High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2057/2018dismissed

Ghansi Ram And ANR. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2022-08-31The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli12 pages

-1-

!"#$%

"&"'

!"#% ()"

* )+)"!)",( -

& /,), )0)"))"!,(

", 2# 342 / ./5 6 / 342 /

",#7 2/)"!

1/()+)6! '), 6 ,( 1

2 "8& 2*,,)96 !!9 ! '), )96 )0)")6:*,( 2 /)&);( 2)<6

, ! '), )9 )0)")6 )"! 5& ()9!

152)"'()"!),(

", *"

,)", 1 ,*,*" () ;

" *9 ! '9)*+*"< ,(), ,( )'=&* *,*" 1'

')* !&, *!

",**'),*"

& !&"!

/ ',*">?@ ,( 4)"! '=&* *,*" ',6 $> !), ! $ $ )"! $$

',* 90A99:

!;0,( ):)!!), !$$6,(

;0)'=&**"< 9)"!)1&;9*'1&1

6")+ 90,( !

",)"!&,*9*B),*" 9)"!)

",*)9)"!++ '*)9/ ',>6 )*!);)!A=&),( 9)"! ,( 1

'+1*

!*"5() )>$CC>CC>D7 E),.*99)< :9)62)())F1&6 ( *9?* ,*', )*!);)!6() 9)1

!*" * : 1 * *"

/ ',*">DE,( *<(,, )*+1 ),*")"! )"

1) "'0*"4)"!'=&* *,*"

();*9*,),*")"!

,,9 ",',6 %D (,6G,( ',%HE :*"<,,( '",

0 &1, !) <)!

*", ,),*" 1 * *"/ ',*">DE,( ',%69*8 +)"0,( :*, 6,( 1'

*",( *"

,)",1 ,*,*":

8 1,*");

0)"'

-2- ):)*,*"<,( !

'* /&1 &,( '",

0:) *")990 1&, ),

, ;0 ,( "

,*,&,*" "'( ,( /&1 &, *"

! "&9,*+), 1))<)1(:(*'(* 1!&'

7*"7;

9:#7 "# $ % & '

('( & ) % &

& % & % *+ %

%& % * & )- ) )) %% .& , & - % & + &,

& & '

('-(% & % * & % / % - * 0)"1 & '(- )

-"1 "1 0 % &2 &, & '(% & % * 3

&) & % %% &

& % & + % - 3&

- )+ & - 3+ &

- + % &

- + -

3 0 .

4 4 %

& '(% & % * & %&

& 0&2&%5 & '( & - ) & 6 % ,

-%& '

)( % %& % &2 & % & % /

- &

&&& ) % & % * & - , & * % &2 & %

/ -% %

+ & *% & &-, 75 %&

' & (

% &2

&, & % 5 ) &

6 % ,%% +&

& % * - 8 )8 % %& % &2

& % & % / 9 & - &

& * '

(% & %

/ + & &2

& '( 5 5 %&

& 0- , &

- , & * '

(

-3- ))% &&

) , %& % , &

+ & & &2 &,

& '(% & % * ! 0 & '(% & % * - % & '( % & '

('-( : 0 % 3, & % / &

& '( - ),%2 ; <&) - 3, & !% & % / +

& '(% & % *+&

- 3 & '( / 0 % & '( ,% % &,

&- & % & 3

% % -% & % *& %&+ &,%

&2 , ) &&

0 % - & %

-& -.& &

% %

& '(% & % * , ) & % & 2 , % && &, % &2 &

&, , %%& % & % *+ + 5- & &&

) ) 2 , % % 3, &,

% %&

% & &2 1 % &+)"! &;

,)"'

,( *", ,),*"/ ',*">DE ', % ;0 ,( /&1 &, * ,(), ,( * , )"! + , '"!*,*" ,

8 9)1 *"< * ,(), ;,( ,( '",*"< "'*

1 *!

! * );&,,( 1(0 *')91

*")"!,( 1)0+ ",'+1 ),*") ,;

&9*99 !6+ )"*"<,(

;06* *,( ,( '"!*,*"

* ", ),* * !6,(

:&9!;

"9)1 *"< )) ;9*<),*",+)8 1)0+ ",*"9* & ,( 9)"! )'=&* ! * '"'

!6 *, () ;

" '9)** ! ,(), &'( ;9*<),*" , 1)0 * '+19 ;0 , *"< ,( '+1 ),*" :(*'( :&9! + )" ,(), ,( '+1 ),*" )+&", :) +)!

) )*9);9 , ,(

-49)"!:"

)"!*( () ",)''

1, !,( )+ 6*,:*99",;

) )*9);9 ,( 9)"! :"

, '9)*+ ,(), ,( '+1 ),*" () ", ;

" 1)*! /*+*9)906:!I!

1 *,J() ;

"*", !,+ )"!

1 *,*"<:*,( 4,( ) &0,(

&,):*"<1)"'(")+) () ;

"'"

!,;

) )9*!1,)8*"<1(0 *')91

*")"! "'

9)"! ,)"!

!*",( /,), 6,(

* "!*

,*"<1 *!

! &"!

/ ',*">DE,( ',%( /&1 &,() &,( '9)** ! ,(), ,( 1 *! :(*'( )"0 *", *+ !

:) *" 1 ),*"6 :*99;

K'9&!

!:(*9 '+1&,*"<,( <)11 *!* 0 ) /*+*9)906 *,() ;

"'9)** !,(),/ ',*">DE,( ',%!

",<* *

, ) "

: ')&

)',*" , =&

,*" ,( 9 <)9*,0 '"'9&!

! 1'

9)"!)'=&* *,*") *,)119*

,"90,(

*" 1'

1 "!*"<",( !), "'

",,( ', % > 1 ,( ')

1&, ,( ;0 ,( 1

6 ,( 0 ) :"

5() ) >$CC>CC> D7 E *,&), ! *" .*99)< 2 :9)6 2)())F1&6 ( *9 )"! * ,*', )*!);)! :(

&1" ,( 0 () '"

,&', ! + )"!) *"1(0 *')91

,*"( )*!9)"!:) )'=&* !;0,( "+ ",)0)");0*

&*"<",**'),*"

!), ! $ $)"! $$&"!

/ ',*">?@,( '=&* *,*"',6 $>99:

!;0):)!!), !$$,( 1&;9*'1&1

")+ 906 !

", )"! &,*9*B),*" 9)"! )

",*)9 )"! '++ '*)9 / ',>6 )*!);)!,* ')

,( 1

,(),!

1*, () *"< )""&"'

!,( ):)!"$$6,(

", () )*9 !,,)8 1

,*" &,( 6,( 0() '", !,(), ,*99!), "

*,( '+1 ),*",( )'=&* !9)"!:) 1)*!,,(

" :) !

1 *, ! :*,( ,(

&, *" )''!)"'

-5- :*,(9):(

6,( )'=&* *,*"1'

=&),(

,*"

,)"!9)1

!*" * :/ ',*">DE,( ',%")!!*,*", )

)*!6,( 1

() '", !,(),,( 9)"!)!F)'

",,,(

() )9 )!0 ;

" )

! + ,( )'=&* *,*" 1'

)8*"<)99,( 19 ) 61

)9* )11)'( !,(* &,;0*9*"< % > :(*'( :) !* 1

! *!

!), ! %> ,(

;0 !* ',*"< ,(

", )&,(*,*

, !

'*!

",),*"

+ !;0,( 1

*"<)99,( <&"!

) )*

!*",( 1 ,*,*"(

",),*"+ !;0,( 1

:) !

'*!

! )"! ,( '9)*+ :) ', ! ;0 1)

*"< ) )8*"< !

!), ! (*9 ',*"<,( '9)*+,( 1

6*,:) ", !,(), 1

)'=&* !9)"!:) ,)8 ")"!()"!

! ,;

*'*)0 !

1),+ ", *!

)1),@@!), !$$ <)!

,),& '+1 ),*"6*,:) ", !,(),,( '+1 ),*") <)!

9)"!*" =&

,*":) ,

!)"!* ) )*9);9 !* ;&

",( 1

*",( *"

,)",1 ,*,*"() '()99 "< !;,(,( )'=&* *,*"1'

) :

99 ) ,( )8*"< !

)"! () ,(& 6 &<(, ,( 9)1 *"< ,( )'=&* *,*"1'

",( <&"!,(),"

*,( 1

9)"! () ;

" ,)8 " " ,( '+1 ),*" () ;

" 1)*! , ,(

(&<(*",( 19 )!*"< ,( 1 ,*,*"6,( 1

() )*

! 19 )!* '*+*"),*";0'", "!*"<,(),)99,( )!F)'

",9)"!,(

() ;

" )

! *" ) & ,( *"9& ",*)9 1

6 (:

6 ), ,( ,*+ ,( *

&)"'

",*'

+,*" ,( "90 '", ",*")*

!;0,( 1

:) ",( 1 +*

/ ',*">DE ,( ',%)9"

)"!,(& 6,( '9)*+) <)!

!* '*+*"),*"

,)"!

*,&)990<* "&1)"!

",( :*

() "+ *, ) 19 )

-6- ;

*"<)*

!* (*<(90 )<& )"!* *")',(*,;0!

9)0)"!9)'(

6 *"'

)'=&* *,*"1'

,!'"'9&!

!:)0;)'8*",( 0 )$$ )"! ) ,)"

+ ,( 19 )!*"< *,

96 ), " 1*", ,*+ ,(

()! '()99 "< ! ,( )'=&* *,*" 1'

6 ,(

6 '"

*"< ,( '1 ,( *"

,)", :*, 1 ,*,*"6 :

:&9! ;

*"<"90,( 19 ))119*');*9*,0/ ',*">DE,( ', %",( )'=&* *,*"1'

,*" @

'",)6 2 "8& 2*,,)96 9 )"

! '&"

9 )11 )*"< ,(

", /,), 6 &;+*,, ! ,(), ,( *"

,)", 1 ,*,*" !

, ;

!* +*

!*" * :,( 9):9)*!!:";0,( /&1 &,*",( ')

", &,(*,0 D &1)E ) ""

,( '",*"< "'*

'*;

!*"/ ',*">DE,( ',%) &9*99 !( * ,)"! + , =&* ", , '9)*+ 9)1 *"< )'=&* *,*" 1'

* , 1 ,(),,( 9)"!:"

* *"1

,*"6:(*'( 1

() )*9 ! , 1 ) ,( 1

*" ,( 9)"! *" =&

,*":) ,)8 ";0,( /,), ;0 '!*"< )1), B")+'()@@ !), ! $$6 :(*'( () ;

" ( 9! ) ) )9*! +!

,)8*"< 1

*" "'

&'(1

*"* ,)8 "6,( 9)"!

);

9&, 90*" /,), )"!:(

,)*"

+)*"

*",( 1

9)"!6 ( * ),

&,( &;+*, ,(),,( ;9*<),*",( /,), , 1)0,( '+1 ),*" ,)"!

!&90!* '()< !) ",* '+1 ),*" )+&",:) ,

!:(*'(* &;

,)",*), !+,( )',,(),&,,,)9 )+&",):)!*

@6@$6>>6>$@C7)")+&",

6>@6 @C7 () ;

"!* ;&

!)"!

,,( )+&",*"'9&!*"<'+1 ),*":*,(

',,9)"!*"=&

,*"* ) )*9);9 !* ;&

", )

=& 9 ) ",*"

! )',6 1)0 () ;

" +)!

, !* +*

,( *"

,)", ,*,*") ""

,( '",*"< "'*

1 *!

!*"/ ',*">DE,(

-7- ',%) &9*99 !:(*'()

",*)9'9)*+*"<9)1 *"<,( )'=&* *,*"1'

) *"< ( )! ,(

',* )<&+ ", 6 <*"< ,(&<( ,(

',* 19 )!*"< )"!); )99,( K1 *,*""!

", &,(*,0 D &1)E6 :

) ,( '"

! 1*"*" ,(), ,( *"

,)", ,*,*"* 9*);9 ,;

!* +*

!+ ,()""

) "

*" ,( *"

,)", 1 ,*,*" () '9)*+ ! , ;

*" ,( 1(0 *')91

,*" *,* ')

,&1;0,(

* ,(),

",(&<(,( ):)!:) 1)

!"$$)"! 0 !*! ", +)8 '()99 "< , ,( )'=&* *,*" 1'

;&, ,( 1(0 *')9 1

*" () ", ;

" ,)8 " + ,( + " ,(* <)!6 ,(

", () *9 !,( :*,, " ,), ", &;+*,,*"<,(),1

*" :) ,)8 " ;0 !):*"< 1)"'(")+) *" ,( + )1), B")+'() @@!), !$$:(*'(() ;

"( 9!) ) )9*!+!

,)8*"< 1

9)"!/ ',*"@,( ', $>1 *!

,(),), ,)8*"< ,( 1

*" ,( 9)"!6 *,

*" ,( /,),

+ )99

"'&+;)"'

(

*" ,(* <)! * +)!

, ,( 99:*"< 1))<)1( +,( F&!<+ ",#7

! "

#$ % & !

( "

) !

$% * +) ,

( "- "

" ! "

$% ."

)

/ ."

-8- )

" &

)

) )

" 0&."

! !

( "

%%& +) )&

& % / + - 3,

& % 03,

& % * )

3, & % =

> &2 )

% 3, + 3,

& % < ,&3%

))&&2+ >

&%& &

- % %)& -&2 &

& )

" ") )

$ (& 6:

) ,( '"

!1*"*",(),,( 1(0 *')91

*" ,(

,*" ,)"!

!&90,)8 ")"!9)"!*

!*",( /,), (& 6 ,( 19 ) ;

*"< )*

! ;0 ,( 1

;

*"< *" 1(0 *')9 1

,*"* :(990+* 7'"'

* !)"!* 9*);9 ,;

', !

! ! " # "

", () '), <*')990 19 )!

! *" ,( :*,, "

,), ",,(),,( )+&",'+1 ),*",( ",* )'=&* !9)"! :) +)!

) )*9);9 , )99 ,( 9)"!:"

)"! ) <)!

,( '+1 ),*"9)"!*"=&

,*"6 )+ :) ,

!)"!* ) )*9);9 !* ;&

",6 :(*'( ,( 1

) ), 9*;

,0 , '

* " ,(*

-9-

<)!622*,,)9() )

!,(),*" * :,( K1 *,*"*""!

", &,(*,0 D &1)E ,( ;9*<),*" ,( /,), , 1)0 ,( '+1 ),*" * !* '()< ! * ,( )+&", '+1 ),*" * ,

! :(*'(() ;

"*", !,+ )",(),,( )+&",:) +)!

) )*9);9 ,,( 9)"!:"

) ;

!*" ))%:(*'(* 1!&'

*" ;

9:#7 2*+ & !

' (

$ % !

3 3

" 4

?) +& % -

) ) -&,% - ,

3 & & - % %

3, - "

" )

+ ++$! "

5 "

)

" ) "

+ %

)

) " )

+) !

* * +

7 8 "

) 8 " ,

+ $%)

?) + & ) , + -

& *+

& 6 "

7 8 " )

+ 9 !) ."

1 5 )

,), ! )', '9 )90

)9 ,(), ,( ;

),*"

+)!

(

*"); ! ", 9 ) )"0 '1 !&;, ,(), ,( /,), () !* '()< !*, ;9*<),*",:)!

+)8*"<,( '+1 ),*",( 9)"! )'=&* ! (

6 ,( '", ",*" ,( 1

,(), "

-10- '+1 ),*")+&",() ;

" '

* !;0,( +* + *,9

)"!,(& 6* (

;0 ', ! ""$ %&'%( %)*+" /&1 &,*""!

",&,(*,0D &1)E() '9 )90 ;

! ,(), !

! 9)1 *"< )'=&* *,*" 1'

&"!

/ ',*">DE,( ',%6;,(,( '"!*,*"

* 1)0+ ", '+1 ),*" )"! ,)8*"< 1

*" +& , ", ;

&9*99 ! * *

*,( ,( '"!*,*" * &9*99 !6 ,( 9)1 *"< ')"", ()11 " ( /&1 &,() ;

!,(),,( :!IJ''&*"<*"/ ',*"> DE,( ',%+& ,;

)!) I)"!C"J

)",1)) +,( F&!<+ ",) 1!&'

*";

9:#7 2- 8 " 5

$%) !

&")

)

! !

* +

" & ) "

( ") '

( " '

( ' ( ,,,, ,,,, ,,,, ,,,,

* - :; 7 & <

- =##) 8

> "

) ,

(

" " " - !

@ '$ +%- !

)

" - ")3 3 3 33 3 - =, 4

3 3 3

$ %!

) " ! ! 3 - ) 3& ,

(

) 6-&9673 ) !

" 3 )33 3

-) ) "

-11-

) ! !

)

! !

- " " ,

7 )*** $ %-) !)

)

3 3 ! !

" " !

& "

" - "

" " " " !

" ,7 )***5 $ 0% & ."

@ - "

A - " & "

( $ " % 0+ % % &2 &, )+ & '(%- - 3+ + & 3+ &

+ &2 &,

#1 ",( ')

),()"!) 9 ', !+,( )8*"<!

) :

99)

190 *9 !6 *, * ", ,(), ), ,( ):)! :) )""&"'

! " $$6 ,( 1(0 *')9 1

*" :) ,)8 " ;0 '!*"< )1),

B")+'()@@!), !$$)"!,( '+1 ),*")+&",:) !&90,

!/*"'

,( '"!*,*"

'*;

!*"/ ',*">DE ,( ',%) &9*99 !6,(

6 )*!1 * *"')"",;

9* ! &1";0,( 1

,'9)*+9)1 *"<,( )'=&* *,*"1'

13.

2 "8& 2*,,)96 " ,( "<,( ,( )', 19 )!

! *" ,( :*,, " ,), ",6() ( ",90'", !,(),,( /,), )'=&* !,( 9)"!,( 1&;9*'1&1

* !

",)"!&,*9*B),*"9)"!)

",*)9)"!++ '*)9/ ',>6 )*!);)!(

,*"*

0 +&'(

",*)9 , )'(*

,( 1&;9*' 1&1

) *, ) ', ,( !

",%+,:*!

/ ',!* *!*"<)!) 1 9)0&,19)"

-12- () '"

!,(* 1),)<&+ ",)*

!;0,(

", )"! :

) *"'+19 )<

",:*,(,( )+ ) ,(* * )"*+1,)",)', , ;

8 1, *" +*"! :(*9 !

)9*"< :*,( ,( ')

)* *"< &, ,( )'=&* *,*"9)"!, )'(*

1&;9*' 1&1

)"!*, * /,), C*, )&,(*,0:(* *",( ;

,1 *,*",!

'*!

);&,&,*9*B),*",( 9)"! )'=&* !6), *,() *"<;

!*"/,), 14.

)

=& 9 ,( ); !* '&

*" )"! *" * : 9):

&++)*B ! *" 1)) %@% "!

", &,(*,0 D &1)E6

'**')990), () *"< '!

!,(),*",( ')

),()"!6,( 1(0 *')9 1

,*"() *"<;

",)8 "6,( ;9*<),*" 1)0+ ",'+1 ),*" ,)"!

!* '()< !)"!)9 '"

*"<,(),,( 9)"!*"=&

,*"* 0+&'(

",*)9,)'(*

1&;9*'1&1

() " (

*,),*" , (9! ,(), *" ,( *"

,)", ')

6 ,( /,), () &990 !* '()< !*, ;9*<),*"=&);,(,( '",*"< "'*

''&*"<*"/ ',*" >DE,( ',%)"!*,;

*"< 6,( *"

,)",1 ,*,*"* !* +*

! )8*"<!

!;0,(

",)&,(*,*

;0 ',*"< '9)*+,( 1

* )''!*"<906)*+ !)"!&1( 9! 15.

) *"< !* +*

! ,( +)*" :*, 1 ,*,*"6 1 "!*"< )119*'),*"6 * )"06)9 +

)+ ), /,),& =&6*)"06 ,)"!

)'), ! D ./5 E / D

44E % "!F ( )8*"<C ) "

C ( 1,);9