← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3863/2013dismissed

Balwinder Kaur v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2017-11-17Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan11 pages



     

!"##$%&%'( )



) !*+%',#-.!/- #"%"%'#- 1#-&/& 2"!"# /'3!4!',"5#-& #&6',#'"&  

      

-#&#'"(0 -2!7##-2!$5,#8!9,8$!"#-"5#6#"%"%'#- -8%'%"8!&"5%99 /'3!4 :::

      5!**#';#%'"5#%'&"!'"6#"%"%'%&""5#-,#-,!"#,)



''#</-# 0= 9+5#-#4>"5#$*!%7"5#6#"%"%'#-&##?%';!66%'"7#'"" "5#6&"#!$5%'; #**+!;!%'&""5#-#&#-8#,$!"#;->6#-"!%'%';"

6!-%&"-%$"95!&4##',#$*%'#,

#-/&!*"5#%76/;'#,-,#--#8#!*&"5!""5#4!&%&-#3#$"%' "5#$!',%,!"/-#"5#6#"%"%'#-%&"5!""5#!$?+!-,!&"##-"%%$!"# /-'%&5#,4>5#-+!&'"$'&%,#-#,8!*%,!&6#-"#-7&!',$',%"%'&"5# !,8#-"%&#7#'",!"#,=@

)%'-#&6'&#"+5%$5&5#5!,!66*%#,-"5# 6&" '"5#%76/;'#,-,#-%"5!&!*&4##'&"!"#,"5!""5#-#+!&' -#&#-8!"%'6-8%,#,-$!',%,!"#&4#*';%';" 26-"& !"#;->!', "5!""5#6#"%"%'#-+5%*#$*!%7%';"4#!$!"#;->$!',%,!"#$!''" $*!%7!66%'"7#'"!;!%'&" <0&#-8%$#7!' $!"#;-> /'&#*  -#6-#&#'"%';  "5#  6#"%"%'#-  +/*,  &/47%"  "5!"  "5# 6#"%"%'#-5!,#!-*%#-%*#,  =

$*!%7%';!66%'"7#'"" "5#6&"#!$5%'; #**+%'-#&6'&#""5#!,8#-"%&#7#'",!"#,=@

)

00 !',+5%$55!,4##',%&6&#,'

=

%'"5#**+%';"#-7&(0 A

 

 

 !  "

#$%& "

#!' ()&  !*    !

  &+ ,     &       !   !,+  !    , ! , ) +     ! ,     ,    , !  , ,!(,  '  !+ !,+   ,

-% 



./0 "%&$'"#',#,"5!"%'&6%"#"5#$*#!-,%-#$"%'&%&&/#,4>! -,%'!"##'$5"5%&/-"9$*!%7"5#6#"%"%'#-5!&4##',#$*%'#, !',!&&/$59"5#%76/;'#,-,#-8%-"/!**>!7/'"&"$'"#76"'"5#&!7# *%74%"%&$'"#',#,"5!""5#-,#-,!"#,

=

+!&6!&&#,4>"5%&/-"

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

00

=

96!&&#,4>"5%&/-"%' 

  

   !"4/""-#&&5%&$*!%7

#-$'"-!9*#!-'#,2"!"#$/'&#*+/*,3/&"%>"5#6!&&%'; "5#%76/;'#,-,#-,!"#,)

 ''#</-# 0= 4>$'"#',%';"5!""5# $*!%7"5#6#"%"%'#-5!&4##'-#3#$"#,&"-%$"*>%'8%#+"5#"#-7&!', $',%"%'&"5#!,8#-"%&#7#'"!',/',#-&/$5$%-$/7&"!'$#&"5#-#+/*, 4#'&$6#%'"#-#-#'$#4>"5%&/-"%'#<#-$%&#%"&+-%"3/-%&,%$"%' /'&#*-"5#6!-"%#&5!8#4##'5#!-, *!/&#"5#!,8#-"%&#7#'",!"#,=@

)!',%'-#&6'&#" +5%$5"5#6#"%"%'#-5!,!66*%#,-"5#6&"#!$5%'; #**+/',#- !"#;->-#!,&!&/',#-(0 1#  2)  &    ,   

,  #-"2+# ,3   (   

 &    !      # #,-"2+  #   #,    !!



4   !   (       /& 4    (      !  ( 5 "

#,    (   ,

) !!

 +  ,6 ,! &  78 799:7;

;

<==>  ()   0 "  %&  '"  %'  ,%&6/"#  "5!"  "5#  *!&"  ,!"#  -  &/47%&&%'   !66*%$!"%'  -7&  !&  6#-  !,8#-"%&#7#'"  ,!"#,  =@

)  +!&   @

) /'&#*-"5#6#"%"%'#-$'$#,#&"5!""+#-"%%$!"#&"5!"5!,4##' 6-,/$#,  !',  -#*%#,  /6'  4> "5#  6#"%"%'#-  +#-#  ,!"#,  BB

 !', @

 5#  !$"/!*  6-#7%&#  #7#-;%';  %&  "5!"  "5#  $#-"%%$!"#  ,!"#, BB

6-,/$#,4>"5#6#"%"%'#-+!&7-#"5!''#>#!-*,%'-#*!"%'

0B0 ""5#*!&",!"#&/47%&&%'!66*%$!"%'-7&%# @

)9+5#-#!& "5#&#$',$#-"%%$!"#,!"#, @

5!,4##'%&&/#,%'!8/-"5# 6#"%"%'#-!"#-"5#*!&",!"#&/47%&&%'!66*%$!"%'-7& "%&4>'++#**&#""*#,"5!""5#"#-7&!',$',%"%'&$'"!%'#, %'!6/4*%$'"%$#C!,8#-"%&#7#'"!-#&!$-&!'$"!',"5#&!7#$!''"4# -#*!<#,-,#8%!"#,-7"5#6#"%"%'#-D&$*!%7-8!*%,!"%'7-# "5!'  '#  >#!-  *,    #-"%%$!"#  %&  !$$#6"#,9  %"  +/*,  -#&/*"  " ,%&$-%7%'!"->$'&#E/#'$#&!&"5#-#7%;5"4#&#8#-!*"5#-$!',%,!"#&+5 7!>5!8#-#*%#,/6'&/$5#<6%-#,$#-"%%$!"#&!',5!8#4##',#'%#,4#'#%" -#&#-8!"%' F%?#+%&#9%"5#8!*%,%">6#-%,&/$5*%?#$#-"%%$!"#%& 8#-*?#,9%"+/*,4#&#*,#&"-/$"%8#""5#43#$"%8#&"5#-#&#-8!"%' 6*%$> -##-#'$#%'"5%&-#;!-,7!>4#7!,#""5#3/,;#7#'",!"#,



96!&&#,4>"5%&/-"%' "#    $   

   ! '%,#'"%$!*%&&/#!-%&%';-7!-#$-/%"7#'"6-$#&&%'%"%!"#, 8%,#!,8#-"%&#7#'",!"#,@

@%&&/#,4>"5#,/$!"%'#6!-"7#'"

+!&,#!*"4>!-,%'!"##'$5"5%&/-"%'##   %&'          

          ! !',  "5#- $''#$"#,  6#"%"%'&  ,#$%,#,  '  



  5#  -#*#8!'"  $',%"%'  %'

!,8#-"%&#7#'",!"#,@

@+5%$5+!&"5#&/43#$"7!""#-$'"-8#-&> %' %&'( $!&# &/6-! +!&%,#'"%$!*"$*!/&#6#-"!%'%';""5# 6-#&#'"$!&#5##-"%%$!"#&/-'%&5#,4>"5#$!',%,!"#&%' %&' ($!&# &/6-! +#-#!*&'"!&6#-"5#"%7#-!7#&"%6/*!"#,/',#-"5# !,8#-"%&#7#'"!',!&&/$5+#-#"-#!"#,'"8!*%,5!**#';#""5#&!7# +!&'#;!"#,4>"5#-,%'!"##'$5%'"5#3/,;#7#'",!"#,



%'

%&'($!&# &/6-! "+/*,4#/&#/*"#<"-!$""5#3/,;7#'"%'

)"

) )*+,!

-#- %&'($!&# &/6-! 5#-#%'4#*+(0 15  

!,#& 6? <<;;7, <=7=@99=4:=884:A9A4:8;;4>>7:4>>A=4>>9A4>;@84A=<A48::94 899<4;8:94;;;9477A<>477>9@47<A>@47<A>;47<8=<47<8=;47<9=84 7@=:<47><7<7;:9@,<=774    (

, 4   + ! B &(4 , 2, #& 6? >>A=,<=77

< ,,   !!!

,,,  )!,!!  ! 43             &  )(       )  &    ' (   )  (     !  ,  3)    "2+-!,$%& #,4' ()    !)( 5 

 ( ))& !  !       3,  ,   )  ,     !& )(

@  +!!

,    )!! & <@ =9 <==94 ,

+ ( #) <8 =9 <==9 5 ( )& )  ,  "2+  #     !  ,  $&   5  &     <@ =9 <==9  $  %<  )  # %A ))& (,"2+# #,!  C% 1A 5 #,,"

 + (,  

,

 #,    ,   78 =7 799:78 ;

<==> ( ! ,6 ,4 3 /&  5  '#) <8 =9 <==9$ %@, ! ,

+C% 1#? AC%5 #,,"

#)(      7(!  ,

,!!

  #,   ! 3 /& 4!  ,6 , ? 7-:7-9@%-7-<=9<:

< <==9

00 

 (4    )    !  ,  $%& 4    & ! ,

+C% 15 &$%& '!!



 ( ,, 3  $%& 

 ,  &+  !!



,  !  $%& -! + !  )

, !  ,

,!!

  (  ! (!! ( /&   ,

) 5  '#) <8 =9 <==9$ %@, ! ,

+C% 1#? ;C%5 2)& B B) D+

 &! ) ,  !  ,

,!!

 ,3

/&  ? :%7@%;@%9>-! %:88<:

799;  ? :%7@%;<%<>-! -A<77 < 7999 (  !  (!! ( /&   ,

) :

?+ ) $!

3,)&  !4 ,,    #,,"2+ !,$%& 4 ! (  4+

 (  ,"2+# -  ) #,+!,!,$% &  #' (4 , &)( & 34)   !)(

>  ' !, , #%" #& 6? 77A:8,<==; 7;

> <==9 & 3 E 5 ,3      ++, &),

+C% 15 ' , ,  #,      (!)  ,

,  !!

 

 "2+#  #,! (  !$! !? A4+  ,   4 4 , !!, )  "2+)( ?    !

 +   !!#,+ ? A,

0)0    &     (      !   (  +     ( !)  ,

, !!

  ! !!

 5 ,  ,+!+  (  # )+ #& 6? 9;>9,<==92 3E

  ,  3         7;

=;

<=77  !!

)      & !)C% +

     !

-&     $ &, !2    , !*  , &   ,         (     "2+  #   #,   ! 

  ('  )  &       +   (  &     !    $! #, &   ,,& 

 (4,  & (!,  2#,& 24  , &        3  ,     &  ! (  +    $  +  (% (  ! !!



  , !&   (   &+2 ( #  & !!



,&  B (4 !

 /& 

=> 7< 799A$%7=  3, & (,  #-"2+# #,, !! ,2) !

(  4 ()+,

+C% 1@       ,               #-"2+# #, (  ! (!     ,     6 ,  !   +

   !  (  

 &  5,  !

,( ! 

  ,+

 ,,,  2)        !

(        , (          !!

, +   -  )   #-"2+  ! !, #, (   ,   -+  ;

 5 (      (  !   '     =;

=7 <=7=$%7<   3 ()+ C%15 

00

  ) ) ( ( /&                    #,      "

# 

 & 

  4 ,

   (  (       )4       !   +

 2    ,   )+ !!

  , !!

()+     &   (     )  ,

 ( (   ) (  , !   (7=( +)&  , "2+  -!  ,  $%&   #,  +   +  + 

,,   !

&"  @= =9 <==;!#& 6? :<:<,<==8./ %/ 

   ! $%; =A =< <==9 !#& 6? 79A:@,<==A0 /1 2'

   ! $%94   "2+# #, &  ,&,  !4 (+ )

  &)( )

"2+# #,+' ! (  ,    , !!  5 ( , ,  *

! #3''/  4%55  !6 % "#  7=  &)   , !4 , ()+( +  &3*3 *!&  &  !  (,   + ) &3*!7;

=> <==94 #% "  &" /( ( !+<@ =:

<==9!#& 6 ? 7@;==,<==;  E ,3   +  ! !  &   ,,      !      &    (    &"  ,

+),,C% 1  ! ' (   #, (), ,   ,  #,   ,!  ! ! "2+# #, +"2+# 

0@0   

 #, )+ !!

,

5  )&  #,+  ,<==>  5 ! &4 +&4 

 +  ,  +   ,)  ( $ <==>  & 4+  ,     ( ! &"

#, , <==>     )  +     !!

  ,     4   ,4 &

 +  2  !  & ! ,'  0 ! !!



   (               +     ! &   )  ! "2+# #,+        (  , ,,  ( &   !!,

(!  )4 ,

(!!



 4+

)(, ! + +2) ,,&! #,       ,  5   /&       => 7< 799A   =;

=7 <=7=$%7=%7<!!



 $,  & & 5   ()) ,#, 

    (      !   (      !&  !    ! !& , !!,  !

(  5  +  & (!, , 5    2+#  #, 

 & 

 ,

 * (%

(*  , !  ! !  ,(& (!     ) ,,&, 2+ 4 & + ,

 )(, ( 5 ,& (!, (   )& 4,  &  B ,4 ,()  ,+   !) ,  ! 

 + !    ) (    5   !  4  +&4    )) )(, !,$%& 4+   ,

+  

 &-#& 6? 8><=, <=77 ,$ 0



   !4 (!, &4 ( 

    

 ,

 ) !(, +!4  !      & & 

 (!

  )

 <

) ( & 2 ! &#, '  , 4  ! 

  

(!     !+ 

 (!



) 5#8%#+"!?#'4>"5#-,%'!"##'$5%'%&'($!&#

&/6-! +/*,!66*>&E/!-#*>""5#!$"&"5#6-#&#'"$!&##<$#6"%' !&&/$5$!'4#"!?#'""5#,#$%&%'"5#-#&6',#'"!/"5-%"%#&%'5!8%'; ,#'%#,""5#6#"%"%'#-4#'#%"-#&#-8!"%'/',#-"5#!"#;->' !$$/'"5!8%';'"/-'%&5#,"5#-#E/%&%"#$#-"%%$!"#%'&/66-"&/$5 -#&#-8!"%'&"-%$"*>!&6#-*!/&#"5#!,8#-"%&#7#'",!"#,=@

) 5#5#!8>-#*%!'$#6*!$#,4>$/'&#*/6'"5#-,#-,!"#,

=

 ''#</-# 0B 96!&&#,4>"5%&/-"+5%*#,%&6&%'; "# 9%&7%&6*!$#,'"5#%-&"%'&"!'$#%"7!>4#4&#-8#,"5!" "5#6#"%"%'+!&,%&6&#,+%"5!,%-#$"%'""5#-#&6',#'"&"$'&%,#- "5#$*!%7"5#6#"%"%'#-&-!66%'"7#'"""5#6&"%'E/#&"%'/',#-"5#  <0&#-8%$#7!' !', 26-"& E/"!5#$'&%,#-!"%'9!&&/$59 "4#!$$-,#,""5#6#"%"%'#-5!,"4#%'!$$-,!'$#+%"5*!+5#+-, A$'&%,#-!"%'G#76*>#,%'"5#-,#-,!"#,

=

96!&&#,4>"5%&/-"

+5%*#,%&6&%'; "#  $!''"4#$'&"-/#,"7#!'

$'&%,#-!"%'   "5#"#-7&!',$',%"%'&"5#!,8#-"%&#7#'"%' -#&6'&#"+5%$5"5#6#"%"%'#-5!,!66*%#,-"5#6&"%'E/#&"%'5# -,#-,!"#,

=

96!&&#,4>"5%&/-"!"''#</-# 0B+!&!;!%'&"!

&"!"#7#'"5!8%';4##';%8#'4>"5#2"!"#$/'&#*9+55!,!66#!-#,4/""5#

&!7#$!''"4#-!%&#,"!6#,#&"!*"$'#-!',8#&"%'"5#6#"%"%'#-! -%;5"$'"-!->"*!+ 5#3/,;#7#'"-#',#-#,4>"5%&/-"%' ( $!&# &/6-! +/*,5!8#'!66*%$!4%*%">%'"5#6-#&#'"$!&#  !-7%',#- .!/-5!,!66*%#,-"5#6&" /'3!4%%&"-#&&/',#-"5#!"#;-> 5##-"%%$!"#-#*%#,/6'4> !-7%',#-.!/-+!&'"%'"#-7&"5# !,8#-"%&#7#'",!"#,@

@5%&/-"5!,%'"#-8#'#,%'"5#7!""#-4> "!?%';$;'%H!'$#"5#6#$/*%!-!$"&9+5#-#4>"5#6#"%"%'#-"5#-#%'%#

!-7%',#-.!/-%77#,%!"#*>!"#-%&&/!'$#"5#!,8#-"%&#7#'"5!,7!,# #-"&";#""5#-#E/%&%"#$#-"%%$!"#%',%$!"%';5#-!"#;->!',"5#-# 4#%';!,#*!>'"5#6!-""5#!/"5-%">%'%&&/%';"5##-"%%$!"#!', +5%$5/*"%7!"#*>+!&%&&/#,'@



%#!"!6%'""%7#+5#'"5# *!&",!"#-&/47%&&%'!66*%$!"%'5!,#<6%-#,5#!$"&%'"5#$!&#  &/6-! !-#$*#!-*>,%&"%';/%&5!4*#

/-"5#-7-#9%"%&'"#8#'"5#$!&#"5#6#"%"%'#-"5!"4> 8%-"/#5#-7#-%",#"#-7%'#,%'"5#&#*#$"%'6-$#&&&5#+/*,!**+%"5%' "5#H'#$'&%,#-!"%'-!66%'"7#'"""5#6&"#!$5%'; #**+%'

"5#6#'$!"#;->

-"5#-#!&'&-#$-,#,!48#9'4!&%&-%'"#-#-#'$#%& +!--!'"#, %'%-7%">%&/',%'"5#%76/;'#,-,#-,!"#,)



''#</-# 0= -#3#$"%';"5#$*!%7"5#6#"%"%'#--!66%'"7#'"""5# 6&"#!$5%'; #**+!;!%'&""5#!"#;->

#"%"%'%&,%&7%&&#,          */$?> 5#"5#-&6#!?%';C-#!&'#,( #&C 5#"5#- #6-"!4*#( #&C