Kartar Singh v. Managing Director & ORS
!""# $% " &
$ $""'()* %"
+ ,
!"#$ % !&#'
!"#$ ( ) # "
"+$%-& "# $% "."- .& %/'.& '
"%, " "!" %"'.&' "" , 0
"12&+3%3 '# ".&4% "#-"5%$' "#-"5%62'.& '
"%" , 7'7
7
"" ,
% !&#' *
8% ""422 , &,
5" $ ' 7'7
'7
7 0
8%4", "
%5- % ,
%& 2% ,
"%"""9 "9 "&' 2524 ) "
+ "# "
7
7 0
7
7
0 8% %22 $ % 4" ,
% 5 9 % ,"&
""7 :; 7
5/4%%%.
-" """$"
#%94 "-28%$"& %, "
%,"9 2<%, "
4" %5 - "%
%9%-$%4 9
52%"""- 8%,"29 "/53 " 5/%" , %% 4",
"%$%2/52= -,," % '"2 4
,2-, 3-$9 % -"
!
"",
*. 0
' " #"
0
%%"% '2"
-
2 "%, "
'4%2 "&" $ % " 5/ % 2"
-
2 " % " , '% "2-, %"",
5/% -" +#. 77
' $
%&% '
74%"5/"2 4 $" %,,22 %" " " $%"""
0 9 % "9% 2 $ &2 #-' ,22/4% #,2*& $
% 94 9
5/( >52%#-,"9-"+2 4 2 ,2 %3-$9
% -" (
))*
( >52%#-,"9-" +,
-
* .-)
8%
- "$" $ 2/ &< $ ?"" "/ 3-" 4
"5/( >52%#-,"9-" + $"
'
$/ '
# = 4 4%%" 9,2/ " %
-%%/4"
0 2525""%$ /"
5- %-25,"9 - "&22%/ %$ /"
8%/4" 22 "&4%
%4",
4" 28%4",
4"-292/224 2 $"2 -, %3-$9 ' 9 %9,2/ '4%2"/
""' 24",
29 $ 95 8%4",
4"2245/%($%-" "9 "2"3-$9 8% 3-$9 %($%-"4 9,-$ 5 "( >52%#-,"9 -"'4%" 4%2" "" $"2"3-$9 ( >52%#-,"9 -" 01
+,'
#0 @ ( 2
3 ( %%'
# 7@$ "
%'
7 #0 4 # 5 "
-(
%'
#0 7'4 , %%,"
4%,,"%% -"52 $,2 $"2 -, "",
9%"
"2"' 5 % " "/"2 - 2/ 2% +2& ,"$",% %" "?"524 A # " %," ,2
- "
'%%
5 25/% -"8%" "'%" B-""2 &"%2$2,", 1-% 2/B- $"
"2 -%%","
4%4" &$2
4<-,%22 $%"""9 ,%
95- 24",
"%3-$9 % -" ("4 "!-9"&% C $ "'!"9<'
#0
%%"%/" 2 9"2 " D 8%" "' "- B- %" "
"
4%%"%9,2/ 4% 4<-,%22 $ %"""9 ,% 9'22%", ""9 5 ' -%,"
5$& %"2
%2$% -5 B- 2&"5/% -"D 8%B- 2/ % 5 ?9 5/% -" "
2/
% 5
"5 9," " ?"
% " "/ "2 - " ."2 %
- % ,"
4% &$2 %
"$% B- 4% % - ' % 4" , 5%" "-,2 /"
%$"- %
9"2 %-25$" %9 4 $" ,"
92"2/ -4%4 &$2 5-% "$%
%22 $% ""9 4%%4 59
$%$ /"
.%"% 5 -,,2 - 4%% % 5 , -% 5- 4" ,
4" 25/%9,2/ %$95 " %"""9 4%" %"""9 4 94%" 54 0
0 7
844",
4"
24%" "2 "9""4 ,
8%/ 4" $" "9 "" 8%" " , 4" ,
224 4%%9,2/ 4%"" % /"
'
'
0'
'4<-, 2 4",
9-% "%"""9 %%" -%,"
%-25$" % 9"2 "
D ?? ??
??
8%" "' % 52 $ 92""2
5$& %,"
4%%& ,,"%% -"%422-
"2/&"5-" %$9 % $9 422 9,22/ 22, 4% % 252/
,/9 % ,"
"9 4/"
> 2"/ " 5 ,
%"
B- 2 5 8%" "'4" 2 $" /"2
%,"
4%%&,,"%%-" "%"
""9 2/% ,"
4%%& 2%4" ,
4% %/4" "&"4%%&5 "9"" "%"""9 '% ,"
%-25 224 5 %"
E F60 00"G
7 = 7 " 8 "" 3""
(" '
7#7 422' 9
-4
" 224 $% "2"3-$9 + $"' 9 -,"'4 , - "
8%5 3-$9 ? -922/%2$" $"2 4", '% ($% -" 2
" % -
5 $ % 2- $ % - % , "= $ '% -" 2<
" 4%%"%4", "% % &"%9" % 4<-, "% % -" = - % % ,,22 ,,"%%-" "2 $2/'% 99/ 2%95 " "/"2 E 60 00"
8% 9&44 2245/% -" 5"(
'
0+#H
= " 3-$9 +
:
"
.
5 '
0 #*+ '( >52% #-,"9-"'4%2
" $%
-"$" $2/ " "" $ "2" 3-$9 %
-' , % ", ","
9422 <,%
- 2&. 2"
-: ,-
5$"&&& -%"," % %"
5 5/%-%"/"$5/$ $" "9% -" %
-"$" $2/ 54%" " "$ 2- 4%" " / -%"",
2/ %," $&"
9 "& 9/,"&%9
%5 4%%%5 $& %"
."2 %
-
= ' - % -"'422 5" 422< 4
%242
&-" % 4%"2" &$2 C& B-2/
% 529%"$%3- -" ?,"/ " 529 C& %" ,"," "5 " 2 $%4", - "."2 %
- = '/ %-25 24% " 52 9.
"","9 $3- " %-2 "922/5%22 $4% ," ?9 % "%9 /" -%,"9 8%-$%
""-2'%-" 24/ "
"& -5 B- %"'5- "2 ,"
'4%224 % $ %,, % ,,"%%-" ,- "4" 229 "/-
2 29"
'
" 2/5" - - 2/ .
/ 4% 2,
&"% "$% 5- -
".
9,2/4% 2, 2<+,)
<2 $-, "9 2-95"% 4 2 -"' "& 5 %"2 - 2/ +2& ,"$",% "9% " 3-$9 "?"524
0%& " -5%%" , -2 %&%22 $%%,"9
"" % 3- "9,2/%"2& 98%/%
" ? /"
% 3- " 9,2/ %2 % ,"9 2, " ?/"
22"$-2","9 < ,2 8% -59
% 2"
-
2 " % " , %%/%$& ","
% "2& 95-% 9 22 "
= " $ %4% %"$-2" 2 <,2'%/ , % , 22/ 5- % "/ 4
9 '%" "'%/< <%"
% "5- 2 2/
0= 2" /%%- %" "
2 $%""4% %3- "
9,2/4 ,"9 %5
0=
4H-$1 %4 2 $4% % , ","
%"
-5/
7 %-"""5- 2
"%","
% %22 $% "3 %" "= % ?'
%-"% ?,"
%-
AC&"/"," %6&"
9 ""2 '
9/ 5 ",2 9" +,"
"2 $9"
4%%%&59 2"
5""5/29 ' 5"3 %$"- 2 '4%-?9 $%9" %29 = "$" ","
- "2 % ,"9 '%",2/9/5 2/
"9% %9" "
%,"9 "
"9 % ,,"," ,"9 +,"
4% 9,2,"-2"
9/ 5 ",2 5/ < $ "2& ,"-2"
8% ",2 -%","
'
-"
%
" %- ""&& 2" 29E ;60 00"<
= ! "
# $ % &'% -"' "" "" $ -,"%
"-2%4% 52"," "$" 2E"AE
-: ,-
" '
9,2 4%" 5/%-":"5- 2
' % -%
5
"
-"
% $ " %- ""&& $%AE
-"95"" ,-8%
- 29 "
2/ %-25
"4%" " % "$ 2- 4%" " % 4%% "" ,
9,2 4%-">
" %" -"> "
" ","
-4%-?9 $%9" ' " $& 9,2 4% -% " ' 422 ? %29 '"" %2/
;"9% " -%" 2" "/ 2% & %-"""5- 2" "
"
","
"2 $ 229"$"& $&" " %- 8%-
" 2<,% ?#92"2/'9"
-59
"," %9, -%"/ "" 9= $ %'(
)* + #
, -
$ .))
/ 0 1'%-" < -2, 24 %4%
"2/ "4 %" , 4"<9 %"
%"9 2 9"9< $ ","
-2
3- /52,,"%
= 2
## '
, , &33
1 1&/' % 5 , %9< $ ", ","
"/?,2 2/ 8% ," ,24 "" 2
## 4 + $+, ' % &3/ 1 3&
7= 5 6 , * , #,
##
#
0 130 %"H-$ 1 % % -" "" % ," ,2
#* 7 &33 / 1 ," 5 "& % % " , %"
," "" 2,&"%""$% ,,"%% "5- 2
7'%/4-2 $%5 %""
77
= .6 #,3 13'
% -"' $%B-2/2- %5"<
2/ ," $$" "&5 '%
"-2%-
A 2 $ ","
2 4-2 & % ," 29 2/ " 2% "2& " "-" 24"9 % B- 4%%" % 29 9 5/
,,2 "&
" 2/ :"
2% %," $&"
9 "& 9/ ,"&%9 %5 4%%%5 $&
%"
."2 %
- = 4-2 ' - % -"' 5 " 422< 4 %242
&-" % 4%"2" &$2 E
8%" 5 &2&"% %%29
,"9 5 % , B-2/ B-52/'5-% "2 % 5294% " 52 9 8% ," ,2 % 5
+,8#* ,,+$#,
& 1 = 6 (
+ )+ '
#'
7 #7 '%-"% , %%-$% %" ," 29 ,"& " 2 $4" , - "."2 %
- = '/ " "2/ 4" , %-2 5 2 4% " 529= %" , % 2 %4", " & /"
%-"'
"2"'< %2/ "2&
"
%"",
5/%($%-" 4%%%?" % " "/3-" " 2/' $ 99% '49/" " 4H-$1 % ' # #( ., 6+ &3 '4%" % 5 2 4 %,"
$$"&5/ "" ,"9 $ 3- "&"% % %-2,,"%%-"2 4% ?9 % "%9 /" -%,"9 = %%" /," 29 "%-"
?" %",4"
- "."2 " % %" &"5 4%"%-"
"
" 9" "%,
$ " 2 $% 9'5- 4-25 - 4 ?" " "% -" " - ?" %" ?"" "/ ,4"
- " ."2 % ,"
4% ,,"%?,- 2/ "%"2 4% 5/ 224% $ %,, % ,,"%%-"
,- "4" 229 "/-
2 29"
"5 2-2/
- % % % %
"/% 5 -"5 %,"9 2" ,"9
9/5-
28%"9/ 5 -
29 2, 5-',"$ '% " , % 2,2<+,) <2 $-,
"9%" 2-95"%"4 2 -"' " 9"
4%% %952%9 2/1- -% %9 $
"
5/ 2 - 24.
/ 4% 2, &"% "$% 5- -
".
4,"&
%"%"5- 2 "%($%-"% ,," % , ,",","
,& ," % 5 %3- "4 ,"9 '%" "'% "
5 %,"9 +9 $52&- % -9 2/ 2% $" $ "2
""/ 22 2 ," ,2 & 4-2 "92/"% , " 9/%
% % 9 9/ 5 ,,252 22 "-9 4%" " $" - 9 2 "$% "
" $ 1-' 2 29 $ $ ,"9 2 5 2/ %-2 %& 5
" 5/%"5- 2 ,5/%($%-" 8"- ' 2,"9 25 %&5 $" 5-% 9 2<2/
%#?%B-""$" 5 $%% ? ,/ %,
8% , %& 5 <
" % -"$5 "- 5/%2"
-
2 "% " , %%/ %-2%&5 B-22/" 4%%&# $%8$1-B-2/% 529 %"$%3- -" "?,"/ 4 " % $'% 5 %&"/% $9/ , 5- %9' "22" 4/ 2& 98%" 9/ 5 /,"& ,"& $ "29 5- $"& "2 $,"9
5$& 4 2 2 /, 9E ;60 00"<
= .
3 0" # 00"%/ 5
- - 3"5.=+
#
'( >52%#-,"9 -", - "
0 ;"
' 4 %22 2 4% % 2/ =
# 8 .
#) ) 5(8 +
4,
# 4"8 &/& 1&'%-"" ""%," ,2% % 5 5/ #" 1"
< * # '
+, '
#)
4 ,# 7+ 4 , 9
($ ,)
' '4%%
224
A4%" 2% -" CB-/
"5""/"% 2" %" 4-2 5 ,"22/ - 3- $& "9/'
%"5- %,"/% '5/% -' %4%%9$% "2/5"$" B-&2 4&" '"4%"5/% -
$2%% '%-$%,"%, 4& $% "9/'/,-%%","/ -
4%%4-2 5" 52,2%9
% "9/ 4" "4" 5
"
%" % '2, 9 2/" 9 9"21- &"/ ' "$-9 $
"2 '4%%%"4 4-253- '
- -, 9"2/'%2/ -"
9- $5"5/ / - 29
'
%&2/ % 9- 5"-,
," ,2
-5 22/ B-52 84 "-9 ' 24/ 9," -% '
"'%2 $% %2/ % -" % -" $% "&2'4%%9$%
%" ,"/ - 52 3- "
3- < $% -"
"%%"'
" "2 %"9/E
= #
, && 0 / 1'4%22 $4%?" ,4" %($% -"- "."2 %
- ' %-" 5 "&%,4" %($%-"5?" - "."2 %
- ' " "/'
?" 9- 53-- " 52'9 "&"
/= "%" ',"
> 29 "
"2 "9 ($% -" - " ."2 %
- '5$
%#" /5/2 '&
- %22$
" $9 % 2$2 "$%' %
"2/ , -, - 5294"%/ - %,"
< $"2 ' %-"" -
$" % " "/"2 -%,"
?" -%,4"'4% %,,"% 4%- 2 %
"5294"%/ -
= '
# 6 #(
# 4"8 & 3 %-" 5 "&% 422 2%,4" %($%-"
- ,,"," 4" - " ."2 %
- " "/ %($%-" ?" " " "2/
%"/ % 2 "%B- %2%"$ =% 5
-"%" %" % %" " 2/ % ," %, " 2 $, -%2/
"2/?,2 '%($%-"9/2 "& $" "2 % ?" 4" 3-" C9,% 4 2 %," ,2 2/ $%" "%?"" "/"9/ - "%4"3-" 52 $ 2<2/ -
- ,-52 & 5" $
3-
8%- '%" 2/ %-2 5 2$%2/5"- % .4"-" "B-"4$%% ?,2
" %,52/ 98% -" %-2 5" 9 % ?" $
0 ?"" "/ B-523-" .
- 2 -"% -/,"%"$% %I
5-
9-2 - 2/ <, 2 2& %,"9"/ ," ,2%4% $$"&,"
'4%-B- " ',,"% %-"% 4 2 -"",2 -"'
%-"4-25- "2$252$ "- I 4%%"%2 52 $ %-25 " "
1 '2/9 %4/ B-/=
" "-9 2/ 9/ 5 25- 9 "-9 " 2/4-2 2/ & " "%2$ 4%< < %"
% -"2/" 2 &/ %," 2$ 2$ 4% % "$ % 5 "9 '
92/'A,"" %$" % 9E
'24 ,"9 2, " 2< ,% ?2/ 5" $ %I" - 3-"/ %2 = % % '%-$%%"% 5 -"
/"
>2/ ,,"% $%-"'/%4"-" % "
9= %-/ %-"
"- I4%%" -% "9- 2/ 5$ " 4%- /3- 8%,"' %," '
-% 52 ,,"% $
9" $ % " , 9,2/5 $5 2-2/"2
% -/ -"-" $2< 2-%" ,
52/ %"9 - -%" 2/5 %,"? 9 < 22%2%",% ", % "9 $
-- 2/52&- -%2/
"%- 3- % ""/'5" $
3- ' " 2<2/
%"
#-%2/9/ %& 9, %"
> ", "$% 9/ -
"2/ "$ %"
2$ 4%%
,52"29 ,"552/'9/%&5 " %& 2/ .-" ?, $& -2$ -% 2 ,"
4%9,4% J!-95%<"
>" "%9">+,) <2>= -"
" , ' -% 2/ "& / -2$ $"- 2 %4"-"
%-2 %& %"4 % , &"5" % &"/ %" %2E ;60 00"<
.
% % '4",
%&5 29"%
/"
" % ""9 % , "
"9 "& %22 $ $,"&
""7 :; 7
'4%% 4
- 7/"
5 " 2 $ %4",
'% '% 9" 9
- 2/ +3 %1 2 H-$
1#2 &
H-$ %%" ,< $:" K : %%"+,"52 K :