High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3960/2011allowed

Suman Sharma v. Union Of India

2018-07-20Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari14 pages

!"#$

!%!& !"#$

'" ()'

***+)

!"

#$ **,! -,.,/0, 1 %

&' "( ) %* +,-.

! "( ) %*

)!/ && 0& &0++ " *(

*(

0- +0 &00-

* 1 * !

" " !

" &2&,3 "( ) +,-, %

* %*

" * " "4! " 5 "

6 6

6( 4 * )!

(

%

" ! 6

&00- " 1! "

2 13 ! 1* * 4"* *(

!

*( ## "

4" *("

" # % "(" *

!

*

!

"

" +&'23 % 1 ( *

!

"

(

# 1( " "

! ! !*(*

# * "

4) % * (" (

"

7("

!

! "

* ("!

"

" #"

"

! !

* "

!" 54 &2&,3 %*

4 "

8

29: #+3

4 * " * 4" 6"

%*

"" 1 *

; +

"

"

* ! "

)

!

!

*(" 4 *

""

(! "

!"

%* "

" "

%

"(

4

! *

!!

" " !

! "(

+&<#

*(

!"

*4" !"

"

! * " 1! ! "4

* ""4!" *

* *( ## "

"

" ( *

% #

" ! " 0' 0= &00- *(

*

*!*( * ! > 4*

" "(

*(

% 1 "

: ("

1 "

4

1

? "

*(

*

! "

!

"

*( " 1( 4

*

* 4 " 1( !

+.<) )

!" "

*(" (! 4* "

) 4 "(

!

6$5>+0 =0 0+ 0= &00-*(

"9

9! *(" (! 4* "

; &=,5&#&=,50+ 4 7( "

"

"" && +0 &00, "

!!

( " 5 0+ 0= &00- "

! * 4 *

% *

!

*( & 4 "4

@#+ * "

!" 9

9! 0+ 0= &00- " (! 4 +0 '0

" ! "

*1 (! 4 *++#+&A"*! *(

!

!

"

"

*

8; *4 )*

!"

4 6$5> !! *( (! 4 7

(* *

( ( 4 *(

" * ! (

* * ( "*

" +&< %

" !" *" !* "

* "

" "!

"(

! 4""

" * 6 " !4

"

(

!

( "4 %

#"

!!

" 4 1

!

*(

#" ! &004"(6

% "

: "(

"

" "

" "

*

*(

%*

(* 4 "*("

% "( " * ! 4

( #

! " *

"

!* "

4 * " B04 %

4

!

" +&<# * ( "(" *

(

" "(*

*

"

"

+&<# " *(

*

*(C

# 1(C" C( *( :( * =< !! ( 4 "(

: ! "(1 ( 1 == *

!" 4 =<== D=< 9:* 4 E

(

*(( "(

* 4 "( :! 1 (

1 ( 4 E 23 1 2*3 4

== *!

!" 4 E 2+3 ;

(!

"(

!

"

4 *

"( *

2&3

*!

*# 2+3

(!

"( *# *

!

* 7 ( (

(*

*

A +'.2+3

( B

"(

"

% D+'. F

(

! !

"

4 E 2+3 (

" "( 23 (!

"(

== 2*3 !

!

4 " (*

1

4 " (*

*

" "( : : " "(

:

"* *

7 ( * 1!

*

A 4

!

" "( 4 (G

!"G 4

"

"

!" 4 * 4

1(

" ) "(+0 %

"(

" "

!"4

%* !

! !

*

*

!"#

"(" "

" 4 " !

!

*

" "* "(" "

!

"4

*

1!

/*(6!)2;!

/ 3 $%& !'(%) !* * +

#,# ,+'

%

:) !*%)-* (.

/

* )&* ,,

* !*

! % ""

"

1 &&' )&*

,,

"

"

"

"

*

+&<#

(* !

!

:

* (

:)) #=B0-#&0+.

!

&= 0< &0+.

7( ! *

. "( 2

!" 3

&00'

"

(*

+&<# "( +,-, < 4 *

7(" (

*

"() %*

"

7( " 0- +0 &00, "

*

0- +0 &00-

*

#

"! )*"

!

%

*

**( %* 6!) %

H"

"

*( ! D

!

+'B )

!

"

(! " "

(

"

" +&< "( +,-,

"" (

"

" " *(("! !

"( >!*(

" 7( *(

"

(

"

"

(*

+&<

"( +,-, @

(*

" < 4 %

"

"!

< 42

FH43

"

*( "" A

,2-,3, ,!405,6,7%8, 2 3 *

* ( +&<#

%

1! D++ ;* *

" *

!

8

! (! 8 * ! (

"

(!

" "

* ! "

(!*

""

(!

"( *

!

* " " 6

*

" " *1

! 2&00'3<))=&<2 ,3 / ( )9 %H 2&00&3+))+,'2 +&3 % )

9) 2&0003+))''& +& "

" * "

*

" " " *1

*

" "

" "

* !

*

*) @4) H % @4 +,B+)B<.2 .3

" H

(

+,-<)+-<&2 ++3 H

H!

H:% :

H +,-+)-=&2 +'3

; 14 %

!

2&00'3<))&.

+&3 ::::

::::

::::

+< "

!

8

! (! 8 +&'23 "( "

"

! !

* "( !

!

"( "

4" (

"

*( "(

(*(

!*( /(! !

" ! "

"

! !

* 2 (

!

!

"( 6

8

! (! 8 " *

!" 4 (! "(

"! "

!

A %

* (

* ( ( !" *(

"(4* !

(*

"*1 *(

:)) #<,<=#&0+-

# 2&+3 0, 0= &0+- %

:)

+&<# * ( " 1( *! # *!"

I" J !

"!! !

!

*! +B B D+B B@ *

*

"

I

1(J" 7 1( !

!

( !

! " 4!

*( !

!

"*

* (* I (J @ ( 1! ) ) H

(!"

!

!

*

"

* I (J +B'

+,--

!

"

1( *! #*!"

I" J

!

"

+&<

(

!

!

*! A

* "*

!

" !!

* * "* !

*( ! * "(

* " *

!

"

#

#

$

%

! " *

) ! ; +

*

"*!

"

" &2&,3 "

"

+&<#

( * 4 *("

* ( " :

"

+&<# *

*

"(

"

*

< 4 !" KBL

0+ 0= &00- 4

! " "

"*(

:) 0!, 09 %:

,; % *

7

(

! + 4 !" % "

"

"

4

F:

!

( !

1( %

# "

"

"

9**+);

)<-1$

" ! #$ % & $' " ! % & $'