High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/41277/2021dismissed

Pankaj Kumar v. Haryana State Pollution Control Board

2022-05-18Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur7 pages

!"#$

#%## # #& # ( & ) **+ ,' -' '

'

- -.

('

- ,-,

#+

/$0

'

"1

1 2# #3 ! "#$ #%& '("

" ") "*"& '("

+

"))

"% ), "& '("

+

(" - -.

- ,-, '

"*", %"& '("

+ (" '

---- 1 2# #3

"'

#0 .

"+ %

" +/"(//

0 " # 12314 "

15 1414

0 ") '

/ & 7" "0" &

&")) " "/ "0) +"(//'

#/"

(/)"

("

8 9:&" "

& *

% 4 " &

"

"'

'"

(/";/ ()"

"3 / ")

#"# /"+"( #+%

:

'"

(/";0 "";

"(9 .&

9 1 .1" ")"";

&""(( 3" ;

);"

& & /"; (

";& + "0'

'"

)

(/";

)+

& ;&

+"( ++) +/ /"+"( ;((

&0'

);) ++) "

%#%

"))"

+ " )" & "

"

/"+"( ;

& *) 0 " 0 "(% + /" "

/0

15" 12+<"

=

" )+ ))

>( &.?@5&%

"+

A

9(/)"

" &%" (

"#"

"/

&" &

("/ "'

&"

&" & ""); &0 %*% + ")& ++) +/ /"+"( ;((

( ))

# " $

&*"

0

3 "/& & 0 "(%0

#(" '

/0

15" 12+

=">

+

+

&0

(( & " & "+

( # + ";

"(( "/

0 ("/ //

%

// # &%"0

(%")) # %#% "

@

) ( ) "

" # +

& %" "# .&%" 0 (

/"+"( ;% & *"

;"

")) + %#% "))"

+ " )" & C"

%#% => 0

# /"

+ ++) & "

/""

+/ /"+"( ;(( &" &")% (

/"D ""#/ (

" "/ ( "

=>&+

);(//

;

0 "(% ="> "

")) # ); "

"( => + "((

"#/ (/)

);/ )"( &"

(

(" 0 " # ";/ " #& +

+"( &(/)

);(

0 "(% '

C""

;'

% + #")'" +/

+"( / C" /"+"( ; 0

# #"#

/"+"( # + %

& /"+"( # ( *% +&

); ++) ((&" & " ); ;

* C

%#% "))"

+"* ))(""(

)" /"+"( ;((

'

*

"#/ % +

++ ("(;& # "

"

/"+"( ;

&")" "))

?

A "))"

"

/"+"( ;

&;

"'

&0;

&" &

+ ""); ++) => +/ /"+"( ;

;

++

);

/"D

*"

0 ;(( &% '

;+

/"+"( ;& " & )

/"

); ) # "

*"

0

#

);))

.4

"# 0; )+ &

"++ /"

""); C"

9 "(( & /";"

" +/ +"( /& )"

")) + '" &"

/"+"( ;&/";0

%)

#(""(

;"

(// "

=> +/"

+))

++)

..

"

/";& "/"

+

&" & 0'

);&

("

/ 0;

.1

)+

&%";

(

(( &"

//

&% %" /"

"0$

""); C" /" "

("

5@+ &'

*% +0 "(

"+

!9 F5@ ++ 0;(/"

=.><% "++ ( %"0

(//

0;"(/";& ; *%"

++

*"(//

*" (%"# +&" *"

(/"; + ( ( +& 0 +

(/";&"* ))" (/";&%"))0

# ;+ ++ " %"))0 "0) (

- "#"

" % "(( #);!'

# ( 09

%")) ";(% "0) "; %/ '

( +% '

++ *"(//

*

% % D*) #

% ( ")) #

(// +(%++

=1> *

% " #";

#( 09

=.>& *% "++ ( %"0

(//

0;"

(/"; "

'

++ %" 0

(//

*

% ( ( '"( +&

0 "0) "; #) " +&"; & /""# & (

"; ++ + (/";&(%

&/""# & (

"; ++ %"))")0

# ;+ ++ " %"))0 "0)

(

"#"

" % "(( #);

8)""

G7 +

&G =">F(/";H/ "";0 ;("

&" () "

/ "(

+ ")I" =0>F H )"

"+ // """

/

.:

"0'

"#/

+"( /&

*" /"+"(

"'"

)"0) "#

&*

% /" "

+0

.+

5@+

&0

'

"/(%"& *"&")/"

") "'"

)"0) # (( /"D "(() &

")) "

") & "";

" "((

&* (%"# &" &* (/";+

( ( &" &0 + (/";

.5 '

#+"0'

/"

"#/ ")&0 % # &" (" "'

/ +&

.2 + "0'

"'

/ " ("

&" &" /"+"(

&0'

); ("( *

%

/" "

("

0

. +

5@ + (

+/ ;" "

"# (

* %;&) ;" '

5 +") &" &&" "' "/ "0) +";(

#" #

'

'

"'

/ =>&

") # & &"

/";); # *% ") +

(/)"

++ % &" &*) 0'

);#

%

"

// # "# &"

9(%"# "#

.B " );& +

'

"

"'

/ &"'

/ *% +" /"+"(

("( *

%

/" "

("

0

.+

5@+ &("0

" ( ); #+ ") (%"# => "*"#"

& " '")+ "+

"#

++

"'

/ &"&/"

&(" " ("0 "# &";

/

+ (

(" 0 " # "

"'

/

.@

'

&""0'

+";+

()"

/

'

="> 0

.+

5@+

("( *

%& "));+ 0

( "

# ; /

(

/)"

"#"

/ 0

.+

5@+ ("0 " ( ); #+ ")&" &

")

.6 + ";(

"'"

)"0) *

&"&(/ /" /+(

+

'"

/";& ##

# "))

3++ + /";&0

9(%"# /";

+ ( ( &" &0 + /";&0 );

/ ("));"/ &0

# (%"# &" &")0

# /"; + ( ( & " & 0 +

(/";& " & & "& (/

+ " )

(" ); ( #& ")) "

") "";

" "((

3(/)"

&0 ("/ " # ; ;

&0 );/ /&% &0 ("/ " #

; ;

% "

"# + "* #+"(%"#

"##

""'

) +&% "D+

("

/

/"

") # (( &% %")) (

"(( "( *

%)"*/"D " &" & +;

"##

;/"; ( "

"(( "( *

%)"* .?

// # => 3" % ) &" &

" /

"+ 0 '"

" / " );+ ")+

&" &%")) "++ /

+ ")" # +/ (/)"

=">

1 2# #3 ,' -'

"&

D"'

#%

! " # $

% " # $