Lilawati v. Fateh Singh & ORS.
!
"# $" %&"
!"#$% #"% &"'$
'
( ) ""*%+&,
-& "
( "&.*%+&,
-&
&/0 &1 . #()*)&(+,! " $ %% %23422455 6."
(&& ,,%
1 6!
*#&
7 -
%& 8"
89"
6.,1 & - %6.-& "
"&-"
& #!6" ": $ 1&& ,,%
" !,) 7,&
96 $ $ & & 0;<0/<=57 -
%& 8"
89 % 1 % 2 ,1 * 6 -* "& 5<4<244>* #!6" ": $7% %9& $"&
?
$" & &- " $" $& $&# $"&* "- &1
1&& .* @!
%* #&
& 1&& ,., 6 $ $ & & 0 =#0543> "
1&& ,., 6 $ % +
6. #!6" " :
$A"
. ,"
& !1& 1
&% 6&! 4B44 1* "
&--
$ + ,1 - &1 && % *"," 6 $% +
6.
&5 "
$$
1
"
% "
%$ 1&& ,., &-% % !&-",""
- & - %
&-"
&%" ?
$"- & $" % &%
& "
&-"
&+ 6&%.&-% "&% %"
& "
%6&%.&-% % )
& 6! $?+ 1 #1 ) & * " "
" & 1& 1 ,& %!, % ?!
%0?
$" "- %&
? "" & * "
"
1 %,&0 $.
C1
% % % ," $ % / ,1 %"% % 22.
&-$
% !
$ "& "," "
"% )
&
- &1 " 16 @" &- #&
$ 52*444D0
1& " % ,& 6! $ 54*444D0-& "&!
"&% C
,1 !--
%1
$& .* "&,) % % + %&- &+ %-- ,& *$!% +, % ;
&5 %2 % + %&
&--
%% & &,& "
,1 &
&,
% 3
- % 6.
& /0 &1 .* !
&- "
&--
$ + * ,1 & ,& % % $ " & ,,%
%"% )
, $& $
%6."
,1 ,&! & "&,
&5 %2
& % & C ,,&1
- &1
&/ & )
"
& 5 & "+ $ +%
-- ,+ % + $ ,
& % + &--
$ + "
+ 1 * !,"* &6.&-"
&1 .& . "
,&1
, % -& 6 ," &- 1 ,& %& &,. &+
%""
&--
6 $!
%-& "
! & &"
" " ,- &,.
&2 & &"+ $ +% $ & , -, * &! 1 %-
, -,
,
&-,,%
&+ %*
&/&&)"
&- ,& 6!& .
$$
&- "
% % ,! $ "
,,%
B
% $ &-"
%&- 1 $&-"
!
-&& '0 A"
% " &- % % #!6" " : $ ,!
&%,,%
","&&),
& 5<4<244> %.%!
& "
$$
% + $ &- !,)D&
& 0;<00/<=5 %.6 $% +
6.
&5"
1 &-,,%
E
- !
& 5 &+ %* & " 1&!
&- ,&1
&
% & - &1"&1E
7/9 A"
&5 &"&% $+% -- ,+ % + $,
%"
!,) $ % +
+&& &- "
1 ,& %& &,."
1 &- ,,%
E
0/ 7;9
- < 6!
% 6 % "
&- A05 ?
$" .
0
&-"
&,,!
& $ &!
% -&& '0 79 "% + !,)"%- %.- &1"
& %"
"% & & %"
!16
!,) ."
79 ""
!,) ,&1 $& &%1 -& ,&1 $- &1 "&#&
% %!.&- % + + "," &, & "
&%
&
&"
.+ ,&1 $- &1 " % & &F 79 " "
%"& , & $"
&% & " 1&& ,., "&! , $ &- "
!,) ,&1 $ - &1 " % %
6 -& "
,,%
F 7+9 "?
$"%% &$ "
$
% 7+9 " "," $
% &
&-# 1*"
&1
& &- 1 &- % + &- "
!,) & "
!,)
!16 7+9 " & & !
# ,& 5</ , % & ,& % & "& " "
&--
&5
+&+
,,%
=
%,&!
-& "
" $!
%"
,,%
?
$""% & + ?! % )
& "
"& "
"
1 %,. C1
% $ $ --, "%,& , %"1 "& 6!"
& & - 1 &-1 %&1) .
G!
&, " "
1)
$ "
1& .&-?
$" &+ %""
,,%
"%)
, %"
& & &% 6 "1 -& "
6!
&
G! &"
&, "
%"
,"
, 6 $ &22>D4>% %5<4<244>* $
%
&, #& ! " $ %&,,%
G!
& -, &, "%
%"
," & 4;55244>$ "
,,!
%"
&,& - , % % $+
& &&
#!% "
%!. , !& & ,& ,"
-, $&"
%&-% 6 + $"
&- .
0
% ?!
% ,,%
& -1 .
$ &!
% >
% ,&!
-& "
& /0
&1 ." $!
%""
& 6 &- +%
-& " $". ,"
% "
,& ,! & " "
,,%
! $ "&-#!6" ": $ &,!
%%!
& "
$$
% + $&-"
6. % +
"# $"0
&5 ?
$""
.
&,,!
" &$+
.+ & &"
&,
"
1 &- $ & &- -& 1&
& 7 9*","
"& ""
& +&+ " ,
& $ "
,&1
"
% 6 % & &
,& &- +%
& ,& % %, -& & -
" 54 ,1 & % & &+ "
, " C1
?
$" A05 " %"& - -!%."
& % & 1&& ,., &- % % A"
.
,"
%
& !1 & 1 &%* "
&--
$ + 6 $ $ & & 0;<00/<=5 ,1
- &1"
&& % 6 $% +
"
$$
1
6. % + %""
1&& ,., &-% %"&- & - % &%" "
"1 -- & $" %
&% "
% !
&+ 6."
!&-",""
+ %$ +&! ?! %% %"
& "- % 6. + & ? " " & * "
"
1 %,&0 $. C1
% %% ," $ %
" -! "
%"& 5<4<244>*"
&, ,& % %"
? "" & * 6&!5444
1 &1"
1& .&-"
""
?!
% .
0
&,,!
" --%+ 7C A05D9"
" $+
!16
& !$$ & $+
&"1""
,,%
%6."1 "% &)
, & "
&
&"
,,%
"
G! %6&!"
1&% &-,,%
+
"," ,& % %&
&-# 1*" -, ,& % %"& ," $"
&"
$ $&--,
,1 &) &"?
$""%6
&"&
+ "
- *"
,"
%"
"& %1 ?
# $""& % ! 6 % &-1 % %%% &$ "
,& % %"
&-"
!
6! % !& "
+ & &-,,%
,& % +
&-"
" &!
%!& 6!"
&- "
" , & ,& % % &
&-?
$" "
$& ,& % %6.# 1"&"% ,"
%"
& "
?
$"
"%$+
!16
1
. $"
& & % % )
.- &1 & %"
"% &
$ & !16 &- !,)"
1 &-,,%
& "% & %"
1 ."
*,&!% &6
& -& % , % $" 1& ." $ %&,,%
"
&-"
""
"%,!
%"
,,%
!
0 "
% %"
& & -& "
&% , %"
1 55
&1"
1& .&- .
0
?
$"" -, &+ % " "
,,%
&&) , " "
&--
52 ,& %G!
& "," -& ,& % &"
,,%
"%)
, %!
& "
$$
% + $&-"
6. % + A05?
$"
" %" - & &- &!1"
%&!6 &%*&
-& $& $& " %&"
-& ,&1 $- &1 " %"
% &% + .% "
,,%
&&), & &%"+ --, ,&1 $ - &1 " & #&
% "
% % , & $"
&%- $ $ &- &1"
&!1 % 1 &-,,%
"
& &%,&1 $- &1 "& #&
% "
%& ,& & 6
+ !,) ,&1 $- &1 "&#&
% % &
&% 1 -& ,&1 $ & #&
% "
6&+
"& " , &-,& 6!& .
$$
"
"% &)
%!
,!& " , & $"
&% "
1 1
!,""$"
% % $% +
"
$$
1
" % + ,&!%
&,& &"
-
$"
1&& ,., " $ "
&+ %"&"% -
& &% @
$"
6&+ -, &,& % * 6 & & ,& 6!& .
$$
&-6&"
+ &&-34'34 5/ 6!
" &
% "
G! !1 &- ,&1
,!16
!& & ,& % ,-, - $ & !
& 2*
- " ,"
% "
,& ,! & ""
,,%
"% &)
, %!
& "
$$
% + $&-"
6. % +
5;
% ,&!
-&
& /0
&1 ." &!$" 1 %&-"
, &"
& " & & *- & & &&" !61 & "
"+
+%
%"
G! !1&-,&1
, 6
" 53 "+ "
%
%,&!
-& "
&
& &-G! !1&-,&1
&6 & " 5B % 22.
&-$ 1&"
&- % " % " "
!
$ ! "& "," )
6."1&
- &1" 16 @" %
&-+$ $@ *#&
%!
%& 52*444D0
1& "- &1"
"& & * & +%
&,& &6&
1& .&- &%!, %" 16 @" &
C1
%& &+ ""
"% &!"
"&&% %& 6 -& "
! ," &-1 & ,,&!
6&&)&-6!
&- %
&%!, %& ,& %
, ,!1 * 6 & & ,&1 &-% % "&- 6&!
.
244>*6&!
,&!% &!
%;444D0 & ;344D0 1& " "
,&1 &- % %* !,"*
% ;444D0 1& " &6 , &-
*
!" # $ $% & % '* !1
G!&34H &6 %% ,&1 %& % -!!
& , +
&"
+ $ -& .
%"
, &- , &-%.
% $%.
6.%."
, &-"
*1) %&"
1 &-%.
!
"+ 1& " %&!6 %%! $"
&% ,%
5< ,1 6 $ 1&"
&- "
% % &
%&,&1
&-5,& % & &- %& &- &+ % -- ,& -& "
% " &- "
& % 23*444D0 & % -!
C
+ &-6&+ % ,! & *"
1&!
&-,&1
&",""
,1
%*& ) &!&6
-&& '0 " # $% 79 ,&1 ;444
1& 79 34H&-796&+ &6 %% % -!!
& , 7;444I24449J 7B444
1& "9 79 5D2 &- 79 % %!, % &
C
7B4440/4449J /444
1& 7+9 &1
- 1! &- 5= 7/444K52K5=9J B;=444 7+9 & &- % & &- &+ -- ,&
544444 7+9
!
C
23444 & <</444 5=
!
%"
& /0 &1 .
&- A05 " * % +
"+ $+%% + $,
& % + "
+. $&&% + & +%
&%!, % 6.
&/0 &1 .& &+ . +&& &- 1 %,& %& &- &,. 5>
% ,&!
$
& /0 &1 . " &!$" && !
. & "
,&1 .& &%!, +%
" $ %& &! 1&-"
&--
&5 %2
6 -&
6!
"
6&+ !61 & &-
% ,&!
-&
& / ,
&6 & % " $
! &-
,& %&-,1 & "& ""
&1 . & % C %?&!
& ,& ,!% +%
" !11&
% & . "
,
, ) &- "
,
, $ !"& .* ("! &&"
"
&& !
. +6
""
&1 .&,&
& &%!, &! 1& "
+ ,& %- &1"
,&
!"& .","- %& &%!, 24 @
$ "
6&+ -, + * &6 % " $ !
*
&/0
&1 . " & -. "
!
% % ,&
G!
.* " 6.&."
1&!
&-,&1
25 + &-1.6&+ % ,! & *" " 1 % & % "
,1 "
%
% & !1 &- /*=B*344D06 $34H&-"
1&!
&-&,&1
5B6&+ "
,1 " &6
%&
:<3H
!1- &1"
% &-- $&-"
,1 & "
% &-,!.1
$"
!
&--
*"
1&!
&-,&1
"6 %6.
&/0 &1 ." C
) 6..&- 1 %% - !()- , .#"% &"'$/ ?) !"& '(() (*+,-