High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25504/2016dismissed

Santosh Lata v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2022-02-03The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli9 pages

!"!#$% & "'(

)

!#* +*"," &

*- #. '*" ) "/#.#

*"# $0 1* 23'!

&!#4'5.2

5* !#* 1* #6,* 1!

75 ..7 .2

#* 75 *- 8!

' 1*& ,* 9'1 45""!"

#* 7 *- * '*"/#.# " :' *"

!. /*"# !" 9!#4 * *.. '*,4' 2!. #*# !#4 "!# /* .!#4" *9!#4 #., .!#2!* , 7,* ;

!" +!. '!#"

/ !#5 !#*8'!7 7 !3!#4

!#/* .!#4"<, '*7 #.'

"7 /".,#.*"

!#:; !4'

!*3/#"

#.* #"/ *# -!#( #. <,!"!

!#5 9!7!

73# 5 %5 '

" # #..

"' /,* '

". ' #.3 ",*!#4=>3 #.1 3/*!".!#?'8

"% #. @% 3!#5 ?'

#! 5 5 ?'

"* # @AA5 "!

. 8!

'!# *2#,"

+!77 4 .'*!5'"!7 .'*!5!"

3,# 2!. "

7 .. .

. @B #. @@ *"/ !27- &' ,* '* !3.

2* !#"''

" #"

*, ',"8'*!#

2 "'!"*"!.!#4'"

!.7 #.8 <,!*.2!. '# !!

!#"!"",.,#.* & !#C '( #. <,!"!

!# 5B@:'*!# 9***.

"B@ ;.

.@@ #.@@*"/ !27-D778.9-

*.,#.*& !# 'B@ .

.%@@%5 '*9- <,!*!#4

#.* '/,97! /,*/"# 37-5.27/3# #., !7!E

!#7 **"!.# 75 33* !

7 #.!#.,"

7 5& *FB5 .'*! 9#/7 ..

* !##!

'* '/'-"!

7/""""!#'

6# #* 3/#"

!# '

" 9# / !.A ./"!

',"59 ' # !#4# !" "/*2!..,#.*"

!#:; %

*,7!77. '!#2!

97 # 7,"!# '*!#!" /"!#4 /* .!#4"<, !# ' 3

* 8 .G,*#."!#.! !#4 '. !"!# #H97 #"

, !# # ' ' #H97 &,/*3 ,* #.!

8'! ' ""!E. '!"", "*4 *." '!# */*

!#& !#:; % " 7 !37 /"!#4 !#'#"

, !## ' . !.. ' /#.!#4 !"", !# "

!" ' /#,7 !3

4* /'" "*4 *." '4,!.7!#"!"",.9- '#H97&,/*3,* #.!

**/*., .'*!#,#.*$0 #$ % & '('( ) &

& & *+ & ,

- & & * ) - ) )) && . , - & + ,

'('-(& & * &/! & - * 0 ) #1 '( - )

- #1

3 #10 & 2 ,

'( & & * 3

) & & &

& + & - 3

- )+ - 3+

+ - 3 0.

4 4 & '( & & * &

0 2 & 5

'( - ) 6 & ,

-& '

)( & & &

2 & & /!

) &

& * - , *& 2 & /! - & &

+ * & -, 75 &

' (

& 2 ,&5 )

6 & ,&& +

& * - 8 )8

& & & 2 &

&/! 9 -

*'( & & /! + 2 '( 5 5 &

0 - ,

, *'()) &

) , & & ,

+ 2

, '(& & * " 0 '(& & *

- & '( & '('-( : 0 & 3, & /!

'(-),& 2 ; <)-

3, "& &/! +

, '( & & *+ - 3 '( / 0 & '( , & & ,

- & 3

& & -& & * &+ ,& 2 , ) 0 & - & - - .

&& !

'(& & * ,

) & 2 , &

, & 2

, , && & & *+ + 5- ,

)

) 2 , & & 3,

, & &

& 2 1 % ,*", '. !"!#/ "".!##.*27/3# - :",/* ;5 '&

8 77.,/# !7*"/#" "*4 *." 2*3# .!# '/*"# / 7" .3#"

'8 "!# #.!" 2*.8!

'G,.43# / "".9- '#H97#"

, !## ' '&,/*3,* #.!

" #"<,# '* 5 '&

"!7. " "'* */7- .

. %*. 1 * '5 8'*!# 8'!7 ***!#4 !# */*

!#3 .9- '#H97&,/*3,* #.!

"9#"

, 8/ * 7"7 #.3 ",*!#4=>3 #.3 !#*

.3!

.7-!" ",9"<,# /,* '

"*<, '/7 3 ",*!#43 5'# 5

## <,"

' 74 7!

- !# /* .!#4"A 7 !3 7 /"!#4

!#/* .!#4"<, '/7 3 ",*!#43 8'! ' "/* '8#

" !#*'

.9#/,* '

".2!."

7...

.@@!

*!"", # # !!

!#,#.*"

!#B@ & " # !#*'

2!#4 #"

*, *"!.# 7',"2* # '*/ * 7 7 #. 3 ",*!#4 = 3 "5 !

" 9# # #..

, = 3 3/*!"!#4!#?'

"* #@AA7 #.3 ",*!#43 : "<- *.";8 *7 ".*3 !#8!#4 '"

*, ,*!#I!"

5 !"", # # !!

!#,#.*"

!#B@ '*3 !#!#4 2

7 #.8 <,!*. "9#,* '*",93!

.!# '*/7-

" <,!*.!" # *#.5 '/""""!# '"

6# 2!.

G# 3 '

=B.

.%@@% #7- '!"5 '3,

!#8 #"**.!# 2,* '9#! !

*-./ 3# !5 :#8&+ ;2!.1,

!#@.

.%&

' 3/#"

!#!" # *#.5!

8 ""

' 3/#"

".,7- #.*. !#*9, "'.!.# '"

38'! '5"' !"

7!9* - * !2 '!7 *7-!#4 ,/# ' .!

7 !. .8# !# #.* 27/3# -:",/* ;!

!" # #..

!#2!8 87 !. .8#9- '#H97&,/*3,* #.!

'/7 9!#4!#/'-"!

7 /""""!#* 3/#"

!#'

2!#4# 9#/ !.!"#3* !7 97

!#* #7- '!"5**# '

7"9#3 . '**# !7.9- !#*,#.*& !#BB@ "6!#4*0.

*3!#

' 3/#"

8'! ' 7" .!"# 7" '* 7 !3

3/#"

!#'

"# 9#/ !. '* ",* '*9#"

.9- '&

!#!

"*/7-

!#!"2*-3, '""# 7* 3/7 !# .27/3# 5*8'! '5!

!"*<,!*."3, '"!

'#* .% *8!.5#"* .@3 *8!.5@# /7 3

4*- "!

#,*"*- " '7 ' *7!

# /7 . 9- ' / !#* ,/# = >3 3 '*(

/*8 "*/77.9- '&

9-***!#4 #.*27/3# -:",/* ;8'*!# '!"G,.43# ""/ !!

77- 9#2*0*,7.# '#. '/* -*!" 3 .*.!"3!""

7 '/*"#

6 "#!

'* ' # !#4# !" "/*2!..!#& !#:; % !" !7 97 !#* "/!

'"'* */7-'

2!#49#!7.#%*.1 * '55 !#* '

" '"# # !7 #- */7!

!# 1* #6,* 1!

// *!#4 * ' &

8'!7 ***!#4 ' I/"!

!# !# #.* 27/3# -:",/* ;'

*4,.

7 !37 /"!#4 "/"

,#.* & !# :; % 5 9 ' # !#4# !" /*2!.. * *<,!*. 9,7!77.3 #!#4 '*9-

'* '/""""!#'

"9#

6##* ' 3/#"

!#'

"9#/ !. '/""""!#'

"9#

' 3/#"

!# !" # / !. #. 2! 02*"

' /7 7 /"!#4 *3

!#!"# !7 97'

.,* '* *4,.

" '/'-"!

7 /""""!#

!# <,"

!" # *#.5 .* 8!#4

# '#

E# 3 '

!" ",! !# #"

' /'-"!

7 /""""!#'

"9#

6## "!#'

#.5 '/""""!# #.!# <,"

!#!""

29#

6#2!.

E# 3 '

=B.

@@% 8'! ' 8 " 778. 9- * *.!#4 ' 3,

!# !# 2,* :#8 &+ ; 2!. 3,

!# @ .

. %5 '# /'-"!

7 /""""!# "

#."

6# " "/ 3/#"

!# !" # *#.58'!7*7-!#4,/#

%#.*27/3# - :",/* ;5' *4,.

#.*!#4 3/#"

!#!"",! !#

.!" '

*4 97!4

3 6 ' / -3# 8'! ' ,* '* 3 #"

8 "3 . !7 97 #.8#*'

",* '* *4,.

!#!"2*-3, '""# 7 3/7 '.27/3# 8*6 /* '/7 ##!#43 . '!2 '/,97! /,*/"5*8'! '5 #.'

9# <,!*. '!#* "

*, ,*'

",* '*

7 .* 8#,*

.!# '7!"

#.2# "8'! ' ",*/*!"!#47- *3!""!#4!# '3 !#/ !#! .3!""!# !#*

9, '*9!#4",9"<,# /,* '

"*<, '/7 3 ",*!#43 #.'* 7 #. 77!#4!#?'

"* #@AA'

2!#49#*7 ".*3 !# '

2 #"!.*. ' *"/ !2 /7 .!#4" *4,3# !". 9- ' 3/ !#4 / !" ' !# */*

!# 3 . 9- ' #H97 #"

, !# # ' !# #.* 27/3# , - :",/* ; 8 " 3!#, 7- /*,".& '74 7/"!

9, //7!

9!7!

-& !#:; % !" # *#.5!

!",# 39!4,,"7- 7

7 !37 /"!#4

!#5 9 ' # !#4# !" * *<,!*. 9 ,7!77. 8'! ' #"

'* ' # !#4# -!"# ,7!77.5 '9#!

.3!#4 !

!#7 /"!#4!"# !7 97& '8*.J/'-"!

7/""""!#H ,**!#4!#& !#:;!" # *#.5!

"9#!# */* 3 #

E# 3 '

!"* *.. ** *.!#4

E# 3 '

#-9.-*0# *" <,!*./* !#*2#*

!# <,!*./* !#5 "

," 8!77 9 #7- *"/ ""* &!3!7 *7-5 " *4 *." ' 8*. / !. ,**.!#& !#:;% D!

"9#!# */* 3 #

8 " 3 . !7 97 ' 7 #. 8#* # ' /*"# "5 "/ !!

77- # #..!# '*/7-

' 3/#"

* !#<,"

!#8 ".,7- #.*. '*5 '**5 !#*#8 ##

'/7

' 3/#"

8 "# / !. '*

9!#4"5 9 ' # !#4# !" !# ' /*"# " * # ,7!77. *",7

'*5 ' 7 !3 !#*"6!#47 /"!#4 !#<, '* #.!"7!

97 9*G .',"5 ' 7 !33 .9- !#*" '*7 #.9!#4 #./,* '

".2!."

7...

.@B

8 77!#4!#?'

"* #@AA8'! '*3 !#.,#.* **7 " 7 #.3 ",*!#4 "<- *."58'

2#'"!

'7.

".!" '

*4.!

"97!4

!#"<, 9 ' # !#4# !" "/*2!..,#.* "

!#:; % "!# */* .9- '#H97&,/*3,* #.!

!##.*27/3# -:&,/* ;"

#.",7!77.',"5 7 !3 /, * '9- !#*<, '!"/ * 77 #."

#."*G .

" ' /7 3 ",*!#4 3 3/*!". !# ?'

"* @AA!" # *#.5"

3 .3!

.7-'

"9#/,* '

".2!."

7...

@@ !#/* .!#4"!# "!#'

#.8*!#!

.2!. # !!

!# ,#.* "

!# B@ .

. @@5 '# 5 ,#.!"/, .7-<, '!"/ * 77 #.5 !#*!" ",9"<,# /,* '

"* " # #.. 9- 1* #6,* 1!

75 ' 7 8 " *4 *." ' 7 ," ",9"<,# /,* '

"* '

77#4 !#/* .!#4"!"877"

#. #"!"

7-5!

"9#'7.

",9"<,# /,* '

"*'

"#*!4'

!7*<,"

!#/* .!#4"'

"***. 'G,.43# "".9- '!",* !# ?=7 " 9& / =@

&> 8'*!# '!",* *.!" ,""!#4

G,.43# "# '/!# !#!"",5*!

",9"<,# /,* '

"*'

# *!4'

!7 !# /* .!#4" !" " 9 ," #- # ,39* # *

.# *!"", # # !!

!#,#.*"

!# ' B@8,7.# 9!#. '&

(!68!"5! #- #"

!# "

"9# **!.8!

'*"/ #.# !!.,#.*"

!# B@5", ' #"

"9"*2.9- '/I,* !# A % & !

9*: !" J2!.

!#H #. # *!4'

# 9 "

!. '

2 9# 78. *3 ", '

!#"8'! ' *2!. 9!#!

!&, '2#.'

"#*!4'

77#4

!# /* .!#4" 3, ' 7"" # ' 7 !3 7 /"!#4 /* .!#4",#.*"

!#:; % = " "<,7 '.!" ,""!# 3 . '* !# 925 **# I/"!

!#!##.*27/3# -:",/* ;56/!#4!#2!8 '

E# 3 '

#." * *.. !# 2,* ' 9#! !

*- ./ 3# ' 3/#"

2!#49#.,7- #.*. 92

776/!#4!#2!8 !#!"2*-""# 7 8'! ' '/,97! /,*/" * 8'! ' ' 7 #. '

. 9# <,!*.5 8 * ' #"!.*. /!#!#

'* ' # !#4# !" /*2!.. ,#.* & !# :; % !"3 ., !# '/*"# " *.!#47- '/*"# / !"'*9-.!"3!"". #.!#4 //7!

!#"5! #-5 *.!"/". : +&? ; & :

((; % 2!#.* '

'*"/ 6!#4A* "#. "A '

'**/*

97 "A