High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16781/2024dismissed

Union Of India And Others v. Ex Naik Jage Ram

2024-12-17Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma8 pages

!"#$%&&

"#"'#( !"#$&& ) * *

!"#$ +$ ,-+ & **

* .

,-+ *& ** * + %&'()*+, #-"((./01&23/45%/1(4'1-(4 6%.2(7(.0.01(%- *

* .

/& 2%'&2.2(01-./1.3%0.7(.0.015.2(7(.0.01(%-2(%(01 10161)0/57%/+-6%.2(-(..01&/-0)(6.2(%)(%)/.()

911(:'%( ;5 /- 7/--() *+ .2( 4(/%1() %<() %=(- %0*'1/4 =1=(%1()532(%(*+-.2(=4/0<6%(-71)(1.6%.2(&%/1.6 -(%>0=((4(<(1.6.2()0-/*040.+7(1-016%.2(-(%>0=(%(1)(%()*+ 20<01(6(1=((='%0.+%7-9;2/-*((1/443()5*+=1)101& .2(-2%.6/446 )/+-6%<.2(%(?'0-0.( +(/%-6?'/406+01&-(%>0=( 6%(/%101&-(%>0=(7(1-0101.2(

0(1'020(34"'#!

(-71)(1. 3/- (1%44() 01 .2( 1)0/1 %<+9!/. (&0<(1.;1

/1)3/-)0-=2/%&().2(%(6%<1 (-71)(1.3/-&%/1.()%(.0%01&7(1-015/-/)<0--0*4(.20</- 7(%.2((1-01(&'4/.01-2(%(/6.(%5%(-71)(1.3/-%( (1%44()01.(6(1=((='%0.+%7-9-(%>0=(;1

==%)01& . .2( 7%(>/4(1. 740=+5 '71 /../0101& .2( /&( 6 -'7(%/11'/.015%(-71)(1.3/-)0-=2/%&()6%<-(%>0=(01.2(

/6.(%%(1)(%01&/-(%>0=(6 +(/%-/1)

)/+-5 320=23/--2%.*+ )/+-5-/-.</@(.2(-4)0(%(1/*4(). =<74(.(.2(?'/406+01&.(%<6 +(/%-56%.2(7'%7-(6&%/1.6 -(%>0=(7(1-015.2'-6%.2(-(=1)-(%>0=(%(1)(%()*+20<01.2(

(-71)(1. 3/- )(10() -(%>0=( 7(1-01 *+ .2( =<7(.(1./'.2%0.+6%20-1.=<74(.01&.2(%(?'0-0.(?'/406+01& 7(%0)6%(/%101&-(%>0=(7(1-0101.2(

((401&/&&%0(>()5%(-71)(1.604()5*(6%(.2( 4(/%1() %<() %=(- %0*'1/4 =1=(%1()5 32(%(*+- 2( =/-. / =2/44(1&(..2(/6%(-/0)%(A(=.01%)(%2(-/0)5*(=/<( /443()>0)(%)(%)/.()

2(7(%/.0>(7/%.6.2(-/0) %)(%0-(:.%/=.()2(%(01/6.(%, :::: ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

!"#

!$ % & & '()

$ $!$ +

"""""#

((401&/&&%0(>()6%<.2(/6%(-/0)%)(%/-7/--()'71 .2(9-'7%/;5*+.2(4(/%1()%<()%=(-%0*'1/4=1=(%1()5.2( 7(.0.01(%10161)0/2/-604().2(%(/&/01-..2(01-./1.3%0.7(.0.01 *(6%(.20-'%.

*'567

7"# "819 2 0# !("'#

28"19 :

1717"#

& 2(4(/%1()='1-(46%.2(7(.0.01(%--'*<0.-5.2/..2( 4(/%1()%0*'1/42/-6/04().=1-0)(%.2/.01.(%<-6(&'4/.01 6.2((1-01(&'4/.01-6%.2(%<+5 /1)(&'4/.01

6.2((1-01(&'4/.01-6%.2(%<+5

5.2'-14+.2( <7(.(1.'.2%0.+3/-(<73(%().=1)1(.2()(60=0(1=+01.2( %(1)0.016?'/406+01&-(%>0=(5.2'-*+.2(-4)0(%6%20-*(=<01& (1.0.4().-((@.2((1)3<(1.67(1-01.20<2(-/0)(&'4/.01- /%((:.%/=.()2(%(01/6.(% 9"B#C5 ;

$%&" '( )* + , )* +

- $./ )* + + $& + + + + ( "# 9"B#C5

;

//"

0 + $%

( 12 )* + ,3 )* + + $& +"

)* - "# 4"

#%(>(%5.2(#010-.%+6(6(1=(>0)(40=+4(..(%

;D DD9(1D4; )/.() 5 01-(%.()=4/'-(90>; 01 .2(

(&'4/.01

6.2((1-01(&'4/.016%.2(%<+5

2( %(4(>/1.7/%.32(%(650-(:.%/=.()2(%(01/6.(% ,-.

- /-

&01 7(%'-/46.2(/6%(/<(1)<(1.3'4)</@(0.=4(/%.2/. %(40(6 ?'/ =1)1/.01 6 )(60=0(1=+ 01 %(1)0.01 6 .2( /77-0.( ?'/406+01&-(%>0=(50-.*(/==%)()1<(%0.5-/-.(1-'%(.2/./1 /%<+7(%-11(40-(40&0*4(6%/.4(/-.1(-(%>0=(7(1-01

2(4(/%1()='1-(46%.2(7(.0.01(%-6'%.2(%-'*<0.-5.2/. .2(A')&<(1.6.2(4(/%1()%<()%=(-%0*'1/45%01=07/4E(1=25 (3(4205%(1)(%()01=/-(.0.4()/-& & '()

3/-1.=%%(=.%/.2(%3/-=1.%/%+.4/3/1)6/=.-5 .2(%(6%(51%(40/1=('&2..2/>(*((174/=()1.2(-/0)A')&<(1. 2(%(4(>/1.7/%/&%/72-5/-=='%01.2(>(%)0=.9-'7%/;/%((:.%/=.() 2(%(01/6.(% %"0 , 5

6 %/"7/"%7$ 1 )* 8

+ 9:

+ ;- <

=9 $/"7 "%77$ >// > - < =9

%7"7."%7$4? * :

+ ?

? * 9 6 9+@ A B"C".7%7$D74"$$"%7$D 50 ? *

50 <

)=9* + +? (((( (((( / " + ;

6 + ;

1 )* E C" )*

) + * ,

+ 9 : +$/ +

> F G : - ++ 9 :

F G F 9 > HF = : = -+

6 9+ = "0 )*" /

//2 - ‟

3 &0 &&

4,.

5 / -

4 /4

& /0 , &0. )*

)* )* + 0

, ,

+# + : %)%*50 %774"0

++$/"7 "%77$ > $%: : >)* "

/ ,

/ . -

!6$+!$ !/ -/7 /

8$ !$ ",.

)* > )*

0 6 9+G"

")+*E C")* >/4 +" #8

"8197 "'1& 01=(.2((:7-.'4/.01-</)(017/%/&%/72 6.2( A')&<(1.%(1)(%()*+.2($1F*4(7(:'%.01=/-(.0.4()/- #7"#"8 #!700#!#"19 ) &*'

*7#49 0605%(7%.()01,!$ 9."

& 0 0 6$65 7/%/&%/72 32(%(6 *(=<(- (:.%/=.() 2(%(01/6.(%5>(%=<(-.2()0-/*401&(66(=.-506/1+56-'7%/(:=(7.01 90>;5/-*(=/<(01-(%.()>0)(740=+D4(..(%)/.() 5.2'-5 01.(1)().3%@/-/1*-./=4(%/.2(%/&/01-..2(-4)0(%=4/0<01&%(40(6 6=1)1/.0101.2(%(?'0-0.(-2%.6/446-(%>0=( $%" ++

, + ( $% " ( F 0

+ 0 "F+

+ %/I $J & $/ %77$ (

"00

+ " 2(%(6%(5.2(A')0=0/4>(%)0=.9-'7%/;5)(-%(1)(%1(&/.() .2(-'7%//%&'<(1.%/0-()*+.2(='1-(46%.2(7(.0.01(%-5.2/..2( (<73(%<(1..=1)1(.2(%(?'0-0.(-2%.6/445*(=<(--40./%04+ >(-.()01.2(<7(.(1.'.2%0.+5(-7(=0/44+32(1.2(2(%(01/*>( '1)(%401()7/%/&%/72-5/-=='%01.2(>(%)0=.</)(01*' #!

*7#49

060, (0

5/44')().01.2(>(%)0=.</)(012/</ /'%F-=/-(5) 01>(-.A'%0-)0=.0101.2(%0.'%.5..2%'&2A')0=0/401.(%>(1.015 .2'-</@(.2((-7'-()=1)1/.01 1-(?'(1.4+5.2(='<'4/.0>((66(=.6.2(/'.2%0./.0>( A')0=0/47%1'1=(<(1./-=/%%0()01.2(/*>((:.%/=.()7/%/&%/725 </)( 01 & & 4 ,. .2'- =<74(.(4+ ='1.(%>/04-*.2.2(-'7%//%&'<(1.-%/0-()*(6%(.20-'%.5*+.2( ='1-(46%.2(7(.0.01(%-5.2'-6%)(1+01&..2(%(-71)(1.5.2( *(1(60.6.2(-(%>0=(7(1-016%20--(%>01&01.2(5<(%(4+1.2( &%'1).2/.2(2/-1.=<74(.().2(?'/406+01&7(%0)6-(%>0=(5 *(-0)(-1.2(6'%.2(%640<-+&%'1)5.2/.14+.2(=<7(.(1./'.2%0.+ 0-/'.2%0G().=1)1(.2(-/0)-2%.6/44 1(.2(4(--5 01 .(%<- 6 .2( )(=4/%/.01 </)( 01 .2( 2(%(01/*>( '1)(%401() 7/%/5 /- =/%%0() 01 .2( >(%)0=. 9-'7%/;5 .2( =4/0<-6)'/46/<04+7(1-0101/))0.01..2(60%-.6/<04+7(1-01506 %(?'0%()53'4)*(%(-.%0=.()6%<

5/-(1>0-/&()*+.2( #010-.%+6(6(1=(B(..(%)/.()

7#02 !

"8197 "'1& 1/6.(%</.25.20-'%.601)-1<(%0.01.2(3%0.7(.0.01 /1)30.2*-(%>/.01-/*>(5.2(-/<(0-)0-<0--() 2(0<7'&1()%)(%5/-7/--()*+.2(4(/%1()%0*'1/4 =1=(%1()50-</01./01()/1)/660%<() 0-7-()6/41&30.2/447(1)01&/7740=/.019-;506/1+ ;*

* .

< ;* * +< &&

1A/4 9 :

037#4= "# !

9 :"1052