Comptroller & Auditor General Of India & Others v. Central Administrative Tribunal & Others
!"#$ %&'
( )*+,-./ 01 !"# .-%23( 3(1"!1(4(32,4(45(6(&(61 74%4*
* 8*2* (3.*(/2(14(36(4)414(36(4%4*
*-3*
!"#$ %&'()$ % *+&
)(( # !"#$ %&'()$ )(
# ,,,,
*+ & (9*4&(13)(1 4-*
:::::
)(
#-% "
4.-%23( 3((34*4( )4(6343 4(3.*(/2(14(36(4 )4$ *4;<'3(3 ="
"
!"#$>2 ?"!'33
=@AA !"=-(B())-64)(. 4-(*-3*
4(--)(?-(*-3*4(3(--()434/B 6 4 ( .3 6( --)( )(.6 4 76 +?
'
! "
# $ %&
'()' * +,-!.) ! ( / + /
(
(0 1(
!
/
/ '()'
* +,-!.) / (
( 2 .(
. ' . . .!
34
!5!+
6 !
.
. /!!( 6
( & 78928.2 .!
(
( 78&2 .! :
2 4( .37 *1 $'4(*/6(3/B4 =
& (9*4 &(1 (3 )2* 4 -* *2/.34(
!""1-***23((3*.64 (--)(* 3))2. "C#-** &2(*D6,( $ *4;&,<'-(B/(3?$@ !!?
!
!!E "0!!' 2 )*)(3 (4(36(4 2 4("C#-**1*>-**7*3 *)4323)(*)(6B 4.*(3)3* 4(3*. 7*()*() (* (2*=$'$'-334((6(>(* (73,A,A )(33(*(6(*2*3-**1/2(* ((* *3-*14*4(/(6(>(2-4B(*4)(* )(33(*/66 )(6B 4..2.F2332)(( F2( )(7(*-33(*"!4)(**-(**1471 )(*2(7D* 6(63%14F23F2( )(7(* >3(*04 )(**-(** 744*-2(4( (--314B74(-(**"!4)(**74 (-3 7B(*
*-3*
#?(--)(*1(/66*)4323 )(*)(6B1*2/.3(--)(*-2*2()4( .3
.
(3*. 71 *-3 # 7(* -****6 4 F2( )( 04)(**-(**(37(*B#4)(**-(** *F2B14* (--)( 4-* &,7(*264B9)3 *-3*
C-()-(34*)-)**(37)(3 7 )32)64714 (.* &,7(*--(3 - 2 )(33(*123*)4323)(*)(6B$74)2 .(D* 0C'174 4(3*)23..(D*4(*-3*
C( 6( )( (34G(*(17*)3(3(--34*(3-**
())2 4?*)1*-3*
#- 34 6(--)()(.64( .3 @
H(3)2* 24*2/.34(4133 3(3 =
!"=$>2 ? '14(3**23(3)4.- % 23 ( $ *4 ;<' .2( 4 62(G( *)4.74 @3(B* 4*(.7(*)4(63/B4(--)(*3
7--)( " !"=(3*.(B14-*(* 3 )** 7 (--)( = !"= 83 3* 3(3
@
!"= $>2* ?@(3 ?C'1/447(--)(*73*.**3 4 *(.3*7)4(63/B( )3-(*1 14(--)(*(34 -*3 * "#CC= !"=(3 @!" !"=1*-)B
4* 21 333(3 = @
!"C $>2 ?#'1.(33 4 .(4 *4(3923)( 4**27444*3 )(6B )(33(* 4(6 *)3 . .(D* 4( 6( )(6B )(33(*)23/(392*3(6(*-)(6B*(*4(6((3 (>((6(*(337/B4->)2%
/0+120'
4 5 616'0 & 0 / 4 6-.'
4 4(3 -(B (73 4 6( --)( /B
6(64 1(*)3(/174)4**2*((/1?((1 4 76623*+?
('
4 4 )(33(* 4( (D 4 / (6 (>(1 4B )( / 6(3 4 / /6 )*334-**.( 6()(6BI /'
4 -> 2 %
/0 +120 ' 34!6 706
6180-7(*3(6744 )&.(32.3(3 "
# "
0**23/B4. 3()*34 -** ,)*=%0 "
)174)4-3* *((6(*,A,% )(6*I )'
4 ( 3)33 )23 2 %
/0 +120 ' 34!6 706 6180- 3( 74 ( .( 74 6(3 (>( (6 714-*)(*14 -)** *)33436 (B-.(B 7*1-4B*)( ))B*1 (7* 73 /B7 4)(33(*7*4*34/(** )2(3(3 #
!"!$>2 ? '174)43.*(* 4(4)(33(*7/(7(33.(D**.-B4 /(** 4 32)(( F2( )(* $ ! .(D*'1 7D >-)$ @.(D*'(37$"@.(D*74)47 24/ 2)(3 @E"!.(D*'14 14)(33(* 7 / *)3 >3 -((.* 742 (B ).-(.64.74*-)4).-)B(3 )(/ 42*14*3)(6B)(33(*4(6((3 4(>( 32)((F2( )((3764(6 7D>-))(/F2(3(314 1)23
9
/33/(392*3(6(*43)F2(()()*I 3'
*2-- 4**2/.**1(3)2* 4 -4(*32-49236.33/B4-> )2:
80$55 616&
) /0 4 6- '(..-74-((6(-4"!17(*434()4 )(33(/66,A,A 4(*((3(>( /6)*33 6()(6B)(33(*14)( )(.(64/(--32346()(6B
#
4( 4(3 4 (3 )2* 4 -*1 (--(*34-(-/D(3( 474(4* )(3. 4( .3*2/.*** 4(3)2* 4-*
723/(--32)3* =$'(3=$'$'
%$' 4)174)4(342*+?
'
78$2 $;<
!. 0(
!
. 1(
7892 ! 7$/ % %%% %%% %%% %%% . = %
/ '&5'59&
. .$ & ! >$
)/ +)/ . / (
$ > $ ! /. )/
%
%
! %
/ .
.%
! '&5'59&5"5 ;%?'.! :
;
3.3B14(--)(?*-3*7 23/. .2*4(4*)3)(33(*46()(6B 4 ()2( .(>(*4-*)(**4((--)(* "@174/63 4*3)(6B((34(>(32)((F2( )( (3764(6.(D*())2 )22**)4*(. 3-(.(-(744)(33(*/6646()(6B
42*14B7F23/)*33.* 4-* &, 46()(6B(*>(*-)(/ 7(*((3/B4*3 )(6B)(33(* 4**)*()7449236.33 %
/0+120' 34!6706 6180-744(*/43(*23+? @74 ./ )/
!
%
/ .
. (
( ! & (&
/ (
. (
.
. ( .
$
!/
! ./ 6
%
(
. ( /
( !
.
. (
)
!5 ! ' ./ $ 3) A)
70
&
!+ .
/ .
(
( +/ B.
!
. 6(
(
$ 8 2 &
&
%
. . (
! !
+
.
)!( .
%
/ & (
( !
! / (
.
. (
(&
'/ (8 2
.
/
( .
/./ !+! .
.
.
'/ (8 2)
.
C?
D1376
/832 $
%. .
.
+/
9 / /6
)/ %! !
%
D.
D ! .
%
/ . / D ( .
.
! D6
/ /
!
(
! .
!(.
! )
(+ ! .
+ )
%!
) .
! .
) / )
%!
!
!
% $ 832
+./
.
+/
/ !
( .
%
)
/ 6! ! ( !
?? !
$77A.
)%!
! (B/($ !
<
*!' ! ()
( .
! /./ !+!
.
.
. ) !!
. (. .
.
.
D
)
.
! / !
! ( <= B
B .
/
:
"!
>(.64 ()2(.(>41B 2-**4 *3)(6B7*)32 *>(3*3-**(37-** 7 3 2- /B 7(B ).-(**( (--. 4 (--)(?
*-3*7((3B)22*B7D6 *.(BB(*(34(3 /).(6 24-2/).-B. 4 ()2. )(.6 (>(4(6(*7(*32)((F2( )(/B46( )(6B)(33(*(34*3)(6B)(33(*4(3/ )3 42*14)(. 4(--)(*4(6((34/ )23/)*33 *3)(6B 714*2(723 4(/3 4(34)(33(*/6646()(6B ((34/ (6(>((332)((F2( )(14 7234(/()(**(-((3142*1)23/F2(3744 *3 )(6B ,.( 7 4(3 / >-**3 4 9236. 33&/0=028
-$ 0>10256&)6-9+#( .- 74)44(3/32- !C!A!! #CA !"@3)33
"
!"C/B4$>2 ?
'
""
649236.32-/B(3)2* 4-*:
80$5!6706 61801*2 ))4(4
()2(.(>1(*)3(/1/6(B3 1(3((6)(/ 334 ./B4.
"
4(***(3(/1623 )* .(32 4))2* 4)(/ (23 *2(B14 7-*3*.**3
$ % *+&
)(( # )(
# %&:?$ %&:?$ '
8 2@ <- 02 4 4 68 0> 3A
/ * 6A
4 4
0@
* 6A