High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2222/2017dismissed

Gian Chand v. State Of Haryana Etc

2018-09-11Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath5 pages

! "#$ $%&'&() "#$ $%&'&() "#$ $%&'&() "#$ $%&'&()

&"(,"(- $#&#&($. /' #"#$ ".0"(""(-#,$.' $'1(-$(#'

)23 )23 )23 )23 44 44 44 44

.$'$(#) ."5&(-$.467".&(89":-;%"#$: .#,$1$#&#&($. ."6."<, ,6(#"::".0"("

44 : 44 : 44 : 44 : ,$ 1$#&#&($. ,"' %,"99$(8$- #,$ .-$.' -"#$-

= 1"''$-<0#,$99$%#."(--"#$-

>1"''$-<0#,$77&''&($. -&.$%#&(8 ,&7 # 1"0 #,$ -$ &%&$(# '#"71 -6#0 "(- .$8&'#."#&( %,".8$' &( .$'1$%# '"9$-$$--"#$-

= ( <.&$ : #,$ 1$#&#&($. $(#$.$- &(# "( "8.$$7$(# # '$99?16.%,"'$#,$9"(-7$"'6.&(8+@"("9 7".9"&$ > ?==',".$6# ##"9 9"(- 7$"'6.&(8

@"("9 = 7".9" %71.&'&(8 &( 4,$A"# >> 4,"#(&B4&##" C'&#6"#$-"#/&99"8$4"."(-&:$,'&9,"(":&'#.&%# "#$,"<"- ."##"9'"9$%('&-$."#&( :C :

( C

=A&#, .$'1(-$(# C $,". ,"(-: A, "%%$1#$- "( "-;"(%$ C :

"' $".($'#7($0#$D$%6#$#,$'"9$-$$-(

C&(%$#,$'"9$-$$- A"'(#$D$%6#$-:#,$.$ .$:#,$1$#&#&($. &9$-"&;&96&# C=-"#$- +

> . '1$%& &% 1$. .7"(%$ #,$ "8.$$7$(# # '$99 A,&%, A"' -$%.$$- <0 #,$ #.&"9 6.# (

* ,$ "11$"9 &9$- <0 .$'1(-$(# C"8"&('##,$56-87$(#"(--$%.$$ #,$#.&"96.#A"'-&'7&''$-(

"(- #,$ $869". $%(- 11$"9 B B

&9$- <0 ,&7 A"' "9' -&'7&''$- ( =*

B ,$ '"9$ -$$- A"' $D$%6#$- #,.68, 56-87$(# A.&#$. #,$ #.&"9 6.# ;&-$ /"'&@"

== (

= ( <$,"9 .$'1(-$(#C&( ";6. #,$1$#&#&($.&(#,$ &%$ 6< $8&'#.".:"@,"9:A,&%,A"'&716(-$-<0,&7("%%6(# (( 1"07$(# 1.1$.'#"71-6#0"(-7"-$#,$.$ $.$(%$##,$99$%#.(A,&%,,$ ,"-1"''$-#,$.-$.(

="'@&(8#,$1$#&#&($.#1"0#,$-$ &%&$(# '#"71 -6#0 :C

"(- .$8&'#."#&( %,".8$' *

"' 1$. #,$ 99$%#."#$ #,$0$".

="(-#,$"11$"9"8"&('##,$.-$.-"#$-

=: &9$- <0 #,$ 1$#&#&($.: A"' -&'7&''$- <0 #,$ 77&''&($.: &'".&;&'&(:&'".;&-$,&'.-$.-"#$-

> 3$".($-%6('$9 .#,$1$#&#&($.,"''6<7&##$-#,"##,$.$&'( -$9"0%"6'$-<0#,$1$#&#&($.&($D$%6#&( #,$.$8&'#."#&( '"9$-$$- ,$ "8.$$7$(# A"' $D$%6#$- ( C

= "(- <$%"6'$ #,$ 9&#&8"#&(: A,&%,,"-#<$&(&#&"#$-<0#,$1$#&#&($.<$&(8#,$16.%,"'$.("%%6(# .$ 6'"9 ( #,$ 1".# #,$ ;$(-.?.$'1(-$(# C &( $D$%6#&( "(- .$8&'#."#&( #,$'"9$-$$-"'1$.#,$#$.7'"(-%(-&#&(' #,$"8.$$7$(# A,&%,%697&("#$-A&#,#,$-&'7&''"9 #,$$869".$%(-11$"9: &9$-<0 #,$ ;$(-.: ( =*

B <0 #,&' 6.# "(- '"9$ -$$- A"' $D$%6#$- (

=#,.68,#,$1.%$'' #,$6.#:#,$.$ .$:7".@$#;"96$',69- <$-$#$.7&($-A,&%,A"'1.$;"9$(#"##,$#&7$ "8.$$7$(##'$99"(-(# "##,$#&7$A,$(#,$'"9$-$$-A"'$D$%6#$-"(-.$8&'#$.$-(#,&'.$8".-: #,$1$#&#&($.,"'.$9&$-61("-$%&'&( #,$61.$7$6.#.$(-$.$-&( #,$%"'$ E ?'$'&-$(#'$9 ".$''%&"#&(:&-" E ?'$'&-$(#'$9 ".$''%&"#&(:&-" E ?'$'&-$(#'$9 ".$''%&"#&(:&-" E ?'$'&-$(#'$9 ".$''%&"#&(:&-"/'#"#$ "(- #"#$ "(- #"#$ "(- #"#$ "(- #,$.'F

* B! &;&9!+ : #,$.'F

* B! &;&9!+ :"-$%&'&( #,&'6.#.$(-$.$-&(#,$%"'$ E6',&9467"./'#"#$ ".0"(""(-"(#,$.F **

! E6',&9467"./'#"#$ ".0"(""(-"(#,$.F **

! 3BB: 3BB: 3BB: 3BB:" -$%&'&( #,$"#("&8,6.#.$(-$.$-&(#,$%"'$ E7#,"(#&$;& E7#,"(#&$;& E7#,"(#&$;& E7#,"(#&$;&

B ."'"-"(-"(#,$. ."'"-"(-"(#,$. ."'"-"(-"(#,$. ."'"-"(-"(#,$./',$#"#$ &,"."(-#,$.'F

!3>

,$#"#$ &,"."(-#,$.'F

!3>

,$#"#$ &,"."(-#,$.'F

!3>

,$#"#$ &,"."(-#,$.'F

!3>

::::" -$%&'&( #,$ 99","<"- &8, 6.# .$(-$.$- &( #,$ %"'$ E;-,$', E;-,$', E;-,$', E;-,$', 0"8& "(- "(#,$. 0"8& "(- "(#,$. 0"8& "(- "(#,$. 0"8& "(- "(#,$. /' 77 77 77 77&''&($. $$.6# &;&'&( "(- #,$.'F &''&($. $$.6# &;&'&( "(- #,$.'F &''&($. $$.6# &;&'&( "(- #,$.'F &''&($. $$.6# &;&'&( "(- #,$.'F

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

! &;&9! * "(- E#"#$ ".0"(" E#"#$ ".0"(" E#"#$ ".0"(" E#"#$ ".0"(" "(-#,$.' "(-#,$.' "(-#,$.' "(-#,$.'/' "(5467".F "(5467".F "(5467".F "(5467".F

=!BC "(-<0#,&'6.#&( +C +

> +C +

>#&#9$-"'E"5-$$1&(8,"(-"(#,$. E"5-$$1&(8,"(-"(#,$. E"5-$$1&(8,"(-"(#,$. E"5-$$1&(8,"(-"(#,$./'#"#$ ".0"(" #"#$ ".0"(" #"#$ ".0"(" #"#$ ".0"(" "( "( "( "(-#,$.'F -#,$.'F -#,$.'F -#,$.'F-$%&-$-(

,";$ ,$".- 9$".($- %6('$9 . #,$ 1".#&$' "(- 1$.6'$- #,$ .$%.- # &' 1$.#&($(# # 7$(#&( ,$.$ #,"# <$ .$ #,$ &(#.-6%#&( $%#&(= &(#,$(-&"(#"71%#: +**G .',.#H#,$%#2I:#,$.$A"' ( 1.;&'&( &( #,$ %# . #,$ .$;$(6$ "6#,.&#&$' # 7"@$ "(0 $(J6&.0 "<6# #,$ ;"96"#&( #,$ 1.1$.#0 '9-# -$#$.7&($ #,$ -6#0 %,".8$"<9$ $;$(& #,$.$8&'#$.&(8"6#,.&#0,"'"'6'1&%&(#,"##,$-%67$(#A"'6(-$. ;"96$-<6#" #$.#,$-$%&'&( #,$61.$7$6.#:.$(-$.$-&(#,$%"'$ E&7"9"0" 6'$ 71"(0 E&7"9"0" 6'$ 71"(0 E&7"9"0" 6'$ 71"(0 E&7"9"0" 6'$ 71"(0 /' ,&$ (#.99&(8 6#,.&#0F ,&$ (#.99&(8 6#,.&#0F ,&$ (#.99&(8 6#,.&#0F ,&$ (#.99&(8 6#,.&#0F * 61.$7$ 6.# +*+ ;".&6' #"#$' "7$(-$- #,$ %# "' $%#&( = A"' "--$-&(#,$%#<0A"0 #"#$"7$(-7$(#

= ,$ -$%&'&( &( #,$ %"'$ #,$ 6',&9 467 6',&9 467 6',&9 467 6',&9 467". 61."!: ". 61."!: ". 61."!: ". 61."!: .$9&$- 61( <0 #,$ 1$#&#&($.: &' (# "119&%"<9$ <$%"6'$ &( #,$ '"&- %"'$: #,$ "8.$$7$(##'$99A"'$(#$.$-&(#&(#,$0$". *+ "(-#,$'"9$-$$-A"' $D$%6#$- #,$ 9"(- &(J6$'#&( #,$.$&(: A,&%, A"'9A 90&(8 9"(- <$&(8 6(-$. 1(- ( *

*+B ,$ 99$%#. &(&#&"#$- 1.%$$-&(8' 6(-$. $%#&(= #,$%#"(-%"7$#"%(%96'&(#,"##,$7".@$#;"96$A"' "<6# :

1$. "%.$ "# #,"# #&7$ # A"' 69#&7"#$90 -$%&-$- <0 #,$ 11$99"#$6.#:.$90&(861("("A".- #,$3"(-%J6&'&#&(99$%#.: &( .$8".- # #,$ "%J6&'&#&( -"#$- B ** &( #,$ '"7$ ;&99"8$ #,"# #,$ %71$('"#&( #,$%,",&9"(-A"'"A".-$-##,$#6($ > :

1$. "%.$"(- .8"&.767@&(9"(-##,$#6($ = :

1$."%.$#A"'"9' ,$9-&(#,$'"&-%"'$#,"##,$;"96$%"((#<$"''$''$- .#,$16.1'$ 1"07$(# '#"71-6#0(#,$<"'&' #,$"%J6&'&#&( #,$9"(-&(#,$0$".

*+#A"'"9'<'$.;$-#,"#9A90&(89"(-&' 9$''$.;"96$#,"(#,$8"&. 767@&(9"(-(#,$%"'$ 7#,"

7#,"

7#,"(#&$;&."'"-"(-"(#,$. (#&$;&."'"-"(-"(#,$. (#&$;&."'"-"(-"(#,$. (#&$;&."'"-"(-"(#,$. 61."!:&# A"',$9-#,"##,$"7$(-$-1.;&'&( $%#&(=

#,$%#',"99,";$ ("119&%"#&(&(.$'1$%# "-%67$(#1.$'$(#$- ..$8&'#."#&(16.'6"(## "-$%.$$ .'1$%& &%1$. .7"(%$ "("8.$$7$(#A,&%,A"'$D$%6#$-1.&. # %7&(8 &(# .%$ #,$ "7$(-$-1.;&'&( #,$ %# ( #,$ %"'$ ;-$',0"8& ;-$',0"8& ;-$',0"8& ;-$',0"8& 61."!

61."!

61."!:&#A"',$9-#,"#9&"<&9&#0#1"0'#"71-6#0&' .#,$ %('&-$."#&( $J6"9 # "76(# 16.%,"'$ 7($0 '1$%& &$- &( #,$ '"9$ %$.#& &%"#$:A,&%,".$(##,$ "%#' #,$1.$'$(#%"'$(#,$%"'$ "-7";"#,& 61."!

"-7";"#,& 61."!

"-7";"#,& 61."!: &# A"' ,$9- #,"# 7$.$90 <$%"6'$ 9"1'$ #&7$ <$#A$$("8.$$7$(# '"9$"(--"#$ $D$%6#&( '"9$-$$-:1"07$(# '#"71-6#0(#,$7".@$#;"96$ #,$1.1$.#0"'(#,$-"#$#,$-%67$(# &'$D$%6#$-"(-1.$'$(#$- ..$8&'#."#&(%"((#<$-&.$%#$-<6##,&'-$%&'&( &' #,$0$". **>" #$.A,&%,#,$56-87$(#' #,$61.$7$6.#&(#,$

C %"'$' ?' 4,"(-"@" "&( $A$99$.' 61."! ?' 4,"(-"@" "&( $A$99$.' 61."! ?' 4,"(-"@" "&( $A$99$.' 61."! ?' 4,"(-"@" "&( $A$99$.' 61."! "(- "(5 467". 61."! "(5 467". 61."! "(5 467". 61."! "(5 467". 61."! ,"-%7$ 3"'#90: #,$ -$%&'&( &( #,$ %"'$ ?' $'&-$(#' $9 ".$ ?' $'&-$(#' $9 ".$ ?' $'&-$(#' $9 ".$ ?' $'&-$(#' $9 ".$ ''%&"#&(: &-" 61."! ''%&"#&(: &-" 61."! ''%&"#&(: &-" 61."! ''%&"#&(: &-" 61."! &' (# &( .$'1$%# "( "8.$$7$(# # '$99: 9&#&8"#&( <$ .$ #,$ &;&9 6.# "(- " '6&# . '1$%& &% 1$. .7"(%$ "(- 69#&7"#$90"(-#,$$D$%6#&("(-.$8&'#."#&( #,$'"9$-$$-."#,$.&#A"'" %"'$ -$$- "''&8(7$(# A,$.$"' #,$ 56-87$(# .$9&$- 61( <0 #,$ .$'1(-$(#'&(#,$%"'$ ?'4,"(-"@""&($A$99$.' 61."!

?'4,"(-"@""&($A$99$.' 61."!

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

"(5467". 61."!

"(5467". 61."!A,&%, A"'"8"&("%"'$1$.#"&(&(8#"'6&# .'1$%& &%1$. .7"(%$ ,6'&(;&$A #,$" .$'"&-9"A9"&--A(<0#,$61.$7$ 6.# &( #,$ %"'$' ?' 4,"(-"@" "&( $A$99$.' 61."!

?' 4,"(-"@" "&( $A$99$.' 61."!

?' 4,"(-"@" "&( $A$99$.' 61."! "(- "(5 "(5 "(5 "(5 467". 61."!

467". 61."!

467". 61."!:"7 #,$%('&-$.$-1&(&(#,"##,$.$&'($...(#,$ 1".# #,$.$'1(-$(#'&(1"''&(8#,$&7168($-.-$.,$A.&#1$#&#&(&' #,6' 6(-#<$A&#,6#"(07$.&#"(-#,$'"7$&',$.$<0-&'7&''$-#,68, A&#,6#"(0.-$."'#%'#' 44 !

44 !

+ ,$#,$.'1$"@&(8?.$"'($- )

$'? ,$#,$.$1.#"<9$ )

$'?