High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3263/2014disposed of

Sadhu Singh Etc. v. State Of Punjab Thru Financial Commissioner Etc.

2015-11-17Mr. Justice S.C. Datta7 pages

!"!#$ %

& '

()*'!#+) '

()*'!#+) !#, !#, !#, !#, -,"*" -,"*" -,"*" -,"*" '

*#.

/ #( ),"

*#.

/ #( ),"

*#.

/ #( ),"

*#.

/ #( ),"

"0#(# "0#(# "0#(# "0#(# 1$ 1$ 1$ 1$ 231'1' 231'1' 231'1' 231'1'

4 ) ),0, ," )5 50 0,"6 7/ 558(

" ) .*(+6# 4 /, ,,( )0, ,",# 4 ) ), ).*(+6# ")*5(/,0, (!# )!+"

,"# $ 1,' +, :(;

!#, 1,'') #(*6 ., :((5:*#.

/ <<< 6.

'!#+):=, 6.

'!#+):=, )!#"

8,!

!#) "/# !5( ,>* ")!#+

) ,(, (

(

=##?*, @&4: 8),/7 5+ # ! ",;(/7 "/#,.

( ,!

" " ,

!#,.!#( #(!

#,67#

A&A8 ", ,*!

(!#'!B)+!6#

='!B)4 #(8 "

('07C &C)0 !#,

B 0 !# #( )!# , =)!#" ++,""!# 4 *,!#+ )8 ,)"*

,(*#') !#.*,7!# ),!+) ,6 !# 5*(!#+ , ,6 #(,!+) 5/8!",!+) ,68 "0,

*0# #("*,+!

557 /#8 "0* !#"!( ),!+) ,68!

*," ,8" !" ;,,(

!#, 5",6 !#(!# *"

(7 )!#",67 #(8 ", *,#( )#(!

#,67 !# 6/,: ) 0 !#, 8 " (6!

( !# ,67 "0!

5:, ! !

53!6/# ,:*# #( ),

,8 ""# 1,,* #!

6!#

!#: )(!"

/!5!

7 !#, " *#( / & D " 0, (!"

/!5!

7 ,

(

=##?*, @ 4 !""*( /7 ) ,67 1(!

* ),!

!" ) 0 !#, "*0, ##*

( ,6 ) ,67 ",;! !# ) 7 , & #( 0,;!"!# 8 " 6 (!# *#.

/ + 5 ,0, !" =!"0"

54 *5": = , "), 2 ) *5"4 , 0,6 ## 57 (!"

/5( "5(!,":

8!(8" , 0 ,# " , )!5(,# "5(!," B!55( !# )!#"

++,""!# : B!"

#++,""!# & #(#(@ # 5!

5 #(*0

,(!# ,7 ,"

#( )0 !#,!""

( /8#, B 5"

#(!#-!55 +():)"!5 / :!"

6,!

,# ;!8 )!":)!"# 5( CB 5" 5 #( "0, )05! 7

#(*5= 4 *5" , )0*,0" 5 #(: !#, "*/6!

( #

!#(

( A

=##?*,@4 #( 5+ 5# ! (

(

=##?*,@4) 5 !6 "/#,.

(# )+,*#(

5 (

B!#+

!#8 " %

/* )"

68 "#

!5(8!

)!#"

!0*5

(0,!(# : )!"8,!

!# #0*,"* # )# ! 6 !#:,057) "/#

!5(#/) ,"0#(# " # ),057:!

!#(

#570,6 ## 57(!"

/5("5(!,"(*,!#+#(@ )!# ++,""!# ,# 5(

,(!# ,7 ,"

;

* +,! *5 *, 55 #(*#(,*5 *5"#

)!",+ ,(: )78,,>*!,(

!# )!"

0*,0"#,/ ,

!# !5(/7 !#,!"(5 7(# !""

(

!,"

57:)!"#

0,6 ## 57(!"

/5(0,"# #(" #(57:)) "# !5(

!#8!

)!#"

!0*5

(0,!(*#(, *5" !"

*, ), 6# !#(

) ) /!5!

!# 0 ) !""*( ,"" (

(

=##?*,@ 4 6 /6# !#(),

),!"#, !#

8 "!""*( !# #7 #8"0 0, #( 8 " 6 ( ;

!5 /5 ) ;

,!*"

+# !"!# 5*(!#+ )?@",;! 6# ) ;) ,(5 !" !#, # #((

!#,!";!, 5570,6 ## 57(!"

/5(0,"#/ *"

(!"

/!5!

7 ) " /# """"( " & D " 0, ##?*, @ ),!"#(!"0* ,+ ,(!#+

,( !#.*,!"

) !6 #( )!# , =)!#"

++,""!# 4)

!#) "/#,.

(#57#

5!6"7+,*#("3 !#,!#"*00,

)!" # !#":) ",5!(*0# !;!"!## ).*(+6#

)!"*, !#CA

%: 5('6 "8 E *, '6 "8 E *, '6 "8 E *, '6 "8 E *, = ,!(84-")'

*#.

/ #( ),": = ,!(84-")'

*#.

/ #( ),": = ,!(84-")'

*#.

/ #( ),": = ,!(84-")'

*#.

/ #( ),":( !((#

C=##?*,@ 4 #( '!#+5# ).*(+6# )!"

*, !#C%

5(?'07E*58 '!#+) ?'07E*58 '!#+) ?'07E*58 '!#+) ?'07E*58 '!#+) -" )'

*#.

/ #( ),": -" )'

*#.

/ #( ),": -" )'

*#.

/ #( ),": -" )'

*#.

/ #( ),": ( !((#

=##?*, @%4: 8),/7 ) (!"

/5( 0,"#" 8, )5( 5( )5 #( !" *, ), # #((

,!"">* ,57 ;,(/7 )".*(+6# " # ) ), ) #(: 5 ,#( '

*#"5 ;)6# 57 # #((

0 !#, !" # # 5( ,

5 #(/ *")!"# 0,6 ## 57(!"

/5( 0,"# #(;#

!#) "/# !5(

, #"!(, /5 (5 7 ) ;+!;# #?!*" )*+)

*5 #"!(,

!# # !#" )5 !" #(0,*"(

), ,( (6!

(57: )(!"

/!5!

7 !#,!"& D 0,,

##?*,@ !""*(/7 ),671(!

5 ,(

#( )!#.*,7) "/# *"((*,!#+ )#()!# ,) !#, 5" ,6 !#( !# )!#" ,67 *"

(7 #( ) "*

,( , *, )!#.*,!" #/ ,6( " ,"*5

5 "* 7 8 ) >*"

!# ,!"" 8) ),

;,#6# !" (* 7 /*#( #"!(, ) 5 !6 !#,#6,!

,# 9 '

, " ) !""* 5!6!

!# , !5!#+

!#*#(,*5 *5"!" # ,#(: 6 ) " /# #"!(,( /7 )!"*, !# '!#+5# ) *(+6# ""( !# ? '07 E*58 '!#+) ="*0, ? '07 E*58 '!#+) ="*0, ? '07 E*58 '!#+) ="*0, ? '07 E*58 '!#+) ="*0, 4 ) ,5;

)!".*(+6# , (" "*#(,$ FA #!(# 5>*"

!# 6 /( !((/7

!;!"!## ) )!"*, :/7;!, * ,(,(

C=##?*,@4!#CA

5( "2'6 "8 E *,-")'

*#.

#( ),"G ;!#+ #"!(,( ) ,"0 !;

#(" !" "!# )0,"# ":!

8 ,*5( "*#(,$@ F),*+) ) !#"

8,!

0 !#: !#, 5 !6" 5 #(!# ,6"

*5 )*#.

/ + 5,0, !"

=!"0"

54 *5": )!" 5 !6 !#, ) " /# ;)6# 57 00"( /7

) 5 ,#( *#"5 , ) ,"0#(# " /7

"", !#+

"#;,6;(

!# *#(, ) "

,7 *5"

( ),@!#@ /;: #, #7 05! 7H !#"

,* !#"!""*(/7 )'

;,#6#

,6 !6 !6 !#,"

!#,/

,((#00, *#!

0,0,

!#!# ,6" #(

*5 )*#.

/ + ,0, !" =!"0"

54: #(

,"0#(# " / (!, (

B !# ( !"!# ),#!# ,6" )6 #(

!(*5" ,#( *#"5 , ) ,"0#(#

#(8)#"* ) #

!#!"

( /7 ) 0 !#,: ( !"!# ),# ") 55 /

B# /7 ) ,"0#(# " !#

,( # 8!

)5 8 ;!#+ #"!(,( )"*/6!""!#"6 /7 )5 ),!;

50 !":8 #"!(,!

.*"

#( 00,0,!

(!"0"

) !#"

8,!

0 !#: 8!

) 5!/, 7 !#, #

!#!# ,6"

)6 #(

*5 )*#.

/ + 5,0, !"=!"0"

54*5": :8!

)!# # 6# ) ,6 ( 7 # ": "* )

!#!"6 (/7 !#,8!

)!#

!6 "

!0*5

( ),@!#@ /; 5#+ 8!

)

!( 07 )!#"

,(,: )"

") 55/ #"!(,(/7 ) 60 ),!

/7 0 ""!#+ 855@, "#( "0 B!#+ ,(,:

)!# 8 6# )" # ": ( !"!#

;*, /5 ) 0 !#, !"

B#: !#,") 55/

(5 #(8!

)!# *, ), 0,!( 86# )" !"0"( ,(!#+57 ,(, ( ! # 0 76# *"* ,+"G ,6 ) 0,*"

5 .*(+6# " !;!"!# # )

(

C #( ) 5 ,#( '!#+5 # ) (

!" 5 ,

"!#) #(!"">* ,57 ;,(

/7 )".*(+6# " #((",;" /( !((!# )"

,6" # ) 5!+)

!( , "#": #( "!#

,!" ;,(/7

!(.*(+6# ": )!#"

8,!

!#!"(!"0"( 8!

)5!/, 7 !#,

00,0,!

!#!# ,6" *5 *5"

)!# 0,!( 86# )" ,6, !0 , !( 07

)!",(,# ":"* )

!#!"6 (/7 !#,

5#+ 8!

) , !( 07 )!" ,(,: ) "

6 ") 55 / #"!(,(/7 ) 60 ),!

78!

)* (),!#+

)#!

5/.

!# ##@ !5!#+

!#8!

)!# !6

#(8!550 "" 855@, "#( #("0 B!#+,(,8!

)!# 8 6# )" ,6 )(

!5!#+

!## ":

),!

!" 6 # 5*"!#

!#,(",;" /

(5 #(: )"

6") 55/(#8!

)!# 0,!( 8 6# )" ),

, )0,"# 8,!

!#!"(!"0"( !#

,6" ;6/, % ;6/, % ;6/, % ;6/, %

& :

& =1'4 =1'4 =1'4 =1'4 # )