High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4082/2013disposed of

Kusum Dhawan v. Central Administrative Tribunal Chd And Other

2015-04-07Ms. Justice Navita Singh,Mr Justice Jaswant Singh9 pages

! "

#" "$ %"&"'

$( %)" * % " +,%

"!#$!%&$ & "'&() &$$!* + !"

,-+.'

/ 1 !) #

+ !

"!/!

,-+.'

/ "

!-$+) !

+3/

" -"#. " ( %&% -"/ 0'" ( %&" ," -" % "1( %&" ",%

45 6 3 ," , ) "%" %% 4 ( ,% '1 "$ %"& "'

$( %)" * ( ! "'1 "5")$ ,,$! $$)% "%" ""&$""&$ "6) "%,"$ ,,$( '%%

7 $) "%"! !,",,( 1'%'"$1 3 ,"6% %"1#%1$1/) "%8" % "9*$)13 4 $ ! ,% " :" / ;) 8" % / $ %)" ( ," ! """% %"1 #%1$1 $&%"%"%% <

3 ,"%%6 !,$,)% % "," " " " " %="

%6 %)"

%"1 #%1$1 /) % !

, ","% >" ,!"

%" "$ 93 ?% %! 1&! "

'"% 1'1% %$&,"%( "$" ,'"%($1(! 1 ' "&%""& <3 ," ",$% !

"") $$)%6 % "'1 %""1""" %)" $ 3 ")$""%,"% %'1 ",% " %1"&$ >,$, " '1 ,"! % ,'$ ;( " ! %%

! % "% " ,"$ ") 4

('" @"$$A

B,% ,&$,B! ," ")$ ""%'" "% ! !&% / %%

,"B%%"'

! " "%! "".@%%"$7%A 43

" ) ! , '$ % %$1!,,"( "'

(%% < <(! $ &$'$ ""% 3 ,"%%,,"","$ ") 3

%"1 #%1$1 /) ,% "%" %% 4 <9,," &' % <3( "%") $$ ," ,89*$)13( ! " "%" C $1( @ $$'%% & ' "&% " "& %"1 #%1$1 /) ! <

$(" % "% 'A %" )) "%"!' ,"'1 /,%%$ "%"1, 3 '& % "%" "&$ " "& ! & $$1'1 /,% <'

")$ &$,!" "% $1"".% &$, @"&%A 7%"'$! " ," " %, &$," ! %"%) " $"&% &$, "' $ ")$ !" "%%$1) ""%

3 ," "$ , % " "

$!! " $1%% <%!"%) $ "%) "( !!1$ ! "%" "&$!'1/,% "%"(,,"(!""&%'1 ," " ) "%"1, <3 D$. ,"% "

"%,%"& ,"! ! ","$ ")( 1%% ) "%""&$""&"$$, '$ % 1!,," 3 ,"$% %,"$,,$) "%" ""&$""&=$$

)" %,,$$ %"))" $. 93 ,"B "

$!E 9'3,"$1.E 93 %

1"B '$ %"& ,,$$

"1( &% "%" %% < 4

( "%%! ,"B,,$')'""%'1$ %%,"" ,,$! %1" % "%"

%",,$!,%(,"&%% %"+ $

"$ &$/"&/9 3+ $(4< 43 /$$))"&%( ,""$1$%!", "'

! %"! % ,," % "$

%"&"'

$#% , )%"%"%% 4 (

$ %% "5")$ ,,$')'""% $)1!)&'1

& "%$"% $" ,"%) " ) ")$""%

3 7 1 ' % ,,$$

"1,"%%"" ," ," % $%,,$ %" 4< + $ ,"B,,$ ) &'"% %" "$ 93 ?% % ! >,"$1,"&% "%1,,$) "%" ,% %" "$ 93< ?% % "$& >" ?% %" $$!)

7,$1 ''="'! %$&"'1% ,"%$&")$$1 )"%" 'C $1>%%( $$,"&$$1 $ $ , $

3 " " ! $%" %1 '" >,"1$& ")$$1)"%" 'C $1>%%( 1'E% '3 ,,)

"1 '" '$1" " >,"1 $&( 1 '( ! " " '1% "$ ,$1 ",")"% 1! $%"

%1%"$1>,$) "" ' "%( $$ ' %% & &$ "$1 '%% "& % ! $%( "'1( ,"&$$1$$ ,

77 ,,)

"1%" ") ,$1"% &$ "$1'%% "&" ,"& '

$ 93 "$( $$,"%"") $ ,$1B $ ,( % &( ,$1 "% $$ ' %% & ' "&% " "& %"1 #%1$1 /) ! " % ") '7( ,,)

"1% ,"& '

$ 93 $ 9%3

"$""% %" ( 1"%"" ,$1 ,$ $%'1 ( '6 %" 1)&")"%) ,1%$$!" ,"% '

F ,$1))"&%'1 "%",% %" '

$ 9<3 "$1 ,"",,$

"1%'1 %"1#%1$1/) "

F ,,$ ,"""% %" "$ $$'"% $ ,"""%! ,"% %1" % ! ,1 "%",,$%)"&%

,,$$E "&%%

"11" ,,$" >,"1 %,"%(% ,,$$!,"&%'1 " ,""") ,,$A

! "#$% "&$% "'$"($ ) * !

%)%

) )+ %

),)

*) * .

),%), ,

! "($)

71'

"1 %" '

$ "$ 93,!"%",,$& " >,"1 $,"% %1% ,,$$ % ",""") ,,$

"1 " ",!"% %" '

$ "$ 93 " "$ "6 % "%"$$%C @"&$""& !""%""%A :

" "(

"1"( %1" % "%" $$)%'"

'%'&( ")$""%% % "%"$$="&$""&!"&%

," "". &'%'1 $

" ")$&$, 'C ",," &'%'1 ",% ")G "%""&$""& ," " ) 1!$$

.! %$., '$!,,"7!" ,"$ " "

$!% ! !!1 $ " % "%,"$1.( ! $%' )"$1 6 %" %$'"$1&%% ", "%" "'1/,%" $% ' ,,$! $! 1

3 + $$1 % &) ")"% % " %'&(,," ,"

'"$1'$%" "%%$1 ""%$) %,"$,,$7 " ",," ( % " ' % ,,$%" ,!"%% )%

%" "$ 93( '

$ ?% % 9%""") 4< + $3(

"1) &'&% "!"6 '$"'1% "

"$! ,"&% ,""$) ,,$ %C $1 !$%%%$1$) ,,$

;&)")"% ,"& '$ %"&""% &"

1"( " ,," ' 6 ") " %%) ,"B ,,$ "

,,$$"%"%%<

( ""( )%( "'1( % "1C ( "%",%'1 "'

$ %%

<3 ;&) $% (!"$ %"%&! ! "

"1 ) &%"% 1, $$1 ,""&% ")G" &"

1"! 1'$ % %%"""%"

," '$1 % " !%"% 6) ! ,$ ,) $ ! ")$1 %,,"& ,"B'"% 1! %% % (&" $

"1! $%' %"

" % 1%"! " %% !"" , "&$""&%=" %6 %C $1''1,)$", $& >"' %".'1

"1$1 !$$ ,," ,,$$

"1 )& ,," 1 ,"$ ") ,"% %% ,,$! ,"% " " %","%,1 "%" 5

6 6 3$89418: