← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25634/2016allowed

Vijay Singh Yadav v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2025-04-07Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj23 pages

 

  

       

          



 !"# !$%&%"'()**  + ,

+  

 , -

     ,   

(.

/

* ,+ ,* 

 *       

     !" #$% 

  &'()   ! &   *+!*

  &,- 0000 + ,* 

 1 * /    . */00  **0 12  *   (33(4335 ! .  6 * +""   *  $  " %  * 7!  " "# "+0  08!  *   #  .* +  9 12  *   4'3)4335!.#    *7!  " " 0 0  !0    .* +  9 12  ""!  '33(433: .$  " . ."*  /0#  .*+  *7!  " "# "./0       .0

  91 2  3'3443'' .6 *

 +""   *    **0"* /0   #  .* +   . . .   * 7!  " "# "

"4'3,433:.0    *.+! *    !    .!0.     0  .!  **  ;!*.  *0    *!"" <       * '=:(  $  "   > *!   #  .* +  1# +2

"   *  "  &* >!  #.* .*    1&>#

2   # " 

!

  &>+ 6   " "      "   /0   "* .*    .*    ! *     >      '' #  .* +    .*     "*     / ? 0* @  "*&!  +0    %  >  !  0* .*  0 + 

+2 !+! /+A!

/!".   ** *  *! (''4'=:=         * 7!   " " $  " > ! !  ! 0!.;! 80            00  *         " .    " .*  .* 

  8 !         +  +"" 

!      +    0   " "*"0 0    /   ".        A *    +"" "3(3''=:( !*  

 ".7    > " !* "   /0    .*  *    *    *!       .*. ! @

   #   #  .*+ 

" & #* !  *   ':3:'=:5   "0   "* /0#  .*+ !*.*0.*  

 $  "   * **   .   *!0 !*   " *0  6!0 ! "*!" * .*  ""* * 8   *  ':3:'=:5 !B "





 



   

     



   

  

          



  

  

   

  

   



   

     



 

     

 

 

  

     !    

    

" 



      !  

#    $  $ 

 %  !

        ! 

        

     



$  & 



   '

(              

     

"

  > !   !*.$  " > *  '53)'=::#  .*+ 

"+ * $  "  " "*"  !0   $  " > 

*  #  .*+  !"!.            0   0< .!  "  0 *  + *$  " ".08 ! !0    "      %  !   A *    +""  "  ".+"" 

 $  " % # " *?*  

$<& 4('4'=:-+""!.;!* ! . !4(3='=:)',3-'==(3:'4'==- 443=433(  *  +""   * ! .  $  "   %     "   

   # 

.*+     *. .*'),3B 4=33         *0         * " 

#  .*+ 

!

.  "*  ! !  !"   *   *? / 3'3)'=:=1  2 !* '33''==- 1  2           # 

.*@

 '33''==-1  2 ! !* ! !  (33,43'-   #  .* +  1# " *7! C " "% 2

     "* # 

.*+  0  .!.+ *  !* * .*  %  $  " "*      *!0   * !*  "   *  ""! * 1" ** 2! +   0 1+2

 .  *  !*  *"   0!*! + * 

!*

"         " 0    D  0  . + *  !* 

** '

  *   0       

   !* :'(( *!" >   >    !. + *

 !*4434'==-4,35'==-3(3)'==: 4

    * 0  

  .    "*  /0#  .*+   !'-3(433-

   !*,: *!" > > !.+ *  !* ( !  +    0  1+2   0   "* #  .*+  '-34433)!  !*,,1 2  !*,',142

!*,= !.+ *  !* *!">  > , # "* ;!    *    0 "*  /0   #  .* + 

  ! % + *  1!"*2 !* > !  !." "! 8B0 

" " "

     "> !."  ! 0    '==3B='      # 

.*+  .*

"*  !E# " *7!  " " %           #  .* +    !       .  .*0  * "* #  .*+  $  " %  6!   "*  *   . 8    "*  *!0   !"  *%+ .*@

  7 $*  /     . .   !  "    $  " %  *0 .  !0    #  .*+    *"     * "  ': * "*     .0#  .*+  ! # " *7!  " "%  

 . ! @*

" +!*  "+   (33,4333 "#  .*+   * . 0 !"*"! "* /0 #  .*+ ! * &!" !  

 !."."*  "**+ * $  "9   / * "*    #  .* +   !  1? 0*2    1  /2     + * "    .!*  +* !  0*    * /0  "     "*" !  !0"E    ',354333+ *"   .!*+* !*! B )*+  





 

    

 

 $ , -

     

  !

    

  !

   

   

              

 

  !

   

 

           

 

   

 

  

     .      

/

  !

  

       



  



 !

  "    

    

   

      

    , 



,                  



 

    



 !

  "       

   

         





 

 ! 0

1   "           

 

    

   0

   

 

 

  





 



      !

 

 

         

  !

  



  

*2  "   

    



       

 



 !

              

       !

  '

    

 

    

     

  



   

  

    



 !

    

 3      

  



    

  

       )    "   E!0"  ',354333 

**0 .    +* ! %0 +!     " +;!*+ **&5=== 4334 *.  %D.*

! "+!  **00!0" .+ *"   .!*+* !+* !%0+!  "* * *0    "* * @ & ==5E% E433, .    + * "   .!*+0   .   ':3,433- * ** )0        

- 

  



     1 



  1  

  .

4+54**  







   .         

 .

4+  4*+   

 ,    

 



  &6 

   7$    

      

    &    .

4** 



 



  

)  A  !*        ! 0    + **&5=== 4334$  " >    !  #  .* + 

" 

 " 3'3,433)$  "   "/  

   *    .*6!  "    "* #  .*+ **0"   .. ..+ *$  " 

   " "   !

.  * * A  !*     ;! $  " >  %    . .0 "* #  .*+ @3)3'433) '33(433)+   %   /       

 " 3'3,433)   !.*    *  %D.* ! "+!  * !!  **0+ **& 5=== 4333A  !*    !   *0 !0" %D.* ! "+! "* /0 #  .*+   0 "*   

 "   0  . !* 

 " % !      B  $  " !** !  *   '33(433: 0 0  .        **    "*    #  .* +   * 8     !B "+ 0

 

 

    

       



 1    

 

    

    !

   &     

 

     

          



 1         8  59

 &    

     :4 ;<       



1      

 

   



 

  $ 5!



;< ===  ===  ===

;<       

            

 

  

     

  

 &   !

 9





 ===  ===  ===" A  !*    .  !     !0"&,:5B ?B'B433:'33(433: 

 #  .*+ .* !    *$ ! !*  " 3'3'433)  !* . !0! &

" A  !*           "*    #  .* +      .  * " *  * 0!*  "  . * .*% $  ""*.   @*

"!**.8 > 0!  !   

 0  0    !   "    $ ! !*  **0*  ! .*8 **!."*0 !0"  %D.* ! " +!     "  "*     $  "   !

    .   *  8  "* * ! "*     $  "!**.0   * * .

!*         





  .  %D.* ! " +!    



   !



 * 

F"#$% &'(   )!!%$ * )'$# +# ,- .#' $ /- * )'$#0  * 8   "  !

   .*B )**    $     

   $

   

;9> - 

$     %$  < *??@    

            >     

 

      !

 

 "             

    !

 

  ,  

  

 

 

  



 !

      

   

   ,          

  !

     

  ,  



 

 

      



            

      

  !

 

===  ===  === *A

   1  &!$-  2

-# 3  

)'$#  4 )

 $ $  5  )'$# 

67 89



687:



67 8 ;

*@ " 8 !

.$<  )'$#  .=8"



2

-#>  !$

##  )'$# 

6 89 

687: ?6

7

8  ;    :4 )0   

          

    

       ,        

    

   

          



      

) *C 





 

   

     

            1  &  *D >

 

 

 





       0

 1        

    



"  

 

 

   

    

     ,    

   0

1      E      

 

9   



  , 



 

 

   

  

 *F " 

  

 

  .

      , 

 

   *A+      "  

 !

        

 



        

 

  !

      

      , 

$

  

    

  

   



      

      

   , 



 !

     









  G



  !

        ,        

  

       

            

.

          

      

 

  

  , 

     

  



      

  

            

 "    

  

      

 

  !

    

  

      



  



*?

  

 



      

    

        0

 1               

      

  



1    E      

    

  





 

+H

       

  

 

       

     

 



 0     

 



  



 



      



  

 

 

 







  



)



 0   .  *  !*     

"*  0!   0    + * "    .!* 1+2  

 " .  #       +* ! %0 +!  "0         .  %D.* ! " +!   0 ""*  .*+      *."*   ".  8! *  !

! 0 . B    "* * ! "* !*   * . 8    A  !* !    %D.* ! " +!     **    * .   *!0  *  ! !  "*   !* . 8          +!*    B         !  !*" 8!*. .! . !0 .  ".*"";!  " !   #  .* + 

" *!  .  $  " > *'=:(*    *

"  &>#

   "   "  

     0!*** " !.$  " >  *!0    . *   !

!  **     0  ". $  " >*   !  " 

 " 3'3,433)  !  B# "  /    * 0 !.*  *0** *.*   '33(433:  &

""*" "3'3'433)"* # 

.*+  *!0  . . 0

"4'3,433: *. .0!0 > "*   '33(433:$6$> 

! "* #  .*+  

*  * $6 "*"&

" >     *0  " ('3( *      *   (33(4335    *     

    # 

.* +       433)B35  *     + * $  " "*  /0   # + !*  .    "*   "$  " % *   . ."* #  .*+  # " *7! C " " "      *   '33(433:      !* . 0  .  *$ ! !*  *  +! *  *.4'3,433: *   . ."*1 *!0 2!*.0  . &

"      *.  ".*  !0"!$6 !    0#  .*+ .    *0 >* "!

'())===EB  *" $6"!    " !0* 3:3'43')+!*    !   !."   *  *  .  !*        !0"    %D.* ! " +!    "   #  .*@

 1! 2"* > 0!%D.*



! "+! "/ * "     "*  >   "  8""  !  >8  !    *',4 +! >*" "!   + *$  "

"*0  "*"!  + *$  "!*.

""00   0  .   " ! /. . ." " !* 0 ':  !0"% !   !0"! " *" . .0 !  !*.   .0  +!**    0 43   " !0"    %D.* ! " +!   ** *   !0"!*.      . .  >!   " 

 0* *.    "   .   "* #  .*+   *.     .        *" .  "0 0 +!* 0!%D.*

! "+!   !0"..0**    !* .    **!0"!* .   % !     . 0  " "0     . !

  " "        

 !0"  .   0  .0 .*0 !   $  "   *  "   > .!* !*    *!0  " "   . ! .  $  "   > "         *      "*     $  "   .    *" !* *.8 +!* !     B   *" ! '=:(

"

 #  .*+ 12.0 .  0    .  !

. .8* 0  !*"@      !* "*    0  .        +!* "< ***  .!  .            .  " ** 0!.  .8.    *  "*"+!* !   !  D $6 

! !!* 43''  *     *+6

!!". !%  B  *      %D.* ! " +!        ""  /*0 12 *.  @*

" +!*   B  !." . 8   0 "* *! !*  0 ! !!0"(33-'==).#    +! +?&'3'43 '==- !*.

. ."!

 *     +!  "> !*    " *    !* 0!   . .**  >  *  !*       0 !0 !"    *.*  * .*   >!!%D.* ! "+! !0" #  .*@

 C@ 1! 28* * !0"!*.   !0" 8   !   *',4 +! >    * "$  " >!   0 0

 0 "* *!   . $  " >       $  "           ** ?*!0"**    " "   "   . " ** !0" + *"   .!*+* !  #   +* !%0+!  * !0"

*!   "*    #  .* +    "* $  " >0!0" %D.* ! "+! "* * "!

"*    "*     *!0   *    !   !0" "!   *',4 *."*  "* * ..*  "  *./ .+! *! 0"*     

 !*""* ** "*10!". 2 #  .*+   +! . +? &'3'43 '==-/0   !E. ."

" ! " !E. ..  !    !*/. 45'''==3    *

 ! " "

 $  " *    " 0 .  .!  "*.000  "8 0 .*  . . " %     !0"  (33-'==)  #   +! * .** $  "! . ."* '==' $  " % **.*

 !.*.   ".    ;!* * * !*. * 8     ! )& 

 



   

   

     



 

   

 

           



  

  

    

 

 

  



4  

 

      

    '  "   

         

     



 

 

        

 *??H  " 

   

*??*  

   7    



  



  ,  

  

 

  

   "   



    !

   "          

  



           

 

4   C 

   

    

  

 



    &      '  "         





  

 



 "   

       

 *?

*??* 

    0 

     &         



     

  

  !

 &     

   !

 &   

  

     ,   

    

   >  

  .   



 *  +      

     !

   &    

.

 

    

 

  

 - 

    

  

    



    





  



   

   ;



  

 



  #  .

<  

   

       

   

     

       7      

   



  

         



  

 





      

  , 

   

  

   

        

 



  

  

    

    

   >       

      !

   &    

      

 

   

 

)

!0*  +!*" 0

  0!0  !0";!(33-'==)   "*"    & 

"  3'3'433)        *"".    !          ** * !.   ! *! *8"0  "* **   *!0 > * "!!  *   + * "   .!*+0  +"&-( 4335 @&==5E% E433,  /0.       0

 #! 0  . +"$  "! * 4'3)4335 !   .! *

  "*"*   "   0  "  00""     /!',3:4335   /  *0 !0" %G.* ! "+! '3''433) 8**.    *"*"   + *"   .!* *!" ())'*/0 BB.!*   "

* '33(433:.! '33(433:. . "*  '33(433:. B  !    0 +"&-( 4335       /0.  "* !*0     "00!"     ! *! ** !  .0 !! ! 0 "  *   "   ! !  

  "!    . .   ... .*  *     ! *. " 0  '33(433: 0 0  . 8.$  " > B   "*" .   ! "+!  .  *  ! *!  *    !** . .E!     "!**.8  B  !.*   

  *

* .  "* ** "*

 "    .  >. * ! 0 !    *;! * . .*   !    !     * % >"    0  

!  !   !*. **. !      +!  *   "  "    "* ** "* > "!      !  /0   B  !   &* # "  * 7! C " " "'===!*433:    " !*."!

   !  .**.  **. !  * ! *! *   ! 0 B# "?*  !* !" " . .0 .  @*

"   **!*. B "/0   0 0. E!

  .  !0.0  " B  *"0 .  % *  B   "* + *$  "**" 0.00!  

" '=:( 0.!*!0" %D.*

! "+!   .#   +!     *."*   " 

 "       *  **    * .         "* **  "* B  !0!* * !   *  

" *8.       *  !* * "/             B  .*!

0 !** 

*".0.*  .*0  0  !"   . ** B   0 .   8 "* ** "*  .*+ .   "! .  *!0.   ! @*

"  B     * !* B " "!  *. !  @*

" * !*!*. "*   "    0        ""!  "  +!*   ! /!.0  " *.*"! **.."  "        *   . ! @*

"!*   .. B  "

  *  !* . "**   ">   .   *. !*" **.

 *   )H !" "8  .  ** !*.! " &*""! $6   * . *.!. . **./    * "!0  0  " 0     **

 0*       + ,* 





/)1        &$

  0

 #



:(

#  0

   :(

#