Union Of India & ORS. v. Mohan Lal Gupta & ANR.
!
" #$%$& $!'$$$
$& $!
(
()
*
*++
(
!
)*
"
# $ %&
+ )
#
+
+
)
( '%&
+
+
)*+$ #
# &
( & &,,-
+ , -",./(*0% * "*%",* ",./(*0% * 0(%*"
- . 2 + '
1343563678+7793:+77;<<+77889+775:;+ 785643674 % + '
1764373674
#+ '
177<6:3674
+ '
177<833674
+ '
( $
+ '
1<57367< 0. + '
7 177889 775:;3674 2(
& + '
7 1764373674 $
.
!/ !0#!$1
=
=
#
&1 343563678+76437+7793:+77;<<+77889+775:;+77<6:+77<83+78564 3674 <57367<
# &
#>
&
#
%?
%
=
#
&'
#>
#
@ # ' =
* #
=
'&
=
# A
& > &
> ="
$&
"/# %
2 3, 4536,7$,, 836 , ,832
3664;% 73<+ 2. 9:;6!719;8<%==2
7::<7% 574 2 , ,836.>.,=?832
36657% 3<4
#>
# =
& #>
=
#
"/# %
#> &
#>
#
=
=
& #
"/#
%
#>= >%
=
'&
$
>=
&
=
> &
=
&'
$&
=# &&
#
#
#>
=
> >
&
=
"%#
' # =
B = #
!'(
$&
/8,3.,=86 , ,832
366<3% 39:=
=
&
#>
'
> C
# =-@
76 &
+= >
+
")C1, . %@ 7;638?;?:4%
0 68+7::<+
& &
&
'
#> "%+ = & 378
. # / ,
C >
+
-@
&
!
/
, . ;8?5;?:5@)1
78;7::5
#'
#$
>
#
#>
>
#
'
&
=
>
A
> +
+ #$
%
'
& "%
#>
> "=
+
# >
&
%
#>"% #
#>
?!
'&
'
% + 7:;;
!
=
=
=
?!
# &
' >
# &'
'
&
"%
% + 7:;;
& "%
?
=
&
?
&
"% > ' & E +
#
=#
#>
!
+"%
> C
&
% +
>
= # #>
'&
> = # #>
#
% =#
>?!
= '
% +7:;;=# '
E '
!
/1
A
>
&>F 77
=
+ #
> #>
'
+
=
&
'
#>
"%
=
766?@
G &
#>
B =
=
=
&= '
#>
"%
")C1,.%@7;638?;?:4%
0
68+ 7::<
#'
+
' >
& & ' & #>
& +
'
&"%
#>
> "=
+
# >
&
#
?!
'&
'
C
&
B = 766?@
#
# #>
'&
> = # #>
#
>
#'
@A
+ #
=# '
E '
73 C
+
=
=
&
#
A
#
B
#>
&
! +
B #>
'
B
+ =
A
36+666?@ =
#
#>
= F
$& = & #>
"/# %
=
=
!' (
" "& 2 , , 83639.8@31?.8372
36747% ;79
=
>&
!'( $&
%& / #
=-@ D;5
+ ,
68647::< =
& ,!
366<366;+
=
A
# +#
$
+ #
+
# >
) ,!
68647::<+
= = #
,
68647::< 75>
' =
& & ,
366<366;+
B = #
= &
,
68647::< =
1 /
/
,
366<366; ,
68647::<
% +7:;; ;< ,
68647::< = #>
# '
$& &, .3683669 #
%
( '
+ 76773669 = #>
!' ( $
"& %
.9<;9?366;+=
#>
#>
= 636;366; #>
$ # "
> "& 1.488: 3664+ 7969366<
+ & #
, .368?3669+
#
%
( '
= &#
"/# %
&
# > ,!
68647::< 366<366;
"/#
%
%696;3673
' =
= #>
"/#
%
96763679
+
$&
#>
#
# ( , .368 3669 76773669+=
&
$&
#>
!'( $
"& % ' .9<;9?366; 636;366;+ =
#>
"/# %
696;3673 ;:
' =
=
1
$
'@ @' >&
'&
+ = $> #
% +7:;;+
& >
>
=
"
A
#
=
' >+ >
> " &
A
#
# #
#>
> +
& +
>+ # &'
&
& +
'
'
'
'
#> B &+
' =&+
''&
& & &
# 86
%
>
' +
3<63367;+
&>
"
%
'
& +
#
&
"%
+
"%
+ =
>
% *"%
&
A
#
& 99 #
& =
"%
+
"% =
' + # '
"%
&
A
# 87
& B D
B F >#
D
&
>
%
&
=F% = +=
?
>+
>
( / = ! >
+
#
=
83
# >
%
'
'&
'
+
# &
&
37+
=
9:9+;7+;9+;<
#
#>
%
+
&
'&
=
.@ '& @
'
> '
#> "% =
'
=
'
37
'
+
%
= = & 1 B ,
366<366;
'
& @"%
=# '
%% +7:;;
"%
# &
#>
'
' & +
$& >
'
&@"%
#
A >
=
&
> =
&
#
'
# >
%
=
' =
(
&> ,
68647::<+.
3 7
=
% +7:;;
'
& @"%
'
>
=
#
&
''
=
&&
>
=
=
= =#
>
>
&
&
@
#
#
&'& >
& > '
"%
,
68647::<
"%%
% +7:;;+ & + #
>+ + >+
+'
7;+74 37
&
#
=
F
&'
$ >
=
> '
+
' =
$&
#>
>= >
=
&=
=
*
&
#>
'
"%
' #
=
& =
#
+
#
#'
=#
> A >+=
"
+
#> 88 363 #9= 7567367< !:;,3.83A #9=
&?
?.
#
?.