High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25948/2016dismissed

Balbir Singh And ANR v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2022-08-31The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli20 pages

! " !

#$#%&#'() * !+,# %(-(.#/#(,)* +012%32(45+('+(,5#% 6#,2,2(#%$ 7#%$-$ 3,+,# +%8+(++(',5#%$ #$9('#(,$

%#$#(,): %3+('##935+%/+;'&.+,#; %,5#9#,2,2(#%$ %(<-%2,,+0;''0'&.+,##(#%+0;+%8+(+; %3+-%+15+4;$$2$,+(,'&.+,##(#%+0+%8+(+;+(' $=-$5+0'##9=+(.5+('+;'&.+,#; %,5#%#$9('#(,$ 5# 2($,+(, 9#,2,2( 5+$ 1##( 20#' .0+2/2(4 ,5+, ,5# +.>-2$2,2( 9%.##'2(4$.+%%2#'-,&2'#,5#(,2 2.+,2($2$$-#'-('#%3#.,2( ,5# ?+(' .>-2$2,2( .,;

'+,#'

+('

%#$9#.,2&#08@

00A#'18,5#+A+%''+,#'**

*;,5#%#18+.>-2%2(4,5#0+(' %+9-102. 9-%9$#; (+/#08 % ,5# '#&#09/#(, +(' -,202B+,2( 0+(' +$ #$2'#(,2+0; //#%.2+0;($,2,-,2(+0+%#+;%#.%#+,2(+0B(#+('9#($9+.#2(3#.,%

;

+(' ;-%-4%+/@>-+,5#0+(' ,5#9#,2,2(#%$./9%2$#'2(=5+$%+ * CC C*C; C;C/#+$-%2(4D=+(+0$$2,-+,#'A2,52(,5# #&#(-#$,+,# 7200+4# =+(5+2; #5$20 +(' !2$,%2., -%-4%+/@ 5+$ 0+9$#' 2( &2#A ,5# 9%&2$2($ 3#.,2( ,5# 245, , +2% /9#($+,2( +('

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

!" 9#(-0,2/+,#9+%+4%+95 A52.52$%#9%'-.#'5#%#2(1#0A): #$ % & '

( )() ' * & '

' &'

& +" & ',

- &'

& + ' *- * **

& & .'

, ' - & ' " ',

' '

( )(-)& '

& + '

& / & - + 0 * #1 '

() - *

-#1#1 0 & '2 ', '

() & '

& + 3

' * '

& && '

' & '

" & - 3 '

- *"'

- 3"'

" & '

- " - 3 0 .

4 4 & '

() & '

& + '

& '

' 0 '2' & 5

() ' - * '

6 & ,

-&'( *) & &' & '2 '

& '

& /

- '

''' * & '

& + ' - , '

+ & '2 '

& / - & &

+ & '

' - , 75 & '

( ' )

& '2 ','&5 * '

6 & ,&& "'

& + - 8 *8 & &' & '2 '

& '

/ 9 ' - '

+ ( )& '

& / "

'2 '

() 5 5 &'

' 0 - , '

- ,

+ ( ) * * & ''

*, &'&,'

" ' '

'2 ',

()& '

& + ! 0 '

()& '

& + - & '

() & '

( )(-) : 0 & 3, '

& / '

()-*,&2 ; <' * - 3,

!& '

& / "

, '

()& '

& +" ' - 3 '

() / 0 & '

() , & & ',

'- ' & '

3 '

&& -& '

& +' &'" ', & '2 , * '' 0 &- '& - ' - .'

()& '

& + , * ' & '

2 , & ''

', & '2 '

', , & &' & '

& +"" 5-'

* *

2 , & & 3,

', & &'

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

$9#%,5#.+$#9-, %,518,5#9#,2,2(#%$;,5#8+%#A(#%$ =5+$%+ * CC*C; C;C$5+%#,,5##H,#(, D=+(+0$$2,-+,#'A2,52(,5# #&#(-# $,+,# 7200+4# =+(5+2; #5$20 +(' !2$,%2., -%-4%+/ 5# $+2' 0+(' A+$ +.>-2%#' 18 ,5# &#%(/#(, +%8+(+ 18 2$$-2(4 (,2 2.+,2($ '+,#'

+('

-('#%3#.,2( ,5#.>-2$2,2(.,;

00A#' 18 +A+%' '+,#' **

* % ,5# 9-102. 9-%9$# (+/#08; '#&#09/#(, +(' -,202B+,2( 0+(' +$ #$2'#(,2+0; //#%.2+0; ($,2,-,2(+0 +%#+;%#.%#+,2(+0B(#+('9#($9+.#2(3#.,%

; +(' ;-%-4%+/,2$ ,5# .+$# ,5# 9#,2,2(#%$ ,5+, '#$92,# 5+&2(4 +((-(.#' ,5# +A+%' ( **

*; ,5# %#$9('#(,$ 5+&# +20#' , ,+<# ,5# 9$$#$$2( ,5# 0+(' 2( >-#$,2(,5-45,5#85+&#%#.#2&#',5#+/-(, ./9#($+,2( %,5#+.>-2%#' 0+(' 5#%# %#; ,5# +.>-2$2,2( 9%.##'2(4$ >-+ ,5# 0+(' 2( >-#$,2( $,+('$ 0+9$#'2(&2#A 3#.,2( ,5#., *

(+''2,2(,,5#+ %#$+2';,5#9#,2,2(#%$5+&#.(,#('#',5+,,5#0+(' ,5#,5#%0+('A(#%$+.>-2%#'&2'#+ %#$+2'+.>-2$2,2(9%.##'2(4$5+$1##( %#0#+$#' %/,5#+.>-2$2,2(; %A52.5%#02+(.#5+$1##(90+.#'(%'#%$'+,#' ; +(' ; +(' ,5-$ 5+&# 90#+'#' ,5+, ,5# %#$9('#(,3,+,#5+$'2$.%2/2(+,#'A2,5,5#9#,2,2(#%$;A5+0$'#$#%&#$2/20+% ,%#+,/#(, # %# +&#%,2(4 , ,5# .(,#(,2($ %+2$#' 18 ,5# %#$9('#(,$; 2, 2$ 2/9%,+(,,1#(,2.#'5#%#;,5+,,5-459%+8#%.0+-$# ,5#9#,2,2(A+$$,80#' 2(,5#/+((#%+$2(1#0A2#

# " $%&"

' ( ' %)*%*$$ + ,-&" .*$.*$% + ,- *$)*$% + ,-." $/*%*$$. + ,- 01 A#&#%;+,,5#,2/# 2$$-+(.# (,2.# /,2(( ;(08 .(,#(,2( A52.5 A+$ %+2$#' 18 ,5# 9#,2,2(#%$ A+$ ,5+, ,5# +.>-2$2,2( 5+$ 0+9$#'-('#%$#.,2( ., *+('+..%'2(408(,2.#A+$2$$-#'+(' ,5# $,+,-$ >- A+$ 4%+(,#' 5# %'#% '+,#' 2$ %#9%'-.#' 5#%#2( 1#0A): 23Claims benefit under Section 24(2) of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,

Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 on the ground of possession.

Notice of motion for 11.05.2017...'

D 5#+ %#$+2'.0#+%08%#&#+0$,5+,+,,5#,2/# ,5#2$$-+(.# (,2.# /,2(;,5#9#,2,2(#%5+'(08.0+2/#'0+9$2(4-('#%$#.,2( ., * +(' % +00 ,5#$# 8#+%$ ,5# /+,,#% A+$ <#9, 9#('2(4 +A+2,2(4 ,5# 2(,#%9%#,+,2( $#.,2( ., * (08 5-$; +, ,52$ $,+4# ,5# 9#,2,2(#%$.+((,+42,+,#,5#90#+ '2$.%2/2(+,2(&#(2 ,5#9#,2,2(#%$+%# +00A#',+42,+,#$-.590#+;(9+%2,8.+(1#.0+2/#'18,5#,5#/2(&2#A ,5# '2$.-$$2(/+'#5#%#2(+ ,#%

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

'+,#' **

*; A52.5 5+$ 1##( 5#0' +$ + &+02' /'# ,+<2(4 9$$#$$2((.#$-.59$$#$$2(2$,+<#(;,5#0+('&#$,$+1$0-,#082(,5#3,+,# +(' A5$#&#% %#,+2($ % %#/+2($ 2( ,5# 9$$#$$2( ,5# 0+('; 5# 2$ + ,%#$9+$$#% # -%,5#% $-1/2,$ ,5+, ,5# 1024+,2( ,5# 3,+,# , 9+8 ,5# ./9#($+,2( $,+('$ '-08 '2$.5+%4#' +$ ,5# #(,2%# ./9#($+,2( +/-(, A+$ ,#('#%#'+,,5#,2/# +((-(.#/#(, +A+%'+('A+$/+'#+&+20+10#,,5#

0+('A(#%$#$-1/2,$,5+,2(,5#.+$#+,5+('+'/2,,#'08,5#9#,2,2(#%$5+&# %#.#2&#',5#+/-(, ./9#($+,2(5#8+0$ 20#'%# #%#(.#-('#%$#.,2( .,

%#(5+(.#/#(,2(,5#+/-(, ./9#($+,2(5-$;2(&2#A ,5# 0+A 0+2' 'A( 18 ,5# (E10# 3-9%#/# -%, ('2+ 2( ,5# .+$# ('%#!#&#09/#(,-,5%2,83-9%+;((# ,5#.(,2(4#(.2#$9%#$.%21#'2( $#.,2( ., *+%# -0 200#'+('+..%'2(408;,5#2($,+(,9#,2,2( /#%2,$'2$/2$$+0

$%#4+%'$,5#90#+ '2$.%2/2(+,2(%+2$#'18,5#9#,2,2(#%$;%2,,+0 $-1/2,$,5+,,5#9#,2,2(#%$+%#(#2,5#%2'#(,2.+008$2,-+,#',$-.59#%$($A5$# 0+('5+$1##(%#0#+$#' %/,5#+.>-2$2,2(9%.##'2(4$(%,5#9#,2,2(#%$5+&# 90#+'#'#&#(+$2(40#A%'$5A2(4+$,5A,5#8+%#$2/20+%08$2,-+,#',,5# 9#%$($A5$#0+('5+$1##(%#0#+$#' %/,5#+.>-2$2,2(9%.##'2(4$#5+$ &#5#/#(,08.(,#('#',5+,,5#9#,2,2(#%$+%#9%#.0-'#' %/%+2$2(4,5#90#+ '2$.%2/2(+,2( 18 %#082(4 -9( ,5# %'#%$ '+,#' ; +(' 1#.+-$# $-.5 90#+ 2$ 1+%%#' 18 '#0+8 +(' 0+.5#$ -%,5#%; 5# 5+$ $,%#$$#' -9( ,5# +., ,5+, 1# %# %#082(4 -9( $-.5 %'#%$ 2, 2$ 2/9%,+(, , -('#%$,+(' 2( A5+, /+((#% +(' A5+, .(,#H, ,5#$# .+/# , 1# 9+$$#' +('

-%,5#%A5#,5#%9#,2,2(#%$+%#2'#(,2.+00890+.#',$-.50+('A(#%$A5$#0+(' A+$%#0#+$#'%(, +<2(4 -$ , ,5# %'#% '+,#' ; 5# 5+$ $-1/2,,#' ,5+, 2, A+$ 9+$$#' 1+$#' -9( ,5# %#.//#('+,2($ ,5# $-1:.//2,,## $#(, , ,5# &#%(/#(,;+$,52$0+('A+$(#+%%#$2'#(,2+0+%#+ &200+4#;A52.5A+$ -008 '#&#09#' 520# %# #%%2(4 , ,5# %#0#+$# %'#% '+,#' 5# 5+$ $-1/2,,#',5+,,5#$+/#A+$9+$$#'2(./902+(.# ,5#'2%#.,2($2$$-#'18

,52$.-%,&2'#%'#%'+,#' 2(

+(' DD

5#9#%-$+0 ,5#%'#% -%,5#%%#&#+0$,5+,,5#.($,%-.,2( ,5#0+('A(#%A+$%#0#+$#'+('%#$, ,5#&+.+(,0+('A+$+.>-2%#'%2,,+0 .(,#('$,5+,(9+%2,8.+(1#'%+A(A2,5,5#$-.5%'#% %#0#+$#+$2,A+$ 9+$$#'2( +&-% $-.50+('A(#%$A55+'+99%+.5#',52$-%,A+81+.< 2(,5#8#+%

;2##&#(1# %#+((-(.#/#(, +A+%'$%#4+%'$,5#%'#% '+,#' ;5#$-1/2,$,5+,2(,5+,.+$#+0$,5#+9902.+(,5+'+99%+.5#' ,5#+-,5%2,2#$A+81+.<2(,5#*+('.+$#A+$.($2'#%#'+$9#%+9902.+10# 902.8A520##H#%.2$2(49A#%-('#%$#.,2(

$+.($9#.,-$ + %#$+2' 5# $-1/2,$ ,5+, ,5# 9#,2,2(#%$E .0+2/ '2$.%2/2(+,2( 2$ /2$.(.#2&#'+(''#$#%&#$,1#%#I#.,#'

-%,5#%/%#; 5# $-1/2,$ ,5+, ,5# 0#4+0 9$2,2( 5+$ 1#./# /%# 0-.2' + ,#%,5#'2.,-/2(('%#!#&#09/#(,-,5%2,83-9%+5#+ %#$+2'%'#%$ A#%#9+$$#'A520##H#%.2$2(4,5#9A#%-('#%$#.,2(

1#.+-$# +,,5+,,2/#,5#%#A+$(,/-.5.0+%2,8+1-,,5#/'# ,+<2(49$$#$$2( ,5#+.>-2%#'0+('A#&#%;(A,5#($,2,-,2( #(.52(('%#!#&#09/#(, -,5%2,8$-9%+5+$5#0',5+,%#.%'2(4 %+9+, B(+/.5+2$&+02'/'# ,+<2(4 9$$#$$2( +(' +$ .($#>-#(.# ,5#%# 0+(' &#$,$ 2( ,5# 3,+,# (.# 9$$#$$2(2$,+<#(;2,2$,%2,#0+A,5+,9A#%-('#%$#.,2(

% A2,5'%+A+0 %/,5#+.>-2$2,2(9%.##'2(4$.+((,1##H#%.2$#'99082(4,5# + %#$+2'9%2(.290#(,5#.+$#+,5+(';5#.(,#('$,5+,$2(.#,5#9$$#$$2( ,5#0+('2(>-#$,2(A+$,+<#(18%#.%'2(4%+9+,( '+,#'**

*;0+(' 5+$&#$,#'2(,5#3,+,# %## %/+00#(.-/1%+(.#$+('$+/#.+((,1#'2&#$,#' 2(+(8.+$#

520# ,+<2(4 ,5# +%4-/#(, -%,5#% 5# 5+$ $-45, , '2$,2(4-2$5 ,5# I-'4/#(,$ 1#2(4 %#02#' -9( 18 ,5# 9#,2,2(#%$ % $-99%,2(4 2,$ .0+2/ '2$.%2/2(+,2(# $-1/2,$ ,5+, (.# %#.%'2(4 %+9+, +/-(,$ , 958$2.+0 9$$#$$2( ,5#0+(';,5#%#.+(1#(#H#%.2$# 9A#%-('#%$#.,2(

18,5#3,+,#+('+..%'2(408;2 +(8$-.5%'#%5+$1##(9+$$#'#+%02#%; ( (#4+,2&# #>-+02,8 .+( 1# '%+A( %/ $-.5 %'#% ( %'#% , 1-,,%#$$ 52$ .(,#(,2(;5#5+$90+.#'%#02+(.#(,5#I-'4/#(,9+$$#'2(,5#.+$#

-%& ( 9)

:9$ +%+$%#02+(.#90+.#'( ,5#I-'4/#(,9+$$#'2(,5#.+$# =' >3 3 .2,#' +$ * 3 *; % 2,,+0 $-1/2,$ ,5+, 2, 5+$ 1##( &#%%-0#' 2( ('%# !#&#09/#(, -,5%2,8 $-9%+;5#(.#(%#02+(.#.+(1#90+.#'($+/#(&2#A ,5#$-1/2$$2($ /+'#5#%#2(+1&#;5#5+$9%+8#' %'2$/2$$+0 ,5#2($,+(,A%2,9#,2,2( * +&2(4 5#+%' ,5# %#$9#.,2&# +%4-/#(,$; 42(4 ,5%-45 ,5# %#$9#.,2&# 90#+'2(4$+('+1&#+00,5##H9$2,2( ('%#!#&#09/#(,-,5%2,8$-9%+; A#+%# ,5#.($2'#%#'92(2(,5+,,5#2($,+(,9#,2,2(2$02+10#,1#'2$/2$$#'

%/%#,5+((#%#+$(

!"#$

$&$'( %"!&)&*+% ($& (!&) (!,%& 5##,2,2(#%$2(,5#2($,+(,9#,2,2(5+&#.0+2/#',1#2(,5#958$2.+0 9$$#$$2( ,5#0+('2(>-#$,2($2,2&#.+$#$#,-918,5##,2,2(#%$2$,5+, #&#(,5-45,5#+A+%'A+$9+$$#'(**

*+(',5#8'2'(,.5+00#(4#,5# +.>-2$2,2( 9%.##'2(4$ 1-, ,5# 958$2.+0 9$$#$$2( 5+$ (, 1##( ,+<#( %/ ,5#/(,52$%#4+%';,5#%#$9('#(,$5+&# 20#',5#A%2,,#($,+,#/#(,$-1/2,,2(4 ,5+, 9$$#$$2( A+$ ,+<#( 18 '%+A2(4 9+(.5(+/+ 2( ,5# %/ +9+,

B(+/.5+ '+,#'**

*A52.55+$1##(5#0'+$+&+02'/'# ,+<2(49$$#$$2( ,5#0+('3#.,2( ,5#.,

9%&2'#$,5+,+ ,#% ,+<2(4 ,5# 9$$#$$2( ,5# 0+('; 2, &#$,$ 2( ,5# 3,+,# %## %/ +00 #(.-/1%+(.#$5#%# #%#(.#2(,52$%#4+%'2$/+'#,,5# 00A2(49+%+4%+95$

%/,5#I-'4/#(,): 3* 4 %.

%)/ '

# 5 # 4 6 '

' # 4 6 '* 4 '

4 %0%*

1 #

%)/" 4

$%&" +

* 7

5 '

4 !

# 5"

* 8 4 !

" ' 4 ' # *

" " #

' 4 # * 9* !

# 5

%)/ +

4 *

&&'

"* *'

& / "-

3, ' & 03, '

& + * 3, ' & ?

@ '2 *

& 3, " 3,

' & < ,'3&

**''2" @

' &' '

- &

&*' -'2 6 '

# 5 # !

* "

" *"

4 6 ' * -. 5-$;A#+%# ,5#.($2'#%#'92(2(,5+,,5#958$2.+09$$#$$2( ,5# 0+('2(>-#$,2($,+('$'-08,+<#(+(',5-$;,5#90#+ ,5#9#,2,2(#%$ 1#2(4 2(958$2.+09$$#$$2( ,5#0+('2(>-#$,2(2$A5008/2$:.(.#2&#'+('2$ 02+10#,1#%#I#.,#' $/#%& !($& !/$+&( '$0 ( % "!&) & *+% ($& 1!

(%&)%0%) !&) 0% %2%) 5#%#$9('#(,$5+&#.+,#4%2.+00890#+'#'2(,5#A%2,,#($,+,#/#(,,5+, ,5#+/-(, ./9#($+,2( %,5##(,2%#+.>-2%#'0+('A+$/+'#+&+20+10#, +00,5#0+('A(#%$+(' -%,5#%2,5+$1##(+'/2,,#'18,5#9#,2,2(#%$,5+,,5#8 5+&# +0%#+'8 %#.#2&#' ,5# +/-(, ./9#($+,2( 5#8 5+&# +0$ 20#' %# #%#(.# -('#%$#.,2( .,

%#(5+(.#/#(,2(,5# +/-(, ./9#($+,2( 5#%# %#; 2( ,5# 42&#( +.,$ +(' .2%.-/$,+(.#$ A5#%# ./9#($+,2($,+('$9+2',,5#9#,2,2(#%$@$#.('.(,2(4#(.8+$9%&2'#'2( 3#.,2( ., *2$+0$(, -0 200#'

$&%$'( % $&)($& #0% 03%)&% ($&45647$'( % ($'48-9 !0%'+"'""%) D 5# (E10# 3-9%#/# -%, ('2+2( ('%# !#&#09/#(,-,5%2,8 $-9%+5+$.0#+%081$#%&#',5+, %'##/#'0+9$2(4 +.>-2$2,2(9%.##'2(4$ -('#% 3#.,2( ,5# ., *; 1,5 ,5# .('2,2($ 2# 9+8/#(, ./9#($+,2(+(',+<2(4 9$$#$$2(/-$,(,1# -0 200#'2#2 #2,5#% ,5# .('2,2(2$ -0 200#';,5#0+9$2(4.+((,5+99#(5#(E10#3-9%#/#-%, ('2+5+$1$#%&#',5+,A%'F%G..-%%2(42(3#.,2( ,5#., * /-$, 1# %#+' +$ F+('C(%G #0#&+(,9+%+$ %/ ,5#I-'4/#(, +%# %#9%'-.#' 5#%#2(1#0A): 23//* 7

4 " ' ' # #*

" '

" "

%)/ '

$%&*

* "

# 1

" 1

# 1 1* ++++ ++++ ++++ ++++ %$%* 7 ;

* * '* <

7 = *00"

# ' ' " +

1 # ?

* 7

# '@ %& 7

* 7

" A A AA A *A 7 4 =+

A A

' A - "

# '*A 7

" A ' +

# 1 # + # "

'* C7DC *A 4 " '

A"A A A '* 7 "

" #

" ' "

# * 7

# +

* %"$$$ #

* % 7 " '" ' "

* A A #

' '

* 7 %

# #

' +

* %"$$$*:

%9 !

@ 7 #

' E 7

' *

# # *

' *

' *1

0" & &'2 ',

*" '

()&- - 3" " ' 3" '

" '2 ', $1 (,5#.+$#+,5+('+$%# 0#.,#' %/,5#%#908 20#';2,2$#&2'#(,,5+,+ ,#% ,5#+A+%'A+$+((-(.#'(D*;,5#958$2.+09$$#$$2(A+$,+<#(18 %#.%'2(4 +9+, B(+/.5+ '+,#' **

*+(' ,5# ./9#($+,2( +/-(, A+$ '-08 ,#('#%#' +(' 9+2' +$ A#00 32(.# ((# ,5# .('2,2($ 9%#$.%21#' 2( 3#.,2( ,5# ., * +%# -0 200#'; ,5#%# %#; $+2'

9%&2$2( .+((, 1# %#02#' -9( 18 ,5# #,2,2(#%$ , .0+2/ 0+9$2(4 ,5# +.>-2$2,2(9%.##'2(4$

%&(!"( $'( %"!&)&*+% ($& 19.

% (<-% 2,,+0 ( ,5# $,%#(4,5 ,5# +.,$ 90#+'#' 2( ,5# A%2,,#( $,+,#/#(, 5+$ &#5#/#(,08 .(,#('#' ,5+, ,5# 3,+,# +.>-2%#' ,5# 0+(' % ,5# 9-102.9-%9$#(+/#08 %'#&#09/#(,+('-,202B+,2( 0+('+$ #$2'#(,2+0; //#%.2+0;($,2,-,2(+0+%#+;%#.%#+,2(+0B(#+('9#($9+.#2(3#.,%

;

+(' ;-%-4%+/5#0+('2(>-#$,2(2$&#%8/-.5#$$#(,2+0,+.52#&#,5# 9-102.9-%9$#+$2,+

#.,$,5#'#&#09/#(, /,%A2'#%+'; /,%A2'# %+'+('%-9-$2(4$2,#$+$9#%,5#0+8-,90+(#5+&#.($2'#%#',52$ 9+%, +%4-/#(,%+2$#'18,5#%#$9('#(,$+('A#+%#2(./90#,#+4%##/#(, A2,5,5#$+/#+$,52$2$+(2/9%,+(, +.,%,1#<#9,2(/2('A520#'#+02(4A2,5 ,5#.+$#+%2$2(4-, ,5#+.>-2$2,2( 0+(',+.52#&#,5#9-102.9-%9$#+(' 2,2$,5#3,+,#C2,$+-,5%2,8A52$2(,5#1#$,9$2,2(,'#.2'#+1-,-,202B+,2( ,5#0+('+.>-2%#';+ ,#%2,5+&2(41##(&#$,#'2(3,+,# V.

Plea of Discrimination 20.

We have also considered the contention of the petitioners seeking parity with the release of land made by the State vide letter dated 18.12.2002, 26.06.2012, 22.08.2012 and 09.12.2006. Though at the time of notice of motion, as noticed herein above, only plea raised was with respect to lapsing of acquisition proceedings under section 24(2) of Act of 2013, thus, virtually the plea of discrimination was given up, yet we deem it appropriate to deal with the contention in view of the averments made in the petition.

21.

The plea of discrimination raised by the petitioner deserves to be rejected, as the petition is highly belated as the acquisition proceedings were concluded way back in the year 1993 and even the letters on which reliance has been placed were issued way back in 2002 and 2012. Therefore, if the petitioners were aggrieved of the action of the State, they ought to have approached the Court at the time when cause of action had arisen. They cannot be allowed to reopen the settled claims under the garb of section 24(2) of Act of 2013. 22.

We are also in agreement with Mr. Mittal who has brought our attention to the facts and circumstances considering which the land was released from the acquisition proceedings. As noticed above,%'#% '+,#' A+$ 9+$$#' -9( ,5# %#.//#('+,2($ ,5# $-1:.//2,,## $#(,,,5#&#%(/#(, +(' $-.50+('A+$%#0+,#'A52.5A+$$2,-+,#'(#+%%#$2'#(,2+0+%#+ &200+4#+('A+$

-008'#&#09#'$ +%+$%'#%'+,#'2$.(.#%(#'2,A+$9+$$#'2( ./902+(.# ,5#'2%#.,2($42&#(18,52$-%,&2'#%'#%'+,#' 2( (

+('(DD

5#9#%-$+0 ,5#%'#% .0#+%08$5A$,5+,,5#.($,%-.,2( ,5#0+('A(#%A+$%#0#+$#'+('%#$, ,5#&+.+(,0+('A+$+.>-2%#'9+%2,8.+(1#.0+2/#'18,5#9#,2,2(#%$A2,5 $-.50+('A(#%$A55+'+99%+.5#',52$-%,A+81+.<2(,5#8#+%

;2# #&#(1# %#+((-(.#/#(, +A+%'32/20+%08;#&#(,5#%'#%'+,#' A+$9+$$#'2(&2#A ,5#+9902.+,2($-1/2,,#'18,5#0+('A(#%A+81+.<2( ,5#8#+%*+('.+$#A+$.($2'#%#'+$9#%+9902.+10#902.8A520##H#%.2$2(4 9A#%-('#%$#.,2(

5#9A#%-('#%3#.,2(

.+(1##H#%.2$#'(082 9$$#$$2(5+$(,1##(,+<#((.#2,2$5#0',5+, 9$$#$$2(A+$,+<#(18%#.%'2(4%+9+,%B(+/.5+;(#2,5#%,5#9#,2,2(#%$.+(

.0+2/ %#0#+$# 0+(' (% %#02+(.# .+( 1# 90+.#' ( +( %'#% 9+$$#' A520# #H#%.2$2(49A#%$-('#%3#.,2(

,5#.,

23.

Further the instant plea is liable to be rejected in view of the fact that the petitioners have failed to aver as to how they are similarly situated persons in whose favour land was released. It is trite law that 2('2(4 '2$.%2/2(+,2( .+((,1#%#.%'#'/#%#08(,5#1+$2$ &+4-#+('1+0'+$$#%,2($+$5+$1##( /+'#18,5#9#,2,2(#%$2(,5#2($,+(,A%2,9#,2,2(5#%# #%#(.#2(,52$%#4+%'; .+(1#/+'#,,5#I-'4/#(, ,5#(E10#3-9%#/#-%, ('2+2(,5#.+$#

-%& ( 9)

:9A5#%#2(,5#9#H -%,5#0'+$-('#%):

# '

# #

' #

# #

D , # 4

" 4* F' 4

" 4 , " * + * 7

' BB "

' # - #

.*/*%//.

4 )%

" #

# * # '

* 7

' #

# !

' # '

' +

* G #

# #

' #

#? '

* "

' 6 'H

' # * 4 "

B #

# #

" % # '

5 #

5 !

* %

' *

4 ' !

" #

# #

* 7 # '

' "

5 ?

5 #

# 4

; 3*1 45 5# + %#$+2' I-'4/#(, 2$ + 0#+'2(4 9%#.#'#(, +$ +% +$ ,5# +$9#., '2$.%2/2(+,2( 2$ .(.#%(#' 5# 9#%-$+0 ,5# + %#$+2' 1$#%&+,2( .0#+%08 %#&#+0$,5+,2,2$2(.-/1#(,(,5#9#,2,2(#%C0+('A(#%+00#42(4'2$.%2/2(+,2( ,$5A,5+,2(A5+,/+((#%5#5+$1##('2$.%2/2(+,#'+('5A5#2$2'#(,2.+008 90+.#',$-.59#%$($2(A5$# +&-%,5#%'#% %#0#+$# 0+('5+$1##( 9+$$#' 3-

2.# , /#(,2( ,5+, 2 ,5# %'#% %#02#' -9( 2$ 2,$#0 200#4+0 +(' +4+2($,,5#9%&2$2($ 0+A;,5#0+('A(#%C9#,2,2(#%$.+((,.0+2/9+%2,8 #&#(2 5#2$2'#(,2.+00890+.#'1#.+-$#%,2.0# ,5#($,2,-,2( ('2+

'#$(,#(&2$+4#,5#.(.#9, (#4+,2&##>-+02,8+(',5-$.+((,1#-$#'+$ ,0 , 9#%9#,-+,# 200#4+02,8 ,2/# +(' +4+2( 99082(4 ,5# + %#$+2' 9%2(.290#$ (, ,5# .+$# +, 5+('; ,5# (08 .(.0-$2( A52.5 .+( 1# '%+A( 2$ ,5+, ,5# 9#,2,2(#%$5+&#/2$#%+108 +20#',$#,-9+90#+ '2$.%2/2(+,2(0$;A#+%# 2(./90#,#+4%##/#(,A2,5%2,,+0,5+,2(&2#A ,5#0+A$#,,0#'18,5# 9#H -%, 2( ('%# !#&#09/#(, -,5%2,8 $-9%+ (.# 9$$#$$2( ,5# 0+('5+$1##( ,+<#(; A52.5 2( ,5# .+$# +, 5+(' A+$,+<#(18 %#.%'2(4 %+9+,

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

.+(1# #H#%.2$#'+(',5-$;(#2,5#%,5#%'#%$%#02#'-9(18,5#9#,2,2(#%$+$%#4+%'$ ,5#%#0#+$# 0+('+('I-'4/#(,$9+$$#'18,5#(E10#-%,2(,52$%#4+%'.+( 1#%#02#'-9( 25.

$+$#>-#0 ,5#+1&#'2$.-$$2(+('2(&2#A 0+A$-//+%2B#'2( 9+%+ ** ('%# !#&#09/#(, -,5%2,8 $-9%+; $9#.2 2.+008 + ,#% 5+&2(4 %#.%'#',5+,2(,5#.+$#+,5+(';,5#958$2.+09$$#$$2( ,5#0+('2(>-#$,2( 5+&2(41##(,+<#(;,5#1024+,2( %9+8/#(, ./9#($+,2('2$.5+%4#'+(' +0$.($2'#%2(4,5+,,5#0+('2(>-#$,2(2$&#%8/-.5#$$#(,2+0,+.52#&#,5# 9-102.9-%9$#;A#5+&#(5#$2,+,2(,50',5+,2(,5#2($,+(,.+$#;,5#3,+,#

5+$ -008 '2$.5+%4#' 2,$ 1024+,2( >-+ 1,5 ,5# .(,2(4#(.2#$ ..-%%2(4 2( $#.,2( *.,+('2,1#2(4$;,5#2($,+(,9#,2,2(2$'2$/2$$#' 26.

+&2(4'2$/2$$#',5#/+2(A%2,9#,2,2(;9#('2(4+9902.+,2($;2 +(8; +0$/##,$,5#$+/# +,#3,+,-$>-;2 +(8;$,+('$&+.+,#' 6!2 !&,%0 !7 %'+ ( % 9-8:4844 !;!& 60+&!""7 +)<% 5#,5#%$9#+<2(4C%#+$(#') "3C 5#,5#% #9%,+10#) "3C