High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/26817/2015allowed

Punjab State Coop Supply Marketing Federation v. Prem Kumar

2024-02-21Mr. Justice Namit Kumar8 pages

! " ####

$$%&$'( ) *(+*%,- .

%(+(/$'( ) $0%+*%, - .

$1212($% 3$%+ ! # $ $%# $4('$(1 !$! # $ $%# $1212($% 3$%+ "

!!##

( $4('$(1 5)6 75 8595

) ( +,-./01,23-0 ! 4& " 5 $ $#$ & " +,26/-7,23-0 # $! #$& '& 5

& " 5 $ 8 $ & "

#* 1 0 +,-./01,23-0 595 - - :$#4 #$#

# 26/-7-./01 (23-0 # "

; # ((" #5 ( # "

& (# $ (" # ( + * 26/-7 ( 23-0& $

<#"## $ ,, 5),

( #$ =

=$#

"$ $#

5 (( $

# " #226<227

# (>#

5 ( !

$ ,@

2A # &

#&& 5$ ""

$ &

-A !$#

( ! $ "$ # $ # $!

# $ #

5 $ (!!# "

# $ 03B!

-&--&3-&376<,

##"# #

-&5$ ( ?

$# ((" # "

-&5$ $ # "( -../,..&-...,23332333,233-5#! ((" # ( &#$

$ 5 & $

-A !5#

# C(("

5$ $ 5# # "

& $ A

#(( $ ## (# 2&22&32&-02<, $ " -../,-...&-...,23332333,233- #"

$ ##&;

# 5 #

* -, !

-6 -- 2330 ,-&$ 5#"$ ,#$

68 -3 ( $ =

##$!

& #&-..3=5$ "$ #5 # $! $ $ # ( "# ## (# 2&22&32&-02<, ""

#$ #; ## "" # (# "# $ $ # $ " # > 5$ "

$ "D -../,-...&-...,23332333,233-&"

5 $ $& C(("

@ ( &

;5#"

-, ! ! -/ 3@ 23-1 ,2

$ 5# ("

#$!

(03B ## (# 2&22&32&-02<, 5 $ $ 5#( $ $ 5 $

# #$# !

( "" $# # :$ ( &

-( #

? $$ $ &

$ &5$"$5#"

# #!## $ # $ 27 3/ 23-1 ,1 $ $ $ $

$!(

&$ &# ((

&5$"$# $ "

( #

#&& $$ $ # $ & -2 30 23-0 ,@$# #

#$!

-/ 3@ 23-1 ,2&#5 # 27 3/ 23-1&

$ ?

-, ! ( ! $ "$ # # $! :$ # -2 30 23-0 ,@& #

#& & $$& $#

$ 5 $

(" # # -./01 (23-0&5$"$ $#

$ , !&$

<#"## ,, 5), 85 (( $#5 -./01 (23-0& $

, !$#

"$ $#

( ;#$ $

-/ 3. 23-@

,-, $ "

!!## &

(& 5$"$ $ ( $!$#

#!## $ 13 30 23-2

2,:$ # EF&

#&G !

3-<36 37 233.&

* @ A :$

& 5$"$

( "

# $#

#!## # !

2/ 36 2336<30 37 2336

0A $

& 5$"$ $ $#

#$!

( 5 " #&5 $"! (( "# ### ( ! $ ! $ $ <

#& $ $ #!

5 ( !$!

5 $ # ;

% "

# (

26/-7

(23-0#! $ $ ,@

2A # &

#&& 5$ ""

$ ( !&$ $#

( ! $ "$ # $ # $!$#

# &# $ ( ! " 6.

#" &-.6- 5 $ -@ (

#&-..3

-& 5$ # 5# "

#"$ & $#

# #!

& $ & $ #!

# #

; # &5$"$# #(

! ( $#

# $ 5$

# $ (

# ( C(("

&5$"$#' ,

:$ # "

# (

##$!

& #&-..3=&5$"$$

-. 37 2336 $ #!

## ),

"#$%&' "( ( ) (*++,- . (*

%(* !* (* *! (/- 0#$%0 01120+3,3-,4-3,,5 (!" ! (

" #$% & ' "( ( ) ) (*++,6 %

( % " ( " 7 8987 8.8( (! " 2 .( #$ (% 35-,5-3,,5!

"%-( 6

H>:>*'

#$ $

- ' ==

"( ' ==

"( ' =,-=

, , ' =,-=

, , , , ' =8=

, , ' =8=

, , , , .

%+466 $:4;,$$ ''; 5*(*<2(< "2%$/1% => $(*;12$ 4$/22$'

2(1?$$ %+;$ %+466 $:4;,$$ ''; 5*(*<2(< "2%$/1% => $(*;12$ 4$/22$'

2(1?$$ %+;$ ' = =

$ ! "( ' = =

$ "( ' = =

$ "(

( " %( " ( (*" 6

H>:>*'

- <*2(11?$'$/22(5"@ 5" => 1 1?$ *%' "2%$/1% <*2(1 1?$ '$/22( 5" 1 1?$ *%'"2%$/1% "$;$1$'

<*2(1 1?$ '$/22( ''; 5*(*<2(<"2%$/1%11?$5*(*<2(< "2%$/1% # $ "# ( $

< '

# $ "# $ (

!("$" % "(-

$%" - : (&

"* 0 #.;<=> = ;='&#/7'' ?/'@A / # #& $ C(("

#' ,

# $

#$ $ "

( ' A

# # $

$ # $

&5$

$ # &

& $ # $ #&

# , @ $ #

#5 #$ 5 $ # "(" " 5# $ A

5 $ !

-&$ &5 $ (5 $

! & $ #$!

# & 5 $

(## " &#

##$!

& #&-..3&5$"$ $

-. 37 2336& #"# " $ $

# $ #&

& $ & $ -2 30 23-0 ,@& #

#&& $$#5 $ #" & ( -3 "

& $ #$!

-/ 3@ 23-1 ,25#

$ '&

-, !$#$ (

&5$"$5#"

# #!## $ # $ 27 3/ 23-1 ,1

!& $ & # ( ( $

< 8

& # # &( #

#&& $$& 5$"$# "

$ $ "

< -- "

& $ ,@& $

#&&

$$#5 $ #" &(! ( -@& & $ #!

#$ # ""

& 26/-7 (23-0# -2 > # -./01 (23-0&5$ $ A !$!$# #!

#&&# $ $# $ $ $ $ # ! & $ & #

! ( $ 5 (## -./01 (23-0#$ #!## 5 $ # "

# #

-, !$!&5$ # + -./01 (23-0

- "# &#

"$ $

$ ( #&

&($ 5 # ""

5 $5

$0%+*%, - .

=595 >