← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR(F)/1156/2023dismissed

Ankush Sharma v. Radhika Sharma

2024-04-15Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra11 pages

$%&$' (%()*+ *,** *% *-$'* - ."/

 1*2 3   

  

 !

  ""  

$ 

  "" 

 !

    *! 4+5&!6 )(6%$ &!*$6*+*%*

% & '  #()"' *

+ 

$ 

"

+   

 ,-!

)"' *

+    

"

+ 

$ 

 ...

!*$6*+*%*3) /  *    "

  00  "#   +  1 '

  "  ' #

   "

#(   

1 '

 " ' #

 '

0"*00 (

 "

"

"

# "1- *#04"( )0-   ) *0* (5/5  6



"7"

 " !82 1-  2"

#-

  +

6

  5   +    "

 +  +0(  +  #

      9

  

" +

) 

 +:

6#  

5 "

6#  

5   

0)

6   1-0-(" 2* * "

 

    +*   -"*  ) +

#

001 +  #  (0  *0  ('



 1 +  0-   : 3 ++*  + * ' +  ##   +"# 0 +

#

   +  " #

 "

    +  "1

+0 "1-

5 +   0+" 1 0+ +  #

5  2     '

   2   

 ** "( ;"

"*   

5 2 00 2 2 (#'

/

5 00 ( '  + "+0- 1 "" # # 2  +

( / - 

"( # (*-#  "" 2  # # *  +

2 1 (# < * '* #  00   "

"  #-*00-0  2 0 

0-* # '

  0  ""*  # 0  *00 (2 #

5   #0 "



2  " (    #'

 , 1    =(  "  2  "2(  0-  +

)

6#   2  22 (;-"

1"

"2 ( +   :)

6# ;

0 "

1  0   +  - +  ++> ""

#  

#- "+ " (  #-  +



 +)

6#    2 00  0+?

+ 0 +0 " #0-1 +  "0- 

00 (( 2

5 2 2 # 10 +   0 "* " 2"

+0  + +0- 1 ;

2

> *   -+  "+0- 1   0+ "0 +   0  2   -*  2(

(0- + 

6#   ## >

0-"""

0'

 *

*;

*0 "  0-0- )@:)

6"

#- "+ "(

  0   " + "  

#('

2

* 

  "1- #

/ #

2 00 2 " '"

/ +

) ##( '"

 # "* ""* "

(

* 

  + #

)

 +0 "1-

2"#  +2 +  ""  "* "#5  +  "





0(" + ")

2 00 '

+0  

 ? #

 )

'

#- "+ 

*   +

"

#" ?

( "1-0 "*  0+ 

 #( " "



 010  "+ ""  +

"

#"

"

 * "

#('

2 +* 

2  (0

"" +

"

* #

5  '

  0  ?

 1

(

 0 2 "

 20 #( #( " "

) 2(  2 2 (0   0* #-"2"2(0-## >

0B:

6# ;

  +*0010

 2 # 

" +  ( '

 '* "  "2( ++*

   +  -1-2- +#   @ ?

   +   ( "   20  0 "(  '"

)   0 " * "1

# "* "  * "1-

# '

0 + "- "- ># "

 (1  1-

5 + 

2 0+ " "*   + #

5  / ># "

  +

5  *0"

"* 0+

) #   ) "*0 >#  ) >  **0  *

  "  *0 ( 

*      ('

   "

0  + 

># "

  +#

5   10

"+ #5 $ +

 "0  > "  "100  2 +

"

  #*   "

 1-     +         "       " 



     +  

6 "

"   1  #" 

5   00++* ?

0 (

21  0# #

 3(0  2* 2  *   +#

 ;1 * " 2 "

#   +(  +  -;

0

 +

*( 0*  /



 2*  #2  + "2 1 "

1 ) ( #( " "

010  "+ ""

-"

('



)  + )

6#   * $     ")      '   #

   +0 "  1- 

) 1

"" ( "1-0 "*  0+ 

#( " "

010

"

>

2* 1

"

#-



 +:

6#  

5 2+ "010  "+ >

2*

  +

6" 

6

"

#"1-

5   (

   +

 "

#"  *0" +

010 "* "*

5 0  ( "   +  -) +  )  C0 # 10 -

*  1



 #

5  9 "*  0+  + 1

5   0+1

+

*(*   +## >

0-

6# ) +  ) ( "2 "1

"

 

+ 2"(-

  )  (0

"" +

 +

" #

5   2  "  *     0'

  #

0-  +     2 +  $ 

 ** "(0-) ( ' #

 +0 "1-

 00 2 "  ?'

"0 "*  0+  #

"'

( 

 ( * "* +00-      + # '"

2+ "-( -  2  (0   +  2+  *0" / #

1, # '  # '  "'(*-" * # 0  +   0 10(  2*  2   *

- #

+2+ "*0"   -  + (( " "



" 

*# # +  *

-" 1-"'

 0+  +'(*-) 0 - "* +  1

 / # 2 "

  

> * "2 "*

 ,"*  2** 

2

0((  2  ("  ' ** * /

; 810 #    * 1

","(

"7

   ""

0 "("

0 1 

 2*

#-10 "

    + 

  "1- 1 '(

 +

 "

*"

" 

1 +#0 "( + #

" 1 +   +(  2 "+   "

"(#   "*

   '(*-" # #   # 

 +* 2*2 0"2 (     + #

D  10 

" +

2+  "  "

"

 *0" D  2

   ##0*    "*

"  "

# +  00-C0+ "D2

##0* -"

"

 *

 +*  D2

*  ++* 10

 "" +0'( 2**    0  2

##0* 2 #0 - "#  ( D2

 2 2 ("(  1

( D2

 2+ 2 C *+* #0 -  ##  

+  ( +0-) *0" ()"0 (+

"0  1  + +0-D  10

*   +0 (  +  2 (2+ ?

0 1

2 00

+*0*#* - + 1")* 0*  )  10 >#  +   2 

) " "

"

 +0-  1   2     10( "

02)010

+-)2 0"1 C

  * "

  ) '

## #

C  +

#"/    '

" (" "" +0'( +

1")2 00 #0(+0  

"(*   +0'(/

#0  + 1" "

 #  - *  +*  

  

 1 0'

 + 0" - 2+ + 10

1 "

"" "*  0C0+*     0* *0 1 #0* "#     !"" #$%&)2 ; 810 #   " 1

2"

"  10 " 0 *)"

' "

 + 2  >  

2"

2+  0"

1   > '( 2*1 *   ## '

"1 10 + 

)  0"   ( "'

 2+ -/

++* *- + C  ","( "  2+ " *0"

#  10  0'

2   10 * +   : ?   * )"

"0-) #

 0'( #

0- ?

0  "#

5 2 00 

2 (/

5  2 '

#0* "  * "* #- + ++"'

 "0-  2   1-     "

(     0  *   1  

9)

6 +*0- 



2   ++"'

" 2  0-*  )@:)

6;

0  2 '

1

,   2  + 2 +0  3(0  "

0C "    +0   0-1 +  (  2

"( 1-2+ ? *  >

+   

- 



)0*   " :) 6/ 0-  " 1 *  2*    *   +#

5 2 "202  0* +#

 2 '

"

+ 1**     + 

 /     0   "  #   EFG  #- 0#  +     2(  0-0-  )$ )$:@6"1- ( '

00

'"

# "* "  * " * "

  )""

#-

 "1 '

  / 2 00

"# #    +02 20 #( "

+(  +

0'( "" + 1")+0- 00 +* 2+ "*0"

'

  2* -2 (20 2+ 20'(   0      * "

  )0 (2 +*0*#* - +



 1")    * 0  *  )    10 >#    +     2 

"010

)+-  ( )  (  * "

 2 '(- 010

/ "0-   +

* "

(*   +1 #

5 "  ('

"   #-



  +

6#  

5  +  "

 ++0( +

  00 "

 + ,"( " +

)   +

6#   00



(  +,  -)2 )#

5 1

"

#"



  +    :

6  #       2 +  

&

#('

2 +*0*#* - + )  + 

"

#"1-  *0"* 00

>* '

  > 1  5  *1 "   (

 ++*

5    ) +  +:

6"

#"  1-     #

  5   1-  2-  +  

  * *  ") " 1 )

5 0 2 (""2( ( "   +0-; 2 ) *  * 

 *  "* "1 '

?

2 00

"# #    +02

2+ 

 "" +0'(2* 2 ** 20  20'(2  1"/

5  0 (+

 #

5  " *  10-1 # 

 0  '

(*  1  +   2*  + 

# # #

# + *0"/  10(   + (

 1"        2+  02-   "      (   # 0 /

 0+"

2 2  + 2 # / (

#0   1-2 " 0C "   1

2  +'  " 1

 0C "

*0+ ") 2*   2     "  1

  "   ' "  010 -   #- 

  ##   + (  "" +0+ 2*  #2 "" +0'( + )    C

   + "0 #

0*#* -  ?  -  * "

"  # )  

#(    '

2   '

00  +*   "

** * ) "0-  ( 0-#  "

+ (  + 

5 "  +

2* 2"

#"1-

5 * 0"

> 1    >* '



 "

# "1- +0-  + ( *  *1

  10   , " 0 *+  ##   +(

 0'

0+  +"( - @ ?'

2 + "* )  0" #- "

1-

+  * 

"

#"

1- 2 00#- "

1- + 

("

#( " "

"  "

**

"/  "

# "1-

+0-  *

++ (+ -00 (0 -*0  + -** "(0-)  0" +"(('

1- +0- 

# 0"""  2 -

+ 1-  

;

)

 +0 "1-1 #

  "

" " $ *    #

   '

 1

  " ")  # "( ##0*  +- "

"+*   7!*$6*+*%*8 )(-'&

1*2 3