High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3345/2014allowed

Sultan Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2016-08-08Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan6 pages

!"##$%&%'( ) )

* +,-"!'+%'./ #"%"%'#1 2#1&,& +"!"#!13!'!!'4"/#1& #&5'4#'"&

1#&#'"(0 1+62#17!849$!"#1"/#5#"%"%'#1 1 !9% 1!"!5+%'./88!13!'! :::

#"%"%'#18;/;!&&#19%'.!& !";!1%%'"/#%$#%&"1%$"

;' -!''#18%'4;!&5-!$#4,'4#1&,&5#'&%';#))

'!$$,'"

%'9-9#7#'"%'!$1%7%'!-$!&#,'4#1"/#519%&%'& 1#9#'"%' 11,5"%'$"8 <))--#.!"%'&"/!"/!4=##'-#9#-#4=3"/#$75-!%'!'" !'&% >!- ;#1# "/!" /# $'"!$"#4 "/# 5#"%"%'#1 1 ="!%'%'. 1#.!14%'.&!-#/%&!.1%$,-",1!--!'47#!&,1%'.?!'!-& 7!1-!&!'41 ;/%$/!4#7!'4%--#.!-.1!"%%$!"%' &

@0/!4=##'1!%&#4 '

"/# &!7# 9#13 !--#.!"%' 4#5!1"7#'"!- 51$##4%'.& ;#1# !-& %'%"%!"#4 !.!%'&""/#5#"%"%'#19%4#$/!1.#&/##"4!"#4*)

%&&,#4,'4#1 ,-#A "/#!13!'!%9%-+#19%$#

,'%&/7#'"55#!- ,-#&8 <)A/#"/#'

%&"1%$";' -!''#186!%"/!-;!&!55%'"#4!&"/#'B,%13 %$#1' <

/#4#5!1"7#'"!-51$##4%'.&$,-7%'!"#4%'"/#,1'%&/%'.!' %'B,%13 1#51" 4!"#4

''#C,1# 8 ;/#1#%' %'4%'.& ;#1# 1#",1'#4"/!""/#1#;!&'#9%4#'$#"519#"/#4#7!'4!'4!$$#5"!'$# !'3!7,'"=3;!3=1%=#!'4!&&,$/"/#5#"%"%'#1;!&#C'#1!"#4 ;#9#18%'"/#$1%7%'!-51&#$,"%'5#"%"%'#1;!&$'9%$"#49%4#

00 D,4.#7#'"4!"#4

5!&&#4=3"/#+5#$%!-,4.#8%'4!'4&#'"#'$#4 ",'4#1. 3#!1&!'4"5!3!%'# &8

@0!&#4'"/# D,4.#7#'"$'9%$"%'5#"%"%'#1;!&4%&7%&&#417&#19%$#9%4#14#1 4!"#4<)

/#!55#!-51##11#4=3"/#5#"%"%'#1!.!%'&""/#D,4.#7#'" $'9%$"%';!&!$$#5"#4=3"/%&,1"9%4#D,4.#7#'"4!"#4 A)

0 !'4/#;!&!$B,%""#4"/#$/!1.#&&!$'&#B,#'$# "/#!$B,%""!-8!'14#14!"#4

0 ;!&5!&&#4=3"/# %1#$"1 #'#1!-8 ;' ,'"13 -!''%'.8 !13!'! 1#%'&"!"%'. "/# 5#"%"%'#1%'&#19%$#=,";%"/%77#4%!"###$"%#;#

%"&#- 1#51#&#'"!"%' %-#4 =3"/#5#"%"%'#1&##?%'. !-- $'&#B,#'"%!- =#'#%"& 5#1"!%'%'.""/#&,&5#'&%'5#1%4!&!-&"/#5#1%4/#1#7!%'#4," &#19%$#&"!'4&1#D#$"#49%4#7#74!"#4<

0* "%&!.!%'&"&,$/=1%#!$",!-=!$?415"/!""/#%'&"!'"5#"%"%' ;!&%'&"%","#4%'"/#3#!1

&##?%'."/#%&&,!'$#!1%"!'4!7,& 14%1#$"%'."/#1#&5'4#'"!,"/1%"%#&"1#-#!&#""/#5#"%"%'#1!--"/# $'&#B,#'"%!-=#'#%"&%'$-,4%'.!11#!1&&!-!131"/#5#1%4"/!"/# 1#7!%'#4,'4#1&,&5#'&%'!&!-&1"/#5#1%44%&7%&&!-!'4,5"%--/%& 4!"#1#%'&"!"#7#'"

5' '"%$# 7"%' /!9%'. =##' %&&,#4 ! D%'" ;1%""#' &"!"#7#'"'=#/!-1#&5'4#'"&' "/!&=##'%-#4!'45-!$#4'

1#$14/#51!3#1"/#5#"%"%'#1/!&=##'55&#4=3"!?%'.!&"!'4"/!" "/#5#"%"%'#1/!41#7!%'#4,"&#19%$#4,#"/%&%'9-9#7#'"%'! $1%7%'!-$!&#!'41&,$/$'4,$""/#5#"%"%'#1"/#4#5!1"7#'"%&'" 1#&5'&%=-#!'4!&&,$/8/#%&'"#'"%"-#4"!'3=#'#%"5#1"!%'%'.""/# &,&5#'&%'5#1%4!&!-&"/#5#1%4/#1#7!%'#4,"&#19%$#>#!1'#4

00 +"!"# $,'&#- %' &,551" &,$/ &"!'4 /!& 5-!$#4 1#-%!'$# ,5' "/# 4#$%&%'&"/#'E=-#+,51#7#,1"%'

!'4 !

# "

'#"

& !

! () **+ >#!1'#4$,'&#-1"/#5!1"%#&/!9#=##'/#!14!"-#'."/

!$",7"/#5#"%"%'#1/!9%'.=##'4%&7%&&#417&#19%$# =!&#4&-#-3,5'$'9%$"%'85#"%"%'#1/!9%'.=##'#C'#1!"#4%'"/# 4#5!1"7#'"!- 51$##4%'.& %'%"%!"#4 !.!%'&" /%7 !'4 /# /!9%'. =##' 1#%'&"!"#4%'&#19%$#,5'14#1$'9%$"%'/!9%'.=##'&#"!&%4#%&'"%' 4%&5,"# '"/#$!&#&

!'4 !

# "

'#"

& !

! () "/#'E=-#+,51#7#,1"/!44#!-";%"/"/# %&&,#!'#75-3###!1-%#1$'9%$"#4=,"&,=&#B,#'"-3!$B,%""#4=3"/# %./ ,1"%'!55#!- !'4"/###$"!$B,%""!-'=!$?;!.#&,5' 1#%'&"!"#7#'"%'1#-!"%'""/#5#1%4"/##75-3##;!&,"&#19%$#4,# "%'9-9#7#'"%'!$1%7%'!-$!&# '"/#$!&#

%"/!4=##'=&#19#4!&,'4#1(0

!"##$%&'($)*+, -$-

. 0

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

#"%"%'#1;!&5-!$#4 ,'4#1&,&5#'&%' ;#))

!'4 &,=&#B,#'"-34%&7%&&#417&#19%$#'<)

'-3'!$$,'"/%& %'9-9#7#'"%'!$1%7%'!-$!&#!'4$'9%$"%'=3"/#1%!-,1""%&=3 ';;#--&#""-#4"/!"!'#75-3##8;/%&4%&7%&&#417&#19%$#&-#-3

00 =!&#4'$'9%$"%'8%&#'"%"-#4"=#1#%'&"!"#4,5'#!1'%'."/#!$B,%""!-%' !55#!- ##1#'$#%'"/%&1#.!147!3=#7!4#"";%9%&%'#'$/ D,4.#7#'"&"/%&,1"%' ,-#.

/ ( + +0*!'4

1 / ( 1 (1 , %.

, 2

0 4 '"/#!$"&"/#51#&#'"$!&#"/#!55#!-%-#4=3"/#5#"%"%'#1 !.!%'&""/#D,4.#7#'"$'9%$"%'/!9%'.=##'!$$#5"#4=3"/%&,1"8/# /!& =##' 1#%'&"!"#4 %' &#19%$# 9%4# 14#1 4!"#4

=," ;%"/ %77#4%!"###$"%&$-!%71"1#!"%'."/#&,&5#'&%'!'44%&7%&&!-5#1%4 !&4,"35#1%4/!&=##'4#$-%'#49%4#%75,.'#47#74!"#4<

0* '"/#--;%'.1#!&'%'.(0

23!-&'((4(#'( ($&&'((

5 . ! 3

7 /#=!&%&4#'3%'.""/#5#"%"%'#1"/#$'&#B,#'"%!-=#'#%"& ,5' 1#%'&"!"#7#'" !'4 1 "/# 5#1%4 4%&7%&&!- %& 1#-#$"#4 %' "/# %75,.'#414#1%"&#-"/!""/#5#"%"%'#1/!4

!"#! +,$/1#!&'%'.%&'"/#!$#%"7%&$'$#%9#4

'4,="#4-38"/#5#"%"%'#1/!4=##'$'9%$"#4=3"/#1%!- ,1"9%4#D,4.#7#'"4!"#4

55#!-51##11#4=3"/#5#"%"%'#1 /!& =##' !$$#5"#4 =3 "/%& ,1" !'4 ! D,4.#7#'" !$B,%""!- 4!"#4

/!&=##'5!&&#4%'/%&!9,1!"''#C,1# 0/#D,4.#7#'" $'9%$"%'/!&=##'&#"!&%4#'"/#1;14&"/#"!%'"$'9%$"%'/!& =##';%5#4,"=3!D,4%$%!-9#14%$"/#5#"%"%'#1/!9%'.=##'1#%'&"!"#4

0*0 =!$?%'&#19%$#8&#19%$#=#'#%"&1"/#5#1%4%'B,#&"%'$!''"=#4#'%#4 =31##11%'."!D,4.#7#'"$'9%$"%'"/!"4#&'"#9#'#C%&"'!'3 $!&#"/#5#"%"%'#1%&'"#9#'$-!%7%'.=#'#%"!11#!1&&!-!131"/# 5#1%4"/!"/#4%4'";1?

'4#1&,$/$%1$,7&"!'$#&8"/#14#11#%'&"!"#7#'" 4!"#4

0 /!&"'#$#&&!1%-31#-!"#=!$?""/#4!"# 5!&&%'."/#14#14%&7%&&!-"%&4%1#$"#4"/!"&,$/5#1%4&/!--=# $,'"#4!&4,"35#1%4 >%?#;%&#8 "/# 5#"%"%'#1 /!4 =##' 5-!$#4 ,'4#1 &,&5#'&%' ;#))

""/!"5%'""%7# /!4=##'1#.%&"#1#4!.!%'&"/%7 !'4#9#'$/!1.#&/##"1%75&%"%'7!D15#'!-"3/!4=##'&#19#4' "/#4#5!1"7#'"!-51$##4%'.&"/#5#"%"%'#1/!&=##',--3#C'#1!"#49%4# %'B,%13 1#51" 4!"#4

''#C,1# 9#' %' "/# $1%7%'!- 51&#$,"%'"/#5#"%"%'#1/!&%'!--3#!1'#4!$B,%""!-!""/#/!'4&"/%& ,1"/#1#;,-4=#'D,&"%%!=-#=!&%&1"/#4#5!1"7#'"'"""1#!""/# 5#1%4&,&5#'&%'!&4,"35#1%4

1 "/# 1#!&'& 1#$14#4 !=9#8 %75,.'#4 14#1 4!"#4 <

0* %&&#"!&%4# /#14#11#%'&"!"#7#'"4!"#4

0 %&74%%#4""/##C"#'""/!"1#%'&"!"#7#'""/# 5#"%"%'#1%'&#19%$#;,-41#-!"#=!$?""/#4!"#5!&&%'."/#14#1 4%&7%&&!- /#5#"%"%'#18/;#9#18;,-4'"=#.1!'"#4!'3!11#!1& &!-!131"/#5#1%4"/!"/#1#7!%'#4,'4#1&,&5#'&%'!&!-&," &#19%$#'!$$,'"14#14%&7%&&!- /#1#9%&#45#'&%'!13=#'#%"&%'5,1&,!'$#""1#!"%'."/# &,&5#'&%' 5#1%4 !'4 4%&7%&&!- 5#1%4 !& ' 4,"3 =# $!-$,-!"#4 !'4 1#-#!&#4""/#5#"%"%'#1;%"/%'!5#1%4"/1##7'"/&17"/#4!"# 1#$#%5"!$#1"%%#4$53"/%&14#1

#"%"%'%&!--;#4%'"/#!1#&!%4"#17& $ % &'&'(&)* -,$?3 /#"/#1&5#!?%'.@1#!&'#4( #& /#"/#1 #51"!=-#( #&