Union Of India And Others v. Vijay Kumar And Another
!"#$
"#"%#& !"#$'
!"
#$% &$ #'
($)$)#)'$
*+ ($ )*( ++
+ ,
)*( + ++ + ( , +-./ 0112
1 3 40 *
51 01612+781 4 *+
+ ,
- )0,00 1:* 20 * 0
4+12*1.40 ,1+ 40 + +1 + "
"
";"
<
"#2 1 *1 + -. 0 3 1 + 6 + 8 )-13 88 +2:0 -.0 83164 *+ 40 ,14 +1-3.* :1133:
.&/%.0.&12 "%#!
"
*+ 5 +6. ;
=
141 40 130 ,0 8 40 20 8 +0 +1-3 4>
)$? $( $ $ @1+> ( )()(?$ $( )$#@1+:1+801, +46 ;
;= ";""
0 6 4+801, 20+1-3 :
* 87 3.1 +A ;B1+";B1++ ,
41++1-3 :
86* 3.1 +ACCB434
)0 +1-3. 8316 4 0 *+ :1 8 6* 0.200 ,+010 *1 +1-3 :
0 1-1-3 - , 1,,171 + -.
+4631.
*+ 43 + 2- 4 0 3 1 +6 8 )-1388 +2:0 -.0 81180133 , 0 14 1+ 8+ )0 1+ 2- 133:
+7+ + +1 "
"
";"
)0 * 17 *11 4 0 1+ + <18 14
! "
!
"
"
#$ %
% &
' ( )
( !
"
"
# % "
#$ % "
*
)
"
" )
)
( # &%
,
3,1,, +460 14 1++ 1*1 +* *1#2-.0 3 1 +6 +8 )-1388 +20 * 4+10143 +0 1,10 1:* 4 0 #3
#&
"3/45 "% / !
& 4 *8
+,61E 1 87 1+5+81* * :* 2 1 43118 4+ 6,:0 41336 41.+ 7 71.6 6- 40 + 8 * 32-*0- , 33 +0 16.2+ * 10 13 1, 2*0- 86, 3 +2116 6- 40 86-11 8 1-306 210 0 16 61,+ 8 +2.
0 1** *20* 36 0 8 ,81-3 -
0 8, 13- ,81-3 - 86 1,,171 +- , 1-1-3 631. 2018G +24620 *8*3 400 5+,6 'H-3 * <281 3 1 #$"!"% &$
2 * + '
()% )0 71 *11,1*0 4 0 1+ 7 +8 1 <18 14
- .
(
( !
( !
/
01 2
"
( )
(
(
"
)
( "
"
(
3
"
% ( 4 5 )
"
( "
"
(
6 7
"
8 "
.) !
-& 9 .
*3''
07
:1
01 .
"
(
' (
5 "
(
"
( ;7 $ <) 7
01=
01 >
0 " 1!
"
3
) " .
(
"
"
" 07 -1
0(1 '
(
(
( !
"
(
)
"
"
( ;7
1=
0(1 '
"
"
)
( ?
"
( !
)
( ?
) (
( ;
01=
0(1 '
(
*
(
) (
( !
@
A
5
;
01=B
0(1 '
"
@
A )
)
3''
9C @
0@ "
8 1!
96 / C 8 9!
!&
(
:
E !
"!
) 5
( (
* 87 1+,#40 1-7 <18 +*8*3 2 0,0* +3.+ 831 201:0 1+1-3.- 86 13 +* 1.6 6- 40 86-11+ 8 1-306 21+:080 < 4";B7 20 *20,01.80+1-3 +6 6- G +- 713+ +460 6.2-.
0 G +- 1, +0 44+1-3.*
20 1,6 4+1-3.* 1.
6- 40 86-11+ 8 1-306 2:0- 86 13 :0 1 +1-3. 1G16 4 ";B 6 2 - 6* 17 3.
G 1 + 8311 46 0 +813 &1+2 10 81++3.
*8,010 1+11 ++1-3.- ,1-1-3 86,1,,171 +-.631.
)0 1++ 8311- 86
5 6 7
"
8 "
.) !
-& 9 .
*3''
07
:1 = 0 6 20,00 1* 6*1, 7 70 +*0.8131+6 130 13041.6 6- 40 8 1-306 88 +2 * 8133.:0 10 1, 40 86, 33 +20 8+1-0- 86,- :01.+
7 20,00 0 13140 * 6*2 01 :0 1. + 1 0 2 0 88 - G 3.2 0 -. 0 1+ 01** , 4 + 1# ,41.+ 210 - * 6 +- 1 G 340 , 1 1 6 6- 4 0 + 8 1-306
6* 17 3.20 4*7,0 +:6 G1- 4 *1#7 70 88 +2- +0 6*3.
21+
81 20 1+ 61 +801, +20 *20 83161 86 3 + 7 +1-3.* 7 21330 418 1+ 88618 1 +1 0 + 4 -. 0 88 +21 - 83 3.8I +204+ 831,:0 0 41.+ 7 70 88 +21 G 3G1 + 4 631. 1+J 0 16 - , 1,,171 + -. - , 1-1-3 631.
;
& 01161.20 - 86 13 40140 *8*3 #01.
0 81- + 134+1-3.* 0 88 +2-3.*/ 1#0 6 4188 *18 40 88 +631.
26 ,- 86, 8+ +813 &1+ 7 7 0 - , - :0 1 + :080 0:
2- 86 883+ +- .
,06 4- 86 3
-# . 40 + 1 0 42 61. 13 - G 3.- 86 883+ +813&1+2 1 46 + 4 631. - , 1-1-3 631. 210 0 16 ,1 8, 13+
0 240 6 +813*03+010 + 83+ 017
+ 8 +6 +813 <16140 88 +- , 61+ 20*0- 86, 3 + 20 *20 16 :33- +
+017 1 +, 2.
0
) 1*1#20 +813&1+ G +1 0 14 883+, "
7 213+ 831 +*120161+1.
40 +813&1+433:0 ,+ 3 31++:01* 40 KL+ +81331.
#2";;"MK$3 / L 13 8*3 K
)0 4 201- :+ 6 +:0 64 1-7 *8*3 2:0 10 6 4 36 40 * *+ 0 6.2014 1* 361.6 +813 <161 ,61+ 7 700 130201 8+ +1- 6 + - , 06 1+J :0 6 - 1** +010 1++ :11+611,
7 2 13 G +- + 6 +2460 418101+2:0 0 18113 < 0 *40 + 21+J0 , 420* 20*0 336 40 * *+ 1E, *318 2 7 7 0 187 + -. 06 4 631. 2:0 -.2061.883+ 010 4 + -10 :11 G 340 , 0 6.
1+180:11-1-3 - 1,,171 +-.0 , 631.
1++213 G +- ,10 +460 8+2:0 0 +813&1+2++133.*8
+61E 1 13 +87 1 1380 8E2*18313.1** 1,0 1+7 40 + 20,0 6*3.6 4 1 46 +813 80G 2 0 7 3, 0 -38E 801 , 8 8 82
:0 46210 0 + 8 7 240 1+
6*3.6 413 313.20 -.61.- 86 883+ +G1
*0 420- G 0 1** 36 1E, *318 210 :18, 13-:
+, +4 631. + - ,1-1-3 - 86,1,,171 -.* 4618 4631.
13.240 *1 6*3.
80G 10 1, 41** 36 1E,*318 20-.0 +813&1+88 +23 1+18832010 1 10 +618+ 8 41.+ 2-.
0 1++61+ *0-,0 36 41.* 30 16.217.1 48
313.0 - G 187 + 8J *0 42 +,0 8 4 +4631. 2-:3+1133.
1+1:
33883-.0 +813&1+201187 * - - 8 + 46 1 87 8113 , 8 8 8 :0 -.0 :3+- + 134+1-3.*
':
2:0 1+ 1720 G - <18,0 8 40 *21- 8+ 6 +813-1+
1 #
)$?
$(
$ $ "D C# $ $ L
;B
11
" 2'
4 L ";;
CCB 4.
4 * 8 4 34 # * 1 12 8113 31 0* :0 1* C +1. 801 4 + +
"!
"
";
";
( )() (?$ ($(
)#8 )C 2 7* ) ";B CCB 4.
4 * 8 4 34 # 8113 31 0* :0
4 11
" '
!
1+,40 8+ 130110 6 40 1** 36 1E,*318 10 61+ 6 40 *8*3 *1#+ 831 'H-3 * <81 3 +1#$"!"% &$
' ,"(-.0 +813 &1+2016 + :0800:
2++4-+0 * *+ 2- 86 3 +0 6.2++61E * 361.
, 4 2 0 + 8311 4 31: 5+,6 *1# 01 -.0 1* 6*010 8,40 1++ :11 G 34 +4 2 G +- 4171-3.
+:
+7 70 *+ )0,00 1+* 6* -1-3 -0 3 1+ 7+ 8 -0 1+* 6* 81 * 0 * ':
2 0 1+ 81 7+ 8 1++8,+801,,7 70 *+ 210 48, 3.
-,0 1+* 6*2-1133.13++811 +.13*0 +813&1+2 ,1, 340 174 10,2 0,0 6*3.6 4 0 1 4 -38E 801 , 8 8113 8 8 80G #2 :0 -. 61. - 17 +010 ,40 + 0 16.* 8 +461 13, 84163.0.
7 2 -.:113 G +- 1 +0 6 +813*201
+ -41:
3346 + 110 :118, 13+ 1+- 0 1,,171 +-.- 1-1-3 631.
':
21 1+,4**1#2+83 0101
8+ + 1 .* + 46 1+ 1 017 -
8+ +0 < *1# 1 +3.28 7+ 8 - * 6**1#01-
3 * 20 -.20 81 +,7 :
,01, 0 *40 6 +813 -1+21 <18 +*1# *83.20 -.8 8 81- 1, +0 *13346 + 12- + 0 -.0 , 40 + 81- 1+- 1 G 341 13, 8 4163.0.
13.2 G +- + 831 +1 46 +4631.
1++2 G +- + 831 + 1-1-3 - 86,1,,171 +-. +4631. -.0 * *+
7 20,01 +0 010 + # 88 +:03 * 46 + 8 * 10 1* 1 12-8 0 <* 61+1 0 71 ,312:08061E 0 ,40 + #1 * 1 12- , 140 G 3011802H ,++ 1 46 0 + 4 631. - 1,,171 +-. +40 631.
8 G 8 20 318E40 1+ <* 61+1 0 ,312+ 810 883+ 201 40 ,40 1++ #* * *+ 088 +1* 1 120 -.20 1+
, 1 - + 831 + - 86 1,,171 + -. - , 1-1-3 +4631.
= 0 28 640 5+,6 * <281 3 +1-
!"?!
%.
)/ :0 21+ 831161+ 0
< 2010 44+,44210 01- 86 +:
0 88 313.130 + 1+ 1-3 ,0 7 + 0 * *+ 4 0
E, G1 0 1** +,44- ,61+ 0417 ";
$7 0 : 8 0 + 8311 4 31: 61+ +8*1#61E 0 1++ 8311- 1 <*31431:
620 -.20 <*31431: 62161+ 7 +8 *1#1361E 0 0 + 84 +- 47 70 8 * 3 88 +2 2
2 13 3 0 88 +2011.6
E0 ,1,40 +:6 1 61+ 0 + 21+0120 433 86*3 21* 3 + 2- + * 87 40 -1241.24+ 31.1+3180 "
)0 4 2 0 ,1, 4 0 - 4 4 0 1** +,442 640 7 +8*1# )-13 88 +213+ 44 461.33 ,13.1+ G +- *0 3+
5#.0 !
"3/45 "% / ""
14 610204+6 0 :* 1+:0- 711-7 20 16 +6
"
)0 6*, ++ 21*1 3 1 +)-13 88 +2611 +1+1446 "C
* +413,:0133* +,1**381#241.
6+
+ ,
6+ + (7 '
+ 0 4 /4 .15#29 .
"# !
$
9"
4 /4 8" /.:0
$
9"