← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25675/2016allowed

M/S Punjab Institute Of Medical Sciences Jalandhar v. Deputy Commissioner Of Income Tax (Exemptions) Chandigarh And Others

2017-05-03Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

          

 

    



   

    !

 

"

#$%$%&'#(

)

     

 * +*  , 



#-.&'/#'$-



 0!

   

)1 2    

 0!

   

 

 !

 

              

     

    

 

 !2 

!

 "

#   $% && $'&( ) *# +&,  - $   "  "  $'&.+&/ #     

     "$0 && $'&() *#+&/, $ !

# " #1'2 '2 &00/# 3 &4(' &'

&'

&00/ 5#&$

 5" !*  )       6 7,  '& && $'''   8"" 5"!*)  685!7,8  !

  #  1 #  ###     

 "      "      9# 

 5  "*#"*"

   " #  &&    !

   #  &$

      85!     $/ &'

$'&. ) *# +.,  !

  

      5" !*

!# " "$0 '0 $'&% !

    :   "  $''(+'2    "    $'22&'2(%;+# *  

" 

5!

- $2&$2/ $'&/    1#  8#

      #  &$

    "  "$''2+'4$'&'+&& +    "    2$&0'2%(';+    !

 

     85!)

, : "$'&.+&/ " (%&.24'0';+

         - $ !

 # '.

'$ $'&(    #"

    !



#          &/ '.

$'&(   # "#  "$''(+'2$'&'+&&   

  $.

'.

$'&( ) *# +0 8 ,  !

 "    

     85! )<*"

,  !

  "   "$'&.+&/ " .'

'.

$'&(

#  "    !

   #   "  # "#    '/ '% $'&( ) *# +&$,  !

   

 "  "$'&.+&/     85!

5 ""  

  " (%&.24'0';+

   "  $'&.+&/  !

 

  "   "

#   $% && $'&( ) *# +&,     

 ""#"#8 !*)     68 !7,  $0 '$ $'&(  "    5# - &0&/  $& '.

&00(   &%= "      

>&$ &$ $'&( 8#      .

?#    "

#  # "#

 

 #

 "    @ #   # #  " "  "  

# 5  "   "

  85! #  "          #  &$

  

#  5#

 #"

  #    1#"   " @  8#         

               

 #

       8# *1# #

         "  @              

 "      &%=   "#        #  !

     "#  "    " $'&.+&/  " 

""#"$0 '$ $'&( # 8 ! "# #   &%=  5 #

   #"   #    1#"  # "8#   

  !  "# $    % & '(

) $   *

 + ,- $      8#         '    '

..



 !  ./ #  0    + 122   1 2 345      @  8#        )   &' . #))

 6    **+,  + ,73 /

   #  "  

    #   



 

""#"$0 '$ $'&() *#+&(,#    8 !   5# - &0&/  $& '.

&00(  #  "

 "      

   

    

  

          

 

     

     

    !  "   

 

  



 #$%$&

    

 "   

       

    ! 

     

 

    





  $'(

   

 ! 

  

       

 

 )   

) 

" !



    * " 

 

  

     

  



         $'(  "



   

 "   

 

 

 

     



 

  

       +    ,    -      *  .

*       

   

*    

 

  *  

!

 !

  

    * " 

 

  

     

  



      "

  $'(  "



   

 "   







 

  





 

     +   ,    -       *  

!

  

       

   

*  /   ! "

      *   

     0            

    



     

   

 "

    

 

        $'(     

    

 

  * !         ,   



*  /       * "      

 

1  

     





" 2 "

  

   





/

     )  *   * "





  

  

* ! 

    

     /    "  2 "

  



  3    

  * "!

 

  

4    

! 

 5    

   

   3 -  !

  !

     

3  



   " 

 

  

 

 " 

 "    6

 

*    * "   

 7 

    

8   



 

 

  

 

!"



      

   

 *

 6

  

*     ,

    !  !

 

  !  

       

   ,    *  

 2'9

:"      "  #       " #"   

 #  #     " #

#  " &%= 5  /),  ## "#* &%= " #  9#         "    #   "# &%= "#  8# # #  "#  *     &%=   " #        " #     

  !

    # #* # ( 5  

     )# , "  

#

   

     

 #     #  #+ 8  

!     

    



 #2  

*   

 * 

-"

* !  



  



 

*  

5 

 *  

  ,   

 

 

     !   

    

 

 

  

  228 :   

 ) 3    ! ;) #   ) !   

! <  '=="3  *  

  

  



    

         

         

"  * 

 -  !"



    " 

 

 "       "

  



  

 "

 

   

  

   

   

 

  /

&

 >    

 

!       "

 

  

    

  



   

 " 

            7

 

   !    "   "

  

 

 

   

     

 !"

 3   

 **  

!       

 

"

!     

   *    

 

   

 " 

  

     

!            

"

  

          *  

      "



 

 

    "    "

   

    

 

7  ?

!  *



   

     *  

   

 -"

* !        

     



  3  

  !  

 

 *

   "   

       

    

 >   

     

"  

*  

 "  

    





!    

  

*    1   3  

  #2   

    * 

   @  *  

  7

*      



 9 A   "   "      ;

#   #1 @    B !   8    #     #   "#

5  # "

#   " 1

 "#

51 #  

 #    #     #

   

  #" #" 1# 5   #

 "  #   #      5"#   #            1#

# 

>  #  "   "    

 #    #   #

 "   "  + #

&'

5"

  # # " " !

1 #  "      "      9# 

 !

 "  $'&&+ &$  # # % 42 :# "        5" !*

 !# )       65!

!7,    $0 '0 $'&% ) *# +. 8 ,         ##&$

  "  #"

  85!

5         "    &2& &/   " 

"# 2$ .0 ;   5 "

# " "  $''(+'2  $'&'+&&         "# &%= 5  #

 # ##

# "# 

 !

" #  "  A    

* #"  # " #  + # 

 

&& !

 1#"  #      #    #  

  5        

  !   "# $    % &  ' (

) $  )# , ##

  # # 5   "  @  8#         #    *  #" A  # * #"    "

# &$ !

1#"   '  ' ..



 !  ./ # 0)# ,#     "*"

 " * #  9#   ##      " #  

 5          ## "      9#  9#  "*# 5  #  #"         8#         1 

     " # 

&.

5   )  &' . #))



6    )# ,              "     "    * 1# @ 8## $$(;$$2 8# 5  #  "         A     1#" # "8#   

  !  "# $   % & '(

) $  )# , 

  * #" 8# "#

&/ :     #  "#

A

     # * "  !

"#

 #       " #

  85!

&% 5 #  "

# $% && $'&() *#+&, !

  "#    

     85!

 A     8  8"" 5"!*  #1@ B ! 8   "   

     )# ,   ;

 #           "# 

 # + 

)1 ,

+ 

 

 !,

   





+"

, +

   ;  C    C