Sumitra Devi v. State Of Haryana And ORS




   


!"#$%$&'($)$(*$"&



 +'$$,-)-&./ 

 0!%-'(+$*- $'-'-&$( 2$()!) 0'+'$+(3+&++&"'4$() $)5&"$&')
 


     

($)$&'.1 (2$" +(6+)47"*,+'$('4$5$'-'-&$( (-'$)4 +&"-'7""87+(3+&+ (092$(%+7"*,+'$(($)5&"$&'& :::

     4$5$'-'-&$(-)+##(-$*$"'4$+,'-&'4$($)5&"$&'1 %$&+&"4-8"$*$85%$&'$5+('%$&'70'+'$+(3+&+-&4+*-&# ($;$,'$"4$(,+&"-"+'!($('4$5)'+&#+&<+(-(6$( $'-'-&$(+8) +))+-8)'4$)$8$,'-&+&"+55-&'%$&'5(-*+'$($)5&"$&'&''4$5)' -&=!$)'-&

$'-'-&$(-))'+'$"'4+*$5+))$"'4$> (+'4%+ (-6)4+?(% -&"-0+4-'3+0+%%$8+&788+4+@+"4$$&'-($,+)$)$'!5&@$4+8'4$ 5$'-'-&$(-)'4+''4$=!+8--,+'-&5))$))$"@3'4$5$'-'-&$(-)$=!-*+8$&' ''4+'%+'(-,!8+'-&<4-,4<+)'4$$))$&'-+8=!+8--,+'-&5($),(-@$"( '4$  5)'    +&#+&<+(-  (6$(  +&"  -&)5-'$    @$-&#  $8-#-@8$  '  @$ ,&)-"$($"(+55-&'%$&'''4$5)'7'4$($)5&"$&'+!'4(-'-$)<-'4!' +&3  ;!)'--+@8$  @+)-)  4+*$  ($;$,'$"  4$(  ,+&"-"+'!($ 
'  4+)  +8)  @$$& ,&'$&"$"'4+',+&"-"+'$)4+"@$$&,&)-"$($"('4$5)'+&"-&)5-'$ '4$5$'-'-&$(4+*-&#)$,!($"A%+(6)-&'4$ (+'4%+ (-6)4+7)4$4+) @$$&-#&($"7<4$($+)($)5&"$&'&7<44+"+8<$(5$(,$&'+#$-&'4$

+'(-,!8+'-&B+%-&+'-&74+)@$$&)$8$,'$"+&"+55-&'$"
&)!55(' 4$(,8+-%,!&)$8+55$+(-&#('4$5$'-'-&$(4+)($8-$"!5&'<-*-)-& $&,4;!"#$%$&')'4-)!('-$


 

        

!+&"
"



#$ %   &'

()     

*

#! !&)$8('4$5+('-$)4+*$@$$&4$+("+'8$&#'4 4$-))!$<-'4($#+("'*+8-"-'3$"!,+'-&+8=!+8--,+'-&) +,=!-($"(%'4$-&"-0+4-'3+0+%%$8+&788+4+@+"-)&8&#$( 
 
  -*-)-&$&,4'4-)!('-& +'        ,

-!
.,

 4+",&)-"$($")!,4 -))!$-&"$'+-8+#+-&)''4$@+,6"(5+,+&"-"+'$)$$6-&#+55-&'%$&'' '4$5)'-&"-$+,4$(<4-,4<+)-&5!()!+&,$'+&+"*$('-)$%$&' -))!$"@3'4$+(3+&+0'+0$8$,'-&%%-))-&
'<+)4$8"+)88<).1

    

                

 



          

         

  

   

      



     

 

   

  
   

   
   



   



       

      

         

            !

 "



  #

  

 $          

    



 

    %&

              !

 "





 

'  !

"

"



 #

  

 $ 

       

        

 

  



( 

 

   

     

             &

     !

         )   !

"

"



 

 

'!

"

"



#



  *     

 

         !

  



 

  

  

 

  "

   + 

           





    

 

,  -./00',- 1000',  

            

    (   

  2 , 

(  

"

 )   3!

"     

     , 

   , &

 

 (   , 



,  !

"

"



#

'

                 

  

   





      &

 

 2            ,  

      

               

     

  , 

       &     4, 56

     

 "



#

'

  

          

  !

   

        

     7 /   

     &     

  !

 "

 "



  

  

'  !

 "



#



          

# 

  " 8

       

  9  :

 

 



+

 :

  , &

 



 " !

      -./00',-1000',

    

 

!  

"  "

  #   "!  "





$$ $  "  "

%"

&$%    ' "  (   "

    $  )$$("  "%   "

    $  *   )$$("      (     ! 

#  

( 

 "(!

+'!

  $"

 "

"  !$" $  $ ( $   &!

&  &&  &!($ & ( ! "

, 4$"-,'!%8+-""<&-& +' / ,+)$ )!5(+ <!8"

)=!+($83+5583''4$+,')'4$5($)$&',+)$-&-(%-'37+))!,47,+&@$ !&"-&'4$+,'-&'4$($)5&"$&'"$5+('%$&'-&4+*-&#($;$,'$"'4$ ,+&"-"+'!($    '4$  5$'-'-&$(  &  +,,!&'    5))$))-&#  +  =!+8--,+'-& +,=!-($"(%'4$-&"-0+4-'3+0+%%$8+&788+4+@+" 4$;!"#$%$&')($8-$"!5&&@$4+8'4$5$'-'-&$(<!8" 4+*$&+558-,+@-8-'3
&'4$,+)$  )!5(+ 7'4$-*-)-& $&,44+"&'#&$-&''4$=!$)'-&+)($#+(")*+8-"-'3+&"($,#&-'-& +&3=!+8--,+'-&'4+' %+34+*$@$$& +,=!-($" (%'4$-&"-0+4-'3+ 0+%%$8+&788+4+@+"4$;!"#$%$&'<+)($&"$($"&'4$@+)-))'+&" '+6$&&@$4+8'4$($)5&"$&')-&'4$8-#4'+&'--,+'-&-))!$"@3'4$ *'
&"-+7-&-)'(3!%+& $)!(,$$*$85%$&' $5+('%$&'

0$,&"+(3"!,+'-& 7$<$84-"+'$" C


&'4$,+)$$ % &'

()  )!5(+ '4$=!$)'-&<+)<-'4($#+("''4$5)' (+%-&+60$<+6+8$+((-$(!&"$('4$ &-&
&"-++&"-&'4+'

,+)$+8)-'<+)+)!@)$=!$&'&'--,+'-&'4$*'
&"-+7-&-)'(3 !%+& $)!(,$$*$85%$&' $5+('%$&'-#4$("!,+'-& "+'$"



'4+'4+"@$$&'+6$&&'$0!-,$-''&'-,$'4+'@'4'4$

1D1 &'--,+'-&)($$(($"'4$($-&+@*$-))!$"@3'4$*'
&"-+"+'$"

C

+&" 

<$($-&($8+'-&'$%583%$&'!&"$('4$$&'(+8 *' 
&'4$,&)-"$($"*-$<'4-)!('7-'-)'4$-*-)-&$&,4 ;!"#$%$&''4-)!('-&+' /,+)$ )!5(+ '4+'<!8"48"'4$ -$8"+)-'-)-&'4-);!"#$%$&''4+''4$=!$)'-&*+8-"-'3"$#($$)7 "-58%+)  +&"  ,$('--,+'$)  +<+("$"  @3  '4$  -&"-  0+4-'3+  0+%%$8+&7 88+4+@+"74+)@$$&$B+%-&$" 4$($-)3$'+&'4$(+)5$,''4+'4+)<$-#4$"<-'4'4-)!('' "$&3($8-$''4$5$'-'-&$( 
'-)@3&<<$88)$''8$"'4+'-'-)('4$ $%583$('5($),(-@$=!+8--,+'-&)(+55-&'%$&''+5+('-,!8+(5)' 4$&$*$(=!+8--,+'-&)+($5($),(-@$"(+5)'7'4$-&,!%@$&'()!,4 5)'<!8"&'@$*$)'$"<-'4+&-&4$($&'(-#4'')$$6'4$@$&$-' $=!-*+8$&'(%+',4-&#=!

+8--,+'-&) 
&'4$+,')'4$5($)$&',+)$ 5$'-'-&$(4+"+558-$"('4$5)'+&#+&<+(-(6$(-&5!()!+&,$' '4$+"*$('-)$%$&'  +' &&$B!($ 7 <4$($@3'4$$))$&'-+8 =!+8--,+'-& 5($),(-@$"<+)%+'(-,!8+'-& 4$($)5&"$&'"$5+('%$&'-&-')<-)"% 5(*-"$"'4$$))$&'-+8=!+8--,+'-&)5$,--,+883$B,8!"

 !"#$#% # !#&" 

'(%#)* !"#$#% #+ @)$&,$    )!,4  +  ,8+!)$  <!8"  ,8$+(83  -&"-,+'$  '4+'  '4$  ($)5&"$&' "$5+('%$&'  "-"  &'  "$)-($  '  +55-&'  5$58$  5))$))-&#  $=!-*+8$&' =!+8--,+'-&,8+!)$$=!-*+8$&,$+)'($+'$"(+,+"$%-,5!(5)$%+3 &'$))$&'-+883@$'(!$(!&-*$()+883+558-,+@8$($%583%$&'5!(5)$)+) <$88
&'4$-$8"$%583%$&'+)5$,--,)'-5!8+'-&)4!8"@$5(*-"$" -&  '4$  +"*$('-)$%$&'  +)  ($#+(")  $=!-*+8$&'  =!+8--,+'-&  '  @$  +8) ,&)-"$($"  &"$()!,4,-(,!%)'+&,$)7'4$5$'-'-&$(,+&&',%5$8'4$ ($)5&"$&'"$5+('%$&'''($+'4$(=!+8--,+'-&> (+'4%+ (-6)4+?'@$

11 '($+'$"+)$=!-*+8$&'<-'4'4+'%+'(-,!8+'-& 
&'+6-&#)!,4*-$<+ ($$($&,$%+3@$%+"$''4$-*-)-&$&,4;!"#$%$&''4-)!('-& 01 2&3    ,

#!
., 

('4$($+)&)($,("$"+@*$7&-&'$($($&,$-&'4$%+''$(-) ,+88$"(

$'-'-&-)"-)%-))$" ,     -  ./.010.2 8!,63 4$'4$()5$+6-&#E($+)&$".

$) 4$'4$( $5('+@8$.

$)