High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/382/2013dismissed

Prem Chand v. Financial Commissioner Coop. Pb. Etc

2015-01-22Mr. Justice S.C. Datta13 pages

! "# "$ %&'(

)# *+) , ),

!

"#$#%#$ &'( &

# # % &'#'#$#& # "#)#%#*

&'( &

) #+#

,

' -./

0

,

1

#2#2 3'4 .2

# 5'

3&

( % & 2#26#2 3'4

.

#57 0

&0

& &4

%$ (%

-8

0

(% '&8-3 9': & & & ;

< & <

#

#+# =

"

) #+&

(

(

.< # "

%

<

(

,

&0

(% # ( &

;

4

/-> 22>

#'

+#2?#88 3'4 .

$= (

'

& 0

( % 1& (

(

%

#? 5 % # ,

(

#?5

& ,

#+( 6#2#88+3'4 .+#%

<

.

((

&

-

( #,

#+5 00

(=<@#&'(% = & "

# A (& "# '( % =

&

# &;

(

.

&

< .

( (

)' =' . 0%.=<

#

&

#+5=<

%

??

'

& 0

( % &%#B

&

4 <

(

# =

&

#'

& ( '

) #-5C ( % &D4;%

%

) #+5=<#,

&

#

( 8#2#22

3'4 .2# &

) #+5=<

%

-6

'

C

3

(% & #* 2#2-#22?3'4 . &C

3

'

4

#' &

(

%

-8

'& 2-#2#22-3'4 .+ C

3 &0

(% & #' &C

3 ( 6#26#22/ 3'4 .?

8#2#22

<

#

(

%

-8

'

%& 0

3'& # * #2?#2263'4 ./&%0

3'&

6#26#22/

C

3 # &( -#2#226 3'4 .6&C

3

) #+5=<#' &

#+5=< (

%&0

&4

$ (&%

-8

'&

C

3 -#2#226

<

(

-#2?#2283'4 .8!;

! "

" !

" "

! # ! #

$% &'

$''(

" " !

)

! #

$% &'

$''( "

# " # #

!

# * #

# # * #

+

# !

#

#

+ ,-

.

,- ! / "

* +,

.,

"

) 0

#

" '

$% 1' 2 / $2 $''$ *

#

2! / "

3 0

#

+ # * + # / + +

# !

, !+ 4 + # ! ! / / "

# # # 2 ! "

# (% %& % '( %1 % '( ! "

,

!

#

# ! " "

* !"

# ! " "

#!

&

#+ 5 =< '

3&0

(% & ( #2#23'4 .2

# &

(

&

7 0

&

& &4

%$ (&(

2#26#23'4 .#A&

# ,

&

#&& +

#

#+&

'4

. .+

C %

( 1 # ,

(

#+

;

#

) #+; =<

0

( %

(

'#

5=<

#

="

"

=

5 =<

&

.

1

% #'4 ;+.

+##88+

& 0

( % &

(

'0% 5 ,

%#'

&

=,

&

E= "

.

<

1

E 1

;

<

E

00=

;

#*

(

=<& &<

#

<FF #,

(

( '4 ;+.+&

1 <

=<

0

=<#=

&

1 #,

1

<

=<# ,(

# @

(

%

(

#

#@

#28#88+ 3'4 .+

% (1 #% &

#'

C

3 # )

#0 C

3 & '

3# 7,

#7,

C % 1 #

(

-#2/#2 '4 . &

-#2/#2 #

'

(#@

0

!!"# $ "!

A G% 0 %

&

' ( !!)# $* )+, # $

-

!!.#"$# $,!

A G= A 0 / & 0

-1 '2-3( #'4 $ !!.#"$ # $," &

# A (&

) #+ (

#?

'4 ;+.+

1 0<

=<

0

=<1

<

"#, ( C

3 &

1

#

'

3 1 (< &

#,

'

C

3

# @

) #+ 1

(

& #,

C

3

#

(

(

#H

&

< #

&

&

.

% (

#

&1

# @ (

+##88+

'0%&

<

" = "

.

<

1

#,

=,

&

#,

&="

(

1 (

<

#,

(

-#2?#228&%0

4

$ (

(

'

(

# 7

(

#

(

# ,(

#

(

(&

%0

4

$ ( ( '

( 1

<

%

% #%= " ( ( #,

( #

FF#'1

# , G

4

< &

( 28##868

="

= #2 #88&

((

#

<

1 (

#'4 ;+.+

#?&

1

<

<

# 7

&

# ,

(

'

#,

#7 & ( ( #7 <

( (

& ((

# '

&

5'

#

C

3 (

&

C

3

&'

<

(

'#

'

( (

7 0

&

4

%$ (#

&

#7

(

( # @

(

# D(

<

(

@

'

( ( &

&

# ,(

(&

# )

# "$ %&'( -

% ./

, "012 (< $30