High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16802/2024dismissed

Union Of India And Others v. Ex Naik Gurjant Singh And Another

2024-12-19Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma9 pages

!"#$%%

!"!&"'

!"#(%%

) * *

!"# $ +# ,-+ % **

* .

,-+ *% ** * + %&'()*+, -. ((/012&34056%02(57'2.(5 87%/3(9(/1/172(%. ::::

* .

/% 3%7'&3/3(12./02/4%1/9(/1/1726/3(9(/1/172(%.3(%(12

2172782)1069%0+.87%/3(.(//12&0.1)(78/3(7%)(%)0/() ! 22(;'%( $6 0. 90..() *+ /3( 5(0%2() %<() 7%=(. %1*'205 =72=(%2()643(%(*+./3(=501<78%(.972)(2/787%/3(&%02/78 .(%>1=((5(<(2/78/3()1.0*151/+9(2.17287%/3(.(%>1=(%(2)(%()*+ 31<12(8(2=((='%1/+7%9.$30.*((205574()6*+=72)7212& /3(.37%/805578"#)0+.8%7</3(%(?'1.1/("+(0%.78?'0518+12&.(%>1=( 87%(0%212&.(%>1=(9(2.17212/3(

0'1&020'34 !&"

(.972)(2/740.(2%755()12/3(2)102%<+1@3 (&1<(2/$72 #!02)40.)1.=30%&()/3(%(8%7<72 !## 08/(% %(2)(%12& /47 +(0%. 02) ! )0+. 78 .(%>1=( 3(%(08/(%6 %(.972)(2/740.%((2%755()12/7(8(2=((='%1/+7%9. .(%>1=($ 72 # A 02) 3( 79/() /7 =7'2/ 31. 87%<(% .(%>1=( /740%)..(%>1=(3(%(08/(%631..(%>1=(.4(%((;/(2)()8%7</1<(

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

((512&0&&%1(>()6%(.972)(2/7815()6*(87%(/3( 5(0%2() %<() 7%=(. %1*'205 =72=(%2()6 43(%(*+. 3( =0./ 0 =3055(2&(/7/3(087%(.01)%(C(=/1727%)(%3(.01)6*(=0<( 05574()>1)(7%)(%)0/() !3(79(%0/1>(90%/78/3(.01) 7%)(%1.(;/%0=/()3(%(1208/(%, ;;;; ;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;

! " #

$ %

&'(&)*

) ),

. . % . -*()

)

/#-

% % 0 12)1 .

,)14 " ((512&0&&%1(>()8%7</3(087%(.01)7%)(%0.90..()'972 /3(.'9%0$6*+/3(5(0%2()%<()7%=(.%1*'205=72=(%2()6/3( 9(/1/172(% 2172782)1030.815()/3(%(0&012.//3(12./02/4%1/9(/1/172 *(87%(/31.7'%/ *&567

7!"

!819 2 "

'!&"

28!

19 :

1717!"

% 3(5(0%2()=7'2.(587%/3(9(/1/172(%..'*<1/.6/30//3( 5(0%2()%1*'20530.8015()/7=72.1)(%/30/12/(%<.78(&'50/172 7 "78/3((2.172(&'50/172.87%/3(%<+6#02)(&'50/172 7

78/3((2.172(&'50/172.87%/3(%<+6 6/3'.725+/3( 7<9(/(2/'/37%1/+40.(<974(%()/7=72)72(/3()(81=1(2=+12/3( %(2)1/17278?'0518+12&.(%>1=(6/3'.*+/3(.75)1(%87%31.*(=7<12& (2/1/5()/7.((@/3((2)74<(2/789(2.172/731<3(.01)(&'50/172. 0%((;/%0=/()3(%(1208/(%

D-E6#$ ), 5

- - 3

6.7

- .

8 1* 7

- ,

% . .

D-E6 $ **

9 % . )%

- - 3<

- ,

7- .

8 4 2 -7%(7>(%6/3(-121./%+78(8(2=(>1)(751=+5(//(%7

$B BB(2B75$ )0/() !6 12.(%/()=50'.(1>$ 12 /3( (&'50/1727

78/3((2.172(&'50/17287%/3(%<+6 3( %(5(>02/90%/43(%(7861.(;/%0=/()3(%(1208/(%

9(%'.0578/3(087%(0<(2)<(2/47'5)<0@(1/=5(0%/30/ %(51(8 ?'0 =72)720/172 78 )(81=1(2=+ 12 %(2)1/172 78 /3( 0997.1/( ?'0518+12&.(%>1=(61./7*(0==7%)()72<(%1/6.70./7(2.'%(/30/02 0%<+9(%.722(51.(51&1*5(87%0/5(0./72(.(%>1=(9(2.172

# 3(5(0%2()=7'2.(587%/3(9(/1/172(%.8'%/3(%.'*<1/.6/30/ /3(C')&<(2/78/3(5(0%2()%<()7%=(.%1*'2056%12=1905F(2=36 (4(5316%(2)(%()12=0.(/1/5()0. ! "# $% 0.%(51()'972*+/3(5(0%2()=7'2.(587%%(.972)(2/ 740.27/=7%%(=/%0/3(%40.=72/%0%+/750402)80=/.6/3(%(87%(627

%(5102=(7'&3//730>(*((2950=()72/3(.01)C')&<(2/3(%(5(>02/ 90%0&%093.60.7=='%12/3(>(%)1=/.'9%0$0%((;/%0=/()3(%(1208/(%, )

3 . - .

% )**)( % : 67 > .

%@ A/ *() $ ** % $ 8 .

%@ A/ )1)2B .7 #

.%.

-% % .%B

. .

- - % -

-% % %. B 7 /0%

" C DC1)'2)'

= -

-B 7 =

@ 6A/7

B *(

. . ? %

- -

? % - -

: 7

F 67

6- % 7

%%. /

- * %

- .

. %

G H.# % -

8 %

G H.G / $ 0.!G

A 6 7

& ‟ '

( )

* ) )

7..

6.7 6 - -

. % %

% 3 % -

% 4

)6)7 %=

. )2

-- .

%*()

$ )# #

$ % 6 7 -

,-.-/ 0 /1-/-/2

67 -.

H -

-6

7F 67 -

$ *2

. "8

!8197 !& 1% 12=(/3((;97./'50/172.<0)(1290%0&%093.7#/7 78 /3(C')&<(2/%(2)(%()*+/3( 72G*5(9(;7'%/12=0.(/1/5()0.

"7!"!8" 700" "!19

) %*&

*7"49 6%(97%/()12 -/3 2 ,-,6 90%0&%093 43(%(78 *(=7<(. (;/%0=/()3(%(1208/(%67>(%=7<(./3()1.0*512&(88(=/.61802+678.'9%0 (;=(9/172 71>$6 0. *(=0<( 12.(%/() >1)( 9751=+B5(//(% )0/() !6/3'.612/(2)()/747%@0.027*./0=5(%0/3(%0&012.//3( .75)1(% =501<12& %(51(8 78 =72)720/172 12 /3( %(?'1.1/( .37%/8055 78 .(%>1=( &

! !

' () *!

+ , &

! !

/ -

01 2&3

......! ......

4 0 5 .. .. .. &

! !

/ -

6' () 5 7

. #

012 %

8 96* !

. )

. % ) % - .

- -

- .

. G- -

)*+

&(,-

* )-

- . % -

3(%(87%(6/3(C')1=105>(%)1=/.'9%0$6)7(.%(2)(%2(&0/() /3(.'9%00%&'<(2/%01.()*+/3(=7'2.(587%/3(9(/1/172(%.6/30//3( (<974(%<(2//7=72)72(/3(%(?'1.1/(.37%/80556*(=7<(..751/0%15+ >(./()12/3(7<9(/(2/'/37%1/+6(.9(=1055+43(2/3(3(%(120*7>( '2)(%512()90%0&%093.60.7=='%12/3(>(%)1=/<0)(12*&

*7"49

, '0

6055')()/712/3(>(%)1=/<0)(1230<00'%G.=0.(6)7 12>(./C'%1.)1=/17212/3(%1/7'%/6/7/3%7'&3C')1=10512/(%>(2/1726 /3'.<0@(/3((.97'.()=72)720/172 72.(?'(2/5+6/3(='<'50/1>((88(=/78/3(0'/37%1/0/1>( C')1=1059%727'2=(<(2/0.=0%%1()12/3(0*7>((;/%0=/()90%0&%0936 <0)( 12 ( ) /3'. =7<95(/(5+ =7'2/(%>015.*7/3/3(.'9%00%&'<(2/.%01.()*(87%(/31.7'%/6*+/3( =7'2.(587%/3(9(/1/172(%.6/3'.87%)(2+12&/7/3(%(.972)(2/6/3( *(2(81/78/3(.(%>1=(9(2.17287%31..(%>12&12/3(6<(%(5+72/3(

&%7'2)/30/3(30.27/=7<95(/()/3(?'0518+12&9(%17)78.(%>1=(6 *(.1)(.72/3(8'%/3(%851<.+&%7'2)6/30/725+/3(=7<9(/(2/0'/37%1/+ 1.0'/37%1H()/7=72)72(/3(.01).37%/8055 72(/3(5(..6 12 /(%<. 78 /3( )(=50%0/172 <0)( 12 /3( 3(%(120*7>( '2)(%512() 90%06 0. =0%%1() 12 /3( >(%)1=/ .'9%0$6 /3( =501<.78)'0580<15+9(2.172120))1/172/7/3(81%./80<15+9(2.172618 %(?'1%()647'5)*(%(./%1=/()8%7< # 60.(2>1.0&()*+/3( -121./%+78(8(2=(D(//(%)0/()!

7"02

!8197 !& 1% 208/(%<0/36/31.7'%/812).27<(%1/12/3(4%1/9(/1/172 02)41/37*.(%>0/172.0*7>(6/3(.0<(1.)1.<1..() " 3(1<9'&2()7%)(%60.90..()*+/3(5(0%2()%1*'205 =72=(%2()61.<012/012()02)0881%<() 1.97.()780572&41/30559(2)12&09951=0/172.$61802+ ;*

* .

< ;* * +< (%% 2C05 3(/3(%.9(0@12&B%(0.72() , E(.B7 3(/3(%%(97%/0*5( , E(.B7