High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3254/2014allowed

Amarjit Singh v. Chairman Punjab Mandi Board & Anrs

2015-02-23Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan13 pages

CWP No.3254 of 2014

23.02.2015 Amarjit Singh Petitioner

Versus

Punjab Mandi Board and ors.

...Respondents

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARINDER SINGH SIDHU

! "#$% &'

!(&)#$% & ** HARINDER SINGH SIDHU, J.

&' +'),$ $-(' % *(+*

)) .& / ++)" +'("

$$01 0123

*56#.& 7,# ,'

') +( 21#89#8:;<*) ".& =0>' &7

$" &+ ( " )) / ++ ?($& &' .'' $( / ++)" .'

+$ $-(' % * (+* )) &, 598 ./ $'(

7, / ++?($& $-(' % $. /$ & + 55@ 555 ( " & $'( ' $

?($& #&.))"$&%++$+

"() %") A( , . $ 0; 15 011 & B") ( ( 4+ $ & ( / ++# ?($& + 551 0111 $ (7+$ 0110

++ $$&'

$ "( & %

# 599 7 $ " & $) A( )

( & & ++ $ & B") ( (# & "&. ($" &' $%&

$) A( ) ' " ))" +* $( $ +7CC)+ '(7)( $ + & .). & "*&$ ( () 9 & ( D7 - "

()( ) / " - % 3( &+ $ '')6 ()# 599# 3

& E599 ()F6#$') , .++ $7,., ++ '

$ "7,&- ,# $ $( & % ()0599 () & & + & $ 7 "& +' (& , '&&"&& "$ ) &- ,# / ++#'' $-& - - ?+7#3- $6 A( , #.&(7+$& A( ,

$$ ; 011@# .& # . )($$ & & ))" " & ' $ '

%$ .

++ $$& +( 21#89#8:;<*) ".& =0>' &()$7 $ +&' & #

, $$ 9 0 0118 3

*06 . ($ )) "(' &' $' +( @:#00#1;0<*

3 ')+( 21#89#8:;<*G 02#@2#:0@<*7 " =0>' 4, 6 &( / ++ )" &' )$ H 219011;&)) " "

&% ()@36&599 () .&&'

%$&

, , +( .()$ 7 + ' ), ) &)) "$& < $$9 0 0118#%$.&&#&&$ 7 $ $ $' & +( @:#00#1;0<* & .

+ )$7, & & $ .

' #.$&&+'("

$ ,. "% &' ( - 05&( D7"

()( ) $( /#58 3 & I&58II6 .% # . $$&7 ( "& &'

$( (

05&58&$ 7 )).$ & ( )

& * $ $ 7 & ( & &, .()$ %$ '' ( ,& "&' $)).& $( '

7$( - 05&58 $ & # , ,7+$#'/ " .()$ 7 '$ , " & ' %. & + #&' .$'$ .&$ &

&&' .()$'' 7 &(& , $)& '),& $$9 0 0118 $& #

)). "'

$( & ,# ,#7'$ . )7 %$& ,$% .'$#.))7'

& &' ,&)) "&+ $ .&). ( ( &$ & ( #&$$ ) $$ $) $$0 2 011

0 '

$ "" &' (

- 05&#58 $''/ " "% "

' ) & " & ' . $ $ & & $ "7 )C$7,5 2 011 $&+ 7 $ &$ 7,00 2 011 $ "),#& & +

0($ ( 0536&58 #)) "(' &' '' ' )& "

8 : 011 & & + # /++#)" & "

&' $4+ "& $#'$ $$ 5 ; 011 3

*;6 )($ " & ) )

90#809*:1 + / $ 9#8@@*1: # ) +( " #8:#092*19&$7 ($ & #(+ #8:#092*19 ) ".& = 0> ' +( "

2#0@#091*:5 3) +( " :#95#@82*@;6 .

7) +&' ( 05&58

% " & & + # / ++# )".'$7, 0 ',&+. , %$ $$ 0; 9 010 3

*96

())$ &

'$7, 0 & #&- ,

($ ++ & ++7

@ +'

" & & ) " # $ $$ ) $+ 3 J6) $& $$& & ++ $$01 0123

*56 )($$ & & ' )7) , '

') +( 21#89#8:;<* ) ".& =0> ' # +( "

02#@2#:0@<* ( " ) ) / ++ ?($& &- ,# $ $ ',& &- ,# / ++)" +/ " , + &' $$'&+ &( / ++?($& " &#+ &),$$( +& ) ,&' . $ +&+ & ( ,# 01: & $ 3

*5 $*16& &%7 &)) "$ &'

& '

+ , )

$ ( ) & ' &&'

$( '

7$( - 05 &#58& 7 )).$ &'

$( "% "&+'), '' ( ,7,.,.

(.&,&&()$ 7 $+/"$&)# .&&& & $&7 ($$ A( & ") + $( &' + & $( $$& $(7& "."% 7,& & + & / ++ )" 7 (7+ " &

*;6 .% #&$ $&

7$ & .

())$ 7, & * $ %$

*9 & # & ++7 ++ . ($4+ & $$ + ,+( . ',7)7,&' &' . $.& & '

$ " & ++# .&& (7+$ 3

*56 ++ $ " , 21#89#8:;<* ) ".& =0>' #+( " 02#@2#:0@<*

( " )) / ++?($& & .

&.( $( 05 &58&7 "% &' 7,& $.&, ,$ + $7,& ++&()$

7+$ &(#& %) &'

% -

05&58 $)&$ & ( H 219011; & ,# & ?

$ ( ) &

&+'&C$& & A( , -& - - ?+7 &$)$ A( , $$ ; 011@&$) ), 7)&$&&' &$($ )) / ++#?($& & & + # / ++)"&$

(& , * A( &) $, A( $ 7,-& - - ?+7 $&& & + # / ++ )"

(), $($ & A( , $ .

"), )($$&&' .)7) ), ,

+( :#95#@82 @; 3'

') $ )($$6 &

;

& / ++ )" +7$, " &

++ $ . . $$ & - ,# / ++ ?($& $ & ) $& ) $ &

++ . ("& & &+ ++ $$ & & ' )7)',&+( $ & A( , (7+$7,-& - - ?+7 & #& & / ++)".

())$ 4 &'.

( 223:6&58 (&+')4,& $ ( +') ' , &$ +/ "

# & - ,# $ $ %$ $$ ; 2 012'' $& ++7 ++4+ & $$ + &+( &&' .)7)', & ++ 4+ "& $ $&++ & - ,# / ++ ?($& # - , / ++#)" $) $& ) ++ $$& & ' )7) , '

') +(

21#89#8:;<* ) ".& =0> ' # +( "

02#@2#:0@<* ( " ) ) / ++ ?($& &)7 +$ 8@ 01:)$7,&' ))" "%) & $$ 5 ; 0115 '$ H 219011; $&& +'' .$+$& ( .$& '' ( ,& "+ $$7,- 05&58 &$7 "%

&% & $ )

$ ( ) & ' $ ' ($& $')$ &) & % , ( $& + - 05&58#.()$7 , '

$(& + *

#$%

()

#$% &

#$% *

#+%

( )

, ' - 0536&58.& &)# . +'') & + , '

' , & ++# $(&)#. +'') '

%$ & & $7&$ A( &

") +'),& ++#& 7 "

"% '' ( , 7, .

&. (# (& +'),+,7( & "$.&&%)(&'

' ,

+( )7,& $ - 05306$).&)#. +'') + , '

' ,& $ & $

1 &-%

+ $&.( 7($ 7,&-%

+ $&+'),+,7( & "$ .& & %)( '

' , & +( ) 7, & - %

+ &(#' & #& 7# $&.( 7($7,& $ &- %

+ $ "&' ( ") +'), & ++ & $ H&& $ "

( "&.( ( & " "&+'),

& ) & ++ $ "( & &+ - 05 ( ( &$ & ( H 219 011;#&$$ ) .

)

$$0 2 011 0 '

$ "" & ' ( - 05 & 58 $ ' '/ " "% "' )& "&' & & + # /++#)" & "&' $ 4+ "& $#'$ $$5 ; 0113

*;6 )($ "& )) 90#809 :1+ / $ 9#8@@*1: #)+( " #8:#092*19&$ 7 ($ & # #8:#092*19) ".& = 0> ' +( " 2#0@#091*:5 3) +( "

:#95#@82*@;6. 7) +&' (

05&58 ''

% "& & + #

/ ++#)".'$7, 0 ', &+. ,

%$ $$0; 9 0103

*96

())$& '$7, 0 & #& - , 0 ($ ++ & ++7 +'

"& & ) " ##$$ ) $+ 3 J6) $& $$& & ++ $$ 01 012 3

*56

++ $$&&' )7) ,'

') +( 21#89#8:;<*) ".& =0>' #+( "

02#@2#:0@<* ( " ) ) / ++ ?($& $ & %$ $$ 09 01:

*16# & / ++# )" . $ $

&+( +&' $ A( ), , ))+ + & + &), ) , & ' . $ $'($&'( ( & ++ $ & & ++7 ++

*5 .

&.(.($&' )) "

(' &+4') .&,&&()$ 7 $+/ "$ & ) $ + $ 7, & ++ ) $'($&&' . $.& & $7,& & ++7 ++7 )C " & &7& 7,& $&).($

0 / ++?($& &$ A( &

") + $( &' # ' &+ $ - 0536# & ' . $ 7 "%

'' ( ,7,.

&.(.&,&&()$

7 $+/"$&) $7( & "$.&& +( ) &$+$),& 7 $ &(#&

*+') .& & + - 0536 $ "),&

*1#$ " , +& ' &% " 7 '$ %) & + $ - 0536&58))") $)7)7A(&$ &' )& ""

$&' 7,& & + # / ++# )" .()$ ( +') .&& + - 0536& <

& / ++ . '$ 7, & $# & .

())$7,& $ & #& ++7 ++. ($7,& $#.&&$+$), $$ &' $.& && ++7 ++ .&& +$ & 7 &

, & 8@01:.()$)# +, ' # )($&( %( & . .& & $$0 ; 011#.&&.'$7, & & + / ++ & & ( +' $ " )($$&& 4 $ $ H

2 219011;. $($ $ '' ( ,& ". "% &' .&&.&+ $- 05& 58 &

()+ & &+ / ++. $ & ( A( ),$$ ' & &

()+ #&&

()+ $.&& &(7A( $$01 012&& ++7 ++ $& ,$ $'( ( & %$ $$09 01:()$7$7 +') .&&

+ - 0536&58

() ),#&.

' )).$&4 & & $$09 01:3

*16A(&$ .% # .()$7' & '

$( & ' &

+ - 05&587, ( ".

&.( &' .&,&7 $ +/"$&) ' & && ++7

++$$01 0123

*56 (HARINDER SINGH SIDHU) JUDGE February 23, 2015 ()