M/S Bahri Hospital v. The Appellate Authority Under The Payment Of Gratuity Act And Others
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH CWP-15950-2023 (O&M) Date of decision : 23.08.2023 M/S BAHRI HOSPITAL
...Petitioner
Versus
APPELLATE AUTHORITY UNDER THE PAYMENT OF GRATUITY ACT, 1972-CUM-ADDITIONAL LABOUR COMMISSIONER, PUNJAB SAS NAGAR, MOHALI AND OTHERS
...Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSH BUNGER Present :
Mr. Vivek Salathia, Advocate for the petitioner.
HARSH BUNGER, J. (ORAL)
!
!
"#$%& ' ($)
*
+
,
(-- ")' . * . .
/ .
0)"
1 0)
2'3 .
4 5
5
6 .
.
$,
-(-"' . . 0)
3 . . % .
4
* . 142 0)
.
7
000
8
---09
9- ---$ - .:-(
8
---09
9 ;
<=($
8
>?!.6 % .
. 4 .
+ .+
* .
.
-(-- &
8
@
+
4
@
!
"
# $ %& '
() *+ ( , ) -. )
$ ) $ -
/
!
0 0 ')
/
!
1
/ !
"
2
! !!
3 #
/ "
/
# $
%& ' ( *+ (
, ) -. ) $ )
$ -
/ 4
!
!!
#
0 '
/ 5
= * $8 8
* . 0)
(-- ")'
4 . @ 6 3
#
) 7
3
78
&
/
78
!
1 0 7 7 ) +
.
3
# /
#
/ #
#
#
.
)
!
:
)!
) 54+
!;
<
#
=
- / #
7
- /
3 )
3
, <
)!
) 54+
> ?
!
@
-3
; *) ! !!)
-
A' 7 $3B
/
= - /)
1C!)
2#
D) -
;
(-- " )'
. .
. 5
)")'
0)
3
8 . . 0)
8 -(- "'
. @ 5
< 3
.
# <
.# ) /) )
#
/ 7
3
=
&
;"! !!
7
/) - ) #
)
7
#
/
CC! !
#&
# <
.# ) /)
# <
.# ) / 7 #
3 <
.#
&
,
/ &
,
/ &
)
3
/
#&
) &
! C! !
7
#
,73)
/
! C! !
) 4 ! !
)
! !
) 1! !
51! !
3
5 +
7
51! !
) #
)
7
; ! !
7
&
3
# A5B
= -
A= &#B )
1C")
=
A!B
A"B
A4B
A5B
<
3
7 )
/
<
7 )
=3
#
# 7
7
# 37
3
< 3
7
#3 <
37 )
<
/)
- &
/)
1C!
7 7
7
) # 7
3 #
/ . 3
#
3 #
# 7
7 .) < 3
#
/) -
/ )
# 7
.
.
# 7
. #
( +
* ) A
8
A
* . .
.
* .
.
+
* .
4 .
+ 3
8
. * .
,. A
4
8
-.
8
, .8
.
+
* . . 4
000
--<-
8 8 +
8
4
8 A
4 . 5
"*'"'
+ >
0=)
+ 3
.
.
+
.
8 .
.
< +8
0 %
! . & 2 5 *
!!"
" "#$"%& !!'# " !!"
" "#$"%( #)* **+ ,- . & B 5 *
8
.
/ .
0)
C@ " AB .
3 /
#
3 / #
-3 A#B -
#
3
/ " *"0 / " "% "1"0 ) "#"1 )& * *2
7
#
#
-3 0
/ 7
7 G
# # -3
#
# 7 3#
#
/
AB
<
37 3
3
0
= - /)
3
=
7
3
=#
) 0
= - /
-3
#
3 /)
#
#
3#
#
/ H )"!)" !
& "" "%"* ""34*+
,-. 5I
AB /
# #
3 0
/ 7
J # 0
4 / 7
3 /
3
7
3
# 3
/
AB .
3 /
3
3
. 3
3
/
# #
AB <
#*"7&"# &"2"
""* "3 + , 8- 8
* "69#0&:$ ##"+, -( +
7 7 K K 7 7
# <
.#
AB 0
!AB /
/
#
-3
0
"
/ 0
"
/ #
/
3
0
3
7
#
/ J
7
#
0#
A!B 0
3 #
# )
) 7
#
)
3
7
7
#
/
7
# . 0
3 0
/)
#
/ # )
)
#
J
/
# <
8
/ 7
J 3
)
#
# )
) J
#
#
)
/
0#
ACB 0
C)
3
/ . /)
7 &
/
#
A5B 0
7
# /7
#
3
/ .
K
3
&
/ #
A5B
0
4) =
7
&
-3
3
/
- +8
8 8
0)
8 8
* 8
0)
8
0)
4
* .
. .
8
. 4
* .
3 > ?!. 6 %
3
8 , .
* . 8 <-)- -=-<- <-<- -<-0- ;-0- +
;-0- 8
9;--$ 3
8 .
.
-(--
8
4 &
9 ";'
.
/ ."! '9 0) @
=
A5B <
3
7 )
/
<
7 )
=3
#
# 7
7
# 37
3
8
9
* . !
5
.
.
* .
+ 8
.
.
. * .
* .
,.
4 , .8 $ -.
8
3
.
4
* .
D * --<- " '
.
@ E .1 "0 . * 0 ' $+
0 / ) %=D () . L $
- #
78 * +
/
,
/ )
, 78 L 3
< 7
$ %& (
*0
=
D * "'
.
4 !
# $7
000
1/
2 . 5
)")'
0)
(-- . * .
8 4 ;
1/
2"<'
@ 5
. )
&
)
8
,73) & )
!
#
3
!
1) 7
8
4
8
<-0
4 8
000
<-0
-. 5
=
0)
8 !
8
.
8
8 .
.
* , .
4 8
8.
000
<-0
4
.
.
.
;
4 .8 !
A * . 5
"*'"'
+ >
0=)
8 0)
.3 +
. + !
.
.
.
* . 0)
!
.
.
.
( +8
8
.
.
.
. . * 9 .
. ) $ .
August 23, 2023 (HARSH BUNGER) gurpreet JUDGE Whether speaking/reasoned:
Yes/No Whether reportable:
Yes/No