← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4119/2011dismissed

Punjab Agro Foodgrains Corp. & ANR v. M/S Shivalik Rice Mills, Sahai

2015-08-13Mr. Justice Arun Monga5 pages



    

 

 !!"#$#%&'('$ )*+

'%,-(. /(.#%$.0. #%1#2# !/*3%/#(.3 00!44% 5!.$'$

6$73#84#9 #"! #44$*'.'.73#*#$ .#"  !.:!0'.

 !$0%/!%   

   !"

#$  ;3! 3!. !0. !.$4"400!.$2<-!44=!/ $!! 3!,'/(2!% >  -!.!!..!/  3! !0. !.$.% > ) ;3! 3!. 3!,'/(2!% $3'4/-!.!0. !/#% 3!#(!$ >

.!$!% &

. %$4*/8" !* . 3!00!44% 

.7%/!!0?3'%(!.*/8" !* . 3!.!$0%/!%  @@@@@  !"

 %&' 3!  "344!%(!  #%  3!  0.!$!%  00!4  #$    3!  ./!.  / !/ AB0$$!/-< 3!#$ .#" '/(!* !.:!0'.*=3!.!-< 3!-,!" #%$ #4!/-< 3!2#44!.(#%$  3!=.// !/BC*38!-!!%""!0 !/-< 34/#%( 3  3!/#$0' !=$% =# 3#% 3!/2#% 3!.-# . .*-' =$  3! %(#%(#.!" .$0!. 3!!D"!0 !/"4'$! 3!(.!!2!% 

. %$4*  4!.%!/  "'%$!4 00!.#%( % -!34   3! 00!44%  $'-2# $  3  3!  -,!" #%$  38!  !..%!'$4<*  2'"3  4!$$* "0.#"#'$4<-!!%""!0 !/* 3'(3 3!"4#2 3!00!44% =$% =# 3#%

3!!D"!0 !/"4'$!%/!8!%.2 3!0!.'$4 3!=./* 3!.-# . . 3$=./!/#% !.!$ %4<EF0!.%%'2%/* 3!.!.!* 3!#20'(%!/ ./!.#$4#-4! -!$! G$#/!!'. 3!.$'-2# $ 3 *#%" * 3!#$ .#" '/(!#4!/ % #"!"%/# #%$C%/B 3!(.!!2!% /# -!!% % #"!/*0!.30$-,!" #%$='4/38!-!!%/#$2#$$!/

.7%/!!0?3'%(!.*4!.%!/"'%$!400!.#%(%-!34 3!.!$0%/!% G2#44!.3$/.=% 3! !% #% 3!'.   3!=./ %%!D'.!G  "% !%/ 3  3!"4#2 3!00!44% G.0. #%*#% !$$!%"!*=$$0!."%/# #%A 3!(.!!2!% $!4!2!% )F8!. %/-8!F#$!%8#$(!/*=3!.!$$0!."%/# #%$C%/B* 3! 00!44% #$!% # 4!/ %4<F%/ 3!.-# . .3$4$=./!/ 3! #% !.!$ EF. 3!#.$ <!.%/'. 3!.#% !.!$ E)F%/* 3!.!.!* .#(3 4<$ 3!#$ .#" '/(!""!0 !/ 3!-,!" #%$%/.!4!( !/ 3! 0. #!$  3! %(#%(#.!" . 38!3!./ 3!4!.%!/"'%$!4. 3!0. #!$%/00.#$!/ 3!00!.-9 % ./!.    00.!"# !  3! "% .8!.$<* #  ='4/  -! 0   .!0./'"!"%/# #%6"4'$!A 3!(.!!2!% *=3#"3.!/$ 3'$&G  



 



                                        !

  

 "#$% &'()&               *        +

           &     

  

 

     

          

(      

 

 



         , -   .'/                0   

 

    12&-33

"   

   1

2

  $    

$           &     +   

             

     !





  "#$  % &  '()   

                                   1 4 

$  

  





                    -         53

 -      )667.66. -   

 





 

 

      8.'/  

    8)6/   

 

    

 , -    

       0       

  +               1

2

     9 3!.-# . .*=3#4!(.% #%( 3!.!4#!*3$=./!/#% !.!$ EF0!.%%'2%/'. 3!.#% !.!$ E)F0!.%%'23!0!. #8!0.  3!./!..!/$ 3'$&G          



        

  

      

    

 

  53    

 

         !):&6;&66766     8.'/  

    8)6/          



 6'6:.667 3

%

         !   

    533  

 

  

                    



      

                            9 %(#%( 3.'(3 3!"%/# #%$%/ 3!0!. #8!0.  3! ./!.$'0.

* 3!./!. 3!#$ .#" '/(!#$0!.!" %/ 3!.!#$% #44!(4# <*2'"34!$$*0!.8!.$# <#% 3!$2!3!#$ .#" '/(!3$.#(3 4< -$!.8!/ 3  3!"4#2 3!00!44% 44$=# 3#% 3!!D"!0 !/"4'$!* % #"!/-8!*%/.!4!( !/ 3!0. #!$  3!/#$0' ! 00!.-!.! 3!

%(#%(#.!" . 3!00!44% 

.%$43$.!4#!/'0% 3!,'/(2!%  3#$'. .!%/!.!/ #% )* +&%*, -./ -''* 0/%*1* 2134&5

6&6/ -7-'

188'-/* %8%&6-3 &3+ &36,/%"

(9 -7-' 9 "% !%/ 3  3!

/#$0' !='4/44=# 3#% 3!!D"!0 !/"4'$!%4<=3!% 3!.#"!$'004#!/-< 3!2#44!./!$% "%.2  3!$0!"##" #%$ 2.#/* 3!.!2!% #%!/.('2!% #$% 44"#'$%4< -'  /!$% 38!%<$'-$ %"! $ 3! !.2$%/"%/# #%$ !"3 (.!!2!% 38! -!.!/...#8#%( "%"4'$#% %0!.'$4 3! !.2$%/"%/# #%$!D ." !/-8!* 3! .-# . .3$-$#"44</!"#/!/ 3!.!!.!%"!-<=./#%(#% !.!$ EF 0!.%%'2%/'. 3!.#% !.!$ E)F0!.%%'2*=3#"3#$%4<0.8#/!/#% "4'$!GA%/% "4'$!$6"%/# #%$C%/B %8#!==3 3$-!!%-$!.8!/-8!* 3!.!#$%#44!(4# <*

2'"34!$$*0!.8!.$# <#% 3!./!./ !/AB3!$2!#$""./#%(4< '03!4/ !$'4 % 4<* 3!00!4#$/#$2#$$!/ 7#%"! 3!#$ .#" '/(!3$4.!/<.!4!( !/ 3!0. #!$  3!

%(#%( #.!" .* 3!<* 3.'(3 3!#."'%$!4* .! /#.!" !/  00!. -!.! 3! %(#%(#.!" . 3!00!44% %B+%/$344#4! 3!#..!$0!" #8!"4#26"'% !.G"4#2*#%<  #$!D0!" !/ 3  3!2 !.$344-!/!"#/!/$!D0!/# #'$4< $0$$#-4!*0.!!.-4<=# 3#%0!.#/!#(3 2% 3$.2 3!/ ! .!"!#0 "!. ##!/"0< 3#$./!. 1:1*6 ("

9  ! %&;/*,

#$