High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2215/2025dismissed

Padma Rani @ Padma Singhal v. Ram Sewak Since Deceased Through His Lrs

2026-03-10Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal10 pages

!"#$%$ &'()(*

' +, ( -.

/, !" # "

$% "# "

!" # "

'"# "

& 000 -.

/,1( ,

&( ) *+ ,- *,*- .$ / & 0 ! 1."

) *2 ,- *,*3 .$ / &/# ! ! 0# "1." .$ / & .$ &&& .$$ & &&

,4 ,5 *,54 * & # $"

.& + && & .$ $ &&& &

,4 ,5 *,54 %

&& # " &

3 + &

$. " # &

6 "

* % 01. && 7 2%3$ 4 &"( % &8 +5"5*"-,,9: & 52"-,",,,9: #. $ & 8

; " 3"-,",,,9:

.$$ & <*- ,5 *,54 5-",,",,,9: $ 8 %

. " % " ,4 ,5 *,54 & + 5 =#

" .8 .& ,4 ,4 *,5> ;*? 5* *,54" . & 55"4*"-,,9:" & & 55",,",,,9:#.$ && $ 8 = # . & 4*"-,,9: . ,5 5, *,5? @ #"

& " & 52 55 *,5?.$ *, 55 *,5? &

$" & .$ $ & & & # ,4 ,4 *,5>" &8& 8 + * =# && $.$

& & . & 8 .$ & = " $ .) =#

+ & ..$ && =

.8. ,4 ,5 *,54" .& "

# & @ #" $

# % # . " $ # " 2-",,",,,9:&

*-,,< $"

& 2"-,",,,9: . $ 3"-,",,,9:

.$$ & < -",,",,,9: % &8 ,4 ,4 *,5? ,4 ,4 *,5> .$ && % . >-"-,"-,,9:

3 5 =# &&"

" 3 * =# & $ .& A8# "% ,? ,4 *,5?"

,4 ,4 *,5?". && .

3 + =# < & 3"-,",,,9: . && $ -",,",,,9:

3 3 = #

" && . # " & " " & && & &

3 - =& #

. .$ &&

& &. ; $ .) . $" & "

3 4 ;" - 1 " &

& :

5( /2 26 274 $& $!!$%& $ 4"! 6"#6 !

7 %%%%$ &89:

9 !%7#$!$#76! 6;

&# &" !

<#3 $ & !% 4"" %76 9"! 6=

( /2 26 2 %3$ ! 2 74 $& $!! $% &

;

$& 84$& 276%& ! 6;= )( /2 26 2 74 $& $!! 2 % # &# 4" ;

6$ 4!

# % &"& # ; 2# 36 :$ 2#4 & &"%= >( /2 26 274 $& $!!%2 ?& 4 #3%%

&"$ &"

& # 3% ! # $ & !$4 276%& %3$ = (

4$!(@ ## ?

/ #) *2 ,- *,*3" &.$ & ) #) *+ ,- *,*-"

> = #

& " !" # " . &

$ .

/ # # $ & .$ && &

A8 05 " & 05" .

" = . 52"-,",,,9: ." &&"

.8"

&8& 8 & ,4 ,4 *,5>"

$& 8

2 5

& . && # $ $

& $#

" 2 *

& :

8 & . $ $& :8 2 +

8 8 # 88.$ & . * &

. .$ && & 2 3

# .$ &

&& 8

.&..$ &&

2 -

..& . " "# A8 5" . 5-",,",,,9: .& . 2 4

$ .& .$ && 5,

& ."

!" % / " # # ) " .& $ 5, 5

. & &

$& . &

. # .& ". $ #& " $ .$ &05

$ *&& . &

* "&" B * # &

&& = # . .$ & 5* 8

$ # %

B ' ' "# $8 A# " & 8

&& % && &. * $ # && 5+ &

$. % && & && . :.

8 #

% &

&& .

& C " & & $ . & & & .. #"$ #$ &8 A# "& A8 505"

8*05 . . & #

" & "&

=& .

# $

" $

# . = &"& & " $ $ *

5- ."88.$.

% 8 8.$ & .

&" 88.$ && = 8 ##&# "

A# "&

$ #

> .$ 8 .$ &" /

.$ .$ && # &$ # .

% $

.8" .

. % & / 6 / " % / 1

/ " 5?

& .$ &" .

5> / 8 & # & && A# A8 * A8 + $ # $ # $ A8 5

A8 *D A8 + $

. & # # .& .& &8" $&& =

#& & &8.

& .$ @ (.

8/ A%-$6B &"3% 6$%&B( (, "(?(A%-& #2 43 $ &% (, "(1>

$?$4 )C(

*, A# " && $ # & " & & .$$ &&& & *5 $. #" & " & && & & "# & =

& "

$ # C " & ** & $

&&& $

$" & & *+ . " & ..& &

$ *3 = 2 66%7 &"&# "3#

$ & 4&% $ $ & ?((3& %2D2 6 &" & 26@ " * " @ (.

8 / &

5E( <<< <<< <<< <<< /2&?61 %3$ $%!$4":$ 2 #4 $;

%(11A

&" 8 ?$%7 $"89# %2 :

6"% &9 &% # $ &1 2# 36 ;3% $& $;

2 % ; 2 F36$%"$# $ & 4 &# ; < 7 ;& ?6$!9 2 &% # $ & &" 2 ?$ 4

$ & !

# $ &*G ! 2&# ; <# 1$! &91 /2&?61 &9%3#2$&! 6;

$ &$%6#$?"$ 26!6 ;

2# 36 6 26:$%1 236$%"$# $ & 4&# ; < 2 6$ %2 44

D 776 76$

% 7%89! 44 :$&B 2"376 #%%$&4 :1 /2&?61 %3; ! %(11A &" 8 ?$%#4 $;"

87 $"89# %2 :

6"%# &%$"6

$ &! 6# &?9 &# ! &9 $;; ?

8476 76 9$& " #3;& 76%& "! 66B$%

$ &1

2F36$%"$# $ & 438 B$% 6%2 44$& $;

2% ;

5, F36$%"$# $ & 4&# ; <3 2 6$ 9:2 %2 44! 44 : 2"3 76 #%%$&4 :8! 6

D$&B &9 # $ &1 /2&?61$ # ;% 2D& :4"B ! &9&# ;

<3 2 6$ 9

%3; ! %(11A 6 8 ?2 %8& $"89:

9 !# &%$"6

$ &$& &9 &% # $ &64

$&B &9 $;; ?

84 76 76 9 !6 ; &9 26 % 36# 6 "36$&B # 36% !% 6#2 6 %%%%;& 76 #"$&B%1 2!

$436 ! 6B$% 6$&B 2 6$ 9%2 44886 3B2 2D& :4"B ! 2$! #6

69 ! 2

! 6 $&$ $

$&B 776 76$

"$%#$74$& 69 # $ & $&% %3#2 !!$#6:2 !

$4" $& $;

2 &% # $ &%(@ *- =" & " #& & *",,",,,9: " "/ ) = %80 #&$ $ #

& *42 %*?50 = %8"5245 % . # *4 ' # $ &" & ) = %8

&$ " *?

"&$" & -.

6#21* ) 9

F .