High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16471/2024dismissed

Naveen Kumar Batra v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2024-12-20Mr. Justice Arun Palli,Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal30 pages

-1-

#$ $ ! %!& !"

$ $

() '$ *

))

() '$ * + ,'

)

! "

#$%& !

& & ! % &

( $) ! % &

#& ! % &

)'( "& ! *

& !

$& ! *++), ----

)) - $ ./ +( ! &

&& .012011. 3*./ " &&

!% .

/01 1 .

$22 !

*04

*++ $ 511 6 7 ! ( 8& " 0911118* .1:"!091118*"

( &$" &! " 6

214118*" 51"!! 04: & !7(&!94: !

-2- !&(

& & && + !&.93/ &

&& " 6

(&$" (&$ & ! &

&& 8 " "&.21;0114"& !

&!& ( 8& (

(&$& &8!

<!" 8!

$ $

3 = "!

$ > ! & !

& && " ), !

! #$ $

456-( # ?$ ? @! & " !!

$ 6 8! .A.0011B "! " !

( ?C! ?$ =) ) 299

$ $

46$ & & & &!

! &!

! "& && #$ $

$ D > !

"! & 3 *+/.;1B0119& ! & !

! &

0.1B0119" 6 (

" $!

! "!"(

" " $" (&& ( 8& ! ( 2$ $

436$ > & !

" & &

&& ? "!

* " &

& (&$ & " 00.00114 "

-30;.00114 8& " > " " & ! 121B0119 $ + !

0114 ( $

& !

.934/ = ( )& !

.;99 3E .;99 !

F/ (

=) =!

&& !!& & $ & ! &" 8! && &

( " ( " && !

1A8.11.011A3*B/ " 7$ " ( # ?$ " ), !

! &&" ( !

" &(& !& !

,& ! 3 &/&.;A97 ( !! !

! 05.1011A3*9/! "8 $

& 0/ " ($ $$ & 1A8.11.011A !

.93A/ .;99 !

& 091201..3*A/! & $

& & &" ( &&

! 091201.. " ! ! $ (&! <! " " &( $

-4- % &"

3& /& ,<*4451*01.B ,

6 &! ! 8$ & !

" " % & !! & & $ >

" ! !$8 $

!$" ( !

(& ( !

" (& " 1A1A01.B " " " &(

& " (

!& < $ % & 5 -"! "" ".;1.01.9 " &(

$& &&

& 42 6&( "&" "! & ' " 091201.. ! " &! ( " 51.101.93*.;/" $ $ " !

! ,

$ # !! $& " .A.001.9 3*01/ 6 $ . *! " &! ! $ . .1.001.; 3*0./ !& " 091201..

" " .;99 !

7 && $ ! ,

$+ && 1B190101 ,

! 1.140105 3*04/ " !

-5-

" !!

&" .2.001053*0B/ &, !

, ! )

& 3410105/&( < & &! '$ !&&$ " .A150102 3*09/ " * , ! ! .11201023*0A/ 6 ! ( 8& ? $ ++),

5/ D !& (

" &

&& &&! 8 + $

(&$ & " !

00.00114 ( $& " 0;.00114 " & !

! !& !

! && (

!!! (

" " 0;.00114 !

" " ! " $ ( " ( & & ($(& !& (&$ & " !

! & !

& &&"! & " ),!

! 1A.0011B >

"&&!

.;1B0119& ! & !

! " $&

-6- ( & ( ! & &

( && < !! B24 5112011A " C! ( ? @! =) & 05.1011A " & !! !

! " & $ 091201..

(

& ($ ( &&!

&+ $

" " 7!

! 3/" *.5 >

! " && & %7 ( &&(

($ &

$ ( & C

& !" ( !&( !! $&

&!"&! ! ,

& $ >&& ! ,

##$%&' & && & ! ) !

( )*"

, $ %(" !* &-##$%.'/ #

, '-##1$%2-

-72/ < & !& & & !& " ($ " !! " ,

4/ &

&& $ $

& 8& " &&

( " !

8! .;99 !

7 3/ ! "&(C

!& - 5- 3 &

&& "!

* 3 $ 0

10 , 1 0

001 "

*" % 11 1 4 ( $0 1 '0 !1

(% 5*% %% * 0 ,(* (

0 41 %%

11 1 4 (%

(( $ , 1"( * , 6 7*

* ,% 5*%

' 8*4%% $

1 *1 0*%4

( 0 ,

(( $ *%(% 0 " * 0 0 %%

0 %% " 500 0( * "* ( *1

1 *1 ""*"-90( "% 1$

0(% 4 ( 0 ,

( "% 1$

" (

( $0 + !!1 : *% 31 ,*0 % (% % % *"

4% (

0" ,( 0 , ( 1 0 4%% 0 0 11 1 4 *% : *%

5* %(%1, - ( 0% 1

,4 ; ,< B/ !& 4/6 6

(&$ & 7/.8/!

! 90 ! &

&& 8

-8- !& 4//6 !

$ 04: (& ! 8&&

"(&$

" .8

!&.94///6- & ! &$ " (! ( 8& "&(& (

< & &10% 3 " $ $

& " ! $ &( " ( & & !

&!& ( & (

(&$&&&!

&& & &" " " ! ! 3;192 1.1A0114/ !

.935/ .;99 !

%:;./ !

< </.% ! 30!

! .

& !.

.6- (

& < 6 !

.932/ ! ..1B. 141;0114 " & $ ! ( ? @! =) " " !$ & & ! & "

8! && "! "&&

" !!*&(

9/ 7 $ ! $ ( (

& $ (&$&" !

( ? @! 00.00114( !'$&

-9- 0;.00114 " :/ & !&/ ( :/ 10/!=> ;% ;

19 ! " !

&& (

(&$ & &8!

< "((& & ! !$& ( " ! ! $ #$

( (&$& $ #$

3$ & $ ( !

&8!& $ 2$

3 < $ ! (*!& 3/3/=>& ! " & !$ !! !&3/ & ! (&$ & ( !! & &8!

$ $

3 6 !

" ! (&$ & " 8!

00.00114" && $ $

!$ ! ? @! (&$&!( ?7 ' > "&C C( " !&&$ ! >

$!& &(& & 6 & $> $ "& " $ &8 ( ( " &!$

!&"(& !

8& + # ?$ ? @!

-10- ),!

! #$ $

$ ! & !

& &&< " $ & ( ! & !

& ! & !

! .;1B0119 @(& !! !

! !& !*C ! &

!& &( &!

& $(&! &<!"

! "&" ! ! $ $

" ' " $ !

! & ( " 2$ $

> ! & " " "! ! 1.1A0114 !

.935/ .;99 !

!!&& & < & % .BBB82 .B10011B )

3 / & % & ( $ ! 3 " ,<*4451*01.B/

& & " H $ !$ $ $ ( & 8 $$ ! & "

!7 " ( ! !

&& !6 '"&$ " (

! ! $ $

!" " !! C! % $ $

7 !!&& "&&&""

!$& 0;.00114

-11A/ " &'"&$ (

& !

.934/ .;99 !

"&(&#3% /$ & ! && .11.011A!!&"

406 !

I 4@6 ), !

! " $ & ( I 4&6 ? @! & $

I46 # ?$ " ),!

! " &(& !& !

I46( " ( &&!

" !! $& " ( " ! 3/ "& C

" C &$"! "&! ! !&& * >? 1

4 % * 0

*" (% 64 *%1"(% $ 0 "

(

( ( ( 1 0 * @ ,

1 *1 4 ; 4 1"(% $ (%

*"( 4 ( !*1

1 1*"

1 0 *"( %

, 0% 4 ) ( $ 4 $ 0 3

0 (% 6 && -A33 (

4 1

(( %% 4%%( 7 0 *

( *1 4 7" 0 " ( 0 0 %41 0 *"( ( ,

001 + ! (

& -4*%1" 0 1 * "

1 %%, !

" "

001

; , 0 *

( (

*"( 4 ( B* 4

-12- * 1

%%4 1 *1 1"(% % % 0 1(%

* *% A' 0 +

, $%

$1 *" !(( %#*% A &2'< ;/ + "& ( !

$ ! &" ! ( "! " $( $

! "!! ! &! (

&& C

! !& !

(& ! & ! & " ( && .1/ " "&$$ ( 1A8.11.011A 5$ $

.93A/ .;99 !

7 ! " & C

&$ " !!& $&&&

& !

8! && !

*% 8/1

0/! 3% / !! "

!& &&$&&8 &!

7 /=/!01

011 .."" !

7$ ( "&&

( " !

/!./01

;% ;

&&($!$H &

( $ & .;1201.. ? @! =) !

& "!

&& ($ !! $& 0B1201..

-13- "(

"! (&$ "!!'( # ?$ " " ($

& & & 8 ! " && 7 (&$ " &$ !& & & &

" & $ )

7" & 3)7/ " .;1201.. ! $ (&$ " &!' !& !

8(&$ $ $( "&$&!' & 9*A ($ & "!!*&( ( && >

=) " &6 " (&$ & " !

I " &&" ( !

I ), !

! " I " !!

& & $!&" 6 ( !!

* >C 0 1 1 &

4 $ 0 (

*0 (% 4 * 0 * %(* ( * 0 %(* ( "0 " (

($ , !$1

(% * 0 % (* ( # (

4 1 %% 0 "

001

1 4 D* 0

$ @ " 6!A33A

001 + ! (

(

*% 0 3% % 6 && A-A33 (

1 1; , B* 0*

*% * 0 % (* ( 0 * % 6

-14- "

1 1

*% %,1% ( "

%, # (

0 " (

4 % 1 %% 4 0 " $ @ "6&2

4 ( 1 4 0*

4 ,*%4 "*"

, (%

4 %1; 4

*%!

"*1<

%% *% ! ( 0 "

0 " *%%,%1; 0 % 'A2" " (

1 $ 0 "

001

*% 1 *1 , *% B * % $ , 1

* * %, 1$ 1 4 + ! 001 % % %%

1 0 %

1 *1

( *1 (

" 1 0 %% " %

$ ( * F 1 *1 + !( (

1 *1 %, 0 % (* ( + 4 4 0 4 0 ( (

%4 4"

* %(% 4 %%

0 ( 101( D 1 4 (1 * 3 1 1*"

1 3 11 ( # $ 0% ,

001 0 !"

$ 41 (% 0 $* 0

> 001 %0

001 % (* 0 "1*1 0 0!"

+ ! % H* , 1

4 *% (% (% 4 1 0 *" ( (

, 4 1

4 * 4

1 1 4 % G! 4 %%4

1 *1 (% 0 *% 001 %0**%

( H* ,*% (* ( *% < 4 *1 ( 1 0 (

C 1""*1

-15- ../ + "& ( !

!& $ ! & 091201..( &

& ! & " </ 90

335 &$ & 091201.. $! & "& $

$ ('!

& &</

%&&

/ ;././ !

! !

" 6 ! 335

A 5 A 2 A # A 0!

$ " " 3/( " "! ( " ! & " ! /!/ ;!

/@1$ ( " !

" ! !

( !! C ( ,

" " &

)

&2IA > 3 1 %,

, *

D* , 0 B* 1 * 0 " (% 1*"

*" 0 (

0 B* 1 %$ , " J ( 0 "

( (% * 0 % ( * %% * *

( 1 $ 0 1 H* 1 *

(

1 % ( $ * %%1 *

"(%, *"( 1 4 4(

0 1"

4 4 4 % * % %* ,0 4 ( 0(

; $ % ( 1

* 41

-160*

0 "

0 D* 1 ????3 * * ,0 *

"( * ( % %( 1 "* 00 1 $ %,1*

"* *

4 0*% * * *D* , *% 0 * 0

( 1 0 *

4 1* 1, "(

% 1 (* $ 1 < 4/6 + 4335 6- ,

!041401.B &&"$

* G!

H* 0 ( D* .' . ( %%( *1 1 1%*

( 1 0%

4 " 4

; * , ( ( K 1 *

, %0 4 " 4

; * , %% 1 *

, 4 %0 ( %% % 0% 00 $

4 10 ( 1 5

( 1 4

( ," 1 *

, %0 ,

1 *

,4 %0< 7 " ! & " 1A1A01.B " " " &(

& * >77 77 77 77

1* %0 (

, %%4 4

4 ( 4 ( 4 %

0% 0 " 1 * 0

1"(%,4 0

- @ , . (% 1 1 % $ 1*" " 4

4 4 %

(

, 0 <

-174//6< & 5 ! 01.101.B * G ( 7 1* G

%4 0 !

,G!0 $* 0 *%)*"

.. % 1(, 0 G! % 4 7(%

0 (( 1 *

0 % -,

0% "(* ! 7* A2 4 ( '

!D*

$ .;1.01.9 " " * G! (

, 0 4 ( " 4

*D 1 ( L

% % 1 %

0% 0 ( " 1 * 0 , % %%

+ 4%% 7(%

* 41 * G

% 4 0 !

, 1*% 7 1* + %% % ( *1

1 %%

0 G

%4 0!

,< 4///6 " " ! ,

32 6 , !($!$H 091201.."$ (& & C& ($ " " 141401.9 * 1 ( 7(% %

% 1

; (%

$ %

A2 4 1$ , " % " ( *"0# % 14 #

B*1 %4 4 ;

%4 *

;

, 0 1 1 H* 1 1 (%

; 0* 0 %

-18- ' '< >

! 3.01901.9/

! ( !!$ " " ' " ( & " '"$ " !

!& 141401.9 " ) ! "& $ !!&&( &&(( $ ! & ,

7 (& ! * > ( ; 4

4 ( ( %

" , 0 0% $ 4

((%1

0 E 1 %"" +

, % *

$ %

4 1$ , " 0 *

-- ' %% % * 1 0 # $ %!* , 0 , *

* %

( "

(( 16 %

( % %

; , * J 7( ,(

% ,0

, %

( 1

( "

( 4 ( 11 %,( 0<

($ " .;99 !

!&!

% 7"J,

&$ )

.1.001.; "&! &( 4/ 6 $ & 32

6-&$!&&$ & .1.001.; !(&

-19- !& 1.140105 $ " "

( !!

* >

1* % 0 ( (

, 0 4

%0 4 ( ( 4 (* *

" , 0 (

" 11 ( 0

4 4 %

0 < .0/ &( ! " " $ ! ,<*;0.2*0101 &

& $& && *! * &, !

% +

, ! )

< $ &

.2.00105!!& * > (( %% 11 % "

(( %% 0% J +K% +*

*"( 41 4 4

4 , (( %% ' '

(( %% 0% $ 4

((%1

0 E 1 % "" 1( %

G$ " 0 +

, 4 * % (

" 0 $ 4 0

414 " *0"

% ,$

'< 77 77 77 77 3$ 40 $ 3 "0 1 $ 4

" , $ % % (( %% 41 1 (* * 0 * ,3$ 40 % %(

(( % , " "

% ( ((%1

0 , %

" < .5/ "" "8 " ! $ $ ! (

-20- $( ,

< ( !

( $(!' ! !&/=8.

1 != 90

" ! ,

335 &$ 3 091201../ ($ " && ! $ 141401.94.8 %=8

;

%& 0.

;0= 6( ,

! 3,<*;B09*01.9/ * 1 ( 7(% % % 1

; (%

$ %

A2 4 1$ , " % " ( *"0# % 14 #

B*1 %4 4 ;

%4 *

;

, 0 1 1 H* 1 1 (%

; 0* 0 % ' '< @ ! ! & "

( ! & " "

$! & " ! !&>

&& 091201.." '"&$" & 7 ! "

( & " $ & ( ! (& 091201.. & " ! !

!& >

$ (

( 51..01.9 "& '$

" & " "

091201.. "'"&$ &

-21-

& ! & $ &$ & !& 8 ( & (

" ! !

&$ $ ! " (& "" !

&&! ! 7 & 091201.. " '"&$ & & &$ + $ ! ! ! " ! C ( ! ( ,

# "

" 4

6 "

% $

2 &IA >-

"1*

1*%

1"""

% "( * %

0%%4 4 I >@ ; , % $ " 11 % ,0

,(% ( *1 , % 1*" , , * 1*" 4%% *11 0*%%,

%% %

, 1 % "

% %, (

, 4%% 1 1

% " 414%% ( 0

% 0 " ( % ,0

( 1* 0 ( D* ,%

0 "

4 11 4% 1 < .2/

$ $ !( & !&( && && $ ! " (& !

" & "$ *!

$ (&$ &

( & & &$ & & &" ( (!

( !! !

! (

-22- "& $ > !!& !

" &&$& &

/. ! & ;/. .80. && !

($&&

( " ! && C

" C " ! ! &"

!8"& 8

" ((&

" $ ! &" ! ( "! " $ &( & &C! !! 5 $ $

# ( !! !

! 5$ $

& ( $ & $

/<- !

.80.

.0=-

0&.%0119 @/!= % <

.8 ;% ;

011 .. ( ( "

(

( ! !!& & # 3% / !

& & & 8 ! " && 7(&$"&$ !& &$ " &!' 9*A * >E " (

1 $ 0 "

001 (

*% 1 *1 , *%B * %

$ , 1

-23-

* * F %,1$ 1 4 + !001 % % %%

1 0 %

1 *1

( *1 (

" 1 0 %% " %

$ ( * F 1 *1 + !( (

1 *1 %, 0 % (* ( + 4 4 0 ( (

%4 4" * %(% 4

0 ( 101( D 1 4 (1 * ?< < $ ! "

$ ! ( & &6 !&&$ .4/ 7 7 !

! 3*.5/ "! &! ($ &!( "

"($ "& !! > ( & ! 3> 7*./ & & !6

01.4*.B 1.812801.4 5181B801.41.819801.4 511;01.4 !& ! & F & ( 0 .8 *%!/8/ 0B ! $! &" $ !( & "" (

3 7/ 7 & ! $ ( &" ( ( 8& "

!& 7 !(& "8 &!!

" !

! !& " $ &&!&

-24- !01.1 ( " &H "&&

$1% / =($ &'& !& !& & ! ""406 "

& I4@6

"8($ I4&6 ( " ' 8 & &I 46 &&A 46 ! & (&$ 6 (! $ D( D"I4<6"$8&

" ($ ( " ' !I 4=6 & * 8!! !

" I 486 " 8&!

! (&& " ($ I 8 4/6 !!(& &" !&! !

&$ (

8&&

7 "&( !

! ,

01/;

*/!=8 0!

+ $ *.0.

< 0 90!0 0!

2 46 * - " "& &$ " & 6!&&( & !

%&./ !

@%/1/!= 0!

& ::!&:!.

< .8 ;

%&./ !

.8 /!.= ;0 . 8! &&

* > - ! 1*

% * % (% 4

511 %

4 $ 4 ( $ 1 $ %%

5 ( * 4 * * % 4 1"1 $ %(" 0

0 H*

"(%," ((

* %% "

%, $ , ( $0+ !!1 &''#*% # *%

* * %, ( $0 * %(%1,0

*1 0 *% 1"" 1 " 0

-25- ( *1

" 1 0

0 %% " (( %%

# $ % *

4 %% +*

1 0 *% 0 $

*% 4 1 *1 0 4 , % ,

%% " 30 1 *1 0 *%4

%%, 1"(% (( %% 1*% $ $ , 4 %% 0% 1"(% 1

4 3 (

(%,

0 # ;

G!0

>4 4%%1 *1

*% 4 7 " 0 " 1 ( 0 " 1*" < J 0 % *

4, # ;

G!*%*

; 1 *1 *%4 7" 0 "

0 1 ( 0"1*" 3

4 "

,* 0*%%, 0 # $ %

* , 41

1"" 0

001 1 $ $ @ "6 &-2

4 4

* IA >? 1%

4 1 *1 %% ( 0 *"( 4

$ 1 *1

%% %%,

7( ,0 (*%

( 0 * % # $ $ " %?< .B/

$ $

! ! ( 6

&" &"&" "!"" (& &

!& &" &&

&& !" & !

! ( !

& "&&& 7 - /!

& !

;&.%

< .8 <0&.%01 ;

/./ !

@.0/!/!= /!

.8/

&0 - D%/. &10

%:;./ !

.8 !19 0!

/! /.0@1 ;./ !$

-26- .9/ < & C !

( )*"

06$ =( & & &

&& 1014011. "&&

& "$ *!

" 7 ,

"& $ &10% 4//6 && &

(&"/ !!& $ &10% &

&& " &C(& * >.#

H*$ % 9 0 % 4%% $ 0 * %*

1""

1 %( *1 4 ,

0 00 0( 0* %(% <

& !& .9 3/ K

$ 9L & &&

8011

" !

90 (&$& ! &

&& 8 (*!&3/ & 0<.

& !

%&./!= 3E (& ! :% . $ ;

%&./ !

7/.8/!

.8 90

< !&B3/$

( 6& 01: & "& ( $ /!% .

/01

%!/.

.0 .

& :: &/01 ;

%&./ !

7/.8/!

.8 90

(*!& 3/ 3/ !& .9

% " !& ".

.80.

/. /

%./1/F <

.8 ;% ;

011 .. 7/.8/!

./;%10. ./:< !&B3/ & "! ! &&

! !& !

" ! (!

& 6 $ !&B3/ "&

-27-

$ 6 !& .93/ 3/ & " !& ($ & >

& !& B3/ & " .7 !

!& C "! ! G/!% .

/01

%!/.

.0 .

& :: &/01 ;

%&./ !H < !& .93/ & G%!/.

:% .

= /!.

;

%&./ !$H

$ ( !&.9 3/ 04: !

& ( !

8 !& B 3/ &&

"&( & ( & &&6

! !

! !&& (& " !

! ! ! ! !"&( $ .A/ < & C ! ( , !"!" ( +!0 0!/

06$,& & ! &!

.;/

" " && "& !$ & " !

( !! !&3/"&(& !& !

& 9 ,& ! 3 &/ & .;A9 & & & " &&

! !& ? @!" 6 ( !!

!! $& ,

=) " &6 $& & *

-28- > 001 % 0

001 % (* 0 "1*1 0 0!"

+ ! % H* , 1

4 *% (% (% 4 1 0 *" ( (

, 4 1

4 * 4

1 1 4 % G! 4 %%4

1 *1 (% 0 *% 001 %0**%

( H* ,*% (* ( *% < = ($ & ' & !&

*& ++),

(

!& !$

(" @ .5 $ ( ( & < !

)

(

" $ "& ,$ "<

01/

" ! ( (

$ " & (& !$

8'8& "' ' ! !$ $ & (&!!& !&( !" ! ( & !& & "8 !! !&!& !

!&!

& ( ,

!! &" "( & "! !

&( !& ! & @

!& && B%/&/01 ;

- ./:-

% & /!< .

%&.% ((!

&& $

-29-

! & $ $$!"6 &" 8 " &!$

$ $ "& $ !@ ! ! & " &

$ " $ ,

D6 ; ! @

;

) ;

'- &. 78/&8 7

19 %; !

7/.8

!&IA >

% %, "A *

71 ( M

1; 4 %

E $%* *% 0% 1 * * " 1

0 D* 1 , 1*" " 1% 0

*1 * *1 $ * 1 41*% (%, %0 * 1 *

(

0% %, 0 0 " % ,,( % *

(* *4

% 1 * 6% 1 $ $

% ,0

%, ( 1 7 "(%0

( 1 0 ( D* 1 "* , *1 *(*%* " 0 % "

( %%*

04 "(% * 11*(

" 0 1*

04*11 $ ((%1

$ 0% ( % $

% ( 4 0 $* % 1 0D* 1 % ( 1 % 0 %* 1 , (

"( $$

% * 1,1 1* %,01*

, " ( * %

(( 1 41 ( %F *1 $

% 11 D* 1 "

11 1 1(% ! " "* 1$ ,

0 D* 1 4%%

%%4 *( ,%

( 0 " % ,0 % 4% " %

; ,

%%1*

4* 1 ,4%% % %1*% * $

0 1 3 * , 0 $ 1*

0 "%, % 4 *1 *

"( 0 7 "(%

, 1 1

, *" 41

-30- (%, 4 * 4 %% ( $ 0%00 $%* 3 %,

1 (

" %$ * 1 * 4 11 0 4

0D* 1 3"( 0

% " 1 % 1

11 1*

$ % % 1 F 4 * $ 1

4 4*% * % "

* "(%,, 4 0* $1 410%

, " *1 *

1 %%4 1" ( + 1 "

%, "

0 1

* * %

1 *( %%1*

% %, " 7(% , 4* 0 "0 % 4 0

% , D* 1 J 1"" %% 1*

% 4 0 $%* 0% " "

< 0./ +!!

7 ($( !! $& ( " ! 4111118*3>D'/ ( " %+ <& >,$

)) 6

4+ ,'

01.00102 ' < '$8 M <

(& M