High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4454/2011allowed

Bal Mukand v. Ashok Kumar & ORS.

2018-12-18Mr. Justice Arun Kumar Tyagi13 pages

! "#$$

%# &'% (

) %

" #

% &&&&&

) % *+ ', "

( )* )+ #)"" ,-

. $, / 0 $,12 % ! - . /%01"

2 3!0!!41)053"

3!,-

( 3 ,-

)% )4 #))4

'#' #

$ ! "88

"4**/0

12 )% )4 #))4,)8"7 (( ! 9 , - . ,( ( :'78 '"""+ ,- # % ,- " (( , ,- (( , - 3 5; 7<* )+ )4 #))4( ! #<4 %%< %%*; . "*8) / 0;

12 ! .-

3 = : =;, >

= ? :

( , %) - ( ") )))@' ,-' - ,,--( , A( $ "

)) )))@' >3 , - , $ "7 )) )))@' , %

$ ,- ; " # B % -

,- ; % ( ,3

'%' " ( ( , ; -,-

, " # A - % +

6, ( (

6 , ,- $,

- ( ,

,- #

(( " (

5(((

; ( ,- (( *

(

,A C'" 3

,- (( ( ,( :'

'"""+,- "

,- - ! "<%/#2. . "4<%/0. .

$$, -

$ ($, (- ( , $

'+'

)) )))@' , - , 3 ,-

-, , 3

6 ! " #

$ %'; . - ( ,- ( - - ((- , (

$ -D A- - ( $ $,

(- $

,( - -, ")

! . " # -( - ,( %, - ""

$ . % - ( - , , , , ( $ ,- ,- - $ A(( A

'7' "#

;

((

( -, , ,, - E (( , ,- , ,

(( ,

,, ( - , % "0 % "

" 3 2! / )3 !4" 5 4"

30""

3! .--($"

6% 7 2!(

0"86+9, +3 5 "/,$9-+(, "%

$ 3

,- (( (,- " ,- # %

,A C'" ,- C'"' - )% )4 #))4 (! '8 (! 9 , - ,)8"7

. ,(( :'78 '"""+ ,- " (( , , ( (, - ,-

( ( $ - C'"' , -, , - ,- , ,-A ,- (, (

'8' "+

, A - (

, - : -( ,

,- '

A- (

-(( $ -C'"

,,3 ( , 3 ( "7

= : =;, > = ? : C'# > = , )% )4 #))4 3

! "<% /#2 . .

> = BB !; > = ? : ,3 , !,B- ,( ,- , ,- !; 5; 7<* )+ )4 #))4( , $ , A - (( 5; ((5; ( ",- "8

(5; ( 6 ( (

'<' , , ! #<4 %%< %%* ;

,- "

!.- -FA '% ! "<%/#2 . .

( $ (

(( ( ,- " -C'"' / 2 "<

,A " # A- ( ,

(( ( ,- "

% , , " #, % - !

!:6 ! .- ( (

, " #

- .B- "% , ( ( - ', '

( ( , ,-$, "*

; 3

)% )4 #))4,- (( (,- " ,(( :78 """+ ,- # % $, -

! (

'*' $, - ,,

(- "4

; 3- , ( /"2

0" 3: 5;

!+(< / 5;

!2' /2 FA ( 9 ( A G /2 D(/ (2 3 ,3 ( /2 D( ( G /,2 D (

,-G /2 5 A /#2 "=< 0" 3> 5;

!+ "

3/ 5;

!, /2 >( ( B 3G /2 D / @ (2G /2 DA /(( -2 +(

8)0532 3!0!8:)053"

" 3+, (0<3 03 !

! 99 "

"; 2 3!0!

3/+"

,' 5

3!..+(,9??, #)

$ A

,A C'" A

'4' >

= C'# C'"' / 2 "

)) )))@'

,(7# )7%@'

$-C'"'

, ,- C'#'>

= - ( %+ )))@'

,A,'

# 6, ,- B , ,-A @ , - (( , ( A +(

8 "

3)0532 3!0!3:"(

430;4//

3* !3 "

3!..-+, ' + 0"86"

3:" ;403 ,"

(5 3!"" 2 3!0! (06 ( ";4 +,=, '

-? + 0"86 "

3:" ;403 ,$ ,- ( ( , - 7# )7%@' $ 7# )7%@' #"

! A - B -

-- ##

( -, ,

(A ,-3 ,(3 ,

#7))@'

'")' 7 )))@' #7))@' #%

$ ' C'"(") )))@' ,- - A -(, A(,-

,-- - - : , , (%4"+@' B( , -, ,!:-,-D, > #+

C'# >

= % ! , #))4 # , #))4 $ ,

- ,% $ , ""

<+#@' ( ( #7

! ,- ( C'"

, - , 3

,- FA, '%# , A - , ,-

B ( - 5 >,- . FA,'%# 7)H ,- - - ;

'""'

, - ( - ,-

,-3 ,-

- #8

: 3 ,- ,

#7 )))@' ( #7 )))@' ! , - ( ( - - A - #<

; , - ( ' (3 5< "! " 7# )7%@' "

FA ( 9 #

5 '' %

FA ( $ !

> ") )))@' %4"+@' /- 2A% I""

<+#@'

D ( -

,- '' +

D( (

( #7 )))@' <

D #7 )))@' *

!(( - '' . /5< "! " *9*-.@= #*

- ( ,- # % $ -

'"#' ( " ,

; - ,- # % % - ( -(( ! " ( ( #

, , - % , - # - -, #4

;

55"

3!2!)'3:"

" 3+, + > /,9 :?,

A.,

8) 0$ . , 9, > - > = =( ! -; /#))%2% !.. "+* -( ,( ,-$, :(. . ; . , 3 , (

, (

( - - ,( ,- ; (

( 3-

1 %)

;(0< "

3!2! "/"!03"

5<": '

" 3.+,(9 :?,

A. 4H

. %"

;(06 ( ";4"

" 32!(4:5( ";4+ ,"

3! $ +, + > /, 9 +(, 8H ,-

.$, ,-:?,! .; 4H

'"%' %#

; , , 3

,- 9 A ,

(- , -

#% <47@'4H ( 9 %%

; ,

( )* )+ #)""

" % - "

#% <47@' "3- - 4H (

9 +

) % , $$ !( C (@ J@ C , J@