High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21852/2017disposed of

Naresh Kumar v. Indian Oil Corporation And ORS.

2018-12-11Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa6 pages

! "

#$

$ "

!"#$

%&'()$ ($%) $

') * ) '

%

&' (#)

& *+&'",- (

.' & +",- /

.' $+",- / '

($%) $

') * ) '

%

+, 1'

$(",

" 34'5'677829 "

#$

: / 2/" $

;'

$$# "/ "

$ ."

, "$$#

"

38'37'6778 " $ "#- *9' $(##

"

" * "64'8'673<(=- "(

" " 9#/.>."

" &, -

."

+ ?$(

#$$ '

$

2 / #" $* * " " "

@'4'673A : =

6@; $" 29

"

$#"29

, * " - # / $

# * " , * $" $#"

* -"+ / - "", (

$* "" =

6@- "- "

/ "

/$ */ "/'

&-, ( 2 B / * %

"

"#9+ $

" 2 ," (

( -

-" "@'<'673A: =

33;$ -$#

, *2

- ," 29 / . *+ # " /

/& '& " "&' B##*

"- -#"/-

/$$#9 */ " 1'

'' $ 96778(#"92/.> .

# $ 9+ )

(#+ .*+ # # /

#$

1 "':'

''1;' -$#

"2 ##*"

" * "/ 2 $/ '

''1 # # 96775 ""2 --$ "29 '

''1 96737' ($ B *-* ? -/--$#

( -

-" "@'<'673A: =

33;"2 ,"$

$ #9 ( - *" - -# / #,

/

#, *2 ##

""

$29/ *( *

/

'3C"9

(*

2

$#9 "$(-

-+-

(- $# "/, #

* "# /1'

$ .#

$## $ # , #

/#6A/ " :1'

'; $*

" "64'8'673<'

$$ #9+$

(

, ( 2

-$ , $#9

-"2

"D /$$#9/-

"- ' &- D ( --"" "

($-"

**

"( -#" / # * / E

3@8<@ 673A 2/ ' (

$

( "

$"/ 5'8'673A %

!"

#$% &$'( )*"+ #, - , *2 $$#

+" #"

$#9" "6<'8'673A: =$ 34;(/ "29

# / ,# $ / * " "

2 + *-

"2 "%

:

;

( $#9

-

,

*

$ " " 68'36'6738 ( - $

" 2 - " **

( ""$ " ( -

" 2 - "'

:

;

.>.

#$ 9( -"2 /"$ $ - - ,#,

+#.

# "& B 9 3555"2 * ""# $/'

''1' $ "

2 "

#," * #

"" "6'37'677@ "-$9/ ( - (

-" # * (

$#9 ( -

-'

" $ #

"" "6'37'677@ # *(

/ #9& B"#/ $ $'

- :

;

($ $""-9 *, " ''6'37'677@"

2 "

2 ( #.

# " #'

($ $""" "6'37'677@(#

-"# *(

$#9

-'

F "

" / * ( $ $""" "6'37'677@'

:

,;

"#9 /" '

''1 (## - =

, "#

" "@'37'677@*"/- /"

#

/

$ $ / .> .

# $ 9 ( - ( #"

* "# $/'

''1'

/

*$ #9#.

# " ($ #9 # " , $ " (2 B-- ($ 37'C'677<'- $$ /- "(#

-"# *

$#9

-'

## " B $#9 " " 6<'8'673A

34;

"2

- ( " $"2 ",

"29 $ "

34'5'6778+ " - -

(

$ .>.

#$ 9 "( -(#, " /

- = / 9677C 6778 "6778 677A'

$* " "

* "

$ #" 29

($" @'4'673A: =

6@;' # /(#"

,# "/ - $29

$#9 (-

-# $$

*"- , , 2

-"- #"# (

' $$ #9+

$-""

*

* /-

"63'36'6738 $#-" -"29# "- # =

3>3 "(

.>.

#$ 9"2

"-

$$# / "# $$ *

/:$ $

;

" $ &'& B, "#

" "3C'33'6775 " *

/.

#:$ $

;/.>.

# $ 9+)

(#+ .*(--$ "29'

''1 63'37'6737'

(#" ,

2,

$* """ "@'4'673A: =

6@;

' $#"29

(

$$#

/ "'

/

$$# "29'

''1, "-

"63'36'6738

3>3;- 2 " #, '

9+ $ "

>-$

9(2# * ( *-

/

- -

"63'36'6738$$# "29 '

''1* "> /

B 29

$#9 " "6<'8'673A: =

34;

-' ( #9

/ $

-#" , 2 /" (

"- ##9 * " "#/ $ $- - #9.> .

#$ 9$ 34'5'6778( $"

2 ",

"29

'$ "

(#2# * - " //- -

$$#

"2 2

"29.>.

#$ 9, "#

" "3C'33'6775 $ *

$ $

" $ '/ $ ''.>.

#$ 9"- ##92 "

#," 6'37'677@ -# "29

"(29

#/ $ $ " -

"/ .>.

#$ 92

-

$$# 2# "#9+ $ /- -#" , (B" $)"

-/

.

/ #9 $- ( -, 2 "# (

29 -$

9 "

$

$ */ $* """ "@'4'673A: =

6@;'

, ( / 2,+ $* " " " " @'4'673A

6@; "'.

""2-B -$

9 "

/ - "

" / $ * "/' &-=- /- "

2-$# "

$ "// / " /- $ /-

/ "-$9/

"'$ #

$ $ */ / # "(#"2$$- "'

+(,+-# / 2,

- " #9/$$/ "

2-B/"-

/ "(#", 2 *

/ -'#-# / "

29, /

* "/ $* """ "@'4'673A

6@; '' $(#" " "

/,/

" (#"22)- -/ / #" (2 "

- 2$"'

E

$

"

$"/ / " '

($%) $

') * ) '

%&*$ #-B9 E $B *> "% > E $ 2#% >