Vinod Kumar And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others
!
"
#$% "& '
!
"
()*+,-(+.
.,/ $
/0 1) )''2&3 )45 2 1&2 '3)45
1 & 3)45
#$% 1
13 ()63 * && "
22"
8 '
#$% 59
&2 5
4&4 8 5
- :
54 5 3 5 4
;5
* "
"
& )5&
%<
.
5 2 5 9 ' % ) ; 0
8
" 5
) ; 0
8 64 .) " & 8
5'
" <
2 " " 02 = ...5"&4
3 3 8
"5
'
, 5"
3
2
5 & =
& 3 5 5
"
"
"
"5
" 02 = 0... 4
"
& ' > ,8?
5 5 > 2 &&
5 5 5 " ' 9
55
) 8' &&
5
2 " 4
3 "
"
8
!
'&* ") 33 ) 5
&&
5 2 '4
'
'
5 55 9 8 " ; 3
2 :
""
' 8
9 & 2
2 "
58 <
4 2
% ) ; 0
8 * "
3 @
5
& "
5
" 0
" '
8 64 .& ?' >8& ;
4&
$#&
!"#!#$!%"
!%#
& 2 3
8
4 = 0...
2&8 & 8= 0...4
"5
8
2&
@
5
&
5 "
#
8 64 3 2
& 5 " A
5"& '2= 0...1
58
!( 5 &:
-836'31 23!:3
"3 !
23 B??3 "3 3 &3 C ' :
& 5 8 '= 0...
& " "4
# 1
)53
$$. & 5 &
5
& "4
5# 8&
..D 5
32 0 4
3
2 !
') 3
8&
0. *
"5 && 9 5 5&'>,8?
5 >
8 55 8 9
2 55 " 8 5
% ) 3&
5
&5
2
( & ' 5
!%'"!% ( !" !%#
& #) #$#$* " !%#
& !!4&A $
%
8 64 5 ?' >8& ;
+ , -'& .
&8& 8 9 .
"
5 3 "& 8 &
"
& 8
& 5 @ 5
& 8 :
"'4 2 "
A
8 >8& )"
; 8 4
5
$ #
8 1 !* " '2 364 .3= 0.
4
""&58& = 0...5"& 24
8 ,58
8 5
&&2 2& ""
' 8 >8& ;
+ , -'& .2&8 @ 5
&&
8
8 , 5
2 && 0
' 2 : 4&
& 5
5"& "5 &&2
&&2 5
24 * > > 2
1
)53
$$ 8
9 & 5& 52 &
8 >8& ;4 $# '4 2&8 &&2 2
A 5
= 0.
;5 "
&&' !&
#0) &1
!&
$
' 45 8 & 5
&
"
4 & ' ' "' 5 4&8& & * 5 &'"5
3
34' ""&5
5
8 >8& ;
, -'& . 2 &&
5& 5
" * "
# '' 8 5
" '= 0...4
" 4'>,8?
5 5 >4 2
%
8 * & 4" "5 /0 D. 5 5
5 :'8
"4 2 4 '
= 0...4
. <& <)&&. * 4 2 2
: * 2 = 0...4
8',
. "
8 >8& "
"
8 6*58 8 "
*
&&2' "5
'
8 :
5 = 0...
25 4 & 8
.
<& <)&&.&*
8 ' : 5 ' = 0... 4
25 8
"5
8
A " 8 8'
5
5 "
8 >8& "
6* 8 5"& 2 *= 0...4
254 & 8
8 A ,& = 0.4
6 &4
)&& 2&&:
"25
5
4&
%
" 8& . 5& 8 &&2 E * & 4" ?'
+ , -'& .
& 4 5' 54 "
5
"5
/0 D#%."3 & 8& 5 5
5
2 ' 2& 8
8?
5 55 5 ;
3 &8 5
&& = 0...
5"&4
)"&3 & ;5 "
5
5
8 5&8 5& 5 *
5 5 8& 8 " 5
8&5 8& 5 5
= 0...5"&4
&& & "&
5& '55& 5: = 0...
* 2&:
5:
&& 55 '&' 4 5&
4&&
8&' 4 5& "5" '&
'
8 )5& 3 & 3 & && 5 2 8 &
"&& ' "8&5 &
55' 8
58 :
" &
"&& & &
5 #$. 3 5 +)54
'
&& :
&
,58 3 %8'
5 "
4
.)1 2&8
& = 0... 5"& 4
)"&3 & 8 55 && 5 * 5& +) 2 '4
5 5 & ; 8& 8&
"& "5 & :
"054
' 5& 5
"5 = 0...
5"&4
5
"'& ' 5& 5
"5 = 0.5"&4
F & 3
.)1
58 ;"
4 2 2&8
5& 5"&5 2 & & +) ? 5 '4 5 5 2 3
55
"
E ) "
8 >8& )"
; 3 "" &&4
325 = 0.5"&
&&8 &.8 5 & 3 8 2 2
& 3
2
& 2
& 5 5&4
A . & 8
5 && 4
'
1
)53
$$ "8 '
54
A 5
= 0.
3 ;5 "" 54 & 8
&8
8
9 & 3
5& 8 >8& ;4 A 325 "5
/0 D.""
2 :
8
$ "5
= 0... 5"& 4 &
153 ' 8 "
8& 4&4 8
50
*
32
& 8& "
= ...5"&4
"5
" 8
153
)"&3 4 55'& E . !%'"!% ( !" !%#
& #) #$#$ * " !%#
& ( & '
$#
5 325 "5 /0 * 55'& &&2 &&2'
/ * !
' ) 2& "
"
.11 " 5& " #
?' A )" 2&8 9 8 8 8 &
& ' & 3
4
& ' 5& * 52& 8 8 !
') & 2
& ' & 3 !
' ) 2&:
4 5 & 4'8
5"& 8
* & 9 8&& 9 &
& " & 4'8
5"& 8
4& 5 ' &
5"& "
3 !
') 2&3 &3:
55 " & " " 4'8
8
<
5 &
5 "&5 8
3
"5
4.5
& " 8
<&
5 "&5 8
8
3
" 8& 4 ' " 3
2 &8
2&& 2 !
') <1@,*
5 8 8
" & '
'& 8
45 '
8 & 4 * 55 !
' ) 2& 4
; 54& & 5 2 5 5"&5 2
" & 5
!
')
5 2 5"& 8
3 2&8 4 5
" !
')
2 55 "'
" 5&4 53
"5
" 5&4 5 ; &&
# # . !%'"!% ( !" + , -'& .3 2
& ' & ; &
" 5
& ' & - 2 5
2
8 5 8 '
& 8
'
5 5& . "
5
3 "5
4
325 2 5" > ,8?
5 5
> 2 &
8 55
* 4
2 &&
8
9 & 4' ,8?
5 5 ""&5 8
5"
* & '
55 5 " 9
8 2
4 2 % )"
& % 5& & 2 5 5 55
:'8
"4 2 4 ' = 0...
. <& <)&&.* 4
2
: -""
2 = 0...4
8'
,
* ""
8 0"
?' >8&
;
+ , -'& . . & % = 0...4
254 & 8
. <& <)&&.&*
8 ' "
& 8 5 ' >8& ;
+ , -'& .
4
25 2 & 8
2 32 &
" * "( " & 2
"& 5 4 ' 5 5 &
4'8
5"& 8
* ' 4
'4 &8 "
5
" & 8
* " 9 8 8 8 & 8 "5
4 2 & "
8 & 0 ' & 3 ' 2&:
4 5 & 4'
5"& 8
-""
3 &
9 8&& 9 & & " & 4'
5"& 8
& 5 ' &
& 8
5"& " 3 ' & :
55 " & " " 4'8
8
<
5 & 5 "&5
3 "5
.5
& "
<& 5 "&5 8
8
3
" 8& ' " 3
2 &8
2&&
2 !
') * 52 8 "
& '
'& &
8 45 '
8 & . 5
3 5
'
2 55 "' 4
" 5&
53 "5
" 5&4 52
; " ## *
>8& ;2 2
55& 5: = 0...5"&4
5 8
5&8 & A >8&
)"
; 8
4 2 :
8 "5
= 0...5"&4 & 8
3' 8 "
8& 4&4 8
50
)55'& 3"
2 ' = ...5"&4
"5
" 8
A +4 2 &
>8& ; 2 = 0...5"&4
5 8
5&8 & A 2 * 5 = 0...
5"&4
2
&&
" *
4 2 '4 5
&'"&&
" 5'54
"5 ' "& 54
4 ' .2 8 5 ' "
& "
5 32558
5"
3 &&
3 5 5&
8& . & 8
8
4 ?' 4 5
!&
8
5&4 & "" 4 2 8?
54 5' " 5' 9& 2 8 5'5 &' "&& ) 5 5 52
&
5 8&
5: = 0...5"&4 ; 8
5 . "
5
3
"
"5
" 02 = 0...4
" *
'>,8?
5 5 > 2 &&
55 5 " ' 9
55
) 8'&&
5
2 " 4
3
"
!
'&* ") 33 *
5&8
4 2 %
8
>8& ;4 = .4 2&8 2& 5 A ) % 3 :'8
"4 2 4 ' = 0...
. <& <)&&.* 4 2 2
: 8 '= ...4
8',
&&2 3 ""
"
' >8& ;2&8 = :
"' 8?
5 3 % 2
8 >8& ;
+ , -'& .8 8 "
. "
5
3 % 4
5&& '
' 5 &8 '4
25 "5
8 5& 8 8
*
"
5
58 8 8 "5
4
2 "5
8 "
% 4
5&& '
& 8 "
A 8 >8& ; * % 58
8 && '&5
8 >8& ;
* ""
&' 8 5&& ''
& ""
8?
53252
?' 88 "
' &
:
.4 2 84 3 9 "' 5 % )55'& 3 "
"
8 ' 4 8
B 3 $ , .
"? :'<
"8&