← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3953/2013allowed

Karnail Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2015-09-24Mr. Justice Darshan Singh8 pages

  

  !

 

   

"#$  $%&'&() *



 

         )+, -

.   



    !"





 ! #$ %  & '   

  ( ) *

 #   

$ ( 

.    / 0"1

"+   

+   " " +,

,  &-.)  '

    "     +   +    "    ""+



+ 

# # "

/ + +



0 "



 ,

+  / + 

# + 1"  2,    

' $     %!

              

 # 

  2,+  3 '

 !

#", +  04!



 # + 

 0+

       "" 

+0#

+

  5  +



+ 

#

 

"

,+, * 6)78.&--9 +

"#    3  #

 !  ,-#"#$ "02"(".'&"0"-&(34&--) :;<

&&.= "  +5"6$7&" :)998<;

&>

+ +  "+ 

+, "



+ 8# ?+  "  +     #     

  "  +  0   5  

 " 

@ " 

+""

+   ,  

A  + "# / + 

   "# 

      +

    !   ,     ""  +  ""    

 ,   )998 +

  #  + +  

"#

  #  "5#,   "



+ "# &--9

 0"

 

""#"

 @+   ,+    ,#

    "#  

       "!     

 

 6&897)997+

#

+ , 1 

   

               



  

 

      !!  "  

   # $ %    

 &'     #&  $ ($ !$ $

((  )*!

 $   $ (

 & #''$   $$ !$"$ (!!

$!! )!"$  )$  $ $!

*!        !$ $

 $  $!       )*!$+      

$,   $    $  (

#'

#'    

      - !

. ) "/* 01( "2 $)" $    &3422  # #''$

$ (                /* 0 -  ,   5 *$    ##&3//  # &'  & #''#  *  $!    $  ,     ,! $    &     $ (

# ! )($   $     

+," 



  !  , "

! / ! +" , 

+ # + ! ! "

);))99-



!B :B$!<

  '

   

"

'

#   + + !

  #  ))C)998 &;))997+

D# + +  #,

+ 8;&--9/ "# " "#  );,  +  "#)998 +    



 @+     + *

6.8;-)9&)+

 ,

#" "# ., &8,   #

"

+ &&&&--2&C&9&---

*  "!

,+   #,

#   )2;)9&) + + +" #

   "!

,#8;C.8E1'

    B , , 

+F

"864"50'7-#"#$

"02"("0'   

  

          

    

        



  

 !

 "  "  "   # !  

$%  "$

$"!  %!

 "!

"

@"

 ,#     !"" #0  + @,'

"



   29&&)9&)       '

  "          0*$ +



 " 1 ,"

 

  /+ 

  ,+ ", 

      

  "#    ,  #,   

  

 , " 

"  " 

  

"



,+    " " + ,"  '

  ,+



# 

    B 5+  "0   

   " 

 " "

"# , 

"#8;&--9F # 

?  ,+ &-)&-.)

   

   

"# 1  ,+  "

  #

#  "#

   ;&9)9&)

 " ,    %!

  $     '  +   #  "#

  

"  +   +  #,  "

    

  "

 

    + #!

# +"

 

, &-.;&-.- #"

 

2,

" 

'

"#  ,  !



  ,   #

"#+

 

"    +;-&--8 

"  "#  "

 

 +   !       

 %!

   #"  

, 

#  

/+   1 + 

#,     0 #     

+-"#9&0'&(347-#"#$ "02"(" 0'  )99):)<   ' 2C;  :$ <   -#"#$      7  07&(6  :85"0 -0&7"'#"7"/:)9&C<&

2;7 "" #, "   " + ,"##  # 

" 

 

#"##, 

   !

  "

#""#"

 "# ! " &;

55 

+D+DD D"

 





,

 " &-.)+",+  5,"

+ 

;

    ++

&-.9 #,  ! ++ + "

!

 ,"

"   ,+

 11  "0&-.)  ","

 "



+       #",,

# 

+ "

'

 

 

  

;&9)9&)+, " 

" 

5#,    

   +  ,

#

#,# +   @ 

 ,-$%0$#"02/-#"#$ :"0("#"<".5" $7&:)998<;

& 5 

  #    D #  "+ 

"



 ," 1"# !

     "  &;    

        "   ", #!

,"

"#   +



#

"#  "



    

 , "

 ? ,, 

# ,"0+ ,

#

" 

 '



,+,  # 

# 

# 

#   

# ,*      +   "   !

  

  #  0  ,    "  

  +, 0  " &;

=   #  # " &;

  #

5D0

#

"@  #+ "

#  ?#  # ?  

 5

" ! + "

#0   #&-.)+ , 

" , "" ,#&-.)",  @"#  &8, 

"

);"      "    1"", 1

 .  &8  ,   ", " #&-.)

# , + + ""  +  " '

+ 

 @#

"

   "         #    

 "

 

! # ## #   



+  5#   7.)9&):  @ 1)E <

 " , %!

'$   '

+   ?, +   

+ # ,*$,* $  '

"!

,    )2;)9&) +  #   0*$ +

  

           #             , "

 

    "   " +# + " @    "



 + +" 



#" "# ., &8, 

"!

,  #" ,  +    

> +

+," 

#"  ! "#  );, 

 5#, 

  # '

1# ,  ,    #&-.)

 

,"   + #/+ "# ,   @+ # "  28  #        

'

      , 

 + # ,  !

+ @ #  ,

+

" + #, 1@ 

, !

 " '

# 

+ "

, )998

 "

, #   ,"" "##" 

# 

  "'

@ " + "# + ;# #

"

 ",  # !  !



   

 !

! "

  #$% &'()&(*+