High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2706/2014disposed of

Executive Engineer And Anrs v. Presiding Officer And Anrs

2024-01-04Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger8 pages

" !

!#$% (%)*+*&,

- -

/%)0$*1% ,2*,%%34 056*) %#6$.

!*1*+*&, &- 4 #2#3 #,&$.%3

------ %$*$*&,%3+ 8%3+0+ 3%+*(*,2

''*)%34 ,(0+$3*#6 3*50,#6)079#5&03 &03$4 75#6# &$.%3+

------

%+:&,(%,$+

; 9

< <

3%+%,$ 3- 3#1%%, .#,(%3 &=#64

((*$*&,#6 (1&)#$% %,%3#64 #3=#,# :%$*$*&,%3+-

3- <0+.*6 >#75&?4 (1&)#$%

3%+:&,(%,$ &- - - - <

%$*$*&,%3+

/%)0$*1% ,2*,%%34 056*) %#6$.

!*1*+*&, &- 4 #2#3 #,&$.%3 .#1% *1*6 3*$ %$*$*&, 0,(%3 3$*)6%+ &,+$*$0$*&, ,(*#4 +%%@*,2

,#$03% )%3$*&3#3* B0#+.*,2 A#3( --

,,%/03% 4 :#++%( 3%+:&,(%,$ &- .% 3%+*(*,2

''*)%34 ,(0+$3*#6 3*50,#6)07 9#5&03 &03$4 75#6#

.%3%*,#'$%3 3%'%33%( ;3*50,#6 5%6&A;4 A.%3%5= 3%'%3%,)% *,(0+$3*#6 (*+:0$% 3%2#3(*,2 $%37*,#$*&, +%31*)%+ 3%+:&,(%,$ &- A&3@7#,4 ,#7%6=4

#+.*(

.%3%*,#'$%3 3%'%33%( ;3%+:&,(%,$A&3@7#,; #,+A%3%( '#1&03 &3(%3%( 3%*,+$#$%( )&,$*,0*$= +%31*)% C 5#)@ $%37*,#$*&, $*66 3%*,+$#$%7%,$-

- 3*%'6=4 3#*+%( #, *,(0+$3*#6 (*+:0$% +%31*,2 (%7#,( ,&$*)% 0:&, :%$*$*&,%3+

.%3%*,#'$%3 3%'%33%( ;:%$*$*&,%3!%:#3$7%,$;- <05+%B0%,$6=4 (*+:0$% 3%'%33%( #(?0(*)#$*&, A.%3% +$#$%7%,$ :6%# %,2#2%( 05%A%66

:%3#$&3 %''%)$ --

#62.#3

#*:034 - <.#(*:034 %.+*6

#2#(.3*4 !*+$3*)$ #2#3-

%+:&,(%,$A&3@7#, )6#*7%( 3%7#*,%( )&,$*,0&0+ +%31*)% $*66 - - A.%, +%31*)%+ A%3% #530:$6= $%37*,#$%(-

%+:&,(%,$A&3@7#, )6#*7%( %/*+$%( 3%+:&,(%,$A&3@7#,-

+$#$%( 5%*,2 :#*(

+- 4 :%3 7&,$.4 70).

6%++ $.#, 7*,*707 '*/%( #3=#,# &1%3,7%,$-

#66%2%( #'$%3 $%37*,#$*&, +%31*)%+ - - 4

3%$#*,%( '3%+.

:%3+&,+ ?&5 #6+& @%:$ ?0,*&3 :%3+&,+ +%31*)%- .%3%'&3%4 +$#$%( $%37*,#$*&, 1*&6#$*&, :3&1*+*&,+

<%)$*&,+ 4 ,(0+$3*#6 !*+:0$%+ )$4

.%3%*,#'$%3 3%'%33%( ; )$;-

))&3(*,26=4 :3#=%( 3%*,+$#$%( +%31*)%

)&,$*,0*$= '066 5#)@ $%37*,#$*&, $*66 3%*,+$#$%7%,$-

- #'&3%+#*( )&,$%+$%( '*6*,2 *$+ 3%:6= A.%3%*, *,$%3 #6*# +$#$%( 0,(%3 )&,$3&6 <#3:#,).

,&$.*,2 (& ?&5 3%+:&,(%,$A&3@7#,-

+$#$%( .*7+%6'

6%'$ A&3@ &A, (*( )&7% :3%+%,$ :#3$ $*7% A&3@ &:%3#$% $05%A%66-

+$#$%( <#3:#,).

)&,$3&66*,2 #''#*3+ $05%A%66 %1%, A%3% 3%)%*1%( :#3$ $*7% ?&5 *-%-

+- 4 <#3:#,).

#,).#=#$4

#*:03-

:#3$*%+ (%,*%( +057*$$*,2 3%+:&,(%,$ A&3@7#, ,%1%3 %,2#2%( *'

3%+:&,(%,$ A&3@7#, %7:6&=%( #,).#=#$4

$.%, #,).#=#$4

#*:034 @,&A+ 3%2#3(*,2 #)$*1*$*%+

3%+:&,(%,$ A&3@7#,-

&$.%3 #1%37%,$+ +$#$%7%,$ #6+& (%,*%( #))&3(*,26=4 :3#=%3 (*+7*++#6 +$#$%7%,$ 7#(%-

3&7 :6%#(*,2+ :#3$*%+4 '&66&A*,2 *++0%+ A%3% '3#7%(

% " &

! !! !

( ) - +0::&3$ )6#*74 A&3@7#, +$%::%( *,$& A*$,%++ 5&/ $%,(%3%( #''*(#1*$ /- - A&3@7#, #6+& %/#7*,%( @5#3 4 +D#( +3#3 -

, &$.%3 .#,(4 !%:#3$7%,$ %/#7*,%( &,% <07*$ #324 <05 !*1*+*&,#6 ,2*,%%34 056*) %#6$.4 #2#3 A.& $%,(%3%( #''*(#1*$ /- - - 5%6&A4 1*(% --

,,%/03% 4 3%$03,%( '&66&A*,2 '*,(*,2+ * +

! -.

/ 0 1 0 2 3

! -.

/ 0 1 0 2 3

! !

! % !

&( 44( $ 4

/ 5

! 6 E-

, #'&3%+#*( '*,(*,2+4 :#++%( (*3%)$*,2 3%*,+$#$%7%,$ )&,$*,0*$= +%31*)% C 5#)@ $%37*,#$*&, $*66 3%*,+$#$%7%,$-

- #'&3%7%,$*&,%( )*3)07+$#,)%+4 :%$*$*&, 5%'&3% $.*+ &03$-

- .*6% *++0*,2 ,&$*)% 7&$*&,4 &:%3#$*&, +$#=%( -- 9%#3,%( <$#$% )&0,+%6 #::%#3*,2 +057*$$%(

#62#3.

#*:034 !*+$3*)$ #2#3 $#@%, &1%3 :%$*$*&,%3!%:#3$7%,$4 1*(% &$*'*)#$*&, -- :3*&3 $.#$4

#62#3.

5%*,2 30,

,& )&,)%3, %,2#2*,2 #,=5&(= 30,,*,2 +#7%-

+057*$$%( ,%*$.%3 %,2#2%( ,&3 A&3@%( 07:

:%3#$&3 :%$*$*&,%3!%:#3$7%,$4 #,(4 $.%3%'&3%4 ,& B0%+$*&, $%37*,#$*&,-

9%#3,%( <$#$% )&0,+%6 A.*6% 3%'%33*,2 +057*++*&,+ :%$*$*&, +057*$+ %,2#2%( <#3:#,).

#,).#=#$4

#62#3.

:03%6= $%7:&3#3= :#3$*)06#3 A&3@ +:%)*'*%( :%3*&( +%31*)%+ A%3% $%37*,#$%( #,(4 $.%3%'&3%4 ,& 3*2.$ 7#@% #,= #2#*,+$ :%$*$*&,%3!%:#3$7%,$- +057*$$%( A.%, $#@%, &1%3

#62#3.4 $*7% ,& :%3+&, A&3@*,2 $.%3%-

'03$.%3 +057*$$%( %1%, +$#$%7%,$4 ,& #1%37%,$ A.& %,2#2%( .*7-

+057*$$%( +*,)% $#@%, &1%3

#62#3.4 1*(% &$*'*)#$*&, -- 4 $.%3%'&3%4 ,& B0%+$*&, %,2#2*,2 --4 )6#*7%( .*7 +$#$%7%,$-

,%/$ +057*$$%( &3(%3 +05+$#,$*#$% *$+ )6#*74 6%( #,= (&)07%,$#3= :3&&'

%/)%:$ (%7#,( ,&$*)%4 +$#$%7%,$ #''*(#1*$

))&3(*,26=4 +057*$$%( '#*6%( (*+).#32% &,0+ :6#)%( 0:&, .*7 :3&1% :6%#(%( )#+%-

+057*$$%( +*,)% %,2#2%7%,$ '&66&A*,2 (0% :3&)%(03% 6#A4 #))&3(*,26=4 +$#$%7%,$ 6*#56% (*+7*++%(-

%'%3%,)% ?0(27%,$ &,;56% <0:3%7% &03$ )#+% 7 7 8

9 :

))&3(*,26=4 :3#=%( +%$ #+*(%-

- %3 )&,$3#4 6%#3,%( )&0,+%6 #::%#3*,2 &::&+%( :3#=%3 6%#3,%( <$#$% )&0,+%6 #::%#3*,2 +057*$$%( :#++%( A%66 3%#+&,%( ?0+$*'*%( :%)06*#3 '#)$+ )*3)07+$#,)%+ )#+%-

+057*$$%( %,2#2%7%,$ 3%+:&,(%,$ &-

#62#3.

(*+:0$%( +*,)%

#62#3.

0,(%3 +0:%31*+*&, :%$*$*&,%3!%:#3$7%,$4 #))&3(*,26=4 %/*+$%( 3%+:&,(%,$A&3@7#,-

.%3%'&3%4 +057*$$%( ,&

*,$%3'%3%,)% 3%B0*3%( #A#3(- ))&3(*,26=4 :3#=%3 (*+7*++#6 :%$*$*&, 7#(%-

- .#1% .%#3( 6%#3,%( )&0,+%6 3%+:%)$*1% :#3$*%+ .#1% :%30+%( :#:%35&&@ $.%*3 #56% #++*+$#,)%-

'$%3 2&*,2 $.3&02.

#A#3(4 &5+%31%( #'$%3 3%'%33*,2 +057*++*&,+ 0$.&3*D%(

%:3%+%,$#$*1% 7#@*,2 3%'%3%,)% )%3$#*, ?0(27%,$+4 )&,)60(%( +*,)% $05%A%66 )&,,%)$*&, %6%)$3*) )&,,%)$*&, #3% ,#7% :%$*$*&,%3!%:#3$7%,$4 $.%3%'&3%4 %/*+$%( 3%+:&,(%,$A&3@7#,-

03$.%3 '*,(*,2 3%)&3(%( A&3@%( (#=+ --

-- - -

- - )&,$*,0&0+6= $.3&A, &0$ ?&5 A*$.&0$ #,= 3.=7% &3 3%#+&,- &5+%31%( A#3( ,& 3%'%3%,)% #,= (&)07%,$%1*(%,)%7#$%3*#64 #'&3%+#*( '*,(*,2 3%$03,%( '&3$.)&7*,2 A.#$ A%*2.%( 7*,( 3%$03, '*,(*,2-

7= )&,+*(%3%( 1*%A4 '*,(*,2 5#+%( 0:&, +&7% 7#$%3*#6%1*(%,)% 3%)&3( )#+%4 ,& 3%'%3%,)% #,= +0).

7#$%3*#6-

3%$03,%( '*,(*,2 3%2#3(*,2 :#3$*%+ &,6= %6%)$3*) )&,,%)$*&, $05%A%66 )&,,%)$*&,4 #3% ,#7% :%$*$*&,%3!%:#3$7%,$-

7= )&,+*(%3%( 1*%A4 #5+%,)% #,= 7#$%3*#6 :3*7# '#)*% +.&A 6%#+$ %,2#2%7%,$ :%$*$*&,%3!%:#3$7%,$4 ,& '*,(*,2 )&06( .#1% 3%$03,%( 3%2#3(*,2 %/*+$%,)% :#3$*%+-

03$.%37&3%4 3%$03,%( '*,(*,2 A&3@%( (#=+ --

-- - -

- - )&,$*,0&0+6=-

&A%1%34 7= )&,+*(%3%( 1*%A4 '*,(*,2 )&,+&,#,)% :3&1*+*&,+ <%)$*&,

)$ 3%#( <%)$*&, )$-

)#+%4 3%+:&,(%,$ A&3@7#, )6#*7*,2 5%,%'*$ <%)$*&,

)$ $.%, :3&1% A&3@%( (#=+ 7&,$.+ :3%)%(*,2 #66%2%( $%37*,#$*&,4 #::#3%,$6= 7*++*,2 $.*+ )#+%-

- &,+*(%3*,2 $&$#6*$= )*3)07+$#,)%+4 #7 )&,+*(%3%( 1*%A --

,,%/03% 6#)@+ 3%#+&,*,2 ,&,+:%#@*,2 #A#3(4 #))&3(*,26=4 +#7% 0,+0+$#*,#56% %=%+ 6#A-

&,+%B0%,$6=4 :%$*$*&, :#3$6= #66&A%( 7#$$%3 3%7#,(%( (%)*(*,2 3%'%3%,)% #'3%+.

#))&3(#,)% 6#A :#++*,2 A%66 3%#+&,%( 7#$%3*#6 #63%#(= #1#*6#56% 3%)&3(4 :3%'%3#56= A*$.*, :%3*&( &,% =%#3 $&(#=- - :%,(*,2 #::6*)#$*&, +4 *'

#,=4 +.#66 +$#,( )6&+%(-

- -

+?@+ .%$.%3 +:%#@*,23%#+&,%(

"%+

& .%$.%3 3%:&3$#56% "%+