Union Of India And Others v. No 1082014a Ex Dfr Lakhwinder Singh And Another





    
    

  

 !"#$# % %& 




     

  !

"



  #$  '&  ()'

 *
*

* +

  ()'

 *
) +
 %$&'( ) * +*,*- *./.

0+#1
 *

* +

 ,- ).

   +%+  +  *  3  #-  +  #  + #*'0+%*$0+$$*$4 5678 *#*$&'+.*$,$9 &*.99$-3+&' +  #$  3*  %*$  +  &0  0  $%  00-  +  0 9,#%+$*&.'.,:7*7:$*&.'#

"

/ 0 "123 /%4

#$3*..$+,' 4;<

*$3*$9+*%$0,:930=; />+ $9+*%  0,  +  :9-  +  #$  3*  %*$  0..3% $*&.'&0*.%3++$

   

      



 = +#$0.$-&0+ &*.99$ *+0+%*0&00&*$&*$%1$%00$*&.' .,0,=?;?304  +*$*##.9*3* *..3$:$$$*$4 5678 +#*: #*0+*$$6*9$+*0
  

 

    

      

             !       "  " 

 

 #$ 

       !"" # $%&'' " 

# &     ( !) * " + ,' -# # ##

.

  +!/, ! -

 

# 0

.%  *%%:$  0, +  *0  $-  +  #7
0$*+*0.$+*%*+*3# */56#$$# %$ ! 70 3%4" /%$0! 3 78 # # %3$ ; +-+.*$9.0+#7
 0$*0+$580:*@$%,&'+ A&. #6/-3+&'-  

       

    

 0+&,+*:30 +6#.*0.*3,*$+-+.*$ &*.99$ +.$+*:9$+%*0**+#$0+ '* 4 *..'-*09>$&,*$#**%*#+ ;*$40+:$9$$&'+ A&.#6/9*

 .$*
) !''1 2222  +!

$, 34+
-

      # 5  6# #7& 8

9 3 $&-$9$$=  +*$#**%*#+;*$4 &9,6*9$+*0 $ ! "        %     &  "  

 '   "   (  '   " 



) %! " (*#   

 "

   " +   %    

 "   

  %    ,         "     "

 "    " "

&" -"  #      #        %                   

 %         % 

 .

""        

   / #  

"      .#           

         -" %%

"        

 

 "       

 0   

  1"   %    

    

               " 0 "

%   )  1" 23" 

      1"    

  

  

    
 

 

"    1"

   

  !  2  3"   

   &"

        

  

    " %       

 

         

   % 



 " %   

 "

  "  4 B *$%0#**%*#+;0+:$95#*89.*.' $9+0*9+*9**'9.*,+&'+:90$.*' *$.*9+-+.,*.'*009%+*##:$$0*&. %+>*+*,'#.-&.*%.'#*',706* 0  #*'    #-  +&'-  +  *$  $.*'$  9.*,-  *+  +* &9,%*%+3*'@9$-+->$&*..3$-&3+ *0+*+**0#&%9$#*#$0+ '*#+$*00.%0+3#  +*$9*#**%*#+4+0-+#6/ $9.*$+*+ %+/3*@0$$9+.*0 **0#9:%*#$04'**$+*3+  < +*$:3*.*##*+*:&*99#$* @$%,&*%
) !''1    +!

$, 34 +
) -1 

  - # 3& )

8

5  6# # 7& %#"

##

   +.:*#**%*#+3+0* 6*9$+*0 5 

 

"





"



"  ! %



 "% , " "





 6 '  



# #  ' # &   &
, ,# :"&     "&  & "& ",#$ #  ' # ,&  

!23" #   

2

  

  " %"    

  

          "   %  

  

     "  " 

    23"     

"   

  "

   "" , )$      ' #/"# $&   & # '    & '   + , 

  %# 

  

    6     

     

    

   23"   "

" 

 !  

  

 "   

  */56#$$# %$ ! 70 3%4" /%$0! 3 73$8 %4%   +++*$-+.*$9.0+#$ &,+*+*0*$@$%,**##.9*&.+* 9*-  *  +  ,,&  0  +  $09  9,&**  *&.+,  3* *.*$'9#0+$*&.'#*$+*+$3,0 +*##&0+9+%+,*C%0$%5800-+ 3.$.'.*@0*&.9*#  ##0+*%,-+#.*9$.*9*+ D$%  E9+  @$%,  #*$  &'  +  A&.  #6  /-  

< 4-9*.$* 9#%43*#%27:$ %# % !
%4#  %4

73$-3+9+ #9#088 0 ;;

 ! *%$ + .:*#**%*#+0+*$:$9*6*9$+*0
!    " *   7  

) / ! " 8 - 

 3     *)9

5   



       "55!! " 

%        



"&  &"

 "         

    

% ! "        



  "

     #### #### + 

         

      ! "       #     

        

   ! "     :

  ;6

  "      

           

    "     

 55  

  "&  &"

  "     %  

 +   "        

    % 

55< 5  

   

     9 4
%!3%"$ ! 7#$ /3    +%+-:&.'9**'$.*'$,*$&'+ *%%:$3+&'*9+*..%9*$*$9.%$#*$ &'+99$-+#-+*%0*$.*'$,&,*C +*,&+&'+:90$.*'*$.*9+ 3:-+ 69#+*&:#9#.-*.$+%+:$99$$&' +#6/9*.$*5  6# #7& 8

9  $&+ ,' -*$9*.$*3& )

8

5  6# #

 7& + ,' -%+*-'+$09#.99$-&9,% .$706*0#:7*7:+,-&3+*0+$ +*+*$&9$.'0*#$0+'*0,+ $*00.%0+# = E+**,*'-*0+69#:+#* 6*9$#**%*#+-*99+:$95#*8$$&'+ #6/-+6-+*9**$0*&.%+&9, :$+*%%:$-+#-+*$:,0*$0*&. %++*%%:$-+3.$0.*9%*9 9*  0  *9  :7*7:  +  *%%:$  .*.'-  +&'  + $.*'$*%0*9.*,-+3.$**9+*++&* 0.,*+&'*'##$:90$.*'*$.*9+ 3.$009:.'

09**,&.%&.9C*%*+%*%0 +0...0+*%%:$   $,%3+++9*0*93+9+*99$ :7*7:+##$+3**9%*9 9*0*9&$0$,%3++*+:'9#- *$0*&.%+:$+##$-+&'- 9*'&*,$+0*9,+*-+.

A&.#6/9*.$*( %# % !
%4# :$

69

3A- #$ * %0#%-$9$$  -3+- *$9.**,*$+6-+*+&00$%00-

*+  +*    &9,  $3$    +  99$  +  .:* #**%*#+*99+:$95#*8*6*9$+*0 7-       '

(   1"     %"



  

   " "

    "   " "  



   "    %     %    ".

 !  '

(  "          

    3 "  9 '

(05<0='>.3(  

"      ?      = @%     

          

        %          )   /

>  %  "  %    

     )   /  >      % $+ %   "      +    "&"'

(

  '

(             ".

   

   

  <! 

    , 23" 



! "  

             

  ; +0-9+*$$0*&.%+&9*,:$ +##$-#-+,*C%0+:$9&'+#6 /-9*.$* ( %# % !
%4# :$

69

3-$/83 .  >.-+$9.**0.*3,*$+:$95#*8-3+$ *009:%+&9,$3$:7*7:+99$-+

. &:$ .*.'-+$3,0+*$%+-:7*7:+ 99$-  +  &9,  +  9  0  +  +0, $,%-  3++    #,#  >.  +  *+  +  # #$*$*9.*,-*$-*$,+3+ 4

9  +  :$9  5#*8  &9*,  #9$     *$+#$*$,0+*$:$9-+* ,&0+ &*.99$-+'*  +%+-+ #$,0+:$95#*8$$**#,#, #*9+-&*$*,.'*0*$.*'0*& =F  '*  *C%  #.*9  3:-  3+  +   $3,  ,*$ +$:7*7:+##$-&**..'90$* $0*&.  %+  >*  +,  +0-  3+  +  $0*&.  %+ :$+##$*++%+:$95#*8& 99,*.' *.  90$  *  9  *$  9%  9*  0 *9 >* + # #$  .*.' *. +$ * $0*&.%+&9*,:$+ ##$0 + C%>*+*##$%00&%,*$+0*: B

:  +3  9  +  $9.**  0  .*3  ,*$   :$95#*8,*C+*$$9.**&*6#.*0.*3 ,-+&'-+6#.*0.*3,-*,*$:$9 5#*8*.,*C++$90$&0:7*7:+ $09  #.  99$-  -    

-  *.  .  + 99$-+**',C+%*%0+$3,*

  ,*$+$-*$+*-+0..9,#.,-*#. +$-&$#9:0+&*0$.*'*$.*9+

#% 0 343 ! 7#$ /3   *0,*+-+/0$,+3# *$  3+  +  &:*  *0*$-  +  *,    $,$  + ,#%$$,**$*$*00,$ <

9+,*9*.0+*&$9$$-+-*..+ #$%*##.9*58-0*'-*.*$58$#$0     -*

* +

.

 -) +
.

 

 C*:%+ 7 73$8 1#%2<3 $ %4 & $< 7 7338 3

& $<