State Of Haryana Th. Execu Eng Pwd B&R Br., Faridabad v. M/S Shiv Shankar Const. Co. And ANR.

 



    
 


























 










 ! ""## $ % &
'(
')
* %
*

'




+"      

 

 ,''
"  

##
-"" 
.!
/
##-



0%1.
2


3
/
  

"  


2


,''
'
0%1.
'%#
/
" 

'
1
2 4   
'-
5%.
6#7
(
-'
 
% (
5%. 7
(

'
""##  
 '
 )7

(
-'

5(
 )7
(

"
  
 

3'


 !


""#
%
9
  / 

*#
7
::;
1
'
 





-' /!
/0
#
%



'
 / 
 *#
7
::;
'  

/
  

<'
<7

1 

'
- 

: 9

7
'
/
.  
'-
5%.
6#7
# 
%#
"" 1
 /'#

'
""##
%/.7
'
- 

'
 / 

" ( 7

##%

= /#!
'1'
."
- 
.%'

'
 '
=

0% 

- 1
'
."
1
'
 . 


'
* 

'
"% "

.

'
7

  '
 
(1
'
%.


&>
"
5
"
! 7
-' 
'  / 
'
- 



&>
"
5
"
.'
1

&>
" 5
"
.'
3' 

%"#

'
" 

;
.'
-''

"
.
'


'
 / 

'%

'
%#

%%  '.
3'
* 
'
/
%/.1
/##

'



&> "
5
"
.'
?(
 
( 
'
)
"#7
'
.
- /1
 
3'%
* 
%#

#.
'
%.




&>
" 5
"
.'
@
'
 / 
"
'
#.

'
*  
3' - 

'
 / 
-
'##1
/!
#1
/0

/0 '(
#
/
.

/01
*% 
'

0%
!


'
/0


#

" 7
'%7
' 

>""#

.7 .%'
#7
#)1
  
 '
 )7
# 

*%#

/!
 5(
 )7
(

"

%/.7
'
 1'17
%"1 

.

'

.
4#-#
 "%
 !7
 
-
 

/-
'
*'
?1 +7
 !
4,
6+
" .7
*'1 '

* 







% 1
'
%/

'
 7
'
+#-!
(
' 6 1
-




/-
4#-#

#1 '
1'-!  1#!7
 


-
( 

'

-''
-
%
'
  3'
41
*
A
4*A
/  
'
( 

'
 


-

; "
!
-(
-1

'
( 7
4*A
 
"'.##!


97
-''
#%
'
'(!
 %)7
.. #
('#

 7
'


.

'

 
. #


' 1 
.!
# 
- 
='1

'
" .
)-#1
'

  ( 

'
.
%#

/
#(

'
* 
 '
#%

"%
' %1'
'
"".

'
 /  7
' .
-
  

'
 /  
3'
 / 

 

#(
' "%
.
-
../ 
*..

"1
'
4*A
 1(

.
" 


"
'

" 7
'
="%  % 

.

'

.


;


"
5
"
.' ?(
'
?=%(
?1

'
" .
1(

" #!
" 


"
'
#%#7
'


.

 -
 (


&>
"
5
"
.'
@
'
 / 
1 1
'   .

- 

%.




&>
"
5
"
.'


% '
%/.
'
"

 1
'
/0

( !
#.
B (-



%##
%
/!
( %
0%1.

'
</#

%" .
*% 7


'
/0

- 
##1
-'
' " (
 

'


" !

.#

'
""# B
'(
' 
# 
%#

" 

"" 
'
"" /)

-##

 

'
 / 
" 1  
6#7
# 
%#

'
""##
'
#
'(!

#
%"
" 




4C @
4 .

C .
 )
@0 4)1
+

>

B %

6 7
-' 

'
/ .
'


" 
D%
/!
'
6
'##
/
=
% 

'
 

'##

/
%/0

0%.

% '  -
'


'
*% 

" 1 "'
 ;



'
C # *

'
* 


'
"!.

'
 
-##
/


'
%
.

'
- )

"

/##

'
.'




'
.

'
/
 
/!
'
 /  
3'

  ( 

'
.
-

" ./#
-''
-
" ./#
%##! -

""#/#
7
'   7

 

'
C # *
-%#

.

"#!
3'
/##
%/.
/!
'
*  - 

'



&>
"
5
"
!
.
-
 
 "!.
-
.
B
.

'
(-
'

-%#
/
"" " 
 " %
#(
" 

'
- 7
-'#
#1
-'
'
(# 

'
" 
 

      



         



     



 

                

  

      





  

         

   !        

              



    

"

"     

#

    

" #



                                "

  " 

    

      $        





     %&            

   

      

" 

   &'

&( ())*    &% )& ())+  "

"       

         

       #

                  ,          #

  

    

      -

    

  

 

    

      .

   

  !    / ) )) / 0 ()    1&'

&( ())* &% )& ())+  2+**%%.,        2&( )(

  

          

      /

 2+**%%.0 (3 4% ++'., /   

   5

5 "

  

          (2 )( ())+  6-       -  57 8         

    

 



          8   ()         0( ()  (     

      &'

&( ())*  &% )& ())+

  

      



     '42)02.,"   2+*0*0.,  



   

            

         



   /         5

5 "

 '42)02.0 (3 2)22'  /  

9  "         5

5 "

     

    !               

"      &'

&( ())*  &% )& ())+   "            *):                   



   !     *)4%++'3 ''*&0 '2)))., /  

          2)22'.,     8        5

5 "

 

       2&4%).,    

$

  '2)))., /      

 



     !   

;

3'
"#

 
6#7
(
'
'
 / 
' ( 
'
 .



'
 
7
'%

"/# 
'
" .


/0

'
"".

'
*..7
 7
1(
'
7
'
""##

""


%'
"#
B


.

 
'
 
-
- 
  %
-
."#






7
-' 
'
+#-!
( 6 17


/(7
-


" #



'  
-

.
'


(
! 

'



&>
" 5
"
! 7
/%
'


.
 
. #
-1
  

41
*
A
.

;


9

 1#!7
' 
/.
/%./#!

%(
3'
.


'
7

" '
 / 
 
. #
3'
../ 

'
*..
#
1( '
" 

'
.
#
B
7
' 
-
!
%"#
 "!.

'
/##

'
" 

;
.'7
'1
" (
' ""##

#
'
""#
)1
 

'
- 

" " (


 

'
 / 

*#
7
::; -( 7
%'
.!
'

/
(#

#!
/0

'
% .
'
/
# B

-

#
#-
'


%
-'
 %.
' - 
'

/
  
-'

3'
D%
-''
'
-
/

 '
  .
""#
'
# !
/
- 
/!
'
</#

%" .
*% 



0%1.7
-' 7

'
/
#
-
' %#

%#
'
- 
%

 
.
##1#!


-


 % #!
"  /
%

 

'
7
'
.

/

    
-'
B
'
=
B


 
'
0%1.

</#

%" .
*% 

 !"# $%&# '% ( % )#%*% !+,%-$&$)!

#$.

/012345 -' *!'

.

 -$% $ #-,%-$$'(  !,6#-% /0122758
B
'
  .
0%1.
'
</#

%" .
*% 
'
%##
%
'


/!
'#1
'
%#
 %#
' 

 
"" 

'


 

'
 / 
'


##-
% !
#1#
"7


#!

'
 %.

-%# /
0% 
  1
-'
'
- 

3'
1'
*% 
'%#



 *% 

""#

"" 
'
. #&(

./ )

 "'
/!
%/%



-
(-
B


'


'
""##
' '
- 

1
'
"%/#
"#!

'
(#
'
" "#


0%#
"" '7
.%'
#
1
'
%

'
" (




'


3'
- 



-'#

0%7


/#
B

- 
#
#-
'
'
 / 

*..

'
#
0%1

D%#!


D%!

'
(
/  
'.



'
/
 (#/#
( 3' 


##1#!

" ( !

'
    1#!7
'
" 
""#

.
3'
*% 
'
.
 

.!
#1

'
1
 A6$7
?=%(
?1 7
4,
" .
 !7
6' 
' 1.
E7

4 % .
1!7
+5?7
4%0/
 , '%1
* " 7
A7
4A A4



##
7

' /

'
'


./ #1

'
#1
-'%
 1 '
1%

1%
#.

'
*  
B

( !
 1
'

   " 

#!1

'


/1
"" (
/!
'


 7
-''

"
'
=" 


%"

'
. )
3'

 ( %


#.

 


-'-'

'
# % 

(/#

'
" 

/1
##-

.

.. # B
.!
(-

'

(%

.)
!
  

 

." (1
'
D%#!

.

'
7
.%'
#7 !
'1

'
" 

'
'
* 

/%

#!
' 

"
'

" 
B
7
%'


(
.%  '(
)
/  
 1

'
* 7
#1
.!


/%
 -%#
/
..


B
'(
# !
.
'
""#
/%
'-(
B
.
 "

1(
##-1
/ (> B
.

"" " 

%
 

*'   !
  
*'
?1 

'



-##

'
4 0
 
'
#
1'-!
%' !

B7

.
%
-'
'
" "#
." (1
'


'


#!

/%
." (1 '
.

#!1

'



-##

.
)"1 
(-

4*A
  E
'
"!

'
 
/


'
*'   !7  !7
4 0
  7
#
1'-!

*'
?1 7
+7 4,
 !



(
."#

"  0311/012