Lakshmi Narain v. State Of Haryana And ANR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH CWP No.2671 of 2015 (O&M) Case reserved on 03.10.2016 Date of pronouncement 21.10.2016
CORAM:/ HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TEJINDER SINGH DHINDSA
!
" #
$
%& !
'
TEJINDER SINGH DHINDSA, J.
()) " $'
,
./& 0 ! && " !! 0 & ) " $$ '*$1,
$*/0 (
2% !) &! )
0 0 3!
! )! ( *.'**5 ")! !
!! 2 0 % ) ,62% 6 / ) & 03! ! )!
& !
0( *5 '**5 2% )
'* '**5 !!
0 3 " ! ( 8& )
2% !) *$ *$ )
.$ '**5 ")!
)! 9: $;+'+ *< '**5 ! 1*;
1'* 1=5 1=+ 15$ $'*4:
( ! 5 $. 1;>++ (
!0 " )! &!! " )
) 2% 0 0 !9: ! ) " ) $'
'**+
. "& ! ) " )
'* '**5 ?withdrawn"
8 )
0 !) "
$$ '*$1,
$*/0(
2% !)
) " &) "
! ") )! ! &))!
!! &!3 *$ *$
) 0 ) !
)! ! !
0 :)0" 0 " )! & 9:>! " ! & 7 ! !) ! ( )0 ) "
9: $;+'+ *< '**5 !70)
) " 3" ';
$$ '*$.,
</ " &!
) )
: " !! ! ! !
3!) 0 " !) 0! ! 0 ) !)$1 $=( :
! )
! )&) " 0 ! 0 )! ( ! ) !! 0 03 "
!&03! ! ! ! > ! )&))! ) ! ()$' )
&!& ))& "
!
"#"$
%& '
'
(
) ' '
% ' (
*
' + 8! "03 00 " 0 !!! !! " !
!
)
!! !07 )0 !70"
0 0&) ) !! &! ) ! ) !) 0 )! 3" 60) (
! ! ! ! ! & )!! 0)
) 0 ) "
0 ! 1 $1 ,/&
0 !!))
! ) '* '**5
3 *$ *$ '**+ & !! )) ""
$'
'**+,
./ 0 )) :
&
)&
)!
@ %& )
! ) " '! !!!)
") "
$$ '*$1,
$*/0
!)
3! "!) " 0
0 ! !
")) ! !!3 !& & ) !! ) !
!! !
!
) (
2% )!)! ! ) 3 *$ *$ '**+ & !))$'
'**+ 0 )
! 8
) ! &!3 0
!! !! & &) )
0 "3
8! !!&)!) ) ! "
$'
'**+
.
0 "& & 0 ))
!
0) & 9: $;+ & ! ) " ) 83" !7) ';
$$ '*$.0)
) " 0 )! !
< 8 3" ))& " , % -
(
- . ' * /
*
* '
0 %
&
( 1 '
1
-- ' ' %
(' '
& '%
% - * -%
2- ' - -- ,
(
(-
3 !
) - ) 4
" 6 % " 6+ &) & !7)
&)0 ?honourable acquittal" !7) ! !) "0 " 0 0 !! A % 4 !(
!
"#$% ?benefit of doubt in criminal proceedings"
:& !& !7)
& ! !
) ! " ?benefit of doubt" 0( )( ) 0) 8
! !!7) "honourable acquittal".
:
&
' (
) * # +,%-#% 4 !( &" ) "& "honourable acquittal".:&0 !
)! ") ( )& &) 00!70)
"0!! ! )( !7 !! )! ! B ! ))" &!&" !) 00)0 ! !
0!7)& ! !)"
!7) !
)! & ! !7)
8 "honourable acquittal" !
) )
!
)3 !
! !
0 "
!!
8!)
7 &))0! )"3" -( ,
& $
(.
# $-%/8! ,
0 1 2 & )) " ") ( 0)
! 02 8
( "
:
)! ! & !) !!) !
&
! ! & & !9: '**$1 *1 $;;+ ! $1+ $1;
.'.
.'< .*5:
)( " )!
4& " "! )0&!7 3" *1 $* $;;;0 ) " 4& "
" " 0 )! ) " ) )! 0 ( ) 8 0 )
( " & 0 $'
*.
'**. & ! "
( 0) ""
0
( 8( " C2 8
( " ) ( )D 0 ( 3" '1 *.
( 8& 8( &) " ( 8 )! ) ! !
1 2 8 "0 60) ( & " 0)2 8
( " " " & 0)!7 !& !!
! !) ! & !) )0 " ! 7 !&! 3" !7)0 :&! !
0! !7)))
D) 3! "! 2 8
( " "3" 0(
60) ( 0 ))& 7
-
-- ' % %
-
* 8(
' . 8( % * -- '
&
5' ( -- ( - .
9
- ( % * -( *%
% (-8( - ' 0 .
* + :
! &( !
0 : !& 3 "
! 0 0 !
!) '* '**5 03 *$ *$ '**+ & " ! ))$'
! 0 "& ! 0! - 0 !7) !
)! !
0 )
E 3" Delhi Administration's case (supra) &) )!0)! ! ! &! !) 0 " !
) ! "& ! ! !) & 0 )! 0 9:
0 "
9 ! 0 ))&
:"
$'
'**+ ,
./ $$ '*$1 ,
$*/ !
!! & .* !! !
)) )))! 7 )0 -!!)
)
))&
21.10.2016 (TEJINDER SINGH DHINDSA) JUDGE √ D "> F> √ D 0) F>