Sourav Oberoi v. Puran Chand & ORS.

 

        

" "#$ %!

 & !' 
 

 




 

  

()%  *+)$, $#( -   

 

 

! "

 

#

$
%
! "
  
% &

' 
 
# 
! "
  
% (

  #
! "
  
% ) ( - ,. +/

! +

!+


 
 
 + 
,
 
- &.

(.&.
 

 
!!

 
 +
* 
/+
%

0


" 
 "

 


1
* 2
,





, 
!+  
+
"



( 3( 4..56

, 
 



"
- 37
 
+ 8


"

"!
"

!



&9 - (..4
! +
+

 

, 
 


 

+
,
 
 
+
!

!  


 
%
:6.(6;64).9
, 

+ 
, 

!!

 
, 

!<
 


 
%











:6)-6'6.9==
, !
,


 







+


>8
,


 
 "

* $ 
,
< 


$
: 
/+
%
"+
,

,
 " 

 ?

 

 

  

 !


@
: 
; 

" 


 
"

>8

 
"

""

 
 !
,
!


 
*
* 
 


!!

 

!! 



!

"

 
"

!<

)012
3("0"-4202(
-56
!+  
"

! +
,
  


< 


!!
 
AB C D5&

C D5&(
, !
,

 

C D
%  

 
+!



"
  

 !


@
: 
; 
*
+  
"

! +


 
 
,

 


 
+  !
 !
AB C 35&

C 35&3
* +
 

 
 
AB C 35&9
@
C 35&-
,


(( 39.56



3. ...56
,

! 
"+

! +
"

 +
"

 

 

  
AB C 95-
*

+
"


-- 4..56
,
  
,
+  !
 + 

"
 + 
  

+
,
  



& 9. ...56
*
!+  
"

( 3( 4..56
,
, 

(7$$$$

89$ 
 



   

             



  



  

:+(:$ 

 !!  


 

     !"



    !" 

 

   



" 

# $%&&'(  %&)

 

  

 *   +,   

    




 "

!


 

!

+


$+ 
"
  



  # $

%& '(   )    *   

     +  

       -

   





    



.&) 

  "

  

 

"



" - # /&&& 







    # /$&&&'(



 

     .&)  

  "   #  % &&'(  

 

     +,     0 #         

 

# +%&  







 



# +%&  



 



 +.

+, +1

 &         

2(

 

 

         

         

               

  !   "  "  

             #         #   

 


  

       " "  

                   

  

$    
% !   & 

      '  (       )         )    

    #    

* !  

            +       "     ) #       #    

        , !   "                #     "     )   #       

               

$     ,- !    

 .     *%* !  
" 



    
 "  

#      )   #            #      /  
  

     
0

*  /  ) 

  

      #   

   *       

         
1 2

            



     

              %,- !

1 "         "    

 3      4  0    !

"
#$% )         

:+(:$ 

 !!  
                

      #         /    &  '   (% '

 5       6  , 
 

   -.) / ,  0++ 12 ++ 1,    /      7# 2       8   )  34 & &  5

 1664) 77 &&0012  5 ) # 9
0#     #  

 

  

 3      4     # 

     

   #      

     

  #              #   0    

      

     #    

  
 4  #                   3      
1  

)     :      #             )  



              

             3               ;     

   /      #       3      



 

               "    /      * ! 

    0     3  


   

  

              3  

< "        "

 

   

                  0        

        #  0    "   )       

   

             

  =#      #  

          

  

    

         "       

  "   )       


   3       

  

   *  :      

         "        /       
% ! 



  

   

   
*"     "        0

         

 # #          " 



  3

 #   % 7      #          /  "  

     #      

:+(:$ 

 !!  
"        /           


% !       /   ;

 
 +
"

 
,
+ 


""


 + 
  
"
4.7

!!
"
+ 
"
, 
 +
 
<

C&5 
, !



 

#



?
 
,
()


"



 +
"



!!

  

 !

, 
 

 
!+


 
!+
!
< 



"

<  
 

=7
)&>?=@'"0&@>&+@"
'



, 
 '



,- !
: ?







7 1.

% A1.B  ,* ! >   
1

,*A
1B- !
:   

* !
?

 




% !
C   


% !
> 

  

1 !
"&"C)&>?=@'"0&@D 7=79!


,%%  !
=@ @)=7>&+@"&: )&>?=@'"0&@

,%% !*%*1B 

*- !
8

!

!+!



 
 


, 


 + 
,

+ "



 B 

+   
 




"
 


!


"+
- 37
 
+


"
=7
 
+

 !


+
"
!+  

        

  5)75 &)& & 8 & 9


//
&   &  "

 
":0#



 

      

   

$!

 !' .( - / ;"<=>?

  ,    

 (9

%4$