High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3016/2014allowed

Jagmohan Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others

2017-09-29Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan4 pages

!"##$%&%'( )) * !+,-!'.%'+- // #"%"%'#0 1#0&2& ."!"# 2'3!4!'5!'"-#0 // #&6'5#'"&

7 7 !+5##6.%'+-"-#0& // #"%"%'#0& 1#0&2& ."!"# 2'3!4!'5"-#0& // #&6'5#'"&

0#&#'"(/ 08.-!0,!95:$!"#0"-#6#"%"%'#0& &'%$!--%44#0.-!0,!9.09 2'3!4 ;;;

-%&05#0&-!<<5%&6&# !+,-!'

.%'+-1&."!"# 2'3!4!'"-#0 !'5 7 7 !+5##6 .%'+-"-#0&1&."!"# 2'3!4"-#0& !&$,,'%&&2#%&%':<:#5 %'4"-"-#&#=0%"6#"%"%'&

#"%"%'#0&9=-!0#20%''2,4#0%'"-#&#"=$''#$"#5 6#"%"%'&9!&&!%<"-#!$"%'"-#0#&6'5#'"/+0%$2<"20##6!0",#'"9."!"# 2'3!4%'-!:%'+5#$<%'#5""-#,!66%'",#'"""-#6&"+0%$2<"20# #:#<6,#'" %$#0 -##6!0",#'"+0%$2<"20#9."!"# 2'3!4"-02+- 2'3!4 +0%$2<"20# '%:#0&%">9825-%!'!%&&2#5!'!5:#0"%&#,#'"5!"#5 %':%"%'+!66<%$!"%'&0%<<%'+267 6&"&+0%$2<"20##:#<6,#'"

%$#0&)6&"&=#0#0#&#0:#50"-#.$-#52<#5!&"#&$!"#+0>-#0# =!&!20"-#04%20$!"%'!+!%'&"&2$-)6&"&%#)"4#%<<#5264> .$-#52<#5!&"#& "-#0& !'5 6&"&4>.$-#52<#5!&"#&

!<,%@%A!B4% $!'5%5!"#& -# 6#"%"%'#0& -#0#%' 4#<'+ " "-# .$-#52<#5 !&"#&

!<,%@%A!B4% $!"#+0>!'5-!5&24,%""#5"-#%0!66<%$!"%'&%'0#&6'&# ""-#!5:#0"%&#,#'"5!"#5 0"-#6&"%'C2#&"%' -#60#$%&#$!&#&#"26'4#-!<"-#6#"%"%'#0&%&"-!" !+!%'&" "-# 6&"& 0#&#0:#5 0 .$-#52<#5 !&"#& !<,%@%A!B4% $!"#+0>9"-0##$!'5%5!"#&9=--!54##'$!<<#50$2'&#<<%'+!&6#0,#0%" -!5 0#,!%'#5 !4&#'" !'5 '# ,0# $!'5%5!"#9 =- -!5 4##' %&&2#5 !66%'",#'"<#""#0-!55#$<%'#5"3%'!'5!&&2$-9"-#6#"%"%'#0&4#%'+"-# $!'5%5!"#&'#D"%'05#0,#0%"!0#:#&"#5=%"-!0%+-""4#%&&2#5 !66%'",#'"<#""#0&

#0$'"0!9<#!0'#5."!"#$2'&#<=2<566&#"-#60!>#0 "-#6#"%"%'#0&4>$'"#'5%'+"-!",#0#6!0"%$%6!"%'!$!'5%5!"#%'! 0#$02%",#'"60$#&&!&!<&&#<#$"%'5#&'":#&"!'%'5##!&%4<#0%+-"" !66%'",#'"8#!0'#5."!"#$2'&#<!0+2#&"-!"'0%+-"-!&$,#":#&"%' "-#6#"%"%'#0&=-%$-,!>4##'0$#54>=!>%&&2!'$#!0%" !'5!,2&2'5#00"%$<#

"-#'&"%"2"%''5%! 2'&#< 0"-#6!0"%#&-!:#4##' -#!05 !" <#'+"-!'5 "-# 6<#!5%'+&'0#$05-!:#4##'6#02&#5 =5$2,#'"&=-%$-&"!'56<!$#5'0#$05!"''#D20#&

!'5 !<'+=%"- 7 7!'5=-%$-=2<54#:%"!<0"-# $'"0:#0&>%'-!'59=2<50#C2%0#'"%$# -#$'"#'"&"-#0#!0#'" 5%&62"#54>"-#."!"#''#D20# 0#<#$"&"-#,#0%"6&%"%'6#0"!%'%'+" .$-#52<#5 !&"#& !<,%@%A!B4% $!"#+0> -# '!,#& "-# 20 6#"%"%'#0&%'"-#&#"=$''#$"#56#"%"%'&!0#!".0&

%'05#0,#0%"&6#0''#D20# =-%$-%&!,#,5!"#5

// %&&2#54>"-#%0#$"09+0%$2<"20#9 2'3!4!'5!&6#0=-%$-!+!%'&""-# 6&"&.$-#52<#5!&"#& !<,%@%A!B4% $!"#+0>9"-0##$!'5%5!"#&9=- -!54##'6<!$#5!",#0%"6&%"%''&9 -!50#,!%'#5!4&#'"

520%'+"-#60$#&&$2'&#<<%'+-!"!6!0"9$!'5%5!"#!",#0%"6&%"%' ' '!,#<> 2060##" .%'+- &' !<=!'" .%'+- -!5 4##' %&&2#5 !66%'",#'"<#""#042"5%5'"3%'52"> &6#0,#,5!"#5

''#D20# 9"-#$'"#'"&=-%$-&"!'5!5,%""#5!&!,!""#00#$059 206&"&.$-#52<#5!&"#& !<,%@%A!B4% $!"#+0>!0#&"%<<<>%'+ :!$!'" %' 0#<!"%' " "-# !5:#0"%&#5 6&"& :%5# !5:#0"%&#,#'" 5!"#5

:#'520%'+"-#$20&#!0+2,#'"&<#!0'#5."!"#$2'&#< 26' %'&"02$"%'& 0, '5#03%" .%'+-9 &&%&"!'"9 %$# %0#$"09 +0%$2<"20##6!0",#'"9."!"# 2'3!49=2<5$'$#5#"-!"206&"& .$-#52<#5!&"#& !<,%@%A!B4% $!"#+0>!+!%'&""-# 6&"&0#&#0:#5 0&2$-$!"#+0>!+!%'&""-#!5:#0"%&#56&"&!0#&"%<<<>%'+:!$!'""-!& !<&4##'$'$#5#5"-!"$!'5%5!"#!",#0%"0!'@' '!,#<> !3=%'5#0 E!20 5!2+-"#0 E2<5##6 .%'+- %<< -!& '" &"!@#5 -#0 $<!%, 0 !66%'",#'"-#6#"%"%'#0&-#0#%'!0#'#D"%'05#0,#0%"-!:%'+0!'@ '&

7 -#0#%&'C2!00#<=%"-"-#606&%"%'"-!",#0#6!0"%$%6!"%' %'!0#$02%",#'"60$#&&!'5&#<#$"%'5#&'":#&"!'%'5##!&%4<#0%+-"" !66%'",#'" =#:#09 !" "-# &!,# "%,# "-# ."!"# :" $!''" !$" !04%"0!0%<>!'55#$<%'#!66%'",#'"""-#$!'5%5!"#&'#D"%'05#0,#0%" =%"-2" !'> 32&"%%!4<# 4!&%& ' "-# 60#&#'" $!&# ' &2$- 4!&%& %& 0"-$,%'+ -#%'"#'""%<<26 6&"&+0%$2<"20##:#<6,#'"

%$#0&0,!,'+&".$-#52<#5!&"#& !<,%@%A!B4% $!"#+0>=!& $<#!0%'!&,2$-!&"-#&#'2,4#06&"&-!54##'52<>!5:#0"%&#5!'5! 0#$02%",#'"60$#&&-!54##'%'%"%!"#5 -#6#"%"%'#0&-#0#%'-!:#+'# "-02+-"-#0%+0&"-#&#<#$"%'60$#&&-#>-!:#&#$20#5,#0%"0!'@%'+

!".0&

7 20$!'5%5!"#&9=--!5&#$20#5!-%+-#0 ,#0%"6&%"%'-!:##%"-#0'"$,#60#&#'"%'"-#60$#&&$2'&#<<%'+0 -!:#5#$<%'#5"3%'"-#6&""%&'""-#$!&#62"0"-'4#-!<"-# ."!"#"-!"4>:%0"2#!$'&$%2&5#$%&%'!,%'%,2,4#'$-,!0@%'"#0,& ,#0%"-!54##'%D#5!'54#<==-%$-'$!'5%5!"#=2<54#$'&%5#0#5 &2%"!4<# 0 !66%'",#'" '5#0 &2$- $%0$2,&"!'$#&9 ."!"# :" =!& 4<%+!"#5"#0!66%'",#'"""-#6&"+0%$2<"20##:#<6,#'" %$#0&""-#$!'5%5!"#&=-=#0#'#D"%'05#0,#0%".2$-$!'5%5!"#& !+!%'&""-#20:!$!'"6&"&!+!%'&".$-#52<#5!&"#& !<,%@%A!B4% $!"#+0>-!66#'"4#"-#60#&#'"6#"%"%'#0& -%&20"=2<5-!:#'-#&%"!"%'%'0#$05%'+"-!""-#!$"& !'5$%0$2,&"!'$#&"-#$!&#!0#32&"0#<#$"%:#!'!5!,!'"!""%"25# "-#0#&6'5#'"/+0%$2<"20##6!0",#'"%''"%&&2%'+!66%'",#'"<#""#0&" "-#6#"%"%'#0&!'5 &2$-!$"%' %&!04%"0!0>9%<<#+!<!& !<&:%<!"%:# 0"%$<#& !'5"-#'&"%"2"%''5%!

0"-#0#!&'&0#$05#5!4:#94"-"-#=0%"6#"%"%'&!0# !<<=#5 #&6'5#'"/+0%$2<"20# #6!0",#'" %& 5%0#$"#5 " %&&2# !66%'",#'" <#""#0& " "-# 6#"%"%'#0& 0 "-# 6&" +0%$2<"20# #:#<6,#'" %$#0&=%"-%'!6#0%55!>&0,"-#5!"#0#$#%6" !$#0"%%#5$6>"-%&325+#,#'".2$-!66%'",#'"&-!<<0#<!"#4!$@" "-#5!"#=-#'"-#"-#0$!'5%5!"#&0,"-#&!,#$!"#+0>%#.$-#52<#5 !&"#& !<,%@%A!B4% =#0#!66%'"#5""-#6&"%'C2#&"%' #"%"%'#0&9 -=#:#09=2<5'"4##'"%"<#5""-#&!<!0>0"-#6#0%5"-#>-!:#'" =0@#5!+!%'&""-#6&"

#"%"%'&!0#!<<=#5%'"-#!0#&!%5"#0,&

<2$@> -#"-#0&6#!@%'+A0#!&'#5( #&A -#"-#0 #60"!4<#( #&A