← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20946/2019dismissed

National Welfare Health And Education Awareness Charitable Society (Regd.) v. Punjab State Board Of Technical Education And Another

2019-09-24Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary,Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal8 pages

 

      

    ! " 

## !$#%&'&()*!%! # +,-& ! .!( (/  0!& 1%#'&(&%! , &  ! "

#$ $

    "

# $$  # ! !2 ")&.

! !,/.2*!")&.

!! & !)%32 %!")&. ! 2 %!")&.

!! & $%&'()(**+,-

 1% ! +!-!&(&!% ,-! )"4 %! !! !!&5% +6 6 7% #%& ##-3*/%##- %!+%! !! !!&5% ##-5 !&(-*+!& #(!%!+7.!!&"% !#!"% +% &(-(!-& #(!)% +! 47-!.%%(/  0!& 1%#'&(& 7&(!#1!-! &%##-##+-!&

# !% &+!  8 ".%(-%%##-% &##%!+ 

!.#  7%  (!%!.!!&%! &(& #!9 /! &&:  4  !-%##-!

 & #  (!    %!+   1%! !"  %  %!+  (#    7& ! &-!&

!.#&&  ; !&(-% !+!

 %& #(!%  ;84$*.!"%##-*( # !%&(!&(!-%  ;84&"%! !".&

# &&  4 4!<(*&! & !!*#  -!& !!-*& #(!%!+1%

#* %& 8 , &*!#!&&   

%##-3-

#+ !% !

!.# 8 "*%% 

!%. -!&.&#!&& ;   " + *%%%  #&!!& +*+ .###(

#  1%& 

!.#

!%. -!& (!( !!&( + &: :  *%#"%##-& !%

# && 6   ! & !! !%8%!+ (!&(!-% 8 !!%!! &%&&(& .!  %##-&%& &(!& *%!(  %##-*!#!&&:   *!-%&&   %&  &(*!-!&-%#& %##-, & ! #&.&#!&&4   +%%!<(&(%& ## !.&&"%" -!&1%

# # #  !& !#3 + # 1%! !"%##- ( &! !&&   "  6  "  6  " 6  "

:  6  & ;  !!*# &-!

# 7 "! &#!&&  ;   + *%%% 

#&!!&%!(-%.###(

#+-%%- #&  (  !  %      (

#&  +  %  ##-  &   ! & !&!     =&  #!  &&  :     )##  7&  (#    1%#

.

'&()71'-!&

!.#%##-(&!%)##7&(# 1%#'&(>!

!.# !1%#7(,-(#  4%! !! !!&5 4,-(#57

!.#.#& !* +! !%& (&!&-%!%! .#&#+ --

# !%! .?.!+90!& 1%#'&(&

(# ##- >.!!<(! !& : 7% !& 3&! "#!&(# !

( % !%& 8 "%##-%&!<(

!.#  &&)71'%&#(&%#! 

!.# @"

& #&( /! &-!

#% ##- !!-8%!+&(!-% 8 1%!

!  8(  %- #&( ! (%&&* *%(  /(!&      !.    % (/    0!&    1%# '&(&7&(!#1!-)"

%! !! !!&5%(/ )5!+!(#&!-(# !&%!(&!(%!! & %!-!&0 !-! #!

!.#")71'%&&(&  & !%  ! !

!%&# #&& (#&- *!#-1%)71' -!# &+(&(&!!# )*## !.#.!! &  &+(&(&!

)    )(-%% )!,(#&,-(# !& %!(&!"(%!&! &-%(!-!&-%#& ##-"(%(%!+*(#&  #*%%(%!+-!&(&!% !##-# <(#+"%!##-#*#& !.#& )71'%&-!&#!

!.#"&& %- #&(!  + &#+(/( & ( #+##-#7 (!%!!-(& %    ! !    !-(#       4  ,-(#  *(#&  %*  %  



#- !&!<(!& !*!&.*)71'

# !.& !*##- 1%(" .(% &%&!&&%##-%!*#!

!.#*(#& %. -!& +)71'$.-&"! & 

!&3&

!&%- -!-

#A##+ !-(&%! &%&-.!*##-% +!  &%.#& !## 1%("%!* !<(!3 !% !%& 8 1%

!)71'&! &*!#!&+.# #&! & *&(+ (&-!

#(&!(%!(,#% 

#&( /(&- $5 # ( !(! &  

  

     

  

 !"

## $! 

 )%!

&.%  #& %# &*%! .!!&%% ! %  #&*%%# / !-

!  )!&-#(4 )##7&(# !1%#'&( >! )

!.# !1%#7(,-(#" "%  (%!+ !-!-& &+*%(%!+% &#-& +% 9?1!& !3-& , &%  (%!+(&!%&#(&B! (%!+"&(+ (&(!%#+##-*%%! (##+ #*%##!<(! !-!&

# ; 

)#(% (&&( && %&( ( (!

 -!

#)

!.#-!& +)71'&#&#+ !%

(!

 -!

#*%%(%!+.&! &1% *!-! &% (&%##-  !

#%- #&

/ ( !%  & +, &(%!&#* %3%( %#&*%%%##-% !(&& (#&(#%%- #&(! ( &"

# -!&1%*! "%("# # && 6 ?&( &#+"*%#-# + #-#(!&% + !##-#(!( +% #&"% #-#%3*+ %!##-#$*.!"( ! %*% %% &% !# #-#(! %& %(%!+   % ! . #*  A!%

(!

"! !*(#& !+%#&%=77% %&(# %( 7&C!&(# !% #&3 +(%! !&"%("%#&% (& !%!-(7   %%!-"*! !&-B%!& & %&! ! (-+ 1%!-(#+ &% 

! ! %)71', !% &+ !. )## 7&(# !1%#'&()" 4;!+,(#!,-(#

!&%!(&!1%("#!&(# !% #& #% %)71'%#+(%!+#&B%( %#&  &(#(3-

!.#7%("%!-( #!& (# !! & &(  ; 

)%   &1%& ;(!% (&&( & " *%% +(3-

#1%  .#&+#(&##% #(&-% !-%#& % 7( ( %#&& #-%##-!( / %!& #"%##(%!(#& !&3(&!% ###* !

- (! % (#&- 13-B #"*%!% ##-%!(& (#&-( !%&#&"%##(%!

*(#&    /( &    3-      %  #&  &  3-    &# % (#&- (%*(#&&.!#+

%!! % (&*%%.3&&"%("% %#&%3-  !!-!&-( %#& ##-3-

#*% %(%!+ 

#- &+7%"%##-&&#+&  %- #&(! ! !-!&-%#&%* ((!!(

 %! &&    (& + 1%#&!"0##+!!%%#& %##-#%

+&%!& ( !-%1%&! # &&    (& +%1%#&!0#!%%#&-(( &  % +1%!&!  .&(& +% (%!+!%%#&# ! !& : +!*%% + &%% #& (#&- #!&(#+

!.& +%1%#&!

!& #(&!&%(%!+(&!*%%%1%#&!"0# (#&((%! )!&-#+"!-( #!&(# !%

! &%&! ! (-+!/&1%/(&-%  

      %"

#+* %. (&%%&! ! (-+!&% !

 1%  !-(    #!&  (#  !  %  !  &   ,-(#  % 4,-(##.&,-(#  ! !&(& #* !!&+! ! 8 & ' ( )% *   

              

  

  !    

! "# 

 $

  %    



&    %             

    

       #

  

    ; 1%&!-(#%%.* 

#- !& !!.&"%)71'*(#& !& (!%! !-%

# 1%!%-!!&&%! &" "-..* %

#( & +%##- 1%("*(% &%&-. .!& .(! %##- % -   (    

!.#  #!  +  % )71'   1%  !-(  % &*

& !!-% /!-!&-%- #&( !%.-!&&% %##-"%("&!.  !/&(!-%#+ 4 1%!%!  %!) !(# ! ! &&   &  6  %*%%##-*3- !!*# %&3- !!*(! 7.* % ! !"%!-( #!&(# !% &&:  4  &&& !*&" #+!&!+C!& (# !% #& (+(!+ !.*%%

!.&%-!&%##( !##7% .* %!"*%.%%#&-% & *B !%& 8  1##% -!&

# -!&&<(#+%!-( #!& (# !%%&&:  4  %&# &" !/&

 1%(%!+ &% ! &&!#+ (%##-%&(&& -

!.# !%)71'&

&" &%

#%(#&%. -!& (##+ 7 -!

# ! !-%( 

!.# %.- -!& +%!#(%!"%%(/ )*(#&  &&#!1% ! -!-%

#*(#& !&(&!

!#+&(!( (#(##-(#& #+*%% ((! %!(&

(%!

!*(#& - ( #!& & & A!% (!

!# #&  #   

   + ,-  

  '$ .

"##''.

*%!% ( !(!B&% !. #(# 1%!'&()"

:&!-(# !&%!(&!&%#&% &          % &  )"  -!    !-         +

!#+   1%*! "%("*%(!&&& 

    $  #   

  $23*2452) - 

   

   '2*'2)23)*+5,2!267