High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4302/2011allowed

Jagtar Singh v. Iffco Tokio Gen. Insurance Comp Ltd

2022-10-11Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul7 pages

!"# $%&%!'() )

( *+

,) ,

- +

#$ % &

" '

()*+,(,+-- ' . - ()/,/(,+--

% 0 &

" ' . ,1 ()*+,(,+-- '

()/,/(,+--

% &

" ' ( 2 # ()*+,(,+--

% .3 &

" ' ( 2 # ()/,/(,+--

- + .) + "'

' # 22 #' 2 2

0 ,+ +1 ,+-- # % 2 & 2 5' &6 67 ()*+,(,+--

' 0 8 "' '' " 0 ( )/,/(,+-- ' 2 ' 2 '

9' " & ' 9 '2

()*+,(,+--

" 0 ' '' " 2# . :

(+-(*/-1 ' 2 & +- -- ,++/ 0 3 '' 6 670 '2 3

2#& '' " 2

2 '2

" #

9 2#'

' 0 " 3

02" & 0"& 2 3 " ; '& . -1<

+- -- ,++/0 = %

' 2 " & " ( 2 #' # 2 '# 0'

"0 0

" ' ; ' #

# '0 2 2 $( ,/) !) # 0!1'

% # 2

)&+++8( ,

)>&+++8( *

! 0 5-8)

-,&+++8( )

' # 2

*<&+++8(

2 '

# 2 '6-16

1&)+&+++8( <

1&+++8( @

1&+++8(

' 2 2 . -

-+&+++8( /

-,&+++8( 2

1&@,&+++8( 2 . - 0 2 '

,&++&+++8( 0 2 . , )0 2 ; ' 2 2 ' *&@,&+++8(

()*+,(,+-- 0 " ' '' " 0 # 2 '2

50 8 "7 ( )*+,(,+-- " 2 # "# ? ( 2 # ' # 2 # ' '9

" 5A?

*7 2 '

0 '" " 0 0 # -& 0 : 2 " 2 ' 9'2 " 5A?

*7 0 '9 " & 0"& '2 '

" 5A?

-70 0" & 0 ( " # " 2 "' '2 # : 2 " '

0 " 2 # '

0 2 2 0 # 0

= & 2 2

0 0 0 0 # 2 0

& 00 0 ' " " & 0 0 ; 0

' # " " 2 #

2 2 #

# " 5A?

*7 0 #

2'' ; 0 0' '9 A?

- ' # 2' #2 2 2 & 0

22 '' 0 ' 2 ' #

#? # #0 2 # #' 0 2

' "80

' 2 # 0

2 2 # 2 2 # ' # 2 ' 0

& #0 2 0 0

" " 2

2 B % &

-/>>5' &6 67 ' 0' & '& '

2 "# ' " 3

;2 2 : & ' # 2 2 '2 0 # '&0 ' ' 0 & 0 2 ; 0 0 0*@#' ' & '& 2 0 ' ? ')+C 2 0 0 2 0 2 2 & #0 D>C 2 2 : 6 2 National Insurance Co. Vs. Pranay Sethi : 2017 SCC 270 ; ' 2 2' -1&+++8( '' '

)+&+++8( '' 2 ' & # : 6 2 ' 2 0 3-+C 2 '"# # '& 2 0 -+C 2 "(2 " 0 National Insurance Co. Vs. Pranay Sethi : 2017 SCC 270. : & 2 '2 "

2 ' -<&1++8( '' '

& 2 ))&+++8( & '' 2 # 2 0 '0$( ,/) !) # 0!1'

% # 2

)&+++8( ,

)&+++8(?-,E )>&+++8( *

5)+C7

)>&+++8(?)+CE -/&,++8( )

2 '

)>&+++8(F -/&,++8(E <@&,++8(

! 0 5-8)

<@&,++8(587)E -<&>++8( <

' '

<@&,++8(5(7 -<&>++8(E

1+&)++8( /

% -1 -+

1+&)++8(?-1E @&1<&+++8( --

' 2

))&+++8(?)E -&@<&+++8( -,

-<&1++8( -*

-<&1++8 -)

-,&+++8( 2

/&@@&+++8( ' 2 2 2 #

0 8 "

' # 2

' # " 2 #

0 '0 " " 5A?

(*7 " #&!2 " 5A?

-7 " '

& 0"& " # ;A?

- ' 2 B ' " " & 2 # " # 2 '#

'0 " 2 # 0' & 0"& 2 ' #

' 2 #2 2

0 8 " ()*+,(,+--0

' 2

()/,/(,+-- '

2 ' 2 ' 2 # # 0 D>C 2'2 '' '

2 B 0

2 2

) )

- +7 # 9 8 $ H8. $ H8.