Harbans Singh v. Financial Commissioner Punjab And ORS




   
   
























































 

 !"!#$

 %& #"'!#() 

!

!#% *"

!# # !

+,,!""!#%- .#/ & #0 )%"  "1#0# "

 2$3  452  '
 6'6 2 
 









 






7")6., % !#-8 % +9 




!"




# $



%& '( )'%*
+,
-

.

+ 

/ +

0"
12
3

!
3  
"
4 -
5 6


!
/ +
"
"

 %7 %) )''8

!!


"
-



!
 




-

!"


 







 


.
+! 
3




 


 

 




,

$




)7 %% )'%.
!




!+








/ +


+




8
$





!9+
 
:"




"
 "

*





0"
 -!
+
+





 

,

 ,

( 8
,

6
-

+

!"

.


33






+!

 

 ,



  



 !
-

"
!+



+

" +
-2





$
-
!!,
" +,

.


+

$


-

!



+

!+








$
-
 
+,




'& '7 )'%&




" 



$


+,
-,



+

# $




#
$







 $








$



 )8 '8 )'%& -

-

!


.

"

 

#
$


+,
-,


$;
)7%*(

)'%&

 
-

-
-



-
 
+2

 #
$






+-




 
-

+,

$!

)& '7 )'%*

#
$

 




!

 

 ",
"
+,

.
+!


-


 !"




!
 
!+



 !

%& '( )'%*

""
"


 !"

 


+


$!



!+ 




  

/ +
4
$",5




$ 

+

!

!
,
,

!

6

 !+ 


.
-



 

.8
 %7 %)
%88*


$!



<!"
/!

- !"


+
 !
+!

-


+!


33  

!,
!"

,





"
 !


"



6


!+ 


.
 




"

-


!"

 



+
2



"

6
!

 !+ 
!





!

3
 9!"




$!

()!

#: !# # !

+,,!""!#%- %;

#

#0 )%"-<89  8!:!+9=<>







.
-
 !


 
"
+,
""

+

!+
 "



 
-


6



$



 

-

 !,

"





 $

 =



!


.

"!
 $




!!+


"!


 
 !,
!"

 



-

!
!+

 "!


-

 ,




 


-
  !
-

"
!+


0"

-!

+

 



 +
-2

=-

-
!+ 

 $

!


.





6 

!+ 


$






!
+!
 #
$




2






,!"

" 


-

&7
,
-


.7
,

"

 



+"


 ,
+2"! 

 
!




! 
$!




 ) :!%'!#():6)!

+!

, #0 )%"-?89  8!:!+9 <
 

"
!


+
2







3@3 


"

 !




-

,!"

"
+ 

6



!




> 
 
-

+




1!
%7


!9+
/ 1!
1!
%8'(
4+


!9+5



 

  

/ +
"

+


!

!"
 

+,






$


2
 
2
/ +

+,

!+
!


2 

+!

!+,



-



9+

 +





!
!


!+
 "

-








!




8 
 


!9+


:"


 
 


"
+!


+

"











+
+,

$
 


+ 
 , 




-
"


 ,


 +




+,

#
$





+ 
-

-"

 , 45 


 45 /



45 



45 8
,
"




45 7'
6 



45 =
09,


,




$


!+
!
 !
,

!
+,

"
!


,
-!

3<3 +







-


2


 

+

+,

$

6



$
 +




+

 ,


-

-  !
-


!+

+


$
 


+
!
+!

.
"
+
 "
+2

 "
-
"


 ,

2-"




0"
 ! 

,!"

"
+!


 
-

-
 
-
.7
,

"



-
&*
,

"


  
!
-



"





-


  


-
! ,
 !
+!

!

 


-!

"
"


;




 
3





()!

#8".1% 9-
6
-!
+
 



3






$

 



 !,
"





 $



!"

$


2



 
.




-

 ,






-


-2
!





.
 -
"

"




-




 

2 ) :!%'!#()8".1% 9+"
,!"

"

1
-

9

+!


-

+!
 +,
,
  


 

6
-!

+

"

!
 
.
+






-

$!
 





 


"

!

 
+



!

 

/ +
+! !

!





+
"!,


+



3=3 +"






!

-




 !


6











 



#
$



 


.
 +





 

&%-

8 6'6 2 
9 %#.

   ;
2"?
@?

;
1+
@?