Union Of India And Others v. Ex Hav Pritam Chand





    
    

  

 !"#$# % %& 




  

    

   '&  ()'

 *
*

* +

  ()'

 *
) +
    !  " #"$"% "&& '# (
 )))) *

* +

 ,- ).

  * # #  #  "  +  %  #    #

" '# " '#  " *,*--.*/012*3 " "  #&" $ 4 "&44 %+# #     +"  "  #  '  '    ''%  #  ' 4$  # "& &$52"25 "&  

"

/ 0 "123 /%4 -

 *+"&& #$ *,.6*,7/ " +" 4#" '$54+'-/*-*,,.8#

4#"   '$  #  54%  #     +"  "  '&&+

"& '"& +## 

 

   

 

      

 !

 

   "  

 #$     

 !%

  &       6 # '& %'# "&44

"#'# "'''"

" ( '' "& &$'$-.9:.9 #" "

&4"+""&&+ 5   " *,*--.*/012*3 # "5 "'#"

 1"4 #"'
       

   

  

   



   

     

 

   

 

 

 

     

      ! 

  

   

  " "





 # $



   

      %

   

   

   

& %' (

) " *       !)%#" %+ * 

, ; &  "

5  '$ #  "'   %  #  2
' "#"'& #"

"#"+  */56#$$# %$ ! 70 3%4" /%$0! 3 78 # # %3$ : #%#&" 4&'# 2
 ' "'# 03'5"<

$ # =& 1%+# %  

       

    

 '#$#"5+'

#1 &"'&"+$"

#%#&"  "&44

' #& #"54 # "'""# '# " 7 "&& %"'48 $"

 ""

"

# :" 7'#5 4   # =& 14" & "
( )%%* &+)

 $,-+
.

* '& '& &   / 0

 1

2  3

!,  % 4 *6./-../ #" ""

"

#:" 7 4$1"4 #"' $ - "        '     .  "  

 )   "   *  )   " 



% '- " */#   

 "

   " 0   '    

 "   

  '    1         "     "

 "    " "

." 2"  #      #        '

                  

 '         '  

 +

""       

   3 #  

"      +#           

         2" ''

"        

 

 "       

 4   

  5"   '    

    

               " 4 "

'   %  5" 67" 

      5"    

  

  

    

 

  

"    5"

   

  -  6  7"   

   ."

       

   

    " '       

 

             ' 



 " '   

 "

  "  , > "

' ""

"

#:'#5 40 "34&"&  4#'"4#"4"" 4&"$# #54' &"

" &"4#%#&$"& "''4 #"

5  '"&  #8"#"$  &%&" &  " $2'1" '  "    %  # %  #  " &"   4&"$%  "#  #" 4$ " #+" <4 %#%8 "&&+ %+# "'#"#""'  4  "  '# " # "''& '#+  / #" 4" ""

"

#7#'%# 1

4&" #"#  #+"<'  4#&"'

""' 45 "  '*7 "" #"+#  , #" 5+"&"

"#"5"44  "

<

$" 
( )%%*"

 "+)

 $,- +
( .*&& .   , (

2 / 0



1

4 5

 &  " #&5" ""

"

#+#'" 1"4 #"'  

 

"





"



"  - '





 "' 1 " "





 0%  

 

   %

   

 !
$ $  65 !   

5   5$     %

 $  

-67" #   

  

  " '"    

  

          "   '  

  

      "  " 

    67"     

"   

  "

  "" $ (     %

 75

  

 !

%   

%  0 1 

  '# 

  

    8     

     

    

   67"   "

" 

 -  

  

 "   

   */56#$$# %$ ! 70 3%4" /%$0! 3 73$8 %4%  *. ###" %#&" 4&'#  $#"#"'" <

$""

&4"&#" 4"%  "  #  $$  '  #  '4  4$""  "&#$  +" "&"

4 '# "&  " #"# +$'

#"

'#4# #$"? ' 03''%# +& & &"<'"&4"  ** 

'#" $%# &"4 &"4"# @

  A4#  <

$  "    #  =&   1  %  

 -..,-.*7%4"& " 9#%43*#%27:$ %# % !
%4#  %4

73$%+#4# #9#088 0 ;;

 ! "   # &5" ""

"

#'#" 5 4"1"4 #"'
-    " /    9 

% 3 - " & 2  7     /%:!   



       "   -- " 

'        



".  ."

 "       

    

' - "        



  "

     #### #### 0 

         

      - "       #     

        

   - "     ;

  <8

  "      

           

    "     

       !

  ".  ."

  "     '  

 0   "        

    ' 

     

   

   

     :  ,
%!3%"$ ! 7#$ /3  *- # #%5& 4""  &"  $"  # "

5 +# "4#"&& 4" " 4&   "

"  #44 %# %#" '" &"  $$"? #"$# #54' &" " &"4# +5%# 14 #"5 4 &%"& # #5 44 # 14"& "/ 0

 1

2 3

!

,  + $% ." 4"& ", (

2 / 0



1

+ $% .4#"% # '4 &44 %4$

& 2'1"' 52"25#$%+#"'#  #"#" 4 & '"  '# "'$#

"''& '#  *6 A#""$" %"'#14 5# "

1"4 ""

"

#%"44#5 40 "3   # 1%#1%#"4"" '"& #4$ 5 #"

5 %# %#" 5$'" '"&  ##"

5 %#+& '&"4 "4 4"  '  "4  52"25  #  "

5   &"& %  #   #

&"  " '"4&"$%#+& ""4#"##" '&$"# "    54' &" " &"4# +& ''45& '4""$& &4?"

"# " '

#'&&&'#"

5 *;  $ +###4"'"4+#4#"44

52"25#  #+""4 "4 4"'"4 ' $ +##"#5 4 % " '"& #5 #  %# % 4" "$ #'"4$#"%#&5"4"'"4

& "44 #  % %#$"? '"5 4 #

=& 14"& "( %# % !
%4# :$

69

3=%    * %0#%<% 4 *.*--.*;%+#% " 4&""$"

#1%#"#'' ''% "#  #"    4$   +    #  44   #  &5"

""

"

#"44#5 40 "3"1"4 #"' 92       ) *   5"     '"



  

   " "

    "   " "  



   "    '

    '    "+

 -  ) *  "          

    7 "  : )*44=)>+7*  

"      ?      = @'     

    A 

     

        '

         %   3

>  '

 "  '    

     %   3  >      ' $0 '   "      0    ".") *

  ) *             "+

   

   

   - 

    1 67" 



- "  

             

 

 *: #'%4#"  '"& #4"$5

#  % %#$"? '#5 4 # 1 %4"& " ( %# % !
%4# :$

69

3-$/83 .  8&%# 4&""'&"+$"

#5 40 "3%+#  "''45 #4$ + 52"25#44 %# 5  &"& %# +$'#"  #%52"25# 44 %  #  4$  #  4  '  #  #'$

$ %  +##    $   8&  #  "#  #    " "4&"$%" %" $#+# *7

4  #  5 4  0 "3  4"$  4   *.*--.*;" # " $'#" 5 4%#"

$'# "&44 %# "-.*/ # #%#  $'#5 40 "3  "" $ $  "4#%" "$& "'" &" '" 6B  "  "? &"4  +5%  +#  #    +$  $"

# 52"25#  %""&& 4' " '"&   #  8"  #$  #'%  +#  #   '"&   # 5 #  "## #5 40 "3 44$"&  "&  4'  "  4  "  4  4"  '

"4 8" #     &"&  "& #  " '"& #4"$5 #  ' # ? 8"#"

 '' $"

#'"5 *>

5  #+  4  #  4&""  '  &"+  $"

   5 40 "3$"?#" 4&"""1 &"'&"+

  $%# %#1 &"'&"+$%"$"

5 4 0 "3"&$"?## 4' '52"25#

'4  &  44 %  %    

%  "&  &  # 44 %#"" $?# " '# +$" $"

# %" #"%#'&&4$ &$%" & # %  45'#"' &" " &"4#

#% 0 343 ! 7#$ /3  */ "'$"#%#' $#+  "  +#  #  5"  "'" %  #  "$    $   # $    $"" " "''$  *,

4#$"4"&'#" 4 %#%"&&#

 "

&4"03%'" %"&" 03   '     -*

* +

.

 -) +
.

 

 ?"5 # 7 73$8 1#%2=3 $ %4 & $= 7 7338 3

& $=