A;&!#. #+0$ #$ 8A !++-!

!#!#
* !&! !"-# /*/674=A<374:8<#!" ! # D"+ >/* %!)0'
* !&* /$+

!+ 84;8(89;:&.#"-#

D"+ >/*!(!((%0# !"-#/*&* #+ #    !  "-  #  /+!  (('  ''&  .#"-   %# %!* '54(#'(895;&!#

%

D"+ >/*%(!!

 ! *#'#%( '+!!!.#+#



 8; $&!+'#
* !& !"-#

D"+ >/*&#!#'#!++0#7 !0%!# '(%  '+!  '#%  "'!%  #*0#  %&  "*  -  #

D"+ >/*(*0#!
 $!+".#! #+#*"'%+&#*0##'*0#!

++!! $!+%&! '" '48(#'(895;&#"- #!%. $$7!7$#!00$!#+ ''*+!+-&#"-!

!#!#
* !&!"'!%

!  "-  #  /*&    .   
* !&  .!  '*  #*0# *

(#!"$'&!"'!% !"-# D"+ > /*'C*'&!

!#!#'
* !&!+! 
 
 #'

* !& !"-# D"+ >/**  /$+

!+ 84;8(89;: 89 /C*+-&  #  %!+    !  '%     # % *0>*788&.#! !%(!  

 $' !"-#/*/674=A<374:8<&#"-''%!+-( #!!#(!$*!"+# *(!$*!"+ #%&-#-!+0!++-'C*!+&#!%"0 ! 0!(#'
* !& !"-# D"+ >/* /$+

!+ 84;8(89;: 4: #(!'(#!"$&#/*(#$.#!$!+ '#!++0!%!"+"%!>*788&!#!'(#





48 #(*#)0!(%!)0!-('.# #% *0!>*&0!+$!E(%#(!'*%&#!# D"+ >/*&.#+ !0
* !&%!)0! "$!&#! #  0$!'  !  "-  #  !  #+  ''&  +!0    # !"+-  (  7 !       #  '+!  '#%&  !# "'%0  2'  "-  #  /+!  (('  ''&  #*  "0 !%!"+("0$'#*0##!

++!!$!+%&! # '48(#'(895; 44 #(&' '44(#'(895;& $ .#(  "'%  >!'  #!(&  #  !  (*#  !

++!  ! $!+%&!$!+!"+#!00$(%#2'! %! "- # /+! ((' ''& * &#  # '+!  '#%  *+!+-&  .#  #  D"+  >  /*&  #*

'0    %!)  !$!+!"+    #    #  !  !

++!  ! $!+%&!!"+#%'!!'#!++0#&! "'!% !"-#/+!(('''&.#"-#2' # #  7 !7!++%!''*0# '+!'#%

& '  (  (  )& +  %('  1  


?
    $ 

   
 
 


 


 


 ,3"# $.

 0(**6%@3,,(**6'
      

 

$


 $     


 

        



 A    
  

B  
 




% '  
  $   $



   
; "# $.

 0 (**62 4< #(&+-#!!

++!!$!+%&( #-.!#!0
* !&#*#'*!"+%&!#"'% !$!+!"+"'%'*"-#!00$ .$&!

!#!- '#%!)0(#
* !&"-# D"+ >/*/$+

!+ 84;8(89;:&#!00$''&'#!$!+ #!!

++!!$!+%&!##-*)(+ *-+0 !&.#!(#-.+(+/674=A<37 4:8<&"(#/*&.#&#!"$ 

'.

!"-#/*&.#'#*"C*+-+C*!++-+0!++-('$ "'%0 !#+$! ! 45 C*+&'! (+%! '" '48 (#'(895;&(#!00$''&!$!+0#!

++!! $!+  %&  !  '"    '  48  (  # '  (  895; *+!+-&.#!

!#!# '"# (+%! #!> &*+!+-#! $%$7!7$#!00$ "-# D"+ >/*&#*'!"!#!0"'%!$!+"- #   4=

'!+-&#!2*'>'!"+&#*( %!)0)0.#(!+E'+!'#%">' !).##* !('&!%( '44 (  # '  (  895;  #  !  (  !++.0  #  !"$  )0 )0+-%!!&(%#(!'*%&#!'#"-! *C* (+$+-*(!'&!%0#!#+''&#"-#



! *C*(+&.##!%!"+("0! !%!"+("0!2*'!* "-#!*#'% +! * '54(#'(895;&#"-!-!2*'!!%!"- #!*#'% +!* '54(#'(895;$7!7$ *'# *C*(+&!#%!)*'#!!2*'!" "-#2*'!+'((#>'!"+2*'$ #%* '54(#'(895;/!+-&%(#$' %!"-# *++B'#(#/*'!+!F* + )   , - 

,'. ..

 / 012&      34   , 4 #&+$! !!0!

#.#("'%>!' #!(&!##2*''!-C*(+.#'# !!%0#!#+''&#*!(#* !( $*'!)0 +!'%( '44(#'(895;& ">'+-"-#/$+/*('% 2*'"-# !*-(*%''

 
 


 

$   $     
   < 
  
   $    
 8

   


 
 




 
C  
 CC  C      
 5 "



  


?


 
   8

      
    
8 

     

  
 


 

   

  < 

     

C  
 C     <   


      
 5 "



 1  
        < 

8

   




((()D(        

  
  



        
 5 "



 $
 

    
#







    8
#






$ $  $  

$  
$  

 #



8

 

       
          

 
  


  
1 
 <
  8   
2 43 #!(%!)0#''+*%(%#(!'*%& #!.##!!!#!!0!#'#!++07!"+#*0# $'!(2*'* '48(#'(895;&#"-.# !#!0
* !&!#* !(#'!) +!'& '!++- .##* !('!) +!'%( '44(#'( 895;&".##!'''*  '48(#'( 895;*+!+-&#"-.#+-!(#'% +0D"0 %!$7!7$'#%  !'(%$7!7$7 !%! "-!-(('&#*#+$!%"0%!"-#!00$ ''&"(#(('!'% +! '48(#'( 895;&#*#* !

('%( '44(#'(895;& !#!) +!'#(&!+-.#+-!#!!0# 2*'* '54(#'(895;&>'!"+"*#! 2*'>'!"+.#!('% +0D"0%! !##* !('!) +!'%( '44(#'( 895; !+-!+.#* !('&#!

+!0!#.)!"+-(%!!( '54(#'(895; !#    #  !  $  #  2*'  "*    #  $!+-  (  %7



!++%*!++%%!#!#+''& %  (  #  $'  %!   * + )2  3'4&  !# >'!"++-"-#/$+/*('% 2*'!*- (*% 4A '!#!0( !0(#$'"-# D"+ > /*/$+

!+ 84;8789;:&#$'(# *++B'#(

D"+ >/* * + )2  3'4&.!('& #(&!&".##!% *'$7!7$# !00$    $' 
* !&  !.  "-  #  D"+  >  /*&  #* $+-!%"!*+!+-&#'+*(#$'!."-#

*++B'#(#/*#+#(*++#+&!&#"-#%- !$!+!"+#!00$&>' 0#!00$*0!'$+* "(  #  2*'!++-  '%   /$+  /*  ''&  (  # #"(  )0  !  '+!!-  '&  #    #  "!  (  #

('0+$# *!'(+!&#*0#!$ & #'+!%0!'+!!-'C*!#!++%%!# '(0#&* !%( '44(#'(895;&!# *((0(%!0(!++!'-&!%*'#!&#"-# '$2*' !'(+!&"'%!#%!2  4; #+0#(#!"$&#/*(#!#' /++'('#'+!'#%&#*0#>* 79  /678995374:8;&  !& >* 75  /678=A=974:8;&  #! *!"+-!% *"# #-'!+ (#!#+ $  #   *  !'  (  +!&  #(  #  !>* 
* !&  ! C*"C*!#&!&!*'#>*79/67

!

8995374:8;&!&>*75/678=A=974:8;!C*!#&!& !&"*>*788/678995374:8;!((%&!&* #+ 49  (!''0+-

66   7

 

( ( 

678   *:; !:

   : *: "

!< )=-&>?" )!%& $'

 !?% : *: "

" <%"*).; '

 !?%