High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/5758/2009dismissed

State Of Haryana v. Subh Ram And ORS.

2016-01-22Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi12 pages

!" !#"$%& '

&

& (()

* + , --.. / +01 - !2)

!3%4 2$"+ 2 5+ 246

!

" # $%$&

$%%'

('') *'*

$'(+

('*' $,,*

$,+$

('') $,+%

$,$)

('') $%+&

('')!

!

" # ,*+, ,*++ ,,+) ,,-%

,,%( +,'( +&&,

('')

$$%+ $*&*

('*' ,,&% $&)-

$)'-

('') +)- +)% $+%

&'( (**-

(**) ,+)* ),& +&%& $(), $,(&

('*'

.

,,)&

('**!

/

# 2 1

" # ,*+, ,*++

('') ),&

('*'!.

!

" # $%$) $%-&

('')!

3 4

4

" # $'(+

('*'!

4/

5 3

" # &'(

('*'!

3

" # ,,+)

('')!

" # $%--

('')!

73

" # ,,)&

('**!

4 3

3

!

" # ,,-%

,,%( ,,&% +,'( +&&,

('') $*&* .

,+)*

('*'!

!

" # $%$& $%-' $%-+ $%-$ $%-*

$%-) $%-, $%-(

('')!

5 5

7

/

!

" # $&)-

$)'-

('') +)- +)%

('*'!

!

" # $,+& $,+) $,+( $,,& $,$, $,$( $,$$ $,+,

$,$+ $,$* $,$' $,,,

$,+$ $,+%

$,$)

('')!

4

50 3

" # $+%

('*'!

" # $,+*

('')!

4

!

" # (**-

(**)

('*' +&%&

('*'!

!

" # $,,* $,,+ $,,- $,+$ $,+%

('')!

0

0

!

" # $(),

('*'!

0

!

" # $$%+ $,(&

('*'!

4 :

7

5

;<2 * :

3= 9>?#@

(

= 9>?#@

, : 3 4

= 9>?#@ AAAAA 2 5+ 2467$ 1

&,

4

1 ++

4 " # $%$&

$%%'

('') *'* $'(+

('*' $,,*

$,+$ $,+%

$,$)

$%+&

('') 0

,)

4 " # ,*+, ,*++ ,,+) ,,-%

,,%( +,'( +&&, ,,&% $&)-

$)'-

('') +)- +)% $+% &'( ),& (**-

(**) ,+)* +&%& $*&* $(), $,(& $$%+

('*'

.

,,)&

('**

8

4

1B4

4

04

3 / C 34

"

D4

1 0

1 B4

1 :

4

1

1

1

14

4

" # $%$&

('')

4

!

7 4

1 1

1

4

3 4 *- &'

1

4

04

/

3 4 *, *-

1

4

04

C 34

41 E

41 4

0 3

4D

1

1 ;+& 4

# 1 1 .

-

1B4 1 *&)+ F 1F

!

4

3

'- *( (''* 1B4 1 0

# (% .

(&

(- ', ('',

0 H 3 /

C 34

4

*('''''?;

1

G

43/

-'''''?;

1

5

51 1 *&

1 1

1

1 *+ 1 0 34

'* '$ ('') 3

4

3

--'?;

B4

3 0 1

,* '* (''( 4 1

1

4

-' -$

1

4

04

/

3 4 *- *%

1

4

04

"

D4

41 E

41 4

41

3 4

# 1 1

9 -

1

4

(+ *( (''( 1B4 1 0

# ,% .

,&

0

($ ', (''+ 3 E 1

3

1

0

# (% .

(&

(- ', ('',

*('''''?;

1

G

43/

-'''''?;

1

7

5

51 1 *&

1

B41

() 1

1 3

1 1 0 34

(& '& ('')

1 3

4

3

--'?;

B4

"

0

34

1 4

0

1 4

10

/ 41 3 1 4

/ 13

0 4

4 4

1

0 4 4

0

/ 0

14

1

1143 1

0

3

3

3

0

4 1

4

3

1

1

1

41

1 4

1

>E ( >E ,

>E +

14 1

(*

34

'* '$ ('')

43 4

41

11 1 0

F 43 4. /"( (7

:;+ *

43 4

1 4

1 4 0 3

1B4 1 0

0 1 ($

1

0

4

/ 4

F 43 4. F 4 !

6 4

0 1 1

0

>E ( >E , >E $ >E :,?$

>E :,?( C

E14

*( ** *))-

(( ** *))-

/ 4

1

0

&''''''?;

1 @

>E ( >E ,

>E 4

1 341

/ 4

>E (

-(%-$,?;

1

0

>E ,

>E +

$,$(%,?;

1

C

1

0 1

1

4 54

E

/

0

1

4

10

1 0 3 C 0

4

*

3

4 1 1

3 0 1

4

1B4

1

/

0

>E ,

>E ( / 4 3

+,*,%&(?;

1

3

1

4

4

1 C 1 1

4

>E :(?*

1

C 0

F 43 .2<7!(.0. -(4/1( $(=1(#.7

:9;+ 97

4

*$I

4 1

/ 4

3

1 1

1 C

1 4

4 4

4 0 4

4

331

4 4 1434 0 3

4 1

F 43 >60/+ ,7

:8;

+. *$I

4 1

/ 4

+,*,%&(?;

0 / 4

4 3

&-%-$$+?;

1 1

1/

*''

1

14

0

0

0

0

3 0

1 0

14

1 4

0

($I 14

4 54

($I 14 / 4 3

-$'%+*$?;

1

1

-$'&'''?;

1

10 3

-$'&'''?;

1

1 1

1

4

43

1 1 413

41

4

0

/ 4 1 3

51

11 1 C

1 4

1

41 0 1

1B4

4

4 C

10 1

C

F 43 2?.6?@( 0:<;7(> /+ #0@17

:;+ 98

43 4

0

1143 1

*(I

4 1

*?, 14

($I

0 / 4 C 1 1

3

F 43 ( /+ ,7

8:;+

3 (F 4 !

4

1

4

4

0

1 4

3 3

4

4

1 C

14

1

1

E 3

1

3

33

1

1

1143 1 /

1

F 43 #00

/+ (.07

:8;+ 88 1 0

4

3 C

4

4

0

C

1

1

14

1

1143 1 #

;5 1/

34

1 3

1 0 0 4 @ 4

0

/

4

3

F 43 %<?0. + / +-(. (. 4 A0((( !

(7 4 89 +-(. (.:(&=(5.

;

/10.<07*4 897 F 43

0 4

14

F 43

20 71

1+(</+

#0@10<4A0((( ..7#(.7

*:; : (=(.;*89 0

0

20 71

F 43

*(

*,

3

1+(<3 4 !

1 4

;

! !

"

"

# ! $ !

" %"" &

'

! # %"" &

" ( '

" )

!

"##$ %"& '''

$()* "##$

+",

* !

!

(

") !

!

!

"+!

,

")

!

"+ !

!

!

(

&"-./' "

&"0"1. " " )

,

"2 !

#

) 4 5 6 !

% - . & / '

!

"##0

+#, * )

#

"

!

!

" )

!

" # $ ! ,

!7.8

( "+

# $ ! !

( &"-971/'7.8" '

, # $ !

"2

3 F 43

2( +(</+ ,7

9:

;+ 7

14 1

14

/ 4

4

14

1 4

1 C 2(+(<3 4 ! +'I 14

41 F 43

*?+ 0

0

F 43

*'

3 2(+(<3 4 !

1

1

;

)

!

, ( !

:

:

;.8 !

-/;

(

&

"2 #

43

4

1B4 14

1

1143 1

0 4

3

0

0 1

31 10

3

4

4 1 4 34

3

3

E 1

0

10 3

-$'&'''?;

1

1 1

1 7

4

3 0 0

1

4

0

0

&,

3

0

2 5+ 246C (( '* ('*- $"&