Ciis Educational Services Society v. State Of Punjab And Others
! " # "
$%&'
(
$%&'
)((*
$%&'
!
+
)
$%&'
)( *
$%&'
)
$%&'
"
+
$%&'
#
" ",,-
( $ !%&'$()*+% #,-%!'' $
'$()*+% #,- !#* '
!.!- &%!/
0! 1
%/ %' 2
0!
%!
0!! 0 %/
0!
3 2
% ! 1 0!
& . / 0 $ 1'
-
1
4 1
.
5654504787085890445:0;:8<905654: 5654= 5<;7 - 1
0
.
;;669
) 5<;5
5=;55<;6
2 >
1
2
1 1
0
1
&3 5 -
2
;<;9*
;8* 1
# 0"
?
2
;9<43<8
1
@ A
1
B
0 1
% > % >
- 2
;9=43=8;
-
1
21
B
:-
0 20
3
2
( ;
1
1
+
1
2
1
2
2
,
+
! 0;96= 2
0
C
1 1
=- 2
1
2
- * 2
&3 .
( 5
D$
6-
1
2
56<7;969
1
2
5- 1&3 ! " # "
" #
#$
# % "
# " &
"" & " " "# ' #
# % ( #
# ) ##
* " "
& + , "# - (
# + .
/ 0 1 " " & # + .
+ ,
2 2
7(
1
2 56<7;969
- 2 1 2
1
4 %
+
! 0;97; 2
1<=<6;97;
1 8- 2
4
;97;! 1
1 1
!
; 0* <:<7;976 -
323
1
0 1
1 2 5:<;;94: <8<6;94:
0 2
1 .( ;;:: ;747 ;94:- 1
1 1
1 2 ;4<8;94:0 2
2 56<7;969-
0
0
1&3
3 4# 3 % -$( $"'+ ..55.6/5
4# " 3 4 3 # 4# "
"# # # .678977
:# $ ; < #= 3& .678 8 >&.677 0 & 3 # ? "# #
" 2 2
9-
1 B
+
! 0;96=
B
E
!
;96=! 1
0
1
&3
( 4 $"$ & " 3 #" # $"$
@" &
# 4#
" 3 % #
4 4 :# $ ; < #= 3& .6*.
< 3= 4 0 A
" &" "$
3 # 4# , * .6*7 "
3
$ & A & ?
# 0
" #
0 3
$ #"
#
* 8 3 0 "
B # " 4 # " " " #
$"$&
2
;< 2 2
2 ;4<8;94:
10
1
20
3 2
56<7;9691
1
;;- 2
56<7;969
2
4
;97;!
1
1
E ;5!
0
F 3
1
1
1 1
2
<=;5;9861
2
2
$'
+ 5*8/ .618 <? C 3 "
A
&:# D C3 = 6- "
*
>
4
&3 &
/ 3"
+ .
+ ,
# 94 0 #
$ "
E &3 .6*.$.87/
2 ;:- 2 1
"
*
;:3*
;97;! 1
>
11
;97;!
1 2
2 0
2 0
-
1
*
&3 ' "
" # .59? 3
# # 94& 0 # 94 4 & F # "
# #
" 2 ;=- 2
1
2 ;4<8;94: <=;5;986
0
;;
;97;! 1
1
1
1
2
1
2
2 ;6 (
1 2
2
;99=0 2
E
2
21
2
% 2
!
1
1
# 1
2 :<<;5<<9 3=C7 1
1
1
2
1
0
4 1 >
2
!
1
1
;;
! - 2
1
2
0
2 G F
1
G 4 ;7$ 2 0
323"
" "
0 "
2 0
;9<95<;;7
2
-
2
&3 . ' ,7 * .676
?& 9D# &?
" # " GB
, ' ,<#=GB
) 5 ' "
"
# 4 :# $;3
,* H. .67HGB 8 ' 94
A
I .. "
" ,7 * .676G 2 ;4 -
( ;
2
'
G 2
!"##$%&
56<7;969
1
'
'4 9E93J C50
2
1
H
.
0
0
5:<;;94:
1
56<7;969 1
1 E
2 ;4<8;94: -
( 5
2
+
20
(
I 2 G
5
;97;
! ( :1
1
257<;;96<
1
2
2 ;8!
( =0
41
'
2
2 :<<;5<<9
> #CB ( . ( ::5= ;99=
0
;9-
F
1
!
"
0 "
2 0 0 B
1
323 !
!
0 2
<=<65<;5 8
1&3 3 ## # # ### ## # " &" > .671976 +#
4 .67797*& .6*59*8& .6*69/H& .6/89/7&.6/691H&.618918&.668967&.6669,HHH ; $+#
IA 0 " ,7 * .676
A
3 ;3&
% # 0 " ## ,* H. .67H 0 " "#
" ,* H. .67H " & & #"
#
2 5<-
!
!
2
1
5;.
55-
1
56<7;969
4
4 ;;
;97;!
2
D-
1
1
56<7;969 >
5:E
1
1
;4<8;94: <=;5;986
1
5= * 1
2
0
2 2 56- 2
1
+
! 0;96:1
2
<9<;;96=
:
!
1
2
2 0
2 0
2 0
0 0
0
J
1
! " 1
0
=
2
H
8
!
@$"$ "
4 " # 3A 57- ;96:!
1
,
+
! 0 ;96=0
<=<:;966 -
1! 1
;96:
! 0
81
1 54 2
;96: ;96=! 1
@ 2
A
! '
10B
1
2
2
1
1
1
1
2
6; 0
2 >
I!
(
G
I
G1
! -
1
1
1
1
2 0
;96: ;96=! 1
1
- 2
0
1 >
58 1
1
*
' (
) *+*,-./0/#"10
2
>
B
&3 <.=' #"
" K 4 % F " " & " & %
" 3 " 4 <,=' %
4 & %
* 3 F
" " " 4 " ' %
% % 3
F "
# " #
F #
&
"
<5=%%%%%%%%%%%% <8=%%%%%%%%%%%% <7= ' 3 % %
#
<*=%%%%%%%%%%%% </=3 % 4 "
" 59 233 4(+ ! / ## " 0 2
=83! /
>
+ 2!
E
@"# % " ; 3 4# $& " $"$
4 &## # 0
4 $"$ # &
#
0 & 4 $" $ A :<!
2 ;96: ;96=! 0
>
8
1
2
- 1
!
> :;3 0
8
!
1
2
1
2
0 20
60 1
2
21
-
0B 0
21 1
1
! :5 ?
0
9
;96: ;96=!
1
!
1
2 0
>
! ::-
1
2 56<7;969
>
- 1 >
!
!
10
1
( ;0
20 2 @
A
@
( 5 2 KA0
1
KA-
;968
- E
I G I
G 0
10
1
:=-
+
! 0;97; 2
1
22
1
<=<6;97;
5
!
@ A1
2
;
6- 2
B
2
2
1
1&3 <= # "
" ,*D &.67H2 :6 1
6
;97;! 0
2
H
2
:7, >
;96: ;96=! 0
4
;97;
! 2
1
!
2
! 0
;;
!
0
2
)
2
2
1
2
2
:4
;:
E
01
2
:8
;:3*1
! ( ;9 ;947
1&3 .&52
*
(
6 L0 " 3 "
& # # # & & # :9
;:3*
' 0
2
1
1
2 ! ( ;9 ;9471 ;6<=;947
0
2
>
;:3*
1
B
21
56<7;969 1
+ =<-
;97;!
56<7;969
1
2
2
0 2
;4<8;94:
"
* 2 <=;5;986 2
2
2 1
2
2 56<7;9690
0
21
0
2 $
'
?
2
2 0
2
2
0 0
!
1B E -
!
!
'
%
1 1
=;.2
11
G
2
2
2 56<7;969
I G I
G
2 ;4<8;94:0
1
2
4
1
=5
1
I
G 2 >
@
1 0
1
A
2
10
2 1
1
1 =:
7 0
1 >
?*
2
89-
.//.:9%.&
1 0
2 =L60
1 - +
==
!
1B '
1
+ 1
0
I G I
G >
1
?
7 0
3 2 1
2 56<7;969
11
E
== 0
10 2
I
G I G
2
I
G
3
2
0
20
2 1
1
2
2;I
G
2 1
- 2
=6'
102 2
2
2
2
1
>
=7!
0I G 1
22
2
1
1
E
1
2
1
=4-
1
1
1
E
-
E
1
1 =8 '
2 1
E
2 56<7;969
1
2
7 0 >
E
0 20
;;
!
0 1 2
1
1 >
3 2 =9-
2
(
!
323
;;
;97;!
3 2
!2
;: L ;= -
B
2
1
1&3 . 0 J ( $ 3 A D & 0 &
" C B ( + /6 5 1 .61/ "
"
@ + 515*956I " 5 1 1/ <
= , 0
4 ,<#= :$;3& .6*.
" # 5 0 " #
# "
# " 8 0 " # 0 #
* 7 0 " I 4 I .5 :$;3 .6*. 4
& #" * 0 " ( $ #
#
/ 0 " .61/
" #J " " "
# " # 1 0"# D &0 4 ( $ 2 6< 2
2
2 2
2
1
1
1
> 2 >
I
G I G-
2 2
2
2
2
)
6;
0
1
2
G
2 ( ;
2
56<7;969 D(
1
0
E
I
G
B 1
2
( ; 65? 1
2
I
G1
2
2 56<7;969
%2
G 1
'4 9E93J& 1
B
2
H
01
- 1
1 B 2
2
6: 0
10
?
0
1
( ;
0
>
-
0
2
)
1
> ?
02
1
1
0 2 3 1
2
1
2
J
6= -
3
2 2 2
B
1
2 >
66
0
2
2 0
2
@
@ A
0 1
2 5:<;;94:
0
"
1
E
2 ;4<8;94: 67-
2 1
1
1
! '4 9E93J& 2
2
1
2
:;
+ ! ;884
'4 9E93J
)
2
-
'4 9E93J 1
!
0
( ;
2 0
2
( ;
>
2 1 1
1
2
2
2 G
64$
I
G I G
2 56<7;969 0
2 1
33 2
4
2
4 ;;
;97;!
2
A -1
2 2
2 2
>
2
567;969 2 1
0
1
1
3 3 2
))
2
2
>
4
+ !
)! )
;;
! 1 E
!
4 1
;;
1
- 1
.
;;669 5<;5
;;
1
2
;;
?
> 68 69 B 1&3 68 $
0 1 1 1
1
2 G
2
1
C
'
10
2
>
;;J
2
1
J
2
H
)+
1
2
1
2 2
1
01
2
2
>
2
1
1 69
E
3
0
1
1J
;9<95<;; 70 <=<65<;5 8 C
E - 2
2
0
- 2 2 0
0> 2 2
;;
01
2
>
I
G I G0
1 -
2 1
2
0
2
E
-
2
>
-
E
E
2
1
)
2
G 5:<;;94:
3B
2 - "
*
1 2
1
2
1
2
2
2 2 0
1
2 2
1
2
&3 @-
567;969
'
) 2 /2 * 00 #0=
0*
( ;;6 ;57;968
1
2
01
1
2
* 0
*
01
1
#
0
0 0
2
2
1
2
'
)
- . H ,!H % ' E 1
22
2
2
)
C1
2 1
2
2 !
1
2 2
'
) 2 /2 * 0 0 #0 =
0 * '
) 1
2 2
'
) $ 22
2
# - 567;969
2
201
1
% 0 !
20
2
A -
1
&3 @!
2
0 2
;465<;7
1
01
;465<;71
1
0
;655<;7
)
'
) ' '
1
'
)
' '
-
2
2
1
2 2
1 0'
) '
'
2
2
E
C
- 0
;465<;7 2
2
A 2
0
B
2
;969
1
1
2
1
1
2
2
2
2
E
1
1 1 0
2
1
0
2
B
B
2
+
3 2
)(
2
2 0
1
1
0
1
.
;969
1
1
"
*
1
.
;;669 5<;501
64
1
567;949
2 1
2
4 ;;
!
2
-
E
1
0
0
68
2
2
1
2 2 2 2
;;
1
1
2
2
1
2 1
:2
-
2
2
1
)*
;655<;7
2!2
1 2
2 2
2 1
:2
;655<;7
21
475<;7 -
2 1
1
-
2 1
>
B
21
1
.
B
2
1
.
1
3
2
@ 9 2
31
1
1
2
2
-
1 ?
01
1
2 1
3
2
2
01
1
1
+
.
;;669 5<;5
1
.2 >
2
1
2
;;1
1
2
0
E
-
1
.
;;669 5<;5 ' 0
1 &
(
,
0
) *
, )
) (
, +
!
2
0
2
2 2 !
$&22343'
56 <7<55<;8 $ 78,3.239'
>
56 .
>
C
MC(
.
MC(